Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1179
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 35 of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act
  • 1994 Act
  • The Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949
  • Section 35(3) of the Act
  • U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994
  • Section 35(1) and Section 35(3), Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 (3 of 1959)
  • Section 9-A of the said Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1179
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 35 of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act
  • 1994 Act
  • The Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949
  • Section 35(3) of the Act
  • U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994
  • Section 35(1) and Section 35(3), Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 (3 of 1959)
  • Section 9-A of the said Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal challenges the judgment dated 22-11-2018 (2018 SCC OnLine Bom 6126) of the High Court of Bombay, which dismissed the appellant’s writ petition. The dispute arose from a no-confidence motion moved on 7-9-2018 against the appellant, the Sarpanch of a Gram Panchayat comprising nine members. Pursuant to a notice issued by the Tahsildar on 7-9-2018, a special meeting was convened on 14-9-2018. Eight members attended; six voted for the motion and two opposed it.

One of the six who voted in favour, Smt. Sushila Prakash Darade, had not filed her caste certificate after the election and was thus disqualified to continue as a member or to vote. The appellant filed a dispute application under Rule 35(3-B) of the Maharashtra Gram Panchayat Rules, 1958 challenging the no-confidence motion. The Additional Collector, Nasik, by order dated 16-10-2018, approved the special meeting and held the motion validly passed. The appellant’s writ petition against that order was dismissed by the High Court. The present appeal followed. The Supreme Court heard the appellant and counsel for Respondent 4 (on caveat) and, since private respondents had common interests, did not issue notice to the others.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How to compute the “two-third majority” under Section 35(3) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959—specifically, whether it is calculated from (a) the total number of members “for the time being entitled to sit and vote” or (b) only those “present and voting,” when one member is disqualified.
  2. Whether, for purposes of Section 35(3), a fractional threshold (two-thirds of the entitled members equaling 5.33) can be rounded down to 5 votes, or whether at least 6 valid votes are mandatory.
  3. Whether the vote of a member who failed to submit the requisite caste certificate within six months of election (and is thus disqualified) can be counted towards the two-thirds majority or in the denominator for computing the threshold.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • With nine total members and one member (Smt. Sushila Prakash Darade) disqualified to sit and vote for failure to submit her caste certificate, the two-thirds requirement under Section 35(3) must be computed on the basis of eight entitled members, yielding a threshold of 5.33, i.e., at least six valid votes.
  • The disqualified member’s vote cannot be counted in favour of the motion; thus, only five valid votes support the motion, which is insufficient to meet the statutory two-thirds requirement.
  • Non-submission of the caste certificate within six months renders disqualification automatic, making the member ineligible to sit or vote.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Because only eight members were present and one was disqualified, the two-thirds majority should be computed from seven “present and voting” members. On that basis, five votes suffice to pass the motion.
  • Section 35(3) should be read as requiring a majority of not less than two-thirds of the “members present and voting,” so the five votes in favour meet the threshold.
  • Alternatively, applying the principle of rounding off, 5.33 should be treated as 5.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. v. Pawan Kumar Tiwari, (2005) 2 SCC 10 Rounding off in context of reservation/quota allocation; High Court had rounded 46.50 to 47 while ensuring reservation does not exceed 50%. Distinguished. The Court held that the case concerned computation of vacancies under a reservation statute and could not be applied to the computation of a special majority under Section 35(3).
Jayram Tolaji Shinde v. Urban Development Deptt., 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 502; (2010) 3 Mah LJ 465 (Full Bench) Clarified that rounding off was not the ratio of Pawan Kumar Tiwari and discussed handling of fractional allocations in a different statutory scheme. Treated as supporting the appellant. The Court noted the Full Bench’s view that Pawan Kumar Tiwari was decided mainly on the 50% cap context, not on a general rounding-off rule applicable here.
Anant H. Ulahalkar v. Chief Election Commissioner, 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9862; (2017) 1 Mah LJ 431 (Full Bench) Submission of caste validity certificate within six months is mandatory; failure results in automatic disqualification and retrospective termination of election. Followed. Used to hold that the member who failed to submit the caste certificate was disqualified and her vote could neither be counted nor included in the computation base.
Shankar v. State of Maharashtra, (2019) 3 SCC 220 Approval by the Supreme Court of the Full Bench view that the caste certificate requirement is mandatory. Affirmed the principle of automatic disqualification for failure to submit the caste certificate within the prescribed time.
High Court decision noted in Pawan Kumar Tiwari: 2003 SCC OnLine All 970; (2003) 6 AWC 5116 Rounded 46.50 to 47 in the general category within the context of reservation percentages. Referenced as part of the discussion in Pawan Kumar Tiwari; no independent application to the present case.
Vasant Gite, 2007 SCC OnLine Bom 425; (2007) 4 Mah LJ 871 Mentioned in the Full Bench’s discussion in Jayram Tolaji Shinde regarding rounding off. Only cited within the quoted discussion from Jayram Tolaji Shinde; no direct application by the Court in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • Statutory text and key phrase: The Court emphasized the language of Section 35(3) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959, which requires that a no-confidence motion be carried by “a majority of not less than two-third of the total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at any meeting of the panchayat.” The crucial words are “entitled to sit and vote,” which set the denominator for computing the two-thirds majority.
  • Denominator is “entitled to sit and vote,” not “present and voting”: With a total of nine members and one disqualified member, the number of members entitled to sit and vote was eight. The Court rejected the respondents’ interpretation that the denominator should be the number “present and voting” (seven, after excluding the disqualified member). It held that “entitled to sit and vote” cannot be read as “present and voting.”
  • Effect of disqualification: Relying on the Full Bench decision in Anant H. Ulahalkar (automatic disqualification for non-submission of caste certificate within six months) and this Court’s approval in Shankar, the Court held that the disqualified member’s vote could not be counted and that she could not be part of the entitlement base.
  • Computation of the threshold and fractional votes: Two-thirds of eight equals 5.33. The statute uses the phrase “not less than two-third,” which the Court read strictly. Votes cannot be fractional; therefore, a fractional requirement of 5.33 necessitates at least six valid votes. The Court rejected the respondents’ plea to round 5.33 down to 5.
  • Rounding off distinguished: The Court noted that rounding off, as discussed in Pawan Kumar Tiwari, was applied in the context of vacancy allocation under a reservation regime and was influenced by the constitutional limit that reservation cannot exceed 50%. It held that such rounding-off logic is inapplicable to the special-majority requirement under Section 35(3). The Full Bench in Jayram Tolaji Shinde was cited to underscore that rounding off was not the core ratio of Pawan Kumar Tiwari.
  • Special-majority compliance must be exact: Drawing on the statutory language and a treatise observation (Shackleton on Meetings) about strict compliance with special majorities, the Court concluded that the statutory threshold had not been met because only five valid votes supported the motion.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: APPEAL ALLOWED; IMPUGNED ORDERS SET ASIDE. The Supreme Court held that the no-confidence motion was not validly passed because it did not secure “not less than two-third” of the total number of members entitled to sit and vote. The proceedings dated 14-9-2018, the Additional Collector’s order approving them, and the High Court’s judgment dismissing the writ petition were set aside.

