AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 377
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 154th Law Commission Report
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in the text. However, it was mentioned that a fine of Rs 5000 and then increased to Rs 25,000 each.
  • Section 326 IPC, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (amended by Act 5 of 2009)
  • Section 326 IPC, Section 357 and Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 377
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 154th Law Commission Report
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in the text. However, it was mentioned that a fine of Rs 5000 and then increased to Rs 25,000 each.
  • Section 326 IPC, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (amended by Act 5 of 2009)
  • Section 326 IPC, Section 357 and Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal, heard by Ajay Rastogi, J., challenges the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla dated 24-3-2008 (2008 SCC OnLine HP 254). The case arises from an acid attack on 12-7-2004 in which the victim, Kumari Ishita (also referred to as Ishita Sandhu), suffered approximately 16% sulphuric acid burns. The victim stated that two boys on a scooter threw acid from a jug and fled. An FIR was registered after the victim’s statement was recorded at the hospital.

The trial court convicted both accused under Sections 307/34 IPC and sentenced each to 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 5,000 (judgment dated 30-11-2005). On appeal, the High Court altered the conviction to Section 326 IPC, reduced the custodial sentence to 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment, and enhanced the fine to Rs 25,000 each (24-3-2008). The respondents accepted the High Court’s judgment, deposited the fine, underwent the sentence, and were released on 9-12-2008.

The State of Himachal Pradesh appealed to the Supreme Court seeking restoration of the trial court’s conviction and sentence or, in the alternative, compensation for the victim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sentence imposed by the High Court (conviction under Section 326 IPC with 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment) was proportionate to the crime.
  2. Whether the victim is entitled to compensation in addition to what was awarded by the High Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (State of Himachal Pradesh)

  • Characterized the crime as an acid attack on a 19-year-old victim and argued that the trial court rightly convicted the respondents under Sections 307/34 IPC with 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment; contended that the High Court lacked justification to interfere with the trial court’s judgment of 30-11-2005.
  • Submitted, in the alternative, that if the Supreme Court was not inclined to restore the trial court’s conviction and sentence, the victim should be awarded compensation as per law.
  • Urged against misplaced sympathy or unwarranted mercy in sentencing for acid attacks.

