Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 994
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302 and 460 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Sections 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 994
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302 and 460 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Sections 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The prosecution alleged that the respondent-accused, harbouring vengeance against his cousin Santosh, entered her house at about 2:00 a.m. and fatally assaulted her with a lathi. A First Information Report was registered on the statement of the victim’s mother, PW-10 Devki Devi, after the police reached the scene on an anonymous telephone call. Upon investigation, a charge-sheet was filed under Sections 302, 460 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code.

The Sessions Court convicted the respondent under Sections 302 and 460 IPC, sentencing him to life imprisonment and ten years’ rigorous imprisonment respectively. On appeal, the Rajasthan High Court (Criminal Appeal No. 678 of 2004) acquitted him, extending the benefit of doubt. The State of Rajasthan obtained special leave and appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging this acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Supreme Court should interfere with the Rajasthan High Court’s order of acquittal in light of the principles governing appeals against acquittal.
  2. Whether the prosecution evidence—particularly the testimonies of two child witnesses and the forensic material—established the respondent’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant-State’s Arguments

  • The High Court erred in granting an acquittal despite clear ocular and forensic evidence establishing the respondent’s guilt.
  • Contradictions relied on by the High Court were minor and did not justify overturning a well-reasoned conviction.

Respondent-Accused’s Arguments

  • The High Court correctly noted substantial contradictions and inadequacies in the prosecution case, creating reasonable doubt.
  • Investigative lapses, unreliable child-witness testimony, and absence of independent corroboration undermined the prosecution version.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bannareddy v. State of Karnataka (2018) 5 SCC 790 Appellate interference with acquittal is warranted only when findings are perverse in fact or law. Framed the standard of review; Supreme Court examined whether the High Court’s acquittal was perverse and found it was not.
Dara Singh v. Union of India (2011) 2 SCC 490, para 94 Presumption of innocence is strengthened after an acquittal. Reinforced reluctance to overturn the High Court’s judgment.
Panchhi v. State of U.P. (1998) 7 SCC 177 Child-witness testimony must be scrutinised carefully and requires corroboration. Used to question reliability of PW-4 and PW-5, whose versions conflicted.
Krishnegowda v. State of Karnataka (2017) 13 SCC 98 When related eyewitnesses are incredible, absence of independent witnesses is fatal; contradictions that strike at the root invite benefit of doubt. Supported the conclusion that contradictions among family witnesses and lack of independent testimony undermined the prosecution case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first reiterated that interference with an acquittal is permissible only on demonstration of perversity. Evaluating the record, the Court highlighted multiple shortcomings in the prosecution case:

  • Conflicting child-witness accounts: PW-4 Kaptan and PW-5 Seema differed on the victim’s posture during the assault and could not specify the exact time, diminishing credibility.
  • Unexplained delay and manner of reporting: No family member informed the police; proceedings began only after an anonymous call, casting doubt on their presence at the scene.
  • Behaviour of key witnesses: PW-11, the victim’s father, allegedly witnessed the assault but neither intervened nor promptly viewed the body, actions the Court deemed “abnormal.”
  • Lack of independent corroboration: Despite the house being in a populated area, no neutral eyewitnesses were examined; related witnesses’ testimony required but lacked corroboration, consistent with Krishnegowda.
  • Forensic inconsistencies: Discrepancies between the seizure memo, forensic report, and testimony regarding a blood-stained lathi raised doubts about scientific evidence.
  • Overlooked defence evidence: The trial court ignored the accused’s explanation of prior enmity and marital discord of the deceased, which the High Court had considered.

Collectively, these factors generated reasonable doubt. Finding no perversity in the High Court’s evaluation, the Supreme Court declined to disturb the acquittal.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED – ACQUITTAL AFFIRMED.

Consequently, the respondent remains acquitted of all charges, and any pending applications stand disposed of. The judgment reinforces the high threshold for appellate interference with acquittals and underscores rigorous scrutiny of child-witness testimony and forensic consistency but does not create new substantive precedent beyond applying established principles.

    State Of Rajasthan v. Madan Alias Madaniya .

