Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1195
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 4/10 of the U.P. Protection of Trees in Rural and Hill Areas Act, 1976.5.
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (Annexure II).13. Khasra
  • FOREST CONSERVATION ACT 1980
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1195
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 4/10 of the U.P. Protection of Trees in Rural and Hill Areas Act, 1976.5.
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (Annexure II).13. Khasra
  • FOREST CONSERVATION ACT 1980
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a journalist and Editor of the Hindi newspaper “Jan Lok Kesari”, filed Original Application (OA) No. 626 of 2016 before the National Green Tribunal (NGT) alleging large-scale tree felling and blasting by private respondents (Respondents 4-8, later renumbered) in Patti Dhamnsu, Narendranagar, District Tehri Garhwal, Uttarakhand. The disputed parcels were Khasra Nos. 512, 513, 514 and 605.

The NGT ordered successive site inspections—first by the Forest Survey of India (FSI) on 1-5-2017 and later by a Regional Office team of the Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change (MoEF&CC) on 5-1-2019. After considering the reports, the NGT, by judgment dated 5-4-2019, held that:

  • Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 are “private forest” attracting the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (FCA).
  • Khasra No. 605 is non-forest (banjar) land to which the FCA does not apply.

The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court, contending principally that Khasra No. 605 is a “deemed forest” and that the NGT erred in exempting it from the FCA.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Khasra No. 605 qualifies as a “forest” or “deemed forest” so as to attract the provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.
  2. Whether the National Green Tribunal correctly relied on revenue records and the MoEF&CC inspection report while rejecting the contrary findings of the Forest Survey of India.
  3. Whether the NGT’s unchallenged directions regarding violations in Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 required further implementation by the State authorities.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Khasra No. 605 is a deemed forest under the principle in T.N. Godavarman (1997) 2 SCC 267; hence the FCA applies.
  • Google Earth imagery (2007–2014) and the 2017 FSI report show progressive loss of dense vegetation due to illegal construction.
  • Oak and Kukat trees were felled without statutory clearance; therefore, all constructions are liable to demolition following M.C. Mehta (Kant Enclave) (2018) 18 SCC 397 and Kerala State CZMA (2019) 7 SCC 248.

Respondent 9 (Mahananda Spa & Resorts Pvt. Ltd.)

  • The relevant land (Khasra No. 605/1) is recorded as banjar (barren) land; it is neither reserved nor private forest.
  • Initial built-up area (13,983.67 sq m) did not trigger environmental clearance; upon expansion to 32,686 sq m, environment clearance was duly obtained on 3-3-2016 after inspection by the State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority.
  • No trees were felled and no blasting occurred; all construction approvals and sanctions remain unchallenged.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India, (1997) 2 SCC 267 “Forest” must be understood in its dictionary sense; FCA applies to all forests irrespective of ownership. Relied upon by the appellant; Court acknowledged but found revenue records decisive for Khasra 605.
T.N. Godavarman (WP (C) No. 202/1995), (1997) 8 SCC 191 FCA applies to all lands recorded as forest in revenue records. Supreme Court used this principle to conclude FCA does not apply where the land (Khasra 605) is recorded as banjar.
T.N. Godavarman, (2006) 5 SCC 28 Identification of deemed forest by Forest Department. MoEF&CC inspection noted Khasra 605 was never treated as deemed forest in that report; Court accepted this.
M.C. Mehta (Kant Enclave matters) v. Union of India, (2018) 18 SCC 397 Unauthorised constructions in ecologically sensitive areas are liable to demolition. Cited by appellant; Court did not apply because construction had requisite approvals and FCA was held inapplicable.
Kerala State Coastal Zone Management Authority v. State of Kerala, (2019) 7 SCC 248 Demolition mandated for constructions lacking statutory clearance. Same as above—mentioned by appellant, not adopted by the Court.
Noida Memorial Complex Near Okhla Bird Sanctuary, In re, (2011) 1 SCC 744 Old revenue records deserve due weight in determining forest status. Court relied on this to give primacy to the 1938 revenue records showing Khasra 605 as banjar.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court conducted a two-tier analysis:

  1. Reliability of Evidence
    • The FSI report assumed Khasra 605 to cover 18.02 ha, whereas revenue records show only 10.39 ha. This discrepancy undermined its conclusions.
    • The MoEF&CC regional report, corroborated by 1938 revenue entries, recorded Khasra 605 as banjar land with sparse vegetation and no recent tree-felling or blasting. The Court accorded greater weight to this contemporaneous, revenue-based evidence.
  2. Application of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
    • Under Godavarman (1997) 8 SCC 191, the FCA extends to land recorded as forest irrespective of ownership.
    • Because Khasra 605 is recorded as banjar—not as reserved, protected, or private forest—the FCA cannot be invoked.
    • Conversely, Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 are recorded as “private forest,” indisputably attracting the FCA; non-implementation of NGT directions warranted further inquiry.