Implications: Directly, the no-confidence motion against the appellant fails and the validating orders are annulled. More broadly, the decision clarifies that under Section 35(3) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959, (a) the two-thirds majority must be computed with reference to members “entitled to sit and vote,” not merely those “present and voting,” (b) votes of disqualified members cannot be counted or included in the denominator, and (c) fractional thresholds cannot be rounded down—“not less than two-third” requires meeting or exceeding the fractional value, which in practice means rounding up to the next whole vote since votes cannot be fractional.

    Ganesh Sukhdeo Gurule v. Tahsildar, Sinnar And Others

    Ashok Bhushan, J.— This appeal has been filed against the judgment dated 22-11-2018 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 6126 of the High Court of Bombay dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellant.

    2. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant as well as the counsel for Respondent 4 who has appeared on caveat. The interest of Respondent 4 and other private respondents being common we have not issued notice to other respondents.

    3. The brief facts of the case necessary for deciding the appeal are: on 7-9-2018, the respondents moved a no-confidence motion against the appellant. The Tahsildar issued notice dated 7-9-2018 convening special meeting of Gram Panchayat for consideration of no-confidence motion on 14-9-2018. On 14-9-2018, out of nine members of the Gram Panchayat only eight members were present in the meeting. Six members voted in favour of the motion and two members were opposed to it. One of the members who voted in favour of no-confidence motion was not qualified to vote, namely, Smt Sushila Prakash Darade who had not filed her caste certificate after election, hence, she was disqualified to continue to be a member or to vote in any meeting.