Respondents

  • Supported the High Court’s judgment altering the offence to Section 326 IPC and imposing 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment, arguing that 16% burns did not justify a conviction under Section 307 IPC.
  • Pointed out that they had served the sentence and were released on 9-12-2008; argued that, after such lapse of time, returning them to custody would be unjust.
  • Relied on Sachin Jana v. State of W.B., (2008) 3 SCC 390, where despite more than 50% acid burns and a conviction under Section 307 IPC, the Supreme Court reduced the sentence to 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 25,000.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sachin Jana v. State of W.B., (2008) 3 SCC 390 In an acid attack with over 50% burns, Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC applied; custodial sentence was reduced to 5 years with a fine of Rs 25,000. Considered as a benchmark on proportionality and sentencing in acid attack cases; supported the view that a 5-year sentence could be appropriate.
Ravada Sasikala v. State of A.P., (2017) 4 SCC 546 Where the High Court released the convict to 30 days’ period undergone for a Section 326 IPC conviction, the Supreme Court restored the sentence of one year; also addressed compensation under Sections 357 and 357-A CrPC. Reinforced that undue dilution of sentence may be corrected and highlighted the framework for compensation to victims.
Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra, (2013) 6 SCC 770 Emphasized victimology (as reflected in the 154th Law Commission Report) and the court’s role in awarding compensation under the amended provisions. Provided the normative basis for addressing and awarding victim compensation.
Laxmi v. Union of India, (2014) 4 SCC 427 Noted insertion of Section 357-A CrPC and directed that acid attack victims be paid at least Rs 3 lakhs by the State/UT for aftercare and rehabilitation. Used to direct State-level compensation under the Victim Compensation Scheme for the acid attack victim.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Mehtaab, (2015) 5 SCC 197 (relying on Suresh v. State of Haryana, (2015) 2 SCC 227) Directed compensation and recognized that, beyond amounts paid by accused, the State must pay compensation under Section 357-A CrPC. Supported ordering both accused-paid compensation and State-paid compensation to the victim.
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Ram Pal, (2015) 11 SCC 584 Held prior compensation inadequate; ordered Rs 1 lakh by the accused and Rs 3 lakhs by the State in a case involving the death of a 20-year-old. Illustrated appropriate quantum and State–accused sharing of compensation, informing the present compensation directions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court took note of the factual matrix: an acid attack on 12-7-2004 resulting in approximately 16% sulphuric acid burns, corroborated by the forensic report of Dr. Piyush Kapila (PW 2).
  • On proportionality, the Court observed that the High Court’s alteration from Sections 307/34 IPC to Section 326 IPC, with a sentence of 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment and enhanced fine, did not warrant interference. The respondents had already undergone the sentence and were released in 2008.
  • The Court acknowledged the gravity and uncivilized nature of acid attacks, emphasizing that such crimes do not merit leniency. Nevertheless, on the specific record, it concluded that the existing conviction under Section 326 IPC with a 5-year sentence should stand.
  • Shifting focus to victim compensation, the Court relied on a line of precedents:
    • Sachin Jana to situate sentencing benchmarks in acid attack cases;
    • Ravada Sasikala to underscore that undue sentence dilution can be corrected and to reference compensation under Sections 357 and 357-A CrPC;
    • Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad and the 154th Law Commission’s emphasis on victimology, highlighting the court’s duty to consider compensation;
    • Laxmi v. Union of India recognizing Section 357-A CrPC and mandating minimum State compensation for acid attack victims;
    • Mehtaab (with reliance on Suresh) and Ram Pal to reinforce both the State’s responsibility under Section 357-A and appropriate quantum of compensation.
  • Applying these principles, the Court determined that additional compensation from the accused, coupled with State compensation under the Victim Compensation Scheme, would provide some solace to the victim, even though such harm is not fully compensable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court modified the High Court’s judgment (2008 SCC OnLine HP 254) to direct: - Each accused shall pay additional compensation of Rs 1,50,000 to the victim (Ishita Sandhu, D/o Late Shri Rikhi Ram Sandhu). - The State of Himachal Pradesh shall pay compensation as admissible under the Victim Compensation Scheme in vogue. - The accused must pay within six months; default will result in six months’ rigorous imprisonment for the defaulting accused. - The State shall deposit its compensation before the trial court within three months; the trial court shall disburse to the victim after proper identification. - The conviction under Section 326 IPC and the sentence of 5 years’ rigorous imprisonment (as imposed by the High Court) stand; the appeal is disposed of.

Implications: The decision affirms the High Court’s conviction and sentence while significantly enhancing victim compensation through contributions by both the accused and the State under the statutory scheme. The ruling primarily affects the parties by adding monetary redress with an enforceable default clause; it reiterates, but does not newly establish, principles regarding victim compensation in acid attack cases.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    THE STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH v. VIJAY KUMAR ALIAS PAPPU

    Ajay Rastogi, J.— The challenge in this appeal is against the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla dated 24-3-2008 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254 filed at the instance of the State of Himachal Pradesh whereby the High Court was pleased to partially allow the appeal filed by the respondents and altered the nature of offence from one under Sections 307/34 IPC to one under Section 326 IPC and reduced the sentence of 10 years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 5000 each to 5 years' rigorous imprisonment and increased the fine to Rs 25,000 each and in default, to undergo further imprisonment of six months.

    2. In the instant case, the victim has suffered 16% burn injury which was caused due to acid attack on the darkest day of her life i.e. on 12-7-2004. To unfold the prosecution version in a nutshell that, on 12-7-2004 at about 9.00 a.m. PW 13 Shami Verma, resident of Mashobra, who was present at BCS at Khalini-Dhalli bypass saw PW 5 Kumari Ishita (victim) crying with burn injuries, who had jumped into the water tank nearby. PW 13 Shami Verma took out PW 5 Kumari Ishita, victim from the tank and informed to the Police Post, New Shimla, that a girl with burn injuries was present near her residence and this information (Ext. PR) was recorded by the In-charge of the Police Post, New Shimla, who deputed a police officer on wireless set to go to the site. PW 36 Shakuntla Sharma went to the site and shifted the victim to the hospital and recorded her statement on which a case was registered.

