Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    P.C. Asokan v. M. Komukutty

    Sathish Ninan, J.:— A decree for specific performance of an agreement for sale is under challenge by the defendant.

    2. Ext. A1 agreement dated 04.01.2007 and Ext. A2 agreement dated 03.5.2007 between the parties relate to the same property. These agreements are sought to be specifically enforced. An extent of 19.67 cents is agreed to be conveyed by the defendant to the plaintiff at Rs. 44,000/- per cent. The period fixed under Ext. A1 was four months. under Ext. A1 an amount of Rs. 2 lakhs was paid as advance sale consideration. Ext. A2 agreement is claimed to have been subsequently executed between the parties on 03.05.2007, whereunder the period for performance is extended by fifteen days therefrom and a further amount of Rs. 3 lakhs is paid towards sale consideration. The defendants denied Ext. A2 agreement. The plea of denial was upheld by the trial court, but has granted a decree for specific performance based on Ext. A1 agreement for sale. Aggrieved thereby, the defendant is in appeal.

    3. Heard Sri. P.V. Kunhikrishnan, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri. T. Krishnanunni, learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the respondent.

    4. The execution of Ext. A1 agreement is not in dispute. It is also not in dispute that an amount of Rs. 2 lakhs was paid towards advance sale consideration under Ext. A1 agreement. The genuineness of Ext. A2 agreement dated 03.05.07 was challenged by the defendant. After analysing the evidence on record, the court below found that the execution of Ext. A2 agreement is not proved. It was also found that the evidence on record does not prove the payment of Rs. 3 lakhs to the defendant under Ext. A2.

    5. Regarding the genuineness of Ext. A2, the trial court noticed that though the plaintiff as PW1 claimed that the attestors to both Ext. A1 and A2 agreements are the same, in fact it is not so. It was noticed that the evidence of PW1, read as a whole, casts doubt regarding the genuineness of Ext. A2. Various discrepancies in the evidence of PWl insofar as it relates to the execution of Ext. A2 agreement are noticed. The court below has also noticed that the counsel for the plaintiff has tried to explain away the discrepancies by saying that PW1 is a cancer patient and that the illness has affected his memory. But the trial court which had the opportunity to see the witness has held that there was nothing to make out that the witness was not competent enough to depose before the court. The trial court further found that Ext. A2 was tampered with and that there is erasion at the place of signature of the defendant. PW2 has admitted the same. pws. 2 and 3 are the attestors to Ext. A2. There are contradictions between the evidence of PWs. 2 and 3 regarding the time of execution of Ext. A2 agreement. The same has been taken note of by the trial court. As noticed by the trial court, the sole purpose for execution of Ext. A2 agreement was for extending the time for a period of fifteen days and to record the payment of an additional amount of Rs. 3 lakhs. The same could very well have been done on Ext. A1 agreement itself. A faint attempt is made by the learned senior counsel to challenge the finding of the trial court regarding Ext. A2 agreement. Though the learned senior counsel would argue that, the indebtedness of the defendant to the Khadi Board having been admitted, the execution of Exhibit a2 agreement and the payment of Rs. 3 lakhs thereunder is probabilised, on the evidence available it is to be held otherwise. There is no evidence to prove the payment of Rs. 3 lakhs on the date of Ext. A2 agreement. Regarding payment of the amount, positive evidence could have been adduced. On the above discussions, I do not find any reason to differ from the conclusion arrived at by the court below regarding the genuineness of Ext. A2 and also the non-payment of amounts mentioned therein. I affirm the said findings.

    6. Having found that Ext. A2 agreement cannot be accepted, is the plaintiff entitled for the relief of specific performance based on Ext. A1 agreement, is the question that next falls for consideration. The learned senior Counsel for the respondent would contend that while considering the question of readiness and willingness of the plaintiff, the failure to perform the reciprocal promises by the defendant assumes significance. In Ext. A1 there are reciprocal promises and unless the defendant fulfills his part of the contract namely clearing of the encumbrance over the property, the plaintiff cannot be expected to pay the balance consideration. unless the defendant has performed his part of the contract, the plaintiff was under no liability to pay the balance sale consideration. The learned Senior Counsel relies on the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court reported in Faizal Eroth v. Venkalath Raveendran [2013 (3) KLT 1041] in support of his contention. Ext. A1 agreement is dated 04.01.2007 and the period fixed for performance is four months therefrom which expired on 05.05.07. Though there is no material to show that the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the contract within that period, it is of no consequence in view of the absence of any material to indicate the performance of the reciprocal promises by the defendant, is the submission.

