Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a body comprising goods transport operators engaged in the business of transportation of goods supplied by customers, challenged show cause notices dated 8.10.2015 and 30.9.2015 issued to petitioners No. 2 and 3. These notices called upon them to show cause why their services should not be classified under "Cargo Handling Services" and taxed accordingly. The petitioners contended that their services fall under the category of "Goods Transport Agency" and that the show cause notices were issued beyond the respondents’ jurisdiction. The petitioners relied on circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs (C.B.E.C.) to support their claim. The respondents issued the notices following intelligence that the petitioners had shown gross income in income tax returns but filed "Nil" ST-3 returns. The respondents contended that the petitioners had bundled services improperly to evade higher tax liability under "Cargo Handling Services". The petitioners approached the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenging the show cause notices.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the services rendered by the petitioners fall under the category of "Goods Transport Agency" or "Cargo Handling Services" for the purpose of service tax liability.
  2. Whether the High Court has jurisdiction to entertain a writ petition challenging show cause notices issued at the preliminary stage of the tax proceedings.
  3. The applicability and interpretation of circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs concerning classification and taxability of composite services involving goods transport and cargo handling.
  4. Whether the provisions of section 66F of the Finance Act, 1994, relating to interpretation of bundled services, apply to the petitioners’ case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners provide services of transportation of goods by road and issue consignment notes, thus falling squarely within the definition of "Goods Transport Agency" as per the Finance Act.
  • The activities of loading and unloading are undertaken by consignors or consignees, and the petitioners do not engage in packing, an essential ingredient for classification as "Cargo Handling Services".
  • They rely on binding circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. clarifying that composite services involving transportation and ancillary activities should be classified under the principal service, i.e., goods transport agency.
  • The show cause notices are contrary to statutory provisions and circulars and hence illegal and without jurisdiction.
  • The writ petition is maintainable at the show cause notice stage since no disputed questions of fact arise and the legal issue can be decided on admitted facts and binding circulars.
  • Section 66F of the Finance Act mandates preference to the most specific description of service, which favors classification under "Goods Transport Agency".

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petition is not maintainable at the show cause notice stage and the proper remedy lies in adjudication and appeal; the High Court should not entertain classification disputes at this preliminary stage.
  • The petitioners have artificially split the transaction into three parts to evade service tax liability, which should be classified as "Cargo Handling Services" attracting higher tax.
  • Section 66F(3)(b) of the Finance Act requires that if elements of a bundled service are not naturally bundled, the highest tax liability applies, which is "Cargo Handling Services" in this case.
  • The petitioners’ services include loading and unloading at ports, which fall within the ambit of cargo handling service as defined prior to 2012.
  • Services provided by shipping lines on behalf of petitioners do not change the nature of the petitioners’ service as cargo handling.
  • The petitioners should be directed to respond to the show cause notices and the matter adjudicated according to law.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Hindustan Dev. Corpn. Ltd., 1998 (100) ELT 14 (SC) Writ jurisdiction is generally not exercisable at show cause notice stage for classification disputes. Respondents relied on this to argue against maintainability; court distinguished the case on facts, allowing writ petition due to absence of disputed facts and binding circulars.
Kyori Oremin Ltd. v. Chief Commissioner of Customs, 2016 (337) ELT 228 (Guj.) High Court slow to entertain writ petitions in tax matters due to availability of statutory remedies. Court found this precedent distinguishable as it involved an order-in-original, unlike the present case challenging show cause notices.
Union of India v. Aravali Min. & Chem. (India) Pvt. Ltd., 2000 (115) ELT 279 (SC) Writ petition maintainable when reliance on binding circulars justifies bypassing alternate remedies. Court applied this to validate writ petition maintainability on basis of binding C.B.E.C. circulars.
Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise v. Sushil & Company, 2016-TIOL-47-SC-ST Writ petition maintainable when no disputed questions of fact and legal issues can be decided on admitted facts. Court relied on this to hold that writ petition challenging classification at show cause stage is permissible.
Oryx Fisheries Private Limited v. Union of India, (2010) 13 SCC 427 Show cause notices must be read reasonably and fair opportunity must be given to rebut allegations. Court emphasized fairness in issuing show cause notices and openness of mind by authorities.
Paper Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, 1999 (112) ELT 765 (SC) Circulars issued under section 37B of Central Excise Act are binding on the Department. Court held that respondents cannot take a stand contrary to binding circulars, supporting petitioners’ case.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Chhabil Dass Agarwal, (2014) 1 SCC 603 Availability of alternate statutory remedy impacts writ jurisdiction. Respondents cited to argue against writ maintainability; court considered but found facts favor writ.
Union of India v. Guwahati Carbon Ltd., 2012 (278) ELT 26 (SC) High Court slow to entertain writ petitions in taxation matters due to alternate remedies. Respondents cited to support objection; court distinguished facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the factual matrix and statutory provisions governing the classification of services under the Finance Act, 1994, before and after the introduction of the negative list regime in 2012. The court noted that the petitioners primarily provide transportation of goods by road and issue consignment notes, fulfilling the definition of "Goods Transport Agency". The activities of loading and unloading at ports are performed by consignors, consignees, or shipping lines, not the petitioners themselves.

The court analyzed the definitions of "cargo handling service" prior to and after amendments in 2008, observing that transportation is included within cargo handling service only when combined with packing, which the petitioners do not perform. The court further noted that after 2012, the definition of cargo handling service was deleted from the statute book, whereas the definition of goods transport agency remained unchanged.

The court relied heavily on binding circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, which clarify that composite services involving transportation and ancillary activities should be classified under the principal service, i.e., goods transport agency, and that splitting of invoices does not alter the nature of the composite service.

Regarding section 66F of the Finance Act, the court held that the provision applies only where a single service provider offers bundled services that are not naturally bundled. Since the petitioners provide only goods transport service and other services are provided by separate providers (e.g., shipping lines), the provision does not apply to bundle the services into cargo handling service.

The court rejected the respondents' contention that the petitioners artificially split the transaction to evade tax, noting that tax is paid on all components either by customers on reverse charge basis or by shipping lines, and double taxation is avoided.

The court also addressed the maintainability objection, holding that since no disputed facts exist and the legal issue can be decided on admitted facts and binding circulars, the writ petition challenging the show cause notices is maintainable. The court distinguished precedents cited by respondents on the basis that those involved orders against which statutory remedies exist, unlike the present case.

Consequently, the court concluded that the impugned show cause notices are without legal basis, contrary to statutory provisions and binding circulars, and cannot be sustained.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed. The impugned show cause notices dated 8.10.2015 and 30.9.2015 are quashed and set aside. The rule is made absolute with no order as to costs. Additionally, the Civil Application No. 2952 of 2017 filed by respondents challenging maintainability is rejected.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners are not liable to pay service tax under the category of "Cargo Handling Services" for the periods in question. Their services are correctly classified as "Goods Transport Agency" services in accordance with statutory provisions and binding circulars. No new precedent is established beyond the application of existing legal principles and circulars to the facts of this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Coastal Container Transporters Association And Another Petitioner(S) v. Union Of India And Another (S).

    Harsha Devani, J.:— Rule. Mr. Ankit Shah and Mr. Nirzar Desai, learned senior standing counsel for the respondents, waive notice of service of rule on behalf of the respective respondents.