    3. During investigation, PW 5 Kumari Ishita (victim) stated that when she was going to college, two boys came on a scooter and threw some acid over her from a jug and ran away from the spot. After investigation, challan was filed against both the respondent-accused who were tried by the learned trial court leading to their conviction which convicted them for offence under Sections 307/34 IPC and sentenced them to undergo rigorous imprisonment of 10 years with a fine of Rs 5000 each by judgment dated 30-11-2005 which came to be challenged by them in appeal before the High Court of Himachal Pradesh.

    4. Taking note of the chemical burns caused by sulphuric acid of around 16%, which is evident from the report of Dr Piyush Kapila (PW 2), Department of Forensic Medicine, the High Court arrived at the conclusion that the offence under Sections 307/34 IPC was not made out and converted the offence from Sections 307/34 IPC to Section 326 IPC and sentenced them for a period of 5 years' rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 25,000 each vide impugned judgment dated 24-3-2008 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254.

    5. The respondent-accused have accepted the conviction and have undergone their sentence in terms of the judgment impugned dated 24-3-2008 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254 and have deposited the fine amount of Rs 25,000 each as informed to this Court and were released on 9-12-2008 after undergoing sentence in terms of the impugned judgment 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254.

    6. The main thrust of the submission of the learned counsel for the appellants is that it was a case of acid attack on innocent young victim of 19 years and the learned trial court has rightly convicted the respondent-accused under Sections 307/34 IPC and sentenced them to 10 years' rigorous imprisonment and there was no reasonable and cogent justification for the High Court to interfere with the impugned judgment of the learned trial court dated 30-11-2005 and once they had been held guilty, their alteration of punishment is uncalled for and prayed for restoring the conviction and sentence held by the learned trial court dated 30-11-2005. The learned counsel further submitted that if this Court is not inclined to restore the conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial court dated 30-11-2005, at least the victim is entitled for compensation admissible under the law.

    7. The learned counsel for the respondents has supported the judgment of the High Court dated 24-3-2008 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254 and submitted that the respondents were young at the given point of time on the date of incident dated 12-7-2004 and looking into the chemical burns of 16% which the victim had suffered, by no stretch of imagination, it could be considered to be a case of Section 307 IPC of committing an attempt to murder. Further, in the given facts and circumstances, it was not even a case of Section 326 IPC but they have accepted the wrong which had been committed by them and after undergoing sentence in terms of the impugned judgment 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254, both were released on 9-12-2008 and there is no justification to restore the conviction and sentence awarded by the learned trial court dated 30-11-2005. In support of his submission, reliance is placed on the judgment of this Court in Sachin Jana v. State of W.B. (2008) 3 SCC 390 and submitted that it was a case where the victims suffered more than 50% burn injury caused due to acid and the conviction was under Section 307 IPC and yet this Court had reduced the sentence to 5 years' rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs 25,000.

    8. In this background, the question for consideration is whether the imposition of sentence by the High Court is proportionate to the crime in question and whether the victim is entitled for any compensation in addition to what has been awarded under the impugned judgment.

    9. The learned counsel for the appellants submits that by no stretch of imagination, the period undergone, can be regarded as appropriate for the offence under Section 326 IPC and definitely not when there is acid attack. She submitted that there may not be any misplaced sympathy and exhibition of unwarranted mercy to pave the path of injustice to the victim.

    10. The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the incident has happened long back on 12-7-2004 and by this time, the victim as well as the respondents have been living their individual lives and the respondents have undergone the sentence passed and were released on 9-12-2008. They are leading a reformed life and after a long lapse of time, to send them to custody would tantamount to a gross injustice to them.

    11. The two-Judge Bench of this Court in Sachin Jana case (2008) 3 SCC 390 where the accused persons faced trial for offence under Sections 148, 323, 324 and 307 read with Section 149 IPC on account of 50% burn injury which was caused due to acid attack were convicted by the High Court for offence under Sections 307/34 IPC but their custodial sentence was reduced to 5 years and a fine of Rs 25,000. The relevant extract is as under:( & 393, paras 9, 12 & 13)

    “9. It is to be noted that three persons suffered injuries on account of acid poured on them. The doctor had indicated that each of the injured persons suffered more than 50% burn injury which was caused due to acid and the same was sufficient to cause death if not attended by medical aid at appropriate time.
    ***
    12. When the evidence on record is analysed, it is clear that Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC has clear application. The acid burns caused disfigurement.
    13. Considering the nature of dispute the custodial sentence is reduced to 5 years. However, each of the appellants is directed to pay a fine of Rs 25,000. If the amount is deposited by the appellants within six weeks from today, out of each deposit, Rs 10,000 shall be paid to each of the victims PWs 1, 2 and 3; in case the amount of fine imposed is not deposited, the default custodial sentence of one year each.”