    4. A dispute application under Rule 35(3-B) of the Maharashtra Gram Panchayat Rules, 1958 challenging the no-confidence motion passed was filed. The Additional Collector, Nasik passed an order dated 16-10-2018 approving the special meeting dated 14-9-2018 holding that no-confidence motion was validly passed. Against the order passed by the Additional Collector, a writ petition was filed by the appellant which has been dismissed by the High Court by the impugned judgment. Aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court this appeal has been filed.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that total members of Gram Panchayat being nine and one member being disqualified to vote the two-third majority has to be computed on the basis of eight members which comes to 5.33 and there being only five valid votes in favour of no-confidence motion, motion cannot be held to be passed. One of the members who voted in favour of no-confidence motion i.e. Smt Sushila Prakash Darade being disqualified to sit and vote cannot be counted in favour of no-confidence motion, two-third majority being 5.33, at least six votes were required for passing the no-confidence motion. It is submitted that caste certificate being not submitted by Smt Sushila Prakash Darade within six months as required by law she automatically became disqualified to sit or vote in the meeting of Gram Panchayat.

    6. The submissions made by the counsel of the appellant were refuted by the counsel for the respondent. It is submitted that there being only eight members present and one being disqualified, two-third majority shall be computed from seven and five votes cast in favour of the no-confidence motion, the motion shall be treated to be validly passed. It is contended that provision of Section 35(3) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 (3 of 1959) has to be read to mean that majority of not less than two-third of total number of members present and voting, thus, there being only 8 members present, majority is to be computed from 7 excluding one disqualified member. He submits that motion of no confidence was validly passed against the appellant and rightly upheld by the High Court.

    7. The learned counsel for the parties relied on a few judgments which shall be referred to while considering the submissions.

    8. Section 35 of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act deals with motion of no confidence. Section 35(1) and Section 35(3), which are relevant for the present case, are as follows:

    “35. Motion of no confidence.—(1) A motion of no confidence may be moved by not less than one-third of the total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at any meeting of the panchayat against the Sarpanch or the Upa-Sarpanch after giving such notice thereof to the Tahsildar as may be prescribed. [Such notice once given shall not be withdrawn.]
    ***
    (3) If the motion is carried by a majority of not less than two-third of the total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at any meeting of the panchayat or the Upa-Sarpanch, as the case may be, shall forthwith stop exercising all the powers and perform all the functions and duties of the office and thereupon such powers, functions and duties shall vest in the Upa-Sarpanch in case the motion is carried out against the Sarpanch; and in case the motion is carried out against both the Sarpanch and Upa-Sarpanch, in such officer, not below the rank of Extension Officer, as may be authorised by the Block Development Officer, till the dispute, if any, referred to under sub-section (3-B) is decided:”

    9. The main issue which arises for consideration is that what shall be two-third majority for holding the no-confidence motion to be passed in the Panchayat in the facts of the present case. Admittedly there are nine members in the Village Panchayat. Out of nine members in the meeting held on 14-9-2018, eight members were present. Out of eight members present, one member was disqualified to sit and vote by virtue of she having not submitted her caste certificate after the election. She was one out of six members who have voted in favour of no-confidence motion. There are five valid votes in favour of no-confidence motion as two against it. The statute provides for special majority for passing a motion.

    10. Shackleton on the Law and Practice of Meetings in Para 7.32, while dealing with special majority, states:

    “In cases where special majorities are prescribed, the provisions of the relevant statute or rules must be carefully observed. Thus, where under an old Act a motion was to be “determined by a majority consisting of two-thirds of the votes of the ratepayers present” at a meeting, and 37 were present, the votes of 20 ratepayers in favour of the motion (the remainder abstaining) were deemed to be insufficient to comply with the statute.”

    11. In the present case statute, Section 35(3) refers to majority as “a majority of not less than two-third of the total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at any meeting of the Panchayat”. The above expression clearly indicates the majority of not less than two-third of the “total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote”. The key words in the expression are members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at a meeting in the Panchayat. The computation of majority thus refers to “entitlement to sit and vote at any meeting”. Thus, the number of members who are entitled to sit and vote in a meeting have to be taken into consideration for computing the majority. Total number of members being nine and one member being disqualified to sit and vote, the computation of majority has to be on the basis of number eight, two-third of the number eight will be 5.33. The submission of the respondent is that the two-third majority has to be computed out of the members present and voting i.e. seven excluding one member who was unqualified to vote and five is more than two-third of seven, the majority has been rightly passed. The interpretation put by the learned counsel for the respondent cannot be accepted in view of the clear language of statute. The crucial words in the statute are members “who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote”. This expression cannot be treated to be expression “members present and voting”. The submission of the respondent that for computation of majority, number of seven members should be treated, cannot be accepted.