    2. Since the matter was heard at length at the admission stage, with the consent of the learned advocates for the respective parties, the matter is adjudicated finally.

    3. By this petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has challenged the show cause notices dated 8.10.2015 and 30.9.2015 (Annexure “M” and “N” respectively), whereby the petitioners No. 2 and 3 have been called upon to show cause as to why the services rendered by them should not be classified under the heading “Cargo Handling Services” and be taxed accordingly.

    4. The facts as averred in the memorandum of petition and as emerging from the record are that the first petitioner is a body whose members are, inter alia, goods transport operators and engaged in the business of transportation of goods supplied by the customers. It is the case of the petitioners that the show cause notices issued by the second respondent are in excess of his jurisdiction and that the other members of the Association are likely to receive such show cause notices in due course. By the impugned show cause notices, the respondents have proposed to demand service tax from the petitioners under the category of “Cargo Handling Services”, while it is the case of the petitioners that the services which have been provided by them fall under the taxable category of “Goods Transport Agency”. To bolster their case, the petitioners have placed reliance upon circulars dated 6.10.2008 and 5.10.2015 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs (hereinafter referred to as “the C.B.E.C”).

    5. It is the case of the petitioners that the members of the petitioner No. 1 Association undertake the following activities for providing services to various customers:

    “(i) When the order is received from customers, it was a clear understanding between members of Petitioner No. 1 and its customers that the Petitioners would merely provide service of transportation of goods by road whereas services at Port area and transportation of goods through waterways would be provided by Shipping Lines;

    (ii) The Petitioners would raise a bill for transportation of goods by road and debit note for recovery of the expenses that would be incurred by shipping lines for providing services at Port area and transportation of goods through waterways;

    (iii) It is clear understanding between the Petitioners and customers that the Petitioners would not add any margin while recovering money from its customers towards port and shipping line charges;

    (iv) Upon receipt of an order from customers to transport goods from their place to persons who are mostly located in South India, the Petitioners hire a truck along with empty container for this purpose and send the same vehicle to the place/factory of customers;

    (v) Consignor undertakes responsibility of loading of goods;

    (vi) The Petitioners approach shipping lines who undertake responsibility for loading containerized good at Kandla/Mundra Port in Gujarat;

    (vii) Shipping lines looks after the containerized goods at Kandla/Mundra in Gujarat;

    (viii) Shipping lines loads containerized goods in coastal vessel at Kandla/Mundra Port in Gujarat;

    (ix) Customers/consignors give a declaration/undertaking to the Customs for coastal movement of goods and recognize the shipping lines as their authorized agents permitted to transport the containers on their behalf. Further, even under Bill of Coastal Goods issued by the Shipping Lines for coastal transportation, the details of the consignor and consignee are clearly indicated. Consignor authorizes shipping lines or its agent to sign/present/process the Bill of Coastal goods at the Customs House on behalf of them;

    (x) Shipping lines transport containerized goods from Kandla/Mundra ports to containerized port in South India;

    (xi) Shipping lines offloads containerized goods at discharge port in South India;

    (xii) Shipping lines looks after containerized goods at discharge port in South India;

    (xiii) Shipping Lines or Customers undertake responsibility of loading of containerized goods on Lorry at discharge port in South India;

    (xiv) Consignee unloads the containerized goods at the place of consignee.”

    6. It is the case of the petitioners that they provide services of transportation of goods by road; the activities of loading and unloading of goods at loading point and discharge point are undertaken by the consignor or the consignee and that the petitioners provide trucks along with its container at the factory of the customers.

    7. Based upon intelligence gathered by the second respondent that the petitioners had shown gross income in their income tax returns filed under section 194 of the Income Tax Act for the year 2012-13, but filed “Nil” ST-3 returns, the second respondent visited the office premises of the second petitioner on 11.3.2015 and recorded the statements of its Managing Director Shri Amar D. Kothari from time to time. The second respondent also visited the Rajkot Regional Unit and the Ahmedabad Zonal Unit of the third petitioner on 11.06.2015 and recorded the statement of its representative Shri Rahul B. Modi from time to time. Subsequent thereto, the impugned show cause notices dated 8.10.2015 and 30.9.2015 came to be issued to the second and third petitioners respectively. It is the case of the petitioners that the impugned show cause notices have been issued contrary to the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) and are also contrary to the circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. from time to time, which has given rise to the present petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    8. At the outset, Mr. Ankit Shah, learned senior standing counsel for the respondents No. 2 and 3 raised a preliminary objection to the very maintainability of the petition; firstly on the ground that the petition has been filed against show cause notices; and secondly, on the ground that the controversy in the present case relates to the classification of the services rendered by the petitioners and that if the show cause notices were to culminate into an order-in-original, the ultimate appeal would lie before the Supreme Court and this court would not have jurisdiction to entertain the same. It was submitted that when this court does not have the jurisdiction to decide a classification dispute while exercising appellate powers, the court should refrain from entertaining a classification dispute in the exercise of its writ jurisdiction. Reliance was placed upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Hindustan Dev. Corpn. Ltd., 1998 (100) ELT 14 (SC), for the proposition that the writ jurisdiction is not exercisable at show cause notice stage for investigating facts of classification dispute. Reliance was also placed upon the decision of a Division Bench of this court in the case of Kyori Oremin Ltd. Chief Commissioner of Customs, 2016 (337) ELT 228 (Guj.), wherein the court had placed reliance upon the decisions of the Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax v. Chhabil Dass Agarwal, (2014) 1 SCC 603, as well as in the case of Union of India v. Guwahati Carbon Ltd., 2012 (278) ELT 26 (SC), for the proposition that in view of the availability of alternative statutory remedy, particularly in the field of taxation, the court would always be slow in entertaining a writ petition. Moreover, when the question in the petition concerns classification of goods, even once the Tribunal decides the appeal, be it of the assessee of the department, further appeal would lie to the Supreme Court and not to the High court, which would be an additional ground why the court would not entertain the writ petition against the order of the adjudicating authority. It was further submitted that the petitioners have directly approached this court against a show cause notice and therefore also in the absence of any lack of jurisdiction on the part of the adjudicating authority or any other circumstances for invoking the writ jurisdiction of this court having been made out, the court may not entertain the petition and ask the petitioners to answer to the show cause notice and avail of the statutory remedy as available in law. It was, accordingly, urged that the petition deserves to be dismissed on this count alone.

    9. On the other hand, Mr. Mihir Joshi, Senior Advocate, learned counsel with Mr. Hardik Modh, learned advocate for the petitioners, submitted that the circumstances necessary for invoking the writ jurisdiction of this court are clearly made out and hence this petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India is maintainable even at the show cause notice stage. It was further submitted that it is not as if in all cases involving a classification dispute a writ petition is not maintainable before the High Court. In support of such submission the learned counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Aravali Min. & Chem. (India) Pvt. Ltd., 2000 (115) ELT 279 (SC), wherein the High Court had relied upon a publication of the Central Board of Revenue to come to the conclusion that soap-stone was the same as talc and therefore, entitled to the benefit of the concerned exemption notification. The Supreme Court held that in these circumstances, one cannot fault the High Court for having given a go-by to the alternate remedy available to the assessee. It was submitted that in the facts of the present case, the issue of classification is squarely governed by the circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. and hence, there is no bar against the High Court entertaining the petition.