On this basis, the Court affirmed the NGT's bifurcated treatment of the parcels and rejected the appellant’s claim that Khasra 605 is a deemed forest.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; NGT judgment upheld in toto.

Implications: The MoEF&CC and State Forest Department must, within three months, complete the inquiry and initiate proceedings for FCA violations in Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 as already directed by the NGT. Construction on Khasra 605 may proceed under existing clearances because the land is not subject to the FCA. The decision reiterates that historical revenue records remain a primary determinant in forest-status disputes; however, it sets no new precedent beyond applying established principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Chandra Prakash Budakoti v. Union Of India And Others

    L. Nageswara Rao, J.— This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 5-4-2019 2019 SCC OnLine NGT 343 passed by the National Green Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter “the Tribunal”) in Original Application No. 626 of 2016.

    2. The appellant who is a journalist and Editor of Jan Lok Kesari which is a Hindi newspaper having circulation in Uttarakhand, filed the application in public interest as he was concerned about the environmental damage caused by Respondents 4 to 8. He alleged in the OA before the Tribunal that there was a large-scale felling of trees in private forests located at Patti Dhamnsu, Narendranagar, District Tehri Garhwal in Khasra Nos. 512 and 514. The appellant also complained of blasting activities being resorted to by Respondents 4 to 8 in the fragile Himalayan region.

    3. The appellant averred in the OA that no action was taken by the district authorities to whom he complained about the violation of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (hereinafter “the Act”). He also referred to Khasra No. 605 in which there were fully grown trees which were being felled. On the basis of the above allegations, the appellant sought a direction to the State of Uttarakhand and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Uttarakhand to stop the tree felling and usage of forest land for non-forest purposes in Khasra Nos. 512, 514 and 605 in Narendranagar District, Tehri Garhwal. He further sought a direction to Respondents 4 to 8 therein to stop construction. Later, the appellant impleaded Respondents 7 to 9 in the OA. The Tribunal on an application dated 11-4-2017 directed an inspection to be done by the Forest Survey of India. The said inspection was done on 1-5-2017 and a report was filed in the Tribunal which showed progressive degradation of forest cover in Khasra No. 605.

    4. The State of Uttarakhand filed a counter-affidavit before the Tribunal in which it was stated that a hotel/villa is being constructed by Mahananda Spa and Resorts Pvt. Ltd., since 2010-2011 in Khasra Nos. 512, 513 and 605. According to the State Government, the land falling in Khasra Nos. 512, 513 and 605 is neither a reserved forest nor a forest in the record of the Forest Department. It was further stated in the said counter-affidavit that Khasra Nos. 512 and 513 were recorded as private forests in the revenue record and Khasra No. 605 as barren (banjar) land. The State Government further submitted that the project proponent was directed to stop construction in view of the complaints made by the residents of Kumar Khera and Daur to Sub-District Collector, Narendranagar. As certain trees were found to be damaged during the construction, a fine was imposed under Sections 4/10 of the U.P. Protection of Trees in Rural and Hill Areas Act, 1976.

    5. By an order dated 19-12-2018 OA No. 626 of 2016, order dated 19-12-2018 (NGT), the Tribunal directed the regional office of the Ministry of Environment and Forests at Dehradun to visit the site and submit a status report. A Committee comprising Ms Komal Preet, Conservator of Forest and Dr S.C. Katiyar, Scientist E inspected the site on 5-1-2019. During the inspection, the Range Officer Narendranagar forest division and Kanungo from the office of Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Narendranagar were also present. The said inspection report dated 17-1-2019 filed before the Tribunal in which the following observations were made:

    Observation during site visit:
    1. Status of Khasra Nos. 512, 513 and 605 in revenue records and as per site inspection:
    Sl. No. Khasra No. Ownership as per revenue records Status of construction Vegetation cover 1. 512 Private land Villas constructed Sparse 2. 513 Private land Villas constructed Sparse 3. 605 Private land Partly under villas already constructed and partly under Westin Resort under construction Sparse
    2. As per the revenue records, the ownership of Khasra Nos. 512, 513 and 605 are “nap” or private land.
    3. The revenue records have not been updated since 1938 and the status of land for Khasra Nos. 512 and 513 is “niji van” or private forest while for Khasra No. 605 is “banjar” or barren.
    4. The land was not considered as deemed forest by the Forest Department in report filed in Godavarman case (2006) 5 SCC 28.
    5. At present, Khasra Nos. 512 and 513 and part of Khasra No. 605 are having independent villas which are devoid of any natural vegetation.
    6. Owner of the project denied having any rights in Khasra No. 514.
    7. On a portion of Khasra No. 605, resort in the name of Westin Resort is being constructed. During the site visit the construction was seen going on at the resort.
    8. There is no evidence of blasting and representatives of both the Revenue and Forest Department denied the same. It was also informed that the land is devoid of hard rocks and hence blasting is not required for any construction activity.
    9. The construction site adjoins civil land at its back side which was seen having natural vegetation akin to miscellaneous degraded forest having mostly shrubs and few trees.
    10. There was no sign of any fresh tree felling at the site. As per the Forest Department, illegal felling was reported and booked under the U.P. Tree Protection in Rural and Hill Areas Act, 1976 of the State during the year 2011-2012 for 34 numbers of trees and year 2015-2016 for 16 numbers of trees (Annexure II).
    11. The land is already broken and construction going on over major part of Khasra No. 605 and adjoining land also bears only degraded forest land with miscellaneous species, and has also not been marked as deemed forest by the Forest Department, hence in its present state it does not qualify as deemed forest on the basis of the vegetation on Khasra No. 605.
    12. Since Khasra No. 605 was recorded as “banjar” or barren in the year 1938 in revenue records, which have not been updated, hence continue to be reflected as banjar. As per the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in T.N. Godavarman WP (C) No. 202 of 1995. Ed., (1997) 8 SCC 191 at p. 326, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 would be applicable to all such lands recorded as forest in revenue records irrespective of the ownership, hence land under Khasra No. 605 would not attract the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (Annexure II).
    13. Khasra Nos. 512 and 513 have been recorded as private forest in the revenue records, hence would attract the provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 over which construction has already been completed in the form of villas (Annexure II).

    6. After a careful consideration of the report, the Tribunal passed the following order:

    (i) We hold that Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 are “private forest” land, as recorded in the revenue records and provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 are applicable. We, therefore, direct the Forest Department and MoEF to initiate proceedings for violation of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 in Khasra Nos. 512 and 513 for non-forestry activities by way of raising constructions, if such constructions had been undertaken without obtaining prior approval of MoEF. It has been stated that there are independent villas in Khasra Nos. 512 and 513. We also direct the Forest Department to conduct enquiry to find out the persons/officials responsible for the violation, if any and to proceed against them in accordance with law.
    (ii) The observations of FSI with regard to Khasra No. 605 are not conclusive and cannot be relied upon. The area of Khasra No. 605 in the report submitted by FSI is given as 1118.02 ha whereas as per revenue record it is 10.394 ha. We cannot arrive at any conclusion as to which part of Khasra No. 605 had been degraded as the area of Khasra No. as given in FSI report is significantly more than the area recorded in the revenue records. In the absence of any report on deemed forest filed by the Forest Department, we would go by the site inspection report of the regional office which is based on the revenue records and the existing character of the land. We, therefore, accept the observations given in the site inspection report of the regional office of MoEF wherein it has been stated that Khasra No. 605 is non-forest land and provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 will not be applicable.

    7. Aggrieved by the judgment of the Tribunal, the appellant has approached this Court by filing the above appeal.

    8. Before we proceed further it is relevant to mention that the direction issued by the Tribunal in respect of Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 has not been challenged by the respondents. The grievance of the appellant in respect of Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 is that the authorities have not implemented the directions.

    9. The main controversy in the above appeal pertains to Khasra No. 605. Mr P.S. Patwalia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that Khasra No. 605 is a deemed forest and would fall within the expression of forest, attracting the provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act. He relied upon a judgment in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India (1997) 2 SCC 267 to submit that the word “forest” should be understood according to its dictionary meaning. He relied upon Google images from 2007 to 2014 which would show that the area which was densely populated with trees has gradually undergone a change.

    10. Mr P.S. Patwalia further submitted that Oak and Kukat trees were cut and construction was commenced by Respondent 9 i.e. Mahananda Spa and Resorts Pvt. Ltd. without obtaining clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act. He referred to the reports submitted by the Forest Survey of India and the joint inspection report of the forest authorities in support of his submission that there has been a progressive reduction in the forest area in Khasra No. 605. He also placed reliance on the judgements of this Court in M.C. Mehta (Kant Enclave matters) v. Union of India (2018) 18 SCC 397 and Kerala State Coastal Zone Management Authority v. State of Kerala (2019) 7 SCC 248 to argue that any construction carried out without requisite permissions is liable to be demolished.

