Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 26 D of SARFAESI Act
  • Securitisation Application u/s l7 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assetsand Enforcement of Security Interest Act,2OO2 (SARFAESI Act, 2OO2i
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 26 D of SARFAESI Act
  • Securitisation Application u/s l7 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assetsand Enforcement of Security Interest Act,2OO2 (SARFAESI Act, 2OO2i
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SHIVAJI COTTAGE INDUSTRY v. KARUR VYSYA BANK LTD

    "ctrliGil\Au' IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL - 1 AT HYDERABAD

    I]ATED THIS THE 1 7TH DAY OF MAY, 201 9

    PRESENT: SRI R. MALLIKARJUNA, PRESIDING OFFICER

    sA.No.29A./2017

    1.M/ s. Shivaji cottage Industry

    Rep. by sole Proprietrix Smt.P. Sharada, W/o P. Shivaji, R/o Plot No.136'

    Road No.26, Kattedan, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad.

    2. P. Shivaji, S/o late P. Ramulu, Plot No.l36,

    Road No.26, Kattedan, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad. ... Applicants Yersus

    l.Karur Vysya Bank Ltd.,

    Malkajgiri branch,

    M.No.25-4o /3-o l3 /2,

    East Anandbagh Main Road, Malkajgiri, Hyderabad

    Rep. by its Branch Manager/ Authorized officer

    2. Yelma Surender Reddy, S/o Y. Krishna Reddy, R/o H.NO.4-9-840lP8, Near Balaji Function hall, Lecturer's colony, Hayathnagar, Kuntloor, Hyderabad

    ... Respondents

    Counsel for tle Applicants

    : Si G.L. Prasada Rao Counsel for Respondent : Sri P. Rajesh Babu

    1

    >

    5A 298/17

    ORDER

    1. The Applicants filed the present Securitisation Application u/s l7 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assetsand Enforcement of Security Interest Act,2OO2 (SARFAESI Act, 2OO2i challenging the action of the Respondent bank in issuing the Auction Sale Notice dt. 03.08.2017 and consequent E Auction Notice dt' 2g.OA.2OlA putting the sale of the properties on 29 09.2018 and to declare the same as illegal, void and arbitrary.

    2. The case of the Applicants, in brief, is that, the 1st Applicant is a self employed cottage industry and availed two loans HPMA (FRESH) and oCC(Fresh) business loan for a consolidated amount of Rs 5o lakhs by hypothecating the machinery and assets of 1"t Applicant unitand also having mortgaged the A&B schedule properties by depositing the original title deeds. The Applicants paid substantial amounts to the Respondent Bank. As per the judgement of Hon'lcle Supreme court reported in AIR 2OO4 SC, the Banks and Financial institutionsare prohibited from collecting interest tax component from their clients, however the Respondent bank has simply adopted the trick of having changed the nomenclature of the levy by recovering the verysame interesttax.

    3. The grounds raised by the Applicants for quashing the action taken by the Respondent against the application schedule property are that, The Respondent bank issued 13(2) notice dt. 03 12.2016and subsequently issued Possession notice dt. 08.05.2017 and both the notices were issued by the Bank without rendering accounts tothe Applicants herein. In reply to the foregoing, the l=t Applicant issued a legal notice dt. 16.05.2017 to render lhe accounts. Though the Bank received the same and issued a reply letter dt 12.05.2017 stating that

    2

    sA 298/r7 the reply legal notice dt. 16.05.2017 is under consideration however the Bark neither replied nor complied with the said noticedt' 16.05.2017. The Respondent Bank has altegedly got issued theSale Notice dt. 2A.O7.2017 and published the same in two newspapers dt' 03.08.2017. Further the Bank has subsequently, atlegedly initiated proceedings for recovery of the sum and subsequent interest forsale of the properties on 29.Og,2O18 consequent to the e AuctionSale Notice dt. 2g.Oa,2}la and the same is bad for want of compliance of Section 26 D of SARFAESI Act

    ld. Counsel for thelst Respondent bank liled their Replyand contended that the Applicants misrepresented the facts and filedthe SA with untenable allegations. It is submitted by the Respondent bank that even aJter the receipt of the Reply legal noticedt. 02.06.2017 wherein it was categorically stated that sincethe Applicants having utterly failed to keep their commitment as per the terms and conditions of the loan agreement and further the amount ol Rs.8,95,IOo/ was kept in suspense account on the promisemade by the Applicants that they will pool up the further funds and clear the balance outstanding, which was not done by the Applicants,the Bank has proceeded further as per the guidelines of RBI and declared the account as NPA. Subsequently, the Bank proceeded further and issued 13(4) notice and then issued Presale notice dl 2807 2ol7 whichwas received by the Applicants but to no effect, as such,the Bank proceeded further ior auction of the schedule properties by way of e auction which was published intwo newspapers on 03 082O17 and accordingly, no procedural irregularity was committed bythe Bank in conducting the auction. Further the main relief claimedby the Applicants in the SA is only on one ground that the impugned Auction Sale Notice dt. O3.O8 2017 is itlegal on account ofthe failure of the bank to render accounts to the Applicants whichis highly untenable since the Applicants got every knowledge about their statement oI account. Since the statement of accountis ,y