    10. Reliance was also placed upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise v. Sushil & Company, 2016-TIOL-47-SC-ST, wherein the High Court had gone by the contract in question which was entered into between the respondent and M/s. Birla Corporation Ltd. and taking into consideration all the averments, which were made in the show cause notice, on the basis of admitted facts, it had come to a conclusion that even when the allegations in the show cause notice are accepted, the said contract did not amount to providing any “Cargo Handling Service” as defined under Entry 23 of section 65 of the Act. The Supreme Court was of the opinion that the High Court did not commit any mistake or illegality in entertaining the writ petition when no disputed questions of fact were involved and the legal issue was to be decided on the basis of the facts as admitted by the parties, which were so specifically recorded by the High Court itself. It was submitted that in the facts of the present case also no disputed questions of fact are involved and the legal issue is required to be decided on the basis of admitted facts and hence, this court is not precluded from exercising its jurisdiction in respect of the impugned show cause notices.

    11. Reference was also made to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Oryx Fisheries Private Limited v. Union of India, (2010) 13 SCC 427, wherein the court held thus:

    “31. It is of course true that the show cause notice cannot be read hyper technically and it is well settled that it is to be read reasonably. But one thing is clear that while reading a show cause notice, the person who is subject to it must get an impression that he will get an effective opportunity to rebut the allegations contained in the show cause notice and prove his innocence. If on a reasonable reading of a show cause notice a person of ordinary prudence gets the feeling that his reply to the show cause notice will be an empty ceremony and he will merely knock his head against the impenetrable wall of prejudged opinion, such a show cause notice does not commence a fair procedure especially when it is issued in a quasi-judicial proceeding under a statutory regulation which promises to give the person proceeded against a reasonable opportunity of defence.

    32. Therefore, while issuing a show cause notice, the authorities must take care to manifestly keep an open mind as they are to act fairly in adjudging the guilt or otherwise of the person proceeded against and specially when he has the power to take a punitive step against the person after giving him a show cause notice.”

    12. Adverting to the merits of the case, the learned counsel invited the attention of the court to the facts of the case to submit that the main activity of the petitioners is of “goods transport agency”. Reference was made to the definition of “goods transport agency” as prevailing prior to the year 2012, as defined under section 65(50)(b) of the Finance Act, which provides that “goods transport agency” means any person who provides service in relation to transport of goods by road and issues consignment note, by whatever name called. It was submitted that the definition contemplates satisfaction of three ingredients, viz., the agency must be any person; it must provide service in relation to transport of goods by road; and the agency must issue consignment note, by whatever name called.

    13. As regards the nature of the activities of the petitioners, reference was made to the memorandum of petition, wherein the activities for providing services to various customers undertaken by the members of the first petitioner association have been set out which has already been referred to hereinabove. The attention of the court was drawn to Circular No. B11/1/2002-TRU dated 1 August, 2002 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, to point out that in relation to “cargo handling services”, the Board has explained that mere transportation of goods is not covered in the category of cargo handling and is, therefore, not liable to service tax. It was pointed out that in terms of the circular, “cargo handling services” means loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and includes cargo handling services provided for freight in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight teminal, for all modes of transport, and any other service incidental to freight. The services which are liable to tax under this category are the services provided by cargo handling agencies who undertake the activity of packing, unpacking, loading and unloading of goods meant to be transported by any means of transportation, namely, truck, rail, ship or aircraft. It was submitted that insofar as the petitioner association is concerned, its members do not carry out any activity of packing or unpacking and if at all any activity of loading or unloading is undertaken, the same is merely incidental to the main activity of goods transport agency. It was pointed out that in the said circular, it has also been clarified that if the bill indicates the amount charged for cargo handling and transportation separately on actuals basis (verifiable by documentary evidence), then the tax would be leviable only on the cargo handling charges. Reference was made to a clarificatory circular being Circular No. 104/7/2008-S.T. dated 6.8.2008 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, wherein the Board has clarified that “goods transport agency” provides service to a person in relation to transportation of goods by road which is a single composite service. Goods transport agency also issues consignment note. The composite service may include various intermediate and ancillary services provided in relation to the principal service of the road transport of goods. Such intermediate and ancillary services may include services like loading/unloading, packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary warehousing etc., which are provided in the course of transportation by road. It was submitted that in view of the above circular, if a common invoice in relation to the composite service is issued, the goods transport agency would be entitled to abatement in respect of the entire transaction, whereas in the case of the petitioner association, a common invoice is not issued, and the invoice is issued only in relation to transportation of goods by road. It was submitted that even after the Finance Act came to be amended in the year 2012, and the negative list regime came to be introduced, the definition of “goods transport agency” remains the same and would therefore, be governed by the previous circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. It was submitted that even after the introduction of the negative list, vide circular No. 186/5/2015-S.T. dated 5.10.2015, the Board has clarified that the single composite service need not be broken into its components and considered as constituting separate services, if it is provided as such in the ordinary course of business; thus, a composite service, even if it consists of more than one service, should be treated as a single service based on the main or principal service; while taking a view, both the form and substance of the transaction are to be taken into account; the guiding principle is to identify the essential features of the transaction.

    14. Referring to the impugned show cause notices, it was submitted that the respondents seek to combine the services of “goods transport agency” and “cargo handling services” together which is contrary to the binding circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. It was submitted that there is no provision in law for combining two services separately invoiced, which is made further clear by the Board by the clarificatory circular dated 6.8.2008.

    15. It was submitted that the present case, therefore, falls within the exception of being contrary to the circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. and hence, the petitioners are entitled to avail of the remedy under article 226 of the Constitution against the show cause notices. Reliance was placed upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Paper Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, 1999 (112) ELT 765 (SC), wherein the Supreme Court has held that the circulars issued under section 37B of the Central Excise Act, 1994 are binding on the Department and the Department cannot be permitted to take a stand contrary to the instructions issued by the Board. Reference was made to the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the third respondent, to submit that with effect from 1.7.2012, the entire scheme of service tax has changed and the definition of “cargo handling service” has been done away with and therefore, there is no definition of “cargo handling service”, whereas the definition of “goods transport agency” continues. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the circular issued by the Board does not apply because it is a clarification in terms of the circular in the new regime. In conclusion, it was urged that the services provided by the petitioners clearly fall within the ambit of “goods transport agency” and that the impugned show cause notices being without jurisdiction as being contrary to the circulars issued by the Board from time to time as well as being contrary to the statutory provisions of law, deserve to be quashed and set aside.

    16. On the other hand, Mr. Ankit Shah, learned senior standing counsel for the respondents, submitted that with effect from 1 July, 2012, the scheme of the service tax has changed and the negative list of regime has been brought into force. It was submitted that therefore, the circulars issued prior to the amendment in the Finance Act, would not be applicable subsequent to such amendment. It was submitted that the petitioners with a view to evade payment of service tax, have split the whole transactions into three parts, that is, from the place of the consignor to Kandla/Mundra Port by road, from Kandla/Mundra Port in Gujarat to Kochi/Tuticorin Ports in South India by sea route and from Kochi/Tuticorin Ports in South India to the place of the consignee by road. It was submitted that if the petitioners had been registered under the “cargo handling services”, no abatement would have been admissible and the whole of the transaction from consignor to consignee would be covered under the taxable service, which attracts a higher rate of service tax. It was submitted that the service provided by the petitioners includes transportation by road from the place of the consignor to the ports in Gujarat where the goods are loaded and unloaded and then shipped to a port in South India from where the goods are either handed over to the consignee at the port or are transported to the place of the consignee.