    12. The next submission pressed by the respondent is that for applying the principle of rounding off 5.33 votes have to be rounded as to five. Thus, five votes are sufficient to accept majority for the purpose of passing no-confidence motion. Whether 5.33 votes can be rounded up into 5 votes or requirement is at least six votes is the real issue. When there are clear words in the statute i.e. “not less than two-third of the total number of members”, applying the principle of rounding off, 5.33 votes cannot be treated as 5. Vote of a person cannot be expressed in fraction. When computation of a majority comes with fraction of a vote that fraction has to be treated as one vote, because votes cannot be expressed in fraction. The principle that figure less than .5 is to be ignored and figure more than .5 shall be treated as one, is not applicable in the statutory scheme as delineated by Section 35. Provision of Section 35(1) which provides for requirement for moving motion of no confidence by not less than one-third of the total number of the members who are for the time being entitled to sit and vote at any meeting of the Panchayat, is the same expression as used in sub-section (3). Obviously, requirement of not less than one-third number for moving motion has to be computed from total number of the members who are entitled to sit and vote. Thus, the same expression having been used in sub-section (3) of Section 35, both the expressions have to be given the same meaning. Thus, one-third of total number of members who are entitled to sit and vote have to be determined on the strength of members entitled to vote at a particular time. The same meaning has also to be applied while computing two-third majority.

    13. The learned counsel for the respondent has placed reliance on two judgments, one, of this Court in State of U.P. v. Pawan Kumar Tiwari (2005) 2 SCC 10. In the above case, this Court was considering applicability of percentage of reservation in the context of the U.P. Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994. The percentage prescribed for the reservation category in the State of U.P. noticed in para 2 of the judgment. The respondent belonging to general category was at the top of the waiting list. He filed a writ petition directing the State to issue a letter of appointment to the respondent. The High Court held 2003 SCC OnLine All 970, (2003) 6 AWC 5116 that 50% of general category which was 46.50 ought to have been treated as 47. The High Court had allowed the writ petition and held the respondent entitled for appointment as 47th general category candidate. The appeal filed by the State was dismissed by this Court. Paras 2, 6 and 7 of the judgment are as follows:

    “2. The percentages of reservation, as applicable and as was actually applied, are set out in the following table:
    Category Percentage (prescribed) Percentage worked out to Number of posts reserved General 50% 46.50 46 Scheduled Castes 21% 19.53 20 Other Backward Classes 27% 25.11 26 Scheduled Tribes 2% 1.86 1
    ***
    6. The High Court has found mainly two faults with the process adopted by the State Government. First, the figure of 46.50 should have been rounded off to 47 and not to 46; and secondly, in the category of freedom fighters and ex-servicemen, total 3 posts have been earmarked as horizontally reserved by inserting such reservation into general quota of 46 posts which had the effect of pushing out of selection zone three candidates from merit list of general category.
    7. We do not find fault with any of the two reasonings adopted by the High Court. The rule of rounding off based on logic and common sense is: if part is one-half or more, its value shall be increased to one and if part is less than half then its value shall be ignored. 46.50 should have been rounded off to 47 and not to 46 as has been done. If 47 candidates would have been considered for selection in general category, the respondent was sure to find a place in the list of selected meritorious candidates and hence entitled to appointment.”

    14. The judgment of this Court in the above case was on rounding off the vacancies. The reserved post being 50% of the total number of posts, reservation in no manner can exceed 50%. In the facts of aforesaid case, there were total 93 posts, 47 was treated more than 50%. Hence, the post for general category which was 46.50 was rounded off to 47 by the High Court which was approved by this Court. The said case related to computation of vacancies for particular category as per the 1994 Act which principle cannot be applied in computation of a special majority as required by the statute in question.

    15. Another judgment is a Full Bench judgment in Jayram Tolaji Shinde v. Urban Development Deptt. 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 502, (2010) 3 Mah LJ 465, which is relied on by the learned counsel for the respondent, by referring to the judgment of this Court in Pawan Kumar Tiwari (2005) 2 SCC 10 the Full Bench of Bombay High Court held that there is no justification that fraction below 0.5 be ignored in allotting the seats to registered or recognised parties on the basis of groups as per statutory scheme delineated by the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949. Referring to the judgment of this Court in Pawan Kumar Tiwari (2005) 2 SCC 10 in para 31, the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court has rightly held that rounding off was not the ratio or principle on which Pawan Kumar Tiwari case (2005) 2 SCC 10 was decided. Para 31 of the judgment is quoted below: (Jayram Tolaji Shinde 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 502, (2010) 3 Mah LJ 465, SCC OnLine Bom)

