Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Sr. Supdt. Of Post Offices v. Shri Painu Ram .

    Ajay Mohan Goel, J. (Oral):— By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has laid challenge to order dated 31.01.2014 passed by learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh bench, in OA No. 426/HP/2013, titled as Painu Ram v. Union of India, vide which, learned Tribunal has granted the following relief in favour of the original applicant therein, who is the respondent in the present petition:—

    “In the light of the above factual and legal position, we are of the view that once the applicant has already been conferred with temporary status and having three years of service on temporary status, as per letter dated 30.11.1992 issued by the respondents, he is entitled for same benefits, which are admissible to regular Group-‘D’ employees and this view has been approved by the Ernakullam Bench of this Tribunal in the case of Chitra Prabhu v. UOI Decided on 14.08.2012 based upon the case of Jagriti Mazdorr Union (supra) passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Therefore, we are left with no option but to allow the O.A and quash the impugned order dated 06.03.2013 with a direction to the respondents to grant the retiral benefits to the applicant as admissible to Group ‘D’ employee of the respondent department.

    10. Let the above exercise be carried out within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. No costs.”

    2. The issue raised for consideration by the original applicant before the learned Central Administrative Tribunal was whether a part timer, who was conferred temporary status, was entitled for same benefits, as are admissible to regular employees in terms of instructions dated 12.04.1991 as amended on 30.11.1992 issued by respondent Department or not?

    3. The original applicant was initially appointed as a part time Chowkidar in Post Office at Talai on 02.02.1982. Though, his appointment was as a part timer, however, he worked with the respondent-Department from 5:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m., which were the same duty hours as that of a regular appointee on the post concerned. It is not in dispute that feeling aggrieved by non-conferment of temporary status upon him, present respondent earlier filed OA No. 405-HP-2010 before learned Central Administrative Tribunal praying that a direction be issued to the respondent to grant him temporary status and subsequently regularize his services against the post of Chowkidar with all consequential benefits in terms of the Scheme of the Department dated 12.04.1991.

    4. This original application was disposed of on 21.03.2011 in terms of the order passed in OA No. 974/HP/2010, titled as Laxmi Chand v. Union of India. The applicant was granted temporary status as per policy dated 30.11.1992 w.e.f. 29.12.1992.

    5. Thereafter, he again approached the learned Tribunal by way of OA No. 426/HP/2013 praying that as he was granted temporary status as per policy dated 30.11.1992, therefore, as an employee, who had completed three years' service upon conferment of temporary status, was to be treated as a regular group ‘D’ employee of the said Department, he was also entitled for the said benefits and he should be granted the same, in terms of the policy of the Department, as also the judgment passed in Chitra Prabhu v. Union of India, dated 14.08.2012 by Ernakullam Bench of the learned Tribunal and the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jagriti Mazdoor Union (Regd) v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd., 1990 Supp SCC 113, dated 29.11.1989.

    6. Learned Tribunal after relying upon the relevant portion of letter dated 30.11.1992 so issued by the respondent-Department, as also directions issued by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jagriti Mazdoor Union (supra) and the order passed by learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, in OA No. 1626 of 2005, titled as Shyam Lal Shukla v. Union of India dated 28.07.2009, which stood confirmed by Allahabad High Court, held that in view of the applicant having been already conferred with temporary status and his having three years of service as such, in terms of communication dated 30.11.1992, he was entitled for the same benefits which were admissible to a regular Group ‘D’ employee.

    7. Feeling aggrieved, the Department has filed this petition.

    8. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and also gone through the orders passed by learned Tribunal as well as record of the case.

    9. During the course of arguments, learned Assistant Solicitor General of India could not dispute that the persons, similarly situated as the present respondent, have already been held to be entitled for benefits which were accrueable to regular Group ‘D’ employees, by various Benches of the learned Central Administrative Tribunal and one such order passed by the Allahabad bench of the learned Tribunal has been upheld by the Allahabad High Court. We have also been informed at the bar that the judgment passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Allahabad has attained finality.

    10. The factum of the respondent having been conferred temporary status w.e.f. 29.11.1989 in group ‘D’ is not in dispute. The relevant portion of the letter dated 30.11.1992, which stands relied upon by the learned Tribunal while granting the relief to the present respondent is quoted herein-below:—

    “3. In compliance with the above said directive of the Hon'ble Supreme Court it has been decided that the casual labourers of this Department conferred with temporary status as per the scheme circulated in the above said circular No. 45-95/87-SPB-I dated 12.04.1991 be treated at par with temporary Group ‘D’ employees with effect from the date they complete three years of service in the newly acquired temporary status as per the above said scheme. From date thy will be entitled to benefit admissible to temporary Group ‘D’ employees such as:

    1. All kinds of leave admissible to temporary employees.

    2. Holidays as admissible to regular employees.

    3. Counting of service for the purpose of pension and terminal benefits as in the case of temporary employees appointed on regular basis for those temporary temporary employees who are given temporary status and who complete 3 years of service in that status while granting them pension and retirement benefits after their regulations.

    4. Central Government Employees Insurance Scheme/

    5. GPF.

    6. Medical Aid.

    7. LTC.

    8. All advances admissible to temporary Group ‘D’ employees.

    9. Bonus.”

    11. The relevant part of the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jagriti Mazdoor Union (Regd) (supra), which has been relied upon by the learned Tribunal is quoted herein-below:—

    “After rendering three years of continuous service with temporary status, the casual labourers shall be treated at par with temporary Grade ‘D’ employees of the Department of Posts and would thereby be entitled to such benefits as are admissible to Group ‘D’ employees on regular basis.”

    12. In view of the contents of communication dated 30.11.1992 as also the directions passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Jagriti Mazdoor Union' case (supra), we do not find any infirmity with the directions issued by the learned Tribunal in favour of the present respondent. Said directions are strictly in consonance with the judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jagriti Mazdoor Union's case (supra), as also the contents of communication dated 30.11.1992. In our considered view, after the conferment of the temporary status upon the present respondent, he was entitled for benefits which are accrueable to a regular Group ‘D’ employee after completion of three years of service on temporary basis. In view of the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court as also the orders passed by various Benches of learned Central Administrative Tribunal, it cannot be said that the relief granted by learned Central Administrative Tribunal in favour of the present respondent is not sustainable in law, especially in view of contents of letter dated 30.11.1992.

    13. Accordingly, we do not find any infirmity with the order passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal. The same is upheld and this writ petition being devoid of merits is dismissed.

    14. The petition stands disposed of in above terms, so also pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sr. Supdt. Of Post Offices v. Shri Painu Ram .
    (Jul 23, 2018)