    17. Reference was made to section 66F of the Finance Act which provides the principles of interpretation of specified descriptions of services or bundled services and more particularly, to sub-section (3) thereof which provides for the manner of determination of the taxability of a bundled service. Clause (b) thereof provides that if various elements of such service are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, it shall be treated as provision of the single service which results in highest liability of service tax. It was submitted that the petitioners have bundled together the service of “goods transport agency as well as “cargo handling service” and the elements of such service are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of service and, hence, the same is required to be treated as provision of the single service which results in highest liability of service tax. It was submitted that out of the services which are being bundled together by the petitioners, the service tax liability of “cargo handling service” results in highest liability and therefore, the services of the petitioners are required to be classified under the said head.

    18. Reference was made to the definition of “cargo handling service” as it stood prior to its substitution by the Finance Act, 2008 on 10.5.2008, to submit that the earlier definition provided that “cargo handling service” means loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and includes cargo handling services in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, for all modes of transport. It was submitted that thus, under the said definition, cargo handling service did not include transportation. It was submitted that with effect from 16.5.2008, the definition of cargo handling service came to be amended by including the service of packing together with transportation of cargo or goods, with or without one or more other services like loading, unloading, packing, unpacking. Thus, transportation was included as an ingredient of cargo handling services.

    19. It was submitted that once the members of the petitioners undertake the responsibility of delivery of goods from consignor to consignee and more particularly, when they are also providing cargo handling services, may be, with help from other service providers, the service provided by them would fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service” inasmuch as taking help from other service providers does not change the nature of service that is being provided by the members of the petitioner association to its clients. It was submitted that the shipping lines raise bills in the name of the petitioners and if any service tax has been charged, the petitioners are well within their rights to take Cenvat credit of the same in accordance with the rules and regulations, however, that would not change the nature of the services rendered by the petitioners from “cargo handling service” to “goods transport agent”. It was submitted that at this stage when only show cause notices have been issued to two of the petitioners, the petitioners may be asked to respond to the same, and the same shall be considered in accordance with law. However, at this stage, the court may not enter into merits of the classification dispute and render a decision one way or the other.

    11. Mr. Nirzar Desai, learned senior standing counsel for the respondent No. 1, submitted that even according to the petitioners, the issue involved in the present case is regarding classification viz., that though the service provided by the petitioners falls under the category of “goods transport agency”, such service is sought to be classified under the wrong category of “cargo handling services”. Thus, the controversy involved does relate to a classification dispute, and hence, this court, in exercise of its extraordinary writ jurisdiction under article 226 of the Constitution of India ought not to enter into the merits of such dispute and the petitioners should be asked to respond to the show cause notices, which shall be adjudicated in accordance with law.

    11.1 Reference was made to paragraph 8 of the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the first respondent, wherein the business activities of the members of the petitioner association have been set out, to submit that the petitioner companies undertake the composite responsibility of delivery of cargo from the place of consignor in Gujarat to the place of consignee in South India. From the business activities undertaken by the said companies, the nature of contract between the company and its customers and also the payment pattern, it is crystal clear that the service provided by the petitioners is cargo handling service. It was submitted that if the petitioners were supposed to provide only the service of transportation by road then the customers would not have given the charges meant for the Shipping Companies to the petitioners. It was submitted that the petitioners have artificially bifurcated the charges into various components to nullify the liability of paying the service tax on the services provided from end to end. It was reiterated that if the petitioner companies had been registered under the “cargo handling service”, no abatement would be admissible and the whole transaction from consignor to consignee would be covered under the service tax. It was, accordingly, urged that the petition being devoid of merits deserves to be dismissed.

    20. Before adverting to the merits of the rival submissions, a brief reference may be made to the facts of the case. From the facts as emerging from the record, it appears that the activities undertaken by the members of the petitioner association are that upon receipt of an order from customers to transport goods from their place to persons who are mostly located in South India, the petitioners hire a truck along with an empty container for this purpose and send the same vehicle to the place/factory of the customer/consignor. The consignor undertakes the responsibility of loading the goods. The goods are then transported to the port at Kandla/Mundra in Gujarat. For onward transport to the concerned port in South India, the petitioners approach the shipping lines which undertake the responsibility of loading the containerised goods at Kandla/Mundra Port in Gujarat. The shipping lines load the goods in the coastal vessel at the port. The customers/consignors give a declaration/undertaking to the Customs for coastal movement of goods and recognise the shipping lines as their authorized agents permitted to transport the containers on their behalf. The shipping lines transport goods to South India and off load the containerised goods at the discharge port in South India. The petitioners either transport the containerised goods to the place of the consignee where the consignee unloads the same or the consignee takes delivery of the containerised goods at the port. It is the case of the petitioners that they provide the service of transportation of goods by road. The petitioners provide trucks along with its container at the factory of the customers. The activity of loading and unloading of goods at loading point and discharge point are undertaken by the consignor or consignee respectively.

    21. Since it is the case of the respondents that the service provided by the petitioners would fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service” reference may be made to the relevant statutory provisions prior to and after 1 June, 2012. The expression “cargo handling service” was introduced with effect from 16 July, 2002 and reads thus:

    Section 65(23) “cargo handling service” means loading, unloading, packing and unpacking of cargo and includes cargo handling services provided for freight in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, for all modes of transport and cargo handling service incidental to freight, but does not include handling of export cargo or passenger cargo or mere transportation of goods.”

    22. Vide Circular: B11/1/2002-TRU dated 1.8.2002 clarifications were issued by the Board in relation of ten new services effective from 16.8.2002. Annexure II to the Circular relates to “cargo handling service” and to the extent the same is relevant for the present purpose reads thus:

    “Cargo handling service

    1. The section referred to hereinafter are the sections or clauses of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended by the Finance Act, 2002. Reference to sub-clause or clause means clause or sub-clause of section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended by the Finance Act, 2002.

    2. As per clause (21), the term “cargo handling service” means loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and includes cargo handling services provided for freight in special containers or for noncontainerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, for all modes of transport, and any other service incidental to freight, but does not include handling of export cargo or passenger baggage or mere transportation of cargo. The taxable service, as per sub-clause (zr) of clause (90), is any service provided, to any person, by a cargo handling agency in relation to cargo handling services.

    3. The services which are liable to tax under this category are the services provided by cargo handling agencies who undertake the activity of packing, unpacking, loading and unloading of goods meant to be transported by any means of transportation namely truck, rail, ship or aircraft. Well known examples of cargo handling service are services provided in relation to cargo handling by the Container Corporation of India, Airport Authority of India, Inland Container Depot, Container Freight Stations. This is only an illustrative list. There are several other firms that are engaged in the business of cargo handling services.

    3.1 The services provided in relation to export cargo and passenger baggage are excluded from tax net.

    3.2 Mere transportation of goods is not covered in the category of cargo handling and is therefore not liable to service tax.

    3.3 Cargo handling service provided in relation to storage of agricultural produce (scope of the term “agricultural produce” is given under the storage and warehousing service) or for goods meant to be stored in cold storage have been exempted from the levy of service tax. (See Notification No. 10/2002-S.T.).