    12. The matter in reference to the victim suffered due to acid attack was further considered by a two-Judge Bench of this Court in Ravada Sasikala v. State of A.P. (2017) 4 SCC 546 where the learned trial court convicted the accused person under Sections 326 and 448 IPC and sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for one year and directed to pay a fine of Rs 5000. The High Court while confirming the conviction under Section 326 IPC released 2016 SCC OnLine Hyd 417 the accused to the period which he had already undergone of 30 days which came to be interfered by this Court and the punishment and sentence of one year under Section 326 IPC was restored. But while doing so, this Court also ousted the compensation which the victim may be entitled for under Section 357 and Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as “CrPC”).

    13. Indeed, it cannot be ruled out that in the present case the victim had suffered an uncivilised and heartless crime committed by the respondents and there is no room for leniency which can be conceived. A crime of this nature does not deserve any kind of clemency. This Court cannot be oblivious of the situation that the victim must have suffered an emotional distress which cannot be compensated either by sentencing the accused or by grant of any compensation.

    14. After going through the material on record, we are of the considered view that the respondent-accused have rightly been held guilty and their conviction under Section 326 IPC and sentence for 5 years at least needs no interference but at the same time, we are disposed to address on victim compensation which may at least bring same solace to the victim for the sufferings which she had suffered.

    15. In Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 6 SCC 770, a two-Judge Bench of this Court referred to the amended provision, 154th Law Commission Report that has devoted entire chapter of victimology, wherein the emphasis was on the victim.

    16. In Laxmi v. Union of India (2014) 4 SCC 427, this Court observed that Section 357-A came to be inserted in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 by Act 5 of 2009 w.e.f. 31-12-2009 which, inter alia, provides for preparation of a scheme for providing funds for the purpose of compensation to the victim or his dependents who have suffered loss or injury as a result of the crime and who require rehabilitation. This Court further directed that acid attack victims shall be paid compensation of at least Rs 3 lakhs by the State Government/Union Territory concerned as the aftercare and rehabilitation cost.

    17. In State of M.P. v. Mehtaab (2015) 5 SCC 197, this Court directed the compensation of Rs 2 lakhs noticing the fact that occurrence took place in 1997 and it observed that the said compensation was not adequate and accordingly, in addition to the said compensation to be paid by the accused, held that the State was also required to pay compensation under Section 357-A CrPC and reliance was placed on the decision in Suresh v. State of Haryana (2015) 2 SCC 227.

    18. Victim Compensation Scheme has been considered by this Court in State of H.P. v. Ram Pal (2015) 11 SCC 584 and this Court opined that compensation of Rs 40,000 was inadequate taking note of the fact that the life of young child aged 20 years was lost and taking note of the precedents observed that in the interest of justice, the accused is required to pay a sum of Rs 1 lakh and the State to pay a sum of Rs 3 lakhs as compensation.

    19. Taking note of the precedents of which reference has been made, we consider it appropriate to observe that both the accused shall pay the additional compensation of Rs 1,50,000 (Rupees one lakh and fifty thousand) each and the State of Himachal Pradesh shall pay the compensation as admissible under the Victim Compensation Scheme as in vogue to the acid victim (Ishita Sandhu, D/o Late Shri Rikhi Ram Sandhu) (Appellant 2). If the accused does not pay the additional compensation amount of Rs 1,50,000 (Rupees one lakh and fifty thousand) each within six months, the defaulting accused shall suffer rigorous imprisonment of six months. The State shall deposit the compensation before the trial court within three months from today and the learned trial court, after proper identification of the victim, disburse at the earliest.

    20. The impugned judgment 2008 SCC OnLine HP 254 of the High Court stands modified and the appeal is accordingly disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    THE STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH v. VIJAY KUMAR ALIAS PAPPU
    (Mar 15, 2019)