    N.V. Ramana, J.— This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 16-4-2010 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Rajasthan at Jodhpur in Madan v. State Criminal Appeal No. 678 of 2004, whereby the High Court acquitted the accused of the charges under Sections 302 and 460 of the Penal Code, 1860, giving him the benefit of doubt.

    2. Brief facts according to the prosecution case necessary for the disposal of this case are as follows. On receiving an anonymous telephonic information, regarding the killing of one Smt Santosh, daughter of Devki Devi Mali, the police reached the spot of occurrence and recorded the statement of PW 10 Smt Devki Devi, mother of the deceased. Therein, PW 10 Smt Devki Devi, alleged that, the respondent-accused, used to reside in vicinity and was harbouring vengeance against the deceased Santosh as he believed that, few days earlier he was assaulted by 7-8 men, at the instance of the deceased Santosh.

    3. On the date of the incident, while PW 10 was at her agricultural farm, at about 6.00 a.m., PW 5 Seema, her minor daughter came up to her and informed that, in the preceding night, the respondent-accused along with one person entered their home at around 2.00 a.m. and gave lathi-blows to the deceased, consequent to which she died. PW 10 Devki Devi, thereafter immediately rushed to the house and found the body of the deceased lying on the roof.

    4. On the basis of the aforesaid statement made by PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi), a case was registered against the respondent-accused and another person, thereafter they were arrested and subsequent recoveries were made in this regard. After completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet was filed charging the accused persons for the offence punishable under Sections 302, 460 and 34 IPC. Thereafter, the accused persons were put on trial as they did not plead guilty to the charges levelled against them.

    5. The trial court vide order dated 11-6-2004, convicted the accused for the offences under Sections 302 and 460 IPC. Accordingly, he was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life under Section 302 IPC, with fine of Rs 1000 and in default of payment of fine, the accused was directed to undergo 2 months' rigorous imprisonment. He was also directed to undergo 10 years' rigorous imprisonment for conviction under Section 460 IPC with a fine of Rs 500 and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo one month's rigorous imprisonment.

    6. On the other hand, the co-accused Sheokar alias Sheokumar was acquitted by the trial court after being given the benefit of doubt for the charges levelled against him under Sections 302 and 460 IPC.

    7. Aggrieved by the above order of conviction, the respondent-accused preferred an appeal before the High Court. The High Court allowed the appeal and set aside the order of conviction and sentence awarded by the learned Sessions Judge. The benefit of doubt was extended in favour of the accused and he was acquitted from all the charges.

    8. Aggrieved by the impugned order Criminal Appeal No. 678 of 2004 passed by the High Court, the State of Rajasthan has preferred this appeal.

    9. The counsel for the appellant State has submitted that the High Court has gravely erred while passing the order of acquittal despite the existing ocular evidence as well as forensic evidence wherein the guilt of the accused was clearly established.

    10. On the other hand, the counsel for the respondent-accused, while supporting the order of acquittal has submitted that, on objective appreciation of evidence, a reasonable doubt exists for disbelieving the case advanced by the prosecution. Hence, the High Court was right in granting the benefit of doubt to the respondent-accused.

    11. Heard the learned counsel for the parties. In an appeal against acquittal, the appellate court would only interfere where there exists perversity of fact and law. [See Bannareddy v. State of Karnataka (2018) 5 SCC 790.] Further, the presumption of innocence is further reinforced against the acquitted accused by having a judgment in his favour. [See Dara Singh v. Union of India (2011) 2 SCC 490, SCC para 94.]

    12. In light of the same, before we proceed to deal with the case, it would be appropriate to render a look at the statements of certain prosecution witnesses.

    13. PW 5 (Seema) aged 14, is the sister of the deceased and the respondent-accused was her maternal cousin, claimed to be an eyewitness to the said incident. She has stated that, on the date of occurrence while she, PW 4 (Kaptan), deceased Santosh and her two sons were fast asleep on the roof, the respondent-accused had come to their house and had started quarrelling with the deceased. The respondent-accused, thereafter hit the deceased on her head with a lathi due to which she fell down. After the incident, she deposed that she went to the fields in the following morning and informed PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi) about the aforesaid incident. She also stated that, when the police came at around 9.00 a.m., her mother (Smt Devki Devi) came with the police, although she admitted that none of the family members had informed the police about the incident.