    4. A point has been raised as to what would be the value of service tax in a case where transport and cargo handling service is provided in a composite manner. The measure of tax is the gross amount charged by the cargo handling agency from the customer. Therefore, if lump-sum amount is charged for both transportation and cargo handling, the tax will be payable on the entire amount. On the other hand, if the bill indicates the amount charged for cargo handling and transportation separately on actuals basis (verifiable by documentary evidence), then the tax would be leviable only on the cargo handling charges.”

    23. The expression “goods transport agency” was brought on the statute book with effect from 1 January, 2005 and reads thus:

    “Goods transport agency” means any person who provides service in relation to transport of goods by road and issues consignment note, by whatever name called.”

    24. The definition of “cargo handling service came to be substituted by the Finance Act, 2008 with effect from 16.5.2008 and reads thus:

    Section 65(23) “cargo handling service” means loading, unloading, packing and unpacking of cargo and includes-

    (a) cargo handling services provided for freight in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, all modes of transport, and cargo handling service incidental to freight; and

    (b) service of packing together with transportation of cargo or goods, with or without one or more of other services like loading, unloading, unpacking, but does not include, handling of export cargo or passenger baggage or mere transportation of goods.”

    25. Pursuant to various representations made by the All India Motor Transport Congress to the Government regarding difficulties being faced by goods transport agencies in respect of the service tax levied on goods transported by road service, the Central Board of Excise and Customs issued Circular: 104/7/2008-S.T. Dated 6 August 2008, the relevant portion whereof reads thus:

    “3. Issue: \GTA provides service to a person in relation to transportation of goods by road in a goods carriage. The service provided is a single composite service which may include various intermediary and ancillary services such as loading/unloading, packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary warehousing. For the service provided, GTA issues a consignment note and the invoice issued by the GTA for providing the said service includes the value of intermediary and ancillary services. In such a case, whether the intermediary or ancillary activities is to be treated as part of GTA service and the abatement should be extended to the charges for such intermediary or ancillary service?

    Clarification: GTA provides a service in relation to transportation of goods by road which is a single composite service. GTA also issues consignment note. The composite service may include various intermediate and ancillary services provided in relation to the principal service of the road transport of goods. Such intermediate and ancillary services may include services like loading/unloading, packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary warehousing etc., which are provided in the course of transportation by road. These services are not provided as independent activities but are the means for successful provision of the principal service, namely, the transportation of goods by road. The contention that a single composite service should not be broken into its components and classified as separate services is a well-accepted principle of classification. As clarified earlier vide F. No. 334/4/2006-TRU, dated 28-2-2006 (para 3.2 and 3.3) [2006 (4) S.T.R. C30] and F. No. 334/1/2008-TRU, dated 29-2-2008 (para 3.2 and 3.3) [2008 (9) S.T.R. C61], a composite service, even if it consists of more than one service, should be treated as a single service based on the main or principal service and accordingly classified. While taking a view, both the form and substance of the transaction are to be taken into account. The guiding principle is to identify the essential features of the transaction. The method of invoicing does not alter the single composite nature of the service and classification in such cases are based on essential character by applying the principle of classification enumerated in section 65A. Thus, if any ancillary/intermediate service is provided in relation to transportation of goods, and the charges, if any, for such services are included in the invoice issued by the GTA, and not by any other person, such service would form part of GTA service and, therefore, the abatement of 75% would be available on it.

    4. Issue 2: GTA providing service in relation to transportation of goods by road in a goods carriage also undertakes packing as an integral part of the service provided. It may be clarified whether in such cases service provided is to be classified under GTA service.

    Clarification: Cargo handling service [Section 65(105) (zr)] means loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and includes the service of packing together with transportation of cargo with or without loading, unloading and unpacking. Transportation is not the essential character of cargo handling service but only incidental to the cargo handling service. Where service is provided by a person who is registered as GTA service provider and issues consignment note for transportation of goods by road in a goods carriage and the amount charged for the service provided is inclusive of packing, then the service shall be treated as GTA service and not cargo handling service.

    5. Issue 3: Whether time sensitive transportation of goods by road in a goods carriage by a GTA shall be classified under courier service and not GTA service?

    Clarification: On this issue, it is clarified that so long as, (a) the entire transportation of goods is by road; and (b) the person transporting the goods issues a consignment note, it would be classified as ‘GTA Service’.”

    26. With effect from 1 July, 2012, a new system of taxation of service known as “Negative List of Services” came to be introduced which provided that all services except those specified in the negative list would be subject to tax. By the amendment, section 65 of the Finance Act came to be deleted and consequently the definition of “cargo handling service” stood deleted. However, a new definition of “goods transport agency” came to be introduced vide section 65B(26), which reads as under:

    “Goods transport agency means any person who provides service in relation to transport of goods by road and issues consignment note, by whatever name called.”

    27. On a conjoint reading of the definition of “goods transport agency” before and after the new regime of negative list services came to be introduced, it is amply clear that even after the introduction of the new regime, the definition of “goods transport agency” remains the same.

    28. Subsequently, another Circular: 186/5/2015-S.T. dated 5 October, 2015 came to be issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, which basically relates to entitlement to abatement. Nonetheless, to the following extent the same is relevant for the present purpose:

    “3. Goods Transport Agency (GTA) has been defined to mean any person who provides service to a person in relation to transport of goods by road and issues consignment note, by whatever name called. The service provided is a composite service which may include various ancillary services such as loading/unloading, packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary storage etc., which are provided in the course of transportation of goods by road. These ancillary services may be provided by GTA himself or may be sub-contracted by the GTA. In either case, for the service provided, GTA issues a consignment note and the invoice issued by the GTA for providing the said service includes the value of ancillary services provided in the course of transportation of goods by road. These services are not provided as independent activities but are the means for successful provision of the principal service, namely, the transportation of goods by road.

    4. A single composite service need not be broken into its components and considered as constituting separate services, if it is provided as such in the ordinary course of business. Thus, a composite service, even if it consists of more than one service, should be treated as a single service based on the main or principal service. While taking a view, both the form and substance of the transaction are to be taken into account. The guiding principle is to identify the essential features of the transaction. The interpretation of specified descriptions of services in such cases shall be based on the principle of interpretation enumerated in section 66F of the Finance Act, 1994. Thus, if ancillary services are provided in the course of transportation of goods by road and the charges for such services are included in the invoice issued by the GTA, and not by any other person, such services would form part of GTA service and, therefore, the abatement of 70%, presently applicable to GTA service, would be available on it.

    5. It is also clarified that transportation of goods by road by a GTA, in cases where GTA undertakes to reach/deliver the goods at destination within a stipulated time, should be considered as ‘services of goods transport agency in relation to transportation of goods’ for the purpose of Notification No. 26/2012-S.T, dated 20-6-2012, serial number 7, so long as (a) the entire transportation of goods is by road; and (b) the GTA issues a consignment note, by whatever name called.”

    29. The facts of the case are required to be examined, in the light of the Circulars issued by the Board and the statutory provisions as prevailing prior to and after 2012 when the negative list regime was brought into force.

    30. The record of the case shows that the petitioners issue invoice in favour of the consignor together with a consignment note. The invoices annexed along with the petitioners show that the service tax component is at the rate of 12% on road freight. The petitioners issue debit notes to the consignor towards the amount debited to his account towards reimbursement of sea-freight. The shipping lines in turn issues invoice in favour of the petitioners which shows that the service tax component is at the rate of 12% on ocean freight. A consignment declaration is issued by the consignor in favour of an agency for processing the bill of coastal goods, etc.

