AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 69 of the Finance Act, 1994
  • Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 69 of the Finance Act, 1994
  • Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Act
Smart Summary

Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent–assessee held two Certificates of Registration under the Finance Act, 1994: one dated 29-10-2004 for “Business Auxiliary Service” and another effective from 1-7-2005 for “Manpower Recruitment Agency.” During an audit of M/s Birla Corporation Ltd. covering August 2003–January 2005, the appellant Department examined a contract between Birla Corporation and the respondent. Based on a statement from the respondent’s officer, Kailash Sharma, the Department believed the respondent was supplying labour for packing, loading and unloading, thereby providing taxable “Cargo Handling Service.” A show-cause notice alleging service-tax evasion was issued.

The respondent challenged the notice by writ petition (Civil Writ No. 5286 of 2005), asserting it only supplied labour and that no cargo handling was performed. The High Court accepted this contention and quashed the notice. The Department appealed the High Court’s judgment, giving rise to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in entertaining the writ petition despite the availability of the statutory adjudicatory and appellate machinery under the Finance Act, 1994.
  2. Whether the respondent’s contract for supplying manpower to M/s Birla Corporation Ltd. constituted “Cargo Handling Service” within the meaning of Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994, thereby attracting service tax.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant Department’s Arguments

  • The High Court should not have bypassed the statutory adjudicatory framework and entertained a writ petition at the show-cause notice stage.
  • The respondent’s activities amounted to “Cargo Handling Service” because labour was supplied for packing, loading and unloading tasks, and separate bills were raised to evade service tax.

Respondent Assessee’s Arguments

  • The contract merely involved supply of labour; actual packing, loading and unloading were performed by automatic machines, not by the supplied workers.
  • Reliance on J & J Enterprises v. CCE (2006) 3 STR 355 (Tri) and Departmental Circular F. No. B11/1/2002-TRU (01-08-2002) clarifying that individuals or entities supplying labour alone are not liable for service tax as cargo handling agencies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
J & J Enterprises v. CCE (2006) 3 STR 355 (Tri.) Supply of labour, without independent involvement in loading, unloading, packing or unpacking, does not amount to “Cargo Handling Service.” The Court referred to this case—and the accompanying Departmental clarification—to reinforce that the respondent’s manpower supply was outside the scope of Entry 23.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Addressing the preliminary objection, the Court held that the High Court was correct in exercising writ jurisdiction because the case involved no disputed facts; only a pure question of law concerning the statutory definition of “Cargo Handling Service.”

On the substantive issue, the Court analysed Entry 23 of Section 65, noting the High Court’s two-pronged test:

  1. The presence of “cargo,” i.e., goods accepted by a transporter for movement from one destination to another; and
  2. Independent involvement of the service provider in loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of that cargo.

Examining the contract and the statement of the respondent’s officer, the Court observed:

  • The respondent’s obligation was confined to supplying manpower for various tasks “as per the customer’s requirement” within the factory premises.
  • Actual loading, unloading, packing and unpacking of cement bags were performed by automatic machines; workers supplied by the respondent were not assigned these activities.

Because the respondent neither handled “cargo” as defined nor independently provided loading/unloading services, the Court concluded that the statutory elements of “Cargo Handling Service” were absent. The Department’s own circular further undermined its position, expressly excluding mere labour supply from the tax net.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Court affirmed the High Court’s decision that the respondent’s services do not constitute “Cargo Handling Service,” and consequently no service tax is payable.

Implications: The decision confirms that the mere supply of manpower, absent independent loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo, does not fall within Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994. It also underscores that writ jurisdiction may be invoked where only questions of law based on undisputed facts are involved, even at the show-cause notice stage.

    The Deputy Commissioner, Central Excise & Anr. (S) v. Sushil & Company (S)

    Order

    1. The respondent assessee herein is the holder of a Certificate of Registration in Form ST2 under Section 69 of the Finance Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). This Certificate was given to him on 29-10-2004 under the category “Business Auxiliary Service”. The respondent also obtained registration as “Manpower Recruitment Agency” under the Act with effect from 1-7-2005.

    2. During the course of audit of accounts of M/s Birla Corpn. Ltd. for the period August 2003 to January 2005, the appellant Department found that the said company had entered into a contract with the respondent assessee. After taking possession of a copy of this contract, the officer of the respondent assessee, namely, one Kailash Sharma was examined. On the basis of the statement given by him, the Department took a prima facie view that the contract was for the purpose of packing, loading and unloading, etc. of the goods, for which labour was supplied by the respondent to M/s Birla Corpn. Ltd. On this basis, a show-cause notice was issued to the respondent assessee alleging that the respondent was a service provider and, by clever means, it was a modus operandi to evade service tax as it was raising two separate bills for the same work i.e. in one bill, the respondent was charging the amount of payments made to labour and by another bill, other expenses were raised and in this manner, service tax was not paid. The show-cause notice further alleged that the aforesaid alleged services provided by the respondent to its customers amounted to “Cargo Handling Service”, on which the respondent was liable to pay service tax.