    14. PW 4 (Kaptan), aged 12, is the brother of the deceased, claimed to be an eyewitness to the said incident and the respondent-accused was his maternal cousin. He stated that, he, PW 5 (Seema), deceased Santosh and her sons were sleeping on the terrace, while their father PW 11 (Lalchand) was sleeping in the courtyard. He stated that he woke up to a hue and cry, and he saw the deceased getting assaulted in a sitting condition. He also stated that, their house is situated in a populated neighbourhood and adjacent to their house, there was a temple and someone was sitting on the roof during the occurrence of the incident. Lastly, he stated that, none of the family members had informed the police about the incident.

    15. PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi), mother of the deceased, improved upon her earlier statement and stated that, while she was working in the fields both PW 4 (Kaptan) and PW 5 (Seema) came to the field to inform about the death of the deceased Santosh. Thereafter, she immediately returned back to the house and found the body of the deceased lying on the roof.

    16. PW 11 (Lalchand), father of the deceased, stated that, he was present in the house when the incident took place in the terrace, but since the respondent-accused threatened him, he did not interfere in the said incident. He further stated that, he sent his minor daughter PW 5 (Seema) at around 6.00 a.m. to the fields to inform his wife PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi) about the murder of deceased Santosh. He further clarified that, he did not send any neighbour to inform PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi) nor did he inform the police.

    17. PW 2 (Sohan Singh) stated that, he along with other villagers, went to the residence of PW 11 (Lalchand) and asked about the incident but PW 11 (Lalchand) and PW 10 (Devki Devi) did not disclose any name and on the contrary stated that, they are yet to confirm the same.

    18. It is equally pertinent to note the statements made by the accused under Section 313 CrPC and other defence witnesses. The accused in his statement under Section 313 CrPC has stated that, he has wrongfully been roped in as accused, due to existing prior enmity between the parties. The accused has also stated that, the deceased did not maintain a cordial relationship with her husband. The husband of the deceased had threatened to kill her pursuant to their disagreements.

    19. DW 1 (Kartar Singh), stated that he came to know about the incident in the morning and thereafter, he along with Gurjeet went to fetch PW 10, (Smt Devki Devi) from agricultural field at the instance of PW 11 (Lalchand). Thereafter, all three of them rushed to spot of occurrence by a tempo. This witness has further, stated that, when he reached the spot of occurrence, PW 11 (Lalchand), did not confirm who the assailants were as he himself was not aware about the same. Additionally, PW 1 (Kartar Singh), stated that one day prior to the incident, the deceased had an altercation with her husband, who had threatened to kill her.

    20. On perusal of the statements, we find that, there exist major contradictions in the statements of the prosecution witnesses while establishing the circumstances surrounding the murder of the deceased Santosh.

    21. Firstly, the case of the prosecution strongly relied upon the testimony rendered by the two child witnesses, PW 4 (Kaptan) and PW 5 (Seema). It is an established rule of practical wisdom, that evidence rendered by the child witness must be evaluated carefully and it must find adequate corroboration before it is relied on. (See Panchhi v. State of U.P. (1998) 7 SCC 177) Although, both PW 4 (Kaptan) and PW 5 (Seema) claimed to be the eyewitnesses to the entire incident, they have given different versions as to the position of the victim, while PW 4 (Kaptan) clearly stated that the accused gave blows to the deceased while she was sitting, PW 5 (Seema) on the contrary has stated that the victim was standing and after receiving the blow she fell down. Moreover, both the witnesses have failed to state the specific timing at which the incident occurred.

    22. Additionally, owing to severe contradictions in the statements of the prosecution witnesses, the prosecution has failed to prove the fact as to who gave the information to PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi). In our opinion, the High Court has correctly laid emphasis on this aspect, as it leads to the inference about the presence of PW 4 and PW 5 at the place of occurrence of the incident. In light of the above circumstances, the statements of both the child witnesses do not inspire confidence.