    31. From the nature of the services rendered by the petitioners as emerging from the record, in essence and substance, the contract is a contract for transport of goods from the place of the consignor to the place of the consignee or to the port in South India from where the consignee picks up the goods. The petitioners do not carry on any activity of packing and unpacking of goods. Insofar as loading and unloading of goods is concerned, the consignor loads the goods into the container and the consignee unloads the same. It is only when the container reaches the port that it has to be unloaded and loaded on the ship, which is done by the shipping company or a cargo handling agency, which renders such services to the petitioners who act on behalf of the customers. Thereafter, the container containing the goods is shipped to the concerned port in South India, where the shipping company unloads it and the goods are thereafter transported to the place of the consignee by the petitioners or the consignee takes the goods at the port itself. Therefore, insofar as the service of loading and unloading at the port and shipping of goods from one port to the other is concerned, the petitioners are the recipients of such service from the shipping line and/or the cargo handling service on behalf of the customers.

    32. Thus, while the petitioners provide transport service from the consignor's place to the port in Gujarat and from the port in South India to the consignee's place, once the goods reach the port in Gujarat till they are unloaded at the port in South India, the petitioners avail services from other service providers on behalf of the customers for which they do not charge them anything. The petitioners issue invoice to the customers only in respect of the transport of goods from the place of consignor to the port in Gujarat and from the port in South India to the place of the consignee, if the consignee does not take delivery of goods at the port itself. Insofar as the service rendered by the shipping line is concerned, the shipping line issues invoice in favour of the petitioners, who in turn issue a debit note to the customer without adding any charge in respect of such service.

    33. The expression “cargo handling service” was defined prior to the 2012. As per the definition of “cargo handling service” as it stood prior to 16.5.2008, “cargo handling service” essentially meant loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo for all modes of transport and cargo handling service incidental to freight. After 16.5.2008, the definition of “cargo handling service” came to be expanded by including “service of packing together with transportation of cargo or goods, with or without one or more of other services like loading, unloading, unpacking. Thus, prior to 16.5.2008, cargo handling service meant only loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo for all mode transport and cargo handling service incidental to freight whereas with effect from 16.5.2008, for the first time transportation came to be brought within the ambit of cargo handling service, which however was limited to the service of packing together with transportation of cargo or goods, with or without one or more of other services like loading, unloading, unpacking. Thus, insofar as transportation is concerned, the same was included within the definition of cargo handling service only in conjunction with packing. The other services like loading, unloading and unpacking were only ancillary to the main function of packing together with transportation. Thus, if transportation is to be included in cargo handling service, packing is an essential ingredient of the same. In other words if there is transportation of goods/cargo without the essential element of packing it would not fall within the ambit of cargo handling service.

    34. In the facts of the present case, while the petitioners provide the service of transportation, they do not provide any service of packing which is an essential ingredient of “cargo handling service” when transportation is a component thereof. It is the case of the respondents that the petitioners provide service of “cargo handling service” because they provide the service of loading and unloading at the ports. Insofar as the definition of “cargo handling service” as it stood prior to 16.5.2008 is concerned, transportation of goods/cargo did not fall within its ambit as it included only loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo for all modes of transport. However, in terms of the definition of “cargo handling service” as amended with effect from 16.5.2008, transportation was brought within its ambit, but only when transportation was in conjunction with packing (packing being the principal element) that it amounted to “cargo handling service”. Mere transportation with any of the other services like loading, unloading and unpacking does not fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service”. Moreover, insofar as the petitioners are concerned, such services are merely ancillary to the main service provided by the petitioners, viz. transport of goods by road. Besides, even the service of loading and unloading is not provided by the petitioners, but by the shipping lines to the petitioners on behalf of the customers in respect of which the shipping line pays service tax as applicable.

    35. Thus, even if the petitioners had not split up the transaction into three parts, viz. transportation by road, then unloading and loading at port and transportation by sea, followed by unloading and loading at the port and transportation by road, the transaction would not fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service” as defined under the Finance Act, 1994 as it stood prior to and after 16.5.2008 inasmuch as the petitioners do not provide the service of packing together with transportation. Insofar as the period after the negative list regime came into force is concerned, the definition of “cargo handling service” stands deleted and is no longer on the statute book. The respondents, however, appear to be categorizing such service on the basis of the definition of such service as it stood prior to the introduction of the negative list regime. Therefore, even if “cargo handling service” is considered in terms of the earlier definitions, the service provided by the petitioners would not fall within its ambit.

    36. Insofar as “goods transport agency” is concerned, as noticed earlier the definition continues to be the same even after the introduction of the negative list regime. In relation to “goods transport agency” the Central Board of Excise and Customs has issued clarificatory circulars both, before and after the introduction of the negative list regime. In terms of the circular dated 6 August, 2008 “goods transport agency” provides a service in relation to transportation of goods by road which is a single composite service and also issues consignment note. The composite service may include various intermediate and ancillary services provided in relation to the principal service of the road transport of goods. Such intermediate and ancillary services may include services like loading/unloading packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary warehousing etc., which are provided in the course of transportation by road. These services are not provided as independent activities but are the means for successful provision of the principal service, namely, the transportation of goods by road. Insofar as the petitioners are concerned, the principal service provided by them is of road transport of goods. However, since delivery from the consignor to consignee also includes transportation by sea, the petitioners avail of services from other service providers on behalf of the customer in respect of which the service provider issues an invoice in favour of the petitioners and the petitioners issue a debit note in favour of the customer. The service providers from whom the petitioners avail intermediary services on behalf of the customers are mainly the shipping lines which provide the service of unloading and loading at the port in Gujarat, shipping of the cargo to the concerned port in South India and unloading and loading of the goods on the vehicle for transportation to the consignee (if the consignee does not take delivery at the port). In respect of the services provided by the service provider, the petitioners do not charge anything nor is the amount charged by the service provider included in the invoice issued to the customer. The customer does pay the charges payable to the service provider (shipping line) to the petitioners, but under a debit note and not under an invoice. Therefore, in the entire process of transportation of goods from the consignor to the consignee there are two service providers involved. Firstly, the petitioners who provide the service of “goods transport agency” to the customer and secondly, the shipping line which provides service to the petitioners on behalf of the customer. Pertinently, neither the service provided by the petitioners nor by the shipping line includes any element of packing, which is a necessary ingredient for falling within the ambit of “cargo handling service” when transportation is one of the elements of such service. Therefore, even if it were to be held that it is the petitioners who are providing the services covered in entire transaction, no part of the transaction falls within the ambit of “cargo handling service” as envisaged under the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended from time to time. Therefore, the contention of the respondents that the service provided by the petitioners fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service” is misconceived.

