Date of Order : 17-06-2019 Between :
A.LakshmammaW/o Late Chinna Swamy, Assistant Postmaster,Gr. 'C ' Kurnool Head Office (Retired),Now resident of 65/21, Kurva Street, Old Bus Stand,
Kurnool-516001. ....Applicant
AND
1. The Superintendent of Post Offices, Kurnool Postal Division at Kurnool.
2. The Director of Postal Services, O/o The Post Master General, Kurnool Region, Kurnool.
3. The Post Master General, Kurnool Region, Kurnool.
4. The Chief Post Master General, A.P.Circle, Vijayawada.
5. The Director General, Department of Posts, Dak Bhavan, New Delhi.
6. Union of India, represented by its Secretary, Department of Posts, New Delhi ...Respondents ---
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr.K.VenkateshwaraRao Counsel for the Respondents : Mr.MegharaniAgarwal, Addl.CGSC ---
CORAM :
THE HON'BLE MRS.NAINI JAYASEELAN,ADMINISTRATIVEMEMBER (Oral Order per Hon'ble Mrs. Naini Jayaseelan , AdministrativeMember) ---
1
The applicant has filed the present OA aggrieved by the impugned order dated 09.04.2018 wherein the payment of interest on the delayed payment of pensionary benefits ( gratuity + commuted pension) was denied to the applicant.
2. The brief facts of the case are that, the applicant was issued a show cause notice vide order dated 09.05.2014 of Respondent No.1 directing her to credit an amount of Rs.74,519/- under UCR regarding misappropriation in NREGS wage payments to which the applicant submitted representation on 12.05.2014. Thereafter the 1st
Respondent issued charge memo dated 20.05.2014 to the applicant proposing to conduct an inquiry under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The applicant filed OA No.931/2014 before this Tribunal and the same was disposed of on 22.08.2014, which reads as under :
"8. In view of the above, without touching the merits of the case, we dispose of this O.A with a direction to the respondents to withhold an amount of Rs.74,519/- till completion of the enquiry proceedings and remaining amounts be released to the applicant within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of copy of the order and the respondents are further directed to complete the enquiry proceedings as expeditiously as possible. There shall be no order as to costs."
3. Aggrieved by this order, the respondents filed WP No.6033/2015 before the Hon'ble High Court and the same was dismissed on 17.03.2017, which reads as under :
" In that view of the matter, the authorities have no basis to withhold the retiral benefits of the first respondent. They shall accordingly release the same expeditiously. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending
2
miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall also stand dismissed. No order as to costs."
The applicant also filed a CP No.87/2017 on the ground that the Respondents had not complied with the orders dated 22.08.2014 in OA No.931/2014 and the same is pending.
4. Later, Disciplinary Proceedings under Rule-9 of CCS (Pension) Rules were initiated against the applicant, retired LSG CC, Kurnool HO in connection with NREGS frauds at Velgode S.O account with Kurnool HO under Kurnool Region, Andhra Pradesh. Thereafter the 6th
Respondent passed the impugned order No.C-14016/16/2017-VP, dated 09.04.2018 wherein it was held as under :
"9. The case was placed before the President. The President after careful consideration of the facts, circumstances, records of the case, advice of the UPSC and the representation of the retired charged official on the advice of the Commission concluded that the Charged Official was given reasonable opportunity to defend her case and the UPSC had taken all the factors mentioned by CO into consideration while tendering its advice and that the advice of the UPSC in this case is just, proper and acceptable.
10. Accordingly, the President of India ordered that the charges against Smt.A.Lakshmamma, Retire LSG CC, Kurnool HO be dropped. The monthly pension and gratuity admissible to her, if not required to be withheld in any other case, may be released."
5. Thereafter gratuity to the tune of Rs.6,70,890/- was sanctioned to the applicant vide Respondent No.1 memo dated 11.04.2018. The commutted pension amounting to Rs.4,20,844/- was also paid to the applicant by the Postmaster, Kurnool HO on 03.05.2018. The final pension has also since been regularized ceasing the provisional pension with effect from
09.04.2018.
3
6. It is the contention of the learned Standing Counsel for Respondents that the department took action under Rule 69(c) of CCS (Pension) Rules which states that, no gratuity shall be paid to the applicant until the conclusion of the Disciplinary Proceedings. However as per the guidelines for determining the delay in gratuity and payment of interest thereon, in case of Government Servant against whom judicial/disciplinary proceedings are pending and in which gratuity is withheld till the conclusion of the proceedings, the payment of gratuity will be due on the date following the date of retirement and if the payment of gratuity has been authorised after three months from the date of his retirement, interest may be allowed beyond the period of three months from the date of retirement.
7. In the instant case, as per order No.C-14016/16/2017-VP, dated 09.04.2018, the charges levelled against the applicant were dropped after the culmination of the proceedings under Rule-9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules. The above orders were issued after due consideration of the facts, circumstances, records of the case, as well as the advice of the UPSC and the representation of the retired charged official. Therefore gratuity would have to be paid within three months from the date of retirement. Regarding commutation of pension amounting to Rs.4,20,844/- which was paid to the applicant on 03.05.2018. It is the contention of the Respondents counsel that all pensionary benefits payable to the applicant after the culmination of the Rule-9 proceeding by the President of India and withholding of the gratuity was in accordance with Rule 69(c) wherein as per rule no gratuity shall be paid to the applicant until conclusion of the departmental / judicial
4
proceedings. However since gratuity becomes due immediately on retirement of the Government Servant or on conclusion of the proceedings, and in case of Government Servant who is exoneratedof all the charges and where gratuity is paid on conclusion of such proceedings, the payment of gratuity will be deemed to have fallen due on the date following the date of retirement. If the payment of gratuity has been authorized after three months from the date of his retirement interest may be allowed beyond the period of three months from the date of retirement. Therefore the Respondents are directed to pay interest as per the prevailing GPF rates.
9. Counsel for the applicant also cited judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi for payment of interest on the commuted value of the pension in the case of Delhi Transport Corporation Vs. K.K.Berry & Ors in which it was held that, "if indeed interest has to be charged at 12%, then a similar rate of interest was required to be paid by the appellant to the pensioners on the commuted value of the pension. In these circumstances, the learned Single Judge was justified in giving the directions as contained in the impugned order dated 03.10.2002" and therefore it was ordered that in the absence of provision of payment of interest on the commuted value of the pension cannot be offered as an explanation for answering the charge of arbitrariness and unreasonableness resulting from the denial of the payment of such interest".
10. In view of the above, the OA is disposed off with the directions to the Respondents to pay interest on the gratuity as well as commuted value of
5
pension with effect from three months after the date of retirement till the date of actual payment at the prevailing GPF rates at that relevant point of time. No order as to costs.
(NAINI JAYASEELAN)
ADMINISTRATIVEMEMBER
Dated : 17th
June, 2019. Dictated in Open Court. vl
6