    “31. Mr Anturkar, learned counsel vehemently contended that rule of rounding off is now well recognised and is based upon the logic and common sense. For this he relied upon State of U.P. v. Pawan Kumar Tiwari (2005) 2 SCC 10. In that case, 93 posts of Civil Judges, J.D. were advertised and 50% of the posts were reserved for different categories and 50% were for the general or open category. In view of this percentage, 46.50 seats would be available for reserved category and 46.50 for general category. The State Government rounded off the number of posts available for general category at 46 and for the reserved category at 47. The High Court found fault with the process and held that the number of posts available for general category could not be rounded off at 46, but should have been rounded off at 47. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal of the State Government and held that if the seats for reserved category are fixed at 47, it would cross the limit of 50% and therefore it could not be upheld and as such number of posts available for reserved category could be fixed at 46 and that for general category should have been fixed at 47. Their Lordships observed as follows in para 9: (Pawan Kumar Tiwari case (2005) 2 SCC 10)
    ‘9. There is yet another reason why the judgment 2003 SCC OnLine All 970, (2003) 6 AWC 5116 of the High Court has to be maintained. The total number of vacancies was 93. Consequent upon the allocation of reservation and calculation done by the appellants, the number of reserved seats would be 47, leaving only 46 available for general category candidates. Meaning thereby, the reservation would exceed 50% which would be unconstitutional. The total number of reserved seats could not have been more than 46 out of 93.’
    In fact, in this case, both the groups had 46.5 and if the same formula would be applied, then in each case .50 could have been rounded off to 1 and each of the groups would be entitled to 47 seats. In that case, the total number would become 94, while the total vacancies available were only 93. Thus, rounding off is not the ratio or principle on which that case was decided. It was decided mainly on the question as to whether reserved categories may get seats more than 50% quota. Therefore the authority in Pawan Kumar Tiwari case (2005) 2 SCC 10 could not be used in support of the view taken in Vasant Gite 2007 SCC OnLine Bom 425, (2007) 4 Mah LJ 871.”

    16. Further, in para 34 of Jayram Tolaji Shinde 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 502, (2010) 3 Mah LJ 465, the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court itself held that there is no justification to ignore fraction below 0.5 in the context of allocation of registered or recognised parties or groups who are entitled to number of seats. The above judgment of the Bombay High Court in no manner supports the case of the respondent, it rather supports the appellant's contention.

    17. The learned counsel for the appellant insofar as disqualification of one of the members who had not filed her caste certificate, is concerned, relied on Anant H. Ulahalkar v. Chief Election Commr. 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9862, (2017) 1 Mah LJ 431; before the Full Bench the issue was raised as to whether on non-submission of caste certificate within six months' period, disqualification is automatic. Answering the reference, the Full Bench held that the provision for requiring submission of caste certificate within a period of six months for election is mandatory and disqualification would be automatic. In para 100 of the judgment, the Full Bench held the following: (SCC OnLine Bom)

    “100. In the result, we hold that the time-limit of six months prescribed in the two provisos to Section 9-A of the said Act, within which an elected person is required to produce the validity certificate from the Scrutiny Committee is mandatory.
    Further, in terms of the second proviso to Section 9-A, if a person fails to produce validity certificate within a period of six months from the date on which he is elected, his election shall be deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and he shall be disqualified for being a Councillor.
    Such retrospective termination of his election and disqualification for being a Councillor would be automatic and validation of his caste claim after the stipulated period would not result in restoration of his election.
    The questions raised, stand answered accordingly.”

    18. It is further relevant to note that this Court in Shankar v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 3 SCC 220 has approved the view taken by the Full Bench vide its judgment dated 23-8-2018 by holding that the requirement of submitting caste certificate is mandatory.

    19. Thus, insofar as vote of one member, Smt Sushila Prakash Darade, is concerned, the same can neither be computed for the no-confidence motion nor is relevant for computing two-third majority as per the statutory scheme. The words “not less than” used in Section 35(3) of the Act has to be given meaning and purpose. When majority comes to 5.33 votes “not less than 5.33 votes” have to be given meaning, hence, 5.33 can never be rounded off to 5, fraction has to be treated as one because votes cannot be treated as fraction. Hence, 5.33 votes to be read as 6 votes for passing of the motion as mandated by Section 35(3).

    20. We are, thus, of the view that no confidence motion was not validly passed and the order of the Additional Collector as well as of the High Court are erroneous. It is held that motion of no-confidence was not passed against the appellant since it was not passed by not less than two-third of the total number of the members who were for the time being entitled to sit and vote. The proceedings dated 14-9-2018, order of the Additional Collector approving the proceedings as well as the judgment of the High Court dismissing the writ petition are set aside. The appeal is allowed accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganesh Sukhdeo Gurule v. Tahsildar, Sinnar And Others
    (Dec 10, 2018)