    3

    sA 29a/17 periodically taken bY them which is usual in all commercial loans. Accordingly, I-d. Counsel prayed to dismiss theSA. The Respondent Bank also filed their additionat Replies in view of the amendment to the SA and Respondent NO 2 adoPted the sameas their Reply. It is contended that amended SA became redundantin view of the auction purchaser having taken back her amount in view of the continuing litigation Therefore the SA has got to be rejected in liminias infructuous since the SA originally filed and now being amended challenging the Auction notice for conducting auctionon 29.Og.2}la. lt is iurther submitted that the Applicant being principal borrower has been continuously creating litigation withoutany reason and that every time has been creating hurdles for the auction either by way of amendment and in view of the interim orders' every the auction purchasers are being baked out for no fault on theirtime, part, only to delay the lawful payments to be made by them to the bank . In view of the above, the Applicants are not entitled to claim any relief against the Respondent bank even by way of 2nd amendment of SA. Further, ilL the auctions conducted on 06 09 2017' 17 2'20)'8 $Y'

    and 2g.g.2o18 ffrlld as hignest bidders took back the bid amounts' Hence the very purpose of the SA itself is redundant' Now the point that arise for consideration is

    whether the Appliconts have made out uatid grounds for setting aside tlLe measures taken bU ttle Respondent agaittst the schedule properly und.er SARFAESI Act and Rules, 2Oo2 as sought for?

    5. Heard both sides and perused the written arguments filed by both the Applicants and Respondents.

    4

    sA 298117

    6. The Applicants vide their written arguments contended that the Appticants have paid the money as per the directions of the Hon'ble Tribunal however the bank has chosen to proceed independently without obeying the stay orders and thus, it is clearly established that the matter is sub-judice before the Hon'ble Tribunaland proceeding further duringthe stay orders amounts to contemptand the Respondent bank has violated the Provisions and the authority of the Hon'ble Tribunal.

    7 The Respondents vide their written arguments submitted that despite the payments made by the Applicants to the Bank, still a total amount of Rs.25,02,11.43 ps. as on 31.01.2019 is due by them which is not disputed by the Applicants. Moreover, the dispute with regard to the allegation about the interest rates was challenged before APSCDRC in C.C.No.106/ 17, which was dismissed for default for non-prosecution, as such, the said point cannot be agitated in this SA' Further, the main relief claimed by the Applicants in the SA is only on one ground thatthe impugned Auction Sale Notice dt. 0308.2017as illegalon account of the failure of the Bank to render accounts to the Applicants which was furnished by way of documents and hence the SA itself becomes infructuous.

    8. The applicant admitted execution oI documents and availing of credit facilities from the respondent bank. Applicant also admitted receipt of demand notice dated 03)2.2016 The applicant claims that he has issued legal notice raising certain objections against demand notice on 16.5.2017, The respondent bank contended that they have replied vide letter dated 02.06.2017. Thus the respondent bankhas complied with Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act and alsothe objections under section 13(3A) were raised beyond mandatory period oI 60 days, hence cannot be sustained. When no paymentis forthcoming from the applicants, the respondent bank issued possession notice on 08.5.2017 and the same is admitted by the s-

    5

    sA29al71 applicants. However challenging demand notice and possession notice are barred by limitation.

    9. The respondent bank issued notice of sale on 28.7.2017 and the same is acknowledged by the applicants on O2.O8.2O17. The applicants admitted that the sale notice is published in two newspapers Hence complied with Rule 8(6) of the SARFAESI Act. The applicant raised consumer dispute bearing no.CC 106l2Ol7 before APSCDRC disputing the interest charged by the respondent bankThe complaint is dismissed due to non prosecution by the applicantsThe applicants alleged that security interest is not registered with central registry. The respondent bank informed that the security interestis registered with central registry vide (1) security interest ID.No' and Asset ID. No.200004869572 (2) Securitv interest ti^O4.9nOo.o+OO4OaO7O56+6A2Z

    5824 and Asset ID.No.2OOO O4a69733. Hence Ihold that the respondent bank has complied with Section 26(d)of SARFAESI Act.

    10. The respondent bank submitted that they have conducted auctions on O6.9.2Of7, fi.2.2l-] 8 and 29.9.2018. During to pending SA in DRT, the highest bidders have taken back their bid amounts an'lthe auctions have been cancelled and the SA is infructuous

    11. From the above discussions, facts and circumstances of the case, the applicant failed to make any valid ground to set aside the SARFAESI measures of the respondent bank and the SA is liabte to be dismissed as infructuous.

    12. Accordingly, the SA is dismissed holding that the demand notice and possession notice are valid in law and does not suffer any legal infirmities. The respondent bank is at liberry to proceed in accordance with law.

    '{-

    6

    sA298/17

    13. ln the result, SA.2g8l2Ol7 is dismissed as devoid of merits'

    14. Communicate a copy of this order to the parties concerned' tDrctated. to the P.A., traftscibed bA her, cotected, signed dnd pronounced bg me in the open

    coutl on thlsthe 17'' daA oJ MaA 2A19).

    (R. MALLIKARJUNA)

    PRESIDING OFFICER

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SHIVAJI COTTAGE INDUSTRY v. KARUR VYSYA BANK LTD
    (May 17, 2019)