    37. Moreover, the circular dated 6 August, 2008 provides that a composite service, even if it consists of more than one service, should be treated as a single service based on the main or principal service and accordingly classified. While taking a view, both the form and substance of the transaction are to be taken into account. The guiding principle is to identify the essential features of the transaction. The method of invoicing does not alter the single composite nature of the service and classification in such cases is based on essential character by applying the principle of classification enumerated in section 65A. Thus, if any ancillary/intermediate service is provided in relation to transportation of goods, and the charges, if any, for such services are included in the invoice issued by the GTA, and not by any other person, such service would form part of GTA service and, therefore, the abatement of 75% would be available on it. Thus, in terms of the circular, if any ancillary services are provided by the goods transport agency and such services are included in the invoice, the goods transport agency would be entitled to 75% abatement on the entire transaction. In the facts of the present case, the principal service provided by the petitioners is of transportation of goods by road and they issue invoice insofar as the component of transportation by road is concerned. If the petitioners had been providing the other services like loading/unloading, packing/unpacking, transshipment, temporary warehousing etc. and included the same in the invoice, in terms of the above circular, they would have been entitled to 75% abatement in respect of the entire amount. Insofar as issue 3 in the circular, on which reliance has been placed on behalf of the respondents is concerned, the same is a clarification as regards whether the service should be classified under courier service or GTA in respect of which it has been clarified that so long as, (a) the entire transportation of goods is by road; and (b) the person transporting the goods issues a consignment note, it would be classified as ‘GTA Service’. Moreover, the circular has to be read as a whole and the clarification on issue 3 cannot be read to mean that in case of GTA service the entire transportation of goods has to be by road, without taking into consideration the earlier part of the circular which provides for a single composite service wherein transportation of goods by road is the principal activity.

    38. On behalf of the respondents the learned senior standing counsel have placed strong reliance on the provisions of section 66F of the Finance Act, which as it stood prior to its amendment by Finance Act, 2015, reads thus:

    66-F. Principles of interpretation of specified descriptions of services or bundled services.-(1) Unless otherwise specified, reference to a service (herein referred to as main service) shall not include reference to a service which is used for providing main service.

    (2) Where a service is capable of differential treatment for any purpose based on its description, the most specific description shall be preferred over a more general description.

    (3) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (2), the taxability of a bundled service shall be determined in the following manner, namely-

    (a) if various elements of such service are naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, it shall be treated as provision of the single service which gives such bundle its essential character;

    (b) if various elements of such service are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, it shall be treated as provision of the single service which results in highest liability of service tax.

    Explanation.-For the purposes of sub-section (3), the expression “bundled service” means a bundle of provision of various services wherein an element of provision of one service is combined with an element or elements of provision of any other service or services.

    39. On behalf of the respondents, the learned senior standing counsel has submitted that in view of the provisions of sub-section (3) of section 66F of the Finance Act, the taxability of a bundled service is required to be determined in the manner provided there under. It was submitted that under clause (b) of sub-section (3) of section 66F, if various elements of such service are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, it shall be treated as provision of the single service which results in highest liability of service. It was submitted that in the present case, the service provided by the petitioners to their customers contain various elements which are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, and hence the same is required to be treated as provision of the single service which results in highest tax liability of service, viz. “cargo handling service” and the tax liability of the petitioners is required to be determined accordingly.

    40. A plain reading of section 66F of the Finance Act, shows that sub-section (1) thereof provides that unless otherwise specified, reference to service shall not include reference to a service which is used for providing main service. Sub-section (2) of section 66F, where a service is capable of differential treatment for any purpose based on its description, the most specific description shall be preferred over a more general description. In this regard, on behalf of the petitioners, it has been submitted that under sub-section (2) of section 66F, the most specific description of a service is to be preferred over a more general description. Therefore, in the facts of the present case, when the petitioners satisfy the ingredients of the “goods transport agency” as defined under the Finance Act, there is no question of placing the petitioners under the amorphous category of “cargo handling service” which is no longer defined under that Act. In the opinion of this court, there is substance in the argument of the petitioners, inasmuch as on a plain reading of sub-section (2) of section 66F of the Act it is amply clear that if a service meets with a specific description, such specific description has to be given a preference over a general description. In the present case, when the service provided by the petitioner falls within the specific description of “goods transport agency”, the same has to be given preference over the general description of cargo handling service, which is not defined under the Finance Act after the introduction of the negative list regime. Insofar as the period prior to the introduction of the negative list regime is concerned, “cargo handling service” was defined under section 65(23) of the Finance Act. As discussed hereinabove, by no means can any part of the service rendered by the petitioners either directly or through other service providers falls within the ambit of such definition. Under the circumstances, the question of classifying such services as “cargo handling service” would not arise at all.

    41. Insofar as the applicability of sub-section (3) of section 66F of the Finance Act is concerned, the same is applicable where taxability of bundled service is involved. The expression “bundled service” has been defined under the Explanation to sub-section (3) of section 66F to mean a bundle of provision of various services where an element of provision of one service is combined with an element or elements of provision of any other service of services. In the opinion of this court, the question of bundling services would arise where more than one kind of taxable service is rendered by a service provider as part of the same transaction. In the present case, insofar as the petitioners are concerned, the only service provided by them is as “goods transport agency”. Insofar as the remaining services are concerned, such services are provided by other service providers to the petitioners on behalf of the customers. In the opinion of this court, the learned counsel for the petitioners is wholly justified in contending that the services rendered by different service providers cannot be bundled together and that it is only if the same service provider provides different services which are not naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business, that resort can be made to the provision of sub-section (3) of section 66F of the Finance Act for the purpose of considering the taxability of the bundled services. Besides, as discussed hereinabove, no part of the services rendered by the petitioners to the customers, either directly or through other service providers falls within the ambit of “cargo handling service”. Therefore, the proposal to levy service tax on the petitioners by categorizing such services as “cargo handling service” is without any legal basis. Consequently, even if the service provided by the shipping line is considered to be service provided by the petitioner and bundled together, it would still not attract liability of service tax in the category of “cargo handling service”.

    42. At this juncture, reference may be made to the impugned show cause notice dated 8.10.2015. The main ground for issuance of the show cause notice is that if the petitioner companies had been registered under the category of “cargo handling service”, no abatement would have been admissible and the whole transaction from consignor to consignee would be covered under the taxable service. In the light of the above discussion, considering the nature of the services rendered by the petitioners even in terms of the show cause notice, the same do not fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service” and therefore, the question of considering the entire transaction as a cargo handling service would not arise.

    43. In the facts of the present case, apart from the fact that the main activity of the petitioners is transportation by road and no cargo handling service activities are carried out by them, even if for the sake of assumption the services rendered by the shipping lines were to be considered as the services rendered by the petitioners, the essential character of the services rendered by the petitioners, viz., goods transport agency, would not be lost. If all the ancillary activities are attributed to the petitioners, then in view of the circulars dated 6 August, 2008 and 5 October, 2015, by including such services in the invoice the petitioners could have claimed abatement qua the entire transaction, which would result in payment of lesser taxes than those collected by the respondents on account of splitting up of the transaction into three parts. Therefore, the allegation that the exercise has been carried out to evade payment of service tax is without any substance.

    44. Significantly, it is nobody's case that any part of the transaction has gone untaxed. Insofar as the “goods transport agency” component is concerned, the tax is paid by the customers on reverse charge basis and insofar as the component of shipping by sea is concerned, the shipping line pays the service tax thereon. What the respondents, however, want is to tax the entire transaction in the hands of the petitioners on the ground that the entire transaction amounts to “cargo handling service” which would fetch a higher rate of tax. At the cost of repetition it is stated that having regard to the definition of “cargo handling service” as defined prior to the introduction of negative list, no part of the transaction falls within the ambit of “cargo handling service. Moreover, the above referred circulars dated 6 August, 2008 (prior to the introduction of the negative list regime) and 5 October, 2015 (issued after the introduction of the negative tax regime) clarify that as single composite service need not be broken into its components and considered as constituting separate services, if it is provided as such in the ordinary course of business. Thus, a composite service, even if it consists of more than one service, should be treated as a single service based on the main or principal service. In the case of the petitioners, if the entire transaction is considered to be a single composite service, even then, in terms of the circulars such composite service is required to be treated as a single service based on the main and principal service, which in the case of the petitioners is “goods transport agency”. Under the circumstances, in view of the binding circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, the service rendered by the petitioners has to be considered on the basis of the main service provided by them, viz. “goods transport agency” and it is not permissible for the respondents to take a stand contrary to such circulars. Besides, the circular dated 1 August, 2002 which relates to “cargo handling service” clearly provides that mere transportation of goods is not covered in the category of cargo handling service and therefore, is not liable to service tax under the said heading.