    11. Mr C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 9 submitted that the land of Respondent 9 in Khasra No. 605/1 is recorded as barren (banjar) land in the revenue records. He referred to the revenue records to contend that the land in Khasra No. 605 is neither a forest land nor in the nature of a forest. Initially, according to him, Mahananda Spa and Resorts Ltd. was to be constructed in 5702.20 sq m for which a sanctioned building plan was granted. According to the Notification dated 14-9-2006, environment clearance is required only if the built-up area of a project is more than 20,000 sq m. As it was decided to increase the built-up area from 13,983.67 sq m to 32,791 sq m, a fresh building plan was submitted for approval. Mr Sundaram contended that the entire shareholding of the erstwhile promoters of Respondent 9 was sold to Mankind Pharmaceuticals Ltd. company. Thereafter, Respondent 9 applied for grant of environment clearance on 1-2-2016 and consent to establish from the Uttarakhand Environment Protection and Pollution Control Board.

    12. Mr Sundaram stated that the State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority conducted a site inspection on 21-2-2016 pursuant to which the environment clearance was granted on 3-3-2016 permitting construction of the total built-up area of 32,686 sq m. He contended that there was no felling of any trees, as alleged by the appellant. The submission of Mr Sundaram that the construction taken up by Respondent 9 was after obtaining all the necessary sanctions and approvals which were not subject-matter of challenge in any forum.

    13. The appellant placed heavy reliance on the report of the Forest Survey of India which conducted an inspection on 1-5-2017. It is no doubt true that it was mentioned in the report that there is a gradual degradation of forest in Khasra No. 605. The Committee proceeded with the inspection on the basis that Khasra No. 605 is a forest on the ground that all lands with the tree canopy density between 10% to 40% shall be treated as open forest. The Committee made no reference to the revenue records. The Committee further proceeded on the ground that the total area of Khasra No. 605 is 18.02 ha to conclude that there is a progressive degradation due to construction of golf courts and other buildings in the area. The Tribunal rightly refused to accept the report of the Forest Survey of India as according to the revenue records, the land in Khasra No. 605 is only 10.39 ha. The Tribunal observed that it is difficult to arrive at a conclusion as to which part of Khasra No. 605 has been degraded as the report of FSI refers to Khasra No. 605 to be more than the area recorded in the revenue records.

    14. The appellant filed MA No. 1672 of 2018 in OA No. 626 of 2016 seeking a direction for a site inspection in view of fact that Respondent 9 is continuing with the construction in the forest area. By an order dated 19-12-2018 OA No. 626 of 2016, order dated 19-12-2018 (NGT), the Tribunal directed the regional office of Ministry of Environment and Forest, Climate Change, Dehradun to conduct an inspection. After conducting an inspection, a report was submitted on 7-1-2019. The clear findings recorded in the report are that the revenue records show that Khasra No. 605 is banjar or barren land. In Noida Memorial Complex Near Okhla Bird Sanctuary, In re (2011) 1 SCC 744, this Court held that due weight has to be given to revenue records, especially those pertaining to a period when the dispute regarding the land being a forest land did not exist. In the instant case, the revenue records relied upon by Respondent 9 are very old when nobody could have imagined about the project.

    15. The observation in the report dated 7-1-2019 is to the effect that the land in Khasra No. 605 was not considered as a deemed forest by the Forest Department in the report filed in Godavarman case (2006) 5 SCC 28. There is no evidence of blasting operations. There is also no sign of any fresh felling of trees and finally it was concluded that the land in Khasra No. 605 cannot qualify as deemed forest. There is a reference in the report to the judgment of this Court in Godavarman case WP (C) No. 202 of 1995. Ed., (1997) 8 SCC 191 at p. 326 wherein it was held that the Forest Conservation Act would be applicable to all lands recorded as forest in the revenue records. The provisions of the Forest Conservation Act are not applicable to Khasra No. 605. We are in agreement with the findings recorded by the Tribunal that the land falling in Khasra No. 605 is banjar or barren land and the provisions of the Forest Conservation Act is not applicable.

    16. Insofar as Khasra Nos. 512 and 514 are concerned, the Forest Department, State of Uttarakhand, Ministry of Environment and Forest have been remiss in not initiating the proceedings as directed by the Tribunal. The inquiry as directed by the Tribunal shall be completed within a period of three months from today and further action be taken immediately thereafter.

    17. For the aforementioned reasons, we uphold the judgment of the Tribunal and dismiss the appeal.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chandra Prakash Budakoti v. Union Of India And Others
    (Oct 24, 2019)