    23. Secondly, it is also pertinent to observe here that, although the incident happened around 2.00 a.m., but none of the family members chose to inform the police about the said occurrence. Rather the wheel of process, in the present case commenced upon receiving an anonymous telephonic information by the police. PW 5 (Seema) voluntarily stated in her statement that, a neighbour might have informed the police about the same. It was only after the reaching of the police on the spot of occurrence, that PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi) has stated about the incident and the guilt of the accused.

    24. Thirdly, the High Court on perusal of the statement of PW 11 (Lalchand) has raised suspicion, as it is quite abnormal that, he being the father of the deceased, did not interfere in the said occurrence although he was in the same house. Further, he admittedly did not go up to the terrace to see the deceased till the police came after long 6-7 hours, till this time the deceased was lying on the roof.

    25. Lastly, the fact as to why he sent his minor daughter instead of some responsible major to inform his wife PW 10 (Smt Devki Devi), who was present in the field at a distance of 2-3 km, at the early hours in the morning, raises doubt as to the credibility of this witness. Our attention is also drawn to the fact that, the statement of PW 11 (Lalchand) does not speak anything about the giving of information to independent witnesses DW 1 (Kartar Singh) and PW 2 (Sohan Singh), whereas, both these witnesses have clearly stated about their encounter with PW 11 (Lalchand) and PW 10 (Devki Devi), wherein they have expressed unawareness about the assailants. These contradictions go to the root of matter raising questions about the credibility of these witnesses.

    26. After having observed the evidence of the above crucial witnesses, a reference may be made to observations of this Court in Krishnegowda v. State of Karnataka (2017) 13 SCC 98, wherein it held that:

    “32. … Although there is no absolute rule that the evidence of related witnesses has to be corroborated by the evidence of independent witnesses, it would be trite in law to have independent witnesses when the evidence of related eyewitnesses is found to be incredible and not trustworthy. The minor variations and contradictions in the evidence of the eyewitnesses will not tilt the benefit of doubt in favour of the accused but when the contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses proves to be fatal to the prosecution case then those contradictions go to the root of the matter and in such cases the accused gets the benefit of doubt.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    27. In the present case, the evidence relied on by the prosecution is full of contradictions. We cannot ignore the fact that although PW 4 (Kaptan) clearly admitted that their house is situated in a populated neighbourhood, it is quite surprising that when the incident occurred on the terrace no one interfered or came to the place of occurrence until morning. The prosecution has failed to provide any independent witness to bring home the guilt of the accused.

    28. Further, the High Court also raised doubt while placing reliance upon the scientific evidence as there existed contradictions in the seizure list of the clothes of the deceased and the forensic evidence on record, which was left unexplained by the Public Prosecutor. Additionally, the prosecution has pressed that recovery was made subsequent to the confession of the accused. In this context, it is pertinent to note that, the alleged recovery was made in the presence of PW 7 (Sukhbir Singh) who is the paternal cousin of the deceased, who in his statement has stated that the lathi recovered had bloodstains in it. Surprisingly, this fact of lathi marked in bloodstains is not only absent in the recovery memo but also in the forensic report. These shortcomings imply a sketchy investigation hence, bringing the reliability of the above evidence into question considering the facts and circumstances of the present matter.

    29. Moreover, the High Court has correctly observed that the trial court totally overlooked the defence adduced by the respondent-accused, especially when he has denied the allegations levelled against him, vitiating the fundamentals of justice. In light of the above observations it is correctly concluded that there exists reasonable doubt for believing the case laid down by the prosecution and the guilt of the accused has not been proved beyond doubt.

    30. It is the duty of the court to separate the grains from the chaff and to extract the truth from the mass of evidence. In our opinion, the case of the prosecution is based on mere conjectures and surmises. Moreover, the material contradictions inevitably raise a doubt as to whether it was the respondent-accused, who had caused the death of the deceased Santosh. After examining the rationale behind the conclusion of the High Court in acquitting the respondent-accused, we do not find any compelling reasons to deviate from the same.

    31. In our opinion, there exists no perversity in the judgment Criminal Appeal No. 678 of 2004 of the High Court. Further, in the absence of compelling reasons, this Court is not keen to entertain this appeal challenging the order of acquittal.

    32. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. Pending applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Rajasthan v. Madan Alias Madaniya .
    (Oct 25, 2018)