    45. A perusal of the impugned show cause notices show that the same propose to levy service tax on the petitioners in the category of “cargo handling service”, which is clearly contrary to the above referred circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. from time to time and are also contrary to the very basic definition of “cargo handling service” as it stood prior to 2012. The impugned show cause notices relate to the period prior to 2012 as well as post 2012, both of which periods are covered by the circulars issued by the C.B.E.C. in the context of “goods transport agency service”.

    46. In the impugned show cause notices, in paragraph 9.2.7.2, it has been stated that necessity of law for taxation under the class “cargo handling service” is that the service provided should be relating to or in relation to cargo handling by a cargo handling agency. The service provided should be integrally or inseparably connected wth handling of cargo or attributable thereto without being a mere activity of transportation of such cargo since transport service independent of cargo handling is an exception under the scheme of levy by section 65(23) of the Act and it may be said that loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and handling of cargo for freight in special containers or non-containerized freight and service provided by container freight terminal or other freight terminal for all modes of transport are subject matter of taxation under the class “cargo handling service”. That apart, any activity incidental to freight of cargo is also liable to be taxed under such class. Mode of transport is irrelevant for incidence of levy once the service provided meets the test of handling of cargo in the manner as envisaged by law. It also appears that it is not necessary that the cargo should only be meant for transport either by vessel in ships or aircrafts.

    47. In clause 9.2.7.3 thereof, it has been observed that for the period prior to 1.7.2012, the service being provided by M/s. Yamuna Shipping which includes arranging for vehicles/containers, loading of goods at the place of consignor in Gujarat by them, transportation of containerized cargo to Mundra Port, Gujarat; unloading of containerized cargo at Mundra Port; handling of containerized cargo at Mundra Port including payment of various port charges, loading of containerized cargo in coastal vessel by shipping companies on behalf of them transportation by sea route, unloading and handling of containerized cargo at Kochi/Tuticorin Ports by shipping companies on behalf of them; transportation of containerized cargo from Kochi/Tuticorin Ports to the place of consignee and delivery of empty containers to the shipping companies after the goods are unloaded at the place of consignee may not be classified as goods transport agency rather it may be suitably classified under “cargo handling services”.

    48. In the opinion of this court, the entire show cause notice is based upon a fallacious premise that even if the service provided by the petitioners is mainly goods transport agency, even if any ancillary service of loading or unloading is provided, the transaction would fall within the ambit of cargo handling service.

    49. In the show cause notice in clause 9.4.3, it has been stated that M/s. Yamuna Shipping is not providing the service of mere transportation so as to make itself eligible to be covered under goods transport agency, but, it is providing “cargo handling services” prior to 1.7.2012 and after 1.7.2012, it is providing service, the main purpose of which is the delivery of cargo from the place of consignor in Gujarat to the place of consignee in South India (i.e. customer). Thus, even in terms of the show cause notice, the main purpose of the petitioners is to deliver cargo to the place of consignor in Gujarat to the place of consignee in South India, which in effect and substance is the transportation of goods and not cargo handling service.

    50. In the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the respondents, it has been stated that once the company undertakes the responsibility of delivery of goods from consignor to consignee and more particularly when the company is providing service, may be, with the help of other service providers but taking help from other service providers does not change the nature of the service being provided by the aforesaid companies to its clients. Thus, even according to the respondents certain services are not provided by the petitioners directly, but are provided to the customers with the help of other service providers. If certain services are provided by other service providers, they would be discharging the service tax liability on such service. Therefore, once the service provider has paid service tax on the service provided by it, the question of taxing such service once again in the hands of the petitioners would not arise as the same would amount to taxing the same transaction twice.

    51. In the light of the above discussion, it is evident that the impugned show cause notices are contrary to the binding circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs from time to time. Under the circumstances, the petitioners are entitled to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this court. The contention that this petition would not lie against a show cause notice, therefore, does not merit acceptance. Besides, the petition does not involve any disputed question of fact and a legal issue is required to be decided on the basis of such facts and binding circulars issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, therefore, it is permissible for this court to entertain the writ petition against a show cause notice. As held by the Supreme Court in Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise v. Sushil & Company (supra) when the petition does not involve disputed questions of fact and a legal issue is required to be decided on the basis of the facts as admitted by the parties, it is permissible for the High Court to entertain a writ petition. In the said case also the question involved was whether the contract amounted to providing any “cargo handling service” and the Supreme Court held that the High Court did not commit any mistake or illegality in entertaining the writ petition when no disputed question of fact were involved and legal issues were to be decided on the basis of facts. The decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Hindustan Dev. Corporation (supra) on which reliance has been placed by the learned counsel for the respondents would not be applicable to the facts of the present case inasmuch as this court is not required to undertake any onerous duty of adjudicating upon any question involving investigation of available facts. Insofar as the decision of this court in Kyori Oremin Ltd. v. Chief Commissioner of Customs (supra) is concerned, the said decision is distinguishable on facts inasmuch as in that case the subject matter of challenge before this court was an order-in-original against which there is a statutory remedy by way of an appeal, whereas the present petition is directed against show cause notices against which the petitioners do not have any remedy except by way of a writ petition. Under the circumstances, the contention that the present petition raises a classification dispute and therefore it is not permissible for this court to entertain the same, does not merit acceptance.

    52. In the opinion of this court, even if the facts as stated in the show cause notices are considered to be true and correct, the services rendered by the petitioners would still not fall within the category of “cargo handling service” as envisaged under section 65(23) of the Finance Act prior to the coming into force of the negative list in the year 2012. From the tenor of the show cause notice, even subsequent to the introduction of the negative list regime, the respondents continue to attribute the same meaning to the expression “cargo handling service”, therefore, whether it be in relation to the period prior to or after the negative list regime, the services rendered by the petitioners would not fall within the ambit of “cargo handling service”. Under the circumstances, no useful purpose would be served in relegating the petitioners to the adjudicating authority for adjudication of show cause notices which have no legal basis. The impugned show cause notices being contrary to the legal provisions as well as to the above referred circulars issued by the Board, therefore, cannot be sustained.

    53. For the foregoing reasons, the petition succeeds and is, accordingly, allowed. The impugned show cause notices dated 8.10.2015 and 30.9.2015 (Annexure “M” and “N” respectively) are hereby quashed and set aside. Rule is made absolute accordingly, with no order as to costs.

    54. For the reasons recorded hereinabove as regards the maintainability of the petition, Civil Application No. 2952 of 2017 filed by the respondents raising a preliminary contention as regards the maintainability of the petition fails, and is hereby rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Coastal Container Tr... v. Union Of India And A...
    (Dec 18, 2017)