    3. The respondent challenged this show-cause notice by filing a writ petition in the High Court, inter alia, contending that no services were provided by the respondent by entering into the aforesaid contract, as it was only supplying labour and the labour was not doing any work of packing, unpacking, loading and unloading of any cargo. The High Court, by the impugned judgment Civil Writ No. 5286 of 2005, has accepted the plea of the respondent, resulting into allowing the writ petition and quashing the show-cause notice. It is this judgment of the High Court, the validity of which is questioned by the appellant Department in the present appeal.

    4. Before coming to the issue at hand, we may record the statement of Mr A.K. Sanghi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant Department, that it was not appropriate for the High Court to deal with the said writ petition, bypassing the adjudicatory machinery provided under the Act, more so when the statutory appeals against the adjudication orders are also provided. However, we find that the High Court has simply gone by the contract in question, which was entered into between the respondent and M/s Birla Corpn. Ltd. and taking into consideration all the averments, which were made in the show-cause notice, on the basis of admitted facts, it has come to a conclusion that even when the allegations in the show-cause notice are accepted, the said contract does not amount to providing any “Cargo Handling Service” as defined under Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Act. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the High Court did not commit any mistake or illegality in entertaining the writ petition when no disputed questions of fact were involved and the legal issue was to be decided on the basis of the facts, as admitted by the parties, which were so specifically recorded by the High Court itself.

    5. Coming to the issue as to whether the contract in question, whereby labour is supplied by the respondent to M/s Birla Corpn. Ltd., could be treated as “Cargo Handling Service” within the meaning of Entry 23 of Section 65 of the Act. This Entry reads as under:

    “65. (23) “cargo handling service” means loading, unloading, packing or unpacking of cargo and includes cargo handling services provided for freight in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, for all modes of transport and cargo handling services incidental to freight, but does not include handling of export cargo or passenger baggage or mere transportation of goods;”

    6. The High Court, on the interpretation of the aforesaid Entry 23, has observed that two conditions for considering any service to be “Cargo Handling Service” need to be satisfied, namely:

    (1) there must be a cargo i.e. a packed or unpacked commodity accepted by a transporter or carrier for carrying the same from one destination to another. It is only after the commodity becomes a cargo, its loading and unloading at the freight terminal for being transported by any mode becomes a cargo handling service, if it is provided by an independent agency and;
    (2) the service provider must independently be involved in loading-unloading or packing-unpacking of the cargo.

    The aforesaid meaning given by the High Court while interpreting Entry 23 of Section 65 is perfectly in order and justified. On that basis, we have to see whether the twin conditions mentioned therein are satisfied in the present case or not.

    7. We find from the record that in the instant case, as per the contract entered into between the respondent and the customer, namely, M/s Birla Corpn. Ltd., the respondent was to supply manpower for working at the packing plant as per the customer's requirement. The respondent contractor was to ensure that manpower deployed on the work given by customer's officers is executed properly, diligently, uninterruptedly and to the satisfaction of the customer in the factory premises of its works.

    8. It is significant to note that no part of loading or unloading was assigned to the workers of the respondent assessee up to transportation of the cement bags out of the factory. This work was, in fact, being performed by the automatic machines. It is through these automatic machines, the cement bags were loaded, unloaded, packed or unpacked and this included Cargo Handling Services provided for freight in special containers or for non-containerised freight, services provided by a container freight terminal or any other freight terminal, for all modes of transport and Cargo Handling Service incidental to freight, but does not include handling of export cargo or passenger baggage or mere transportation of goods.

    9. On the reading of the aforesaid contract, coupled with the statement of Mr Kailash Sharma, an officer of the respondent Company, the High Court has rightly concluded that the aforesaid services would not fall within the definition of “Cargo Handling Services”.

    10. Mr Kavin Gulati, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent assessee, has drawn our attention to a judgment of the Delhi Bench of the Tribunal in J&J Enterprises v. CCE (2006) 3 STR 355 (Tri). In this judgment, almost similar services provided by the assessee were held not to be “Cargo Handling Services”. In arriving at such a conclusion, the Tribunal had referred to the clarificatory instructions, being F.No. B11/1/2002-TRU dated 1-8-2002 and the relevant portion therein was extracted at paras 3 and 15. These paragraphs read as under:

    “3. The services which are liable to tax under this category are the services provided by cargo handling agencies who undertake the activity of packing, unpacking, loading and unloading of goods meant to be transported by any means of transportation, namely, truck, rail, ship or aircraft. Well-known examples of cargo handling service are services provided in relation to cargo handling by the Container Corpn. of India, Airports Authority of India, Inland Container Depot, Container Freight Stations. This is only an illustrative list. There are several other firms that are engaged in the business of cargo handling services.
    ***
    15. Another doubt raised in relation to cargo handling services is that whether individuals undertaking the activity of loading or unloading of cargo would be leviable to service tax. For example, if someone hires labour/labourer for loading or unloading of goods in their individual capacity, whether he would be liable to service tax as a cargo handling agency. It is clarified that such activities will not come under the purview of service tax as a cargo handling agency.”

    The aforesaid clarification given by the Department itself negates the case of the Department insofar as the facts of this case are concerned.

    11. We, therefore, uphold the conclusion of the High Court that services provided by the respondent assessee did not amount to Cargo Handling Services and, therefore, no such service tax was leviable. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Deputy Commissioner, Central Excise & Anr. (S) v. Sushil & Company (S)
    (Apr 13, 2016)