    7. The court below found that though Ext. A1 agreement is dated 04.01.07, the same was executed by the parties only on 15.01.07. In Ext. A1, below the signature, the date 15.01.07 is seen. Here it is to be noticed that neither in the plaint nor in Ext. A4 notice issued by the plaintiff he had a case that Ext. A1 was signed not on the date mentioned in the notice but at a later date. There is no such case for the plaintiff even at the time of evidence. It is not even put to the defendant when he is examined. The learned senior counsel would submit that being a document produced along with the pleading the same forms part of the pleading and hence it should be considered as a plea raised. The said contention could have been accepted provided there was no mention about the date of Ext. Al in the plaint. But here, the plaint specifically mentions the date of the agreement as 04.01.07. Accepting the arguments of the learned senior counsel, it can only be considered as contradictory pleadings. under such circumstances the evidence adduced by the plaintiff assumes significance-Even in the evidence, the plaintiff has asserted the date of Ext. A1 as 04.01.07. Therefore, I am unable to agree with the finding of the court below that Ext. A1 agreement was executed only on 15.01.07 and not on the date mentioned in Ext. A1 namely 04.01.07. Incidentally I must notice that the manner in which the date is seen written below the signatures, as 15.01.07, does not inspire confidence. Any how, being an agreement for sale of immovable property, whether the date is 04.01.07 or 15.01.07 may not by itself tilt the scale since generally time need not be taken to be the essence, of course, unless demonstrated otherwise by circumstances. Suffice to notice that the date, 15.01.07, found below the signature remains unexplained either in the pleading or in the evidence of the plaintiff and also that it was not even put to the defendant.

    8. The definite case of the plaintiff is that under Exts. Al and A2, the defendant has agreed to sell property to the plaintiff and that out of the total consideration, an amount of Rs. 5 lakhs has been paid; that the plaintiff is ready and willing to pay the balance sale consideration and get the sale deed executed. It is the said agreement that is sought to be specifically enforced. Having found that Ext. A2 agreement cannot be upheld and that the payment of Rs. 3 lakhs is not proved, the plaintiff cannot get a decree for specific performance based on Ext. A1 since that will be at variance from the case as pleaded by him and at variance from the agreement pleaded by him. The plaintiff is entitled to seek for specific performance of the agreement as it stands. After having sought for specific performance based on Exts. A1 and A2 agreements and on the basis of the consideration as stated therein, it is not open for the plaintiff to resile therefrom and seek for a decree for specific performance on varied terms.

    9. Even assuming that the plaintiff is entitled to seek for specific performance on varied terms than that as pleaded and confining to Ext. A1 alone, the relief for specific performance having its roots in equity, it needs to be considered whether on the facts of the case the plaintiff needs to be granted a decree for specific performance. Law is too well settled that the situations enumerated in section 20 are not exhaustive and are only illustrative. [see Mademsetty Satyanarayana v. G. Yelloji Rao (AIR 1965 SC 1405) and Ganesh Shet v. Dr. C.S.G.K. Setty (1998) 5 SCC 381)]. In G. Rosaiah v. C. Balarami Reddy (AIR 1989 AP 179) it was observed that the plaintiff must come to the court with clean hands and that if his conduct is tainted with falsity of the case or unworthy of acceptance, equity denies him the relief. The Apex Court in K. Kalpana Saraswathi v. P.S.S Somasundaram Chettiar . ((1980) 1 SCC 630 : AIR 1980 SC 512) observed that, “The final end of law is justice and so the means to it too should be informed by equity”. In Lourdu Mari David v. Louis Chinnaya Arogiaswamy [(1996) 5 SCC 589] the Apex Court held, “It is an important condition that a party who desires specific relief must come with clean hands as otherwise specific performance would be refused”. I do not think that it is necessary to multiply authorities on the point.

    10. Ext. A2 based on which specific performance is claimed in the suit is found against. The payment of amount claimed thereunder is found against. The contradiction in the dates in Ext. A1 found in the body and below the signature remain unexplained. Under such circumstances, definitely the exercise of discretion under Section 20 of the specific relief Act would be against the plaintiff. The exercise of discretion under Section 20 is, as is stated in the section itself, subject to correction by a court of appeal. On the materials as noticed supra, I am of the opinion that the discretion is to be exercised to refuse a decree for specific performance.

    11. For the reasons as stated above, I am inclined to interfere with the judgment and decree of the court below.

    12. The receipt of Rs. 2 lakhs as advance sale consideration under Ext. A1 agreement having been admitted, in the absence of any plea or evidence to find that the defendant has sustained any damages, necessarily the plaintiff is entitled to get refund of the said amount with reasonable interest thereon. I am of the opinion that grant of interest at the rate of 12% per annum would be just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case. The plaintiff can be granted a decree accordingly.

    13. In the result, this appeal is allowed. The decree and judgment of the court below is set aside. The plaintiff is granted a decree for realisation of an amount of Rs. 2 lakhs with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 04.01.2007 till the date of realisation, from the defendant personally and as a charge on the plaint schedule property. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P.C. Asokan v. M. Komukutty
    (Sep 27, 2018)