Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Second Appeal arose from a suit filed by the plaintiff seeking a permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendant, who were joint owners in possession of a land measuring 4 kanals 10 marlas in village Dhanori. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant encroached upon a common passage between their respective houses by raising a plinth for construction. The defendant contended that the construction was on his settled possession and challenged the maintainability of the suit on the ground that the property was joint and unpartitioned, and thus the plaintiff should have sought partition instead. The trial Court framed four issues, deciding the preliminary issue of maintainability in favor of the plaintiff but dismissed the suit on other grounds, including lack of specific demarcation of the passage and extent of encroachment. The appellate Court reversed the trial Court’s decision, decreeing the suit in favor of the plaintiff, holding that the plaintiff had sufficiently proved the existence of the common passage and encroachment by the defendant. The defendant appealed to this Court on a substantial question of law regarding the right of a co-owner to seek injunction against another co-owner without partition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a co-owner can seek an injunction restraining the other co-owner from using a joint property or raising construction thereon without seeking relief of partition?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellate Court erred in decreeing the suit without proper identification and demarcation of the suit passage and the exact encroachment.
  • The suit for permanent prohibitory injunction by one co-sharer against another was not maintainable because the plaintiff had an alternative efficacious remedy by filing a suit for partition.
  • The suit passage was jointly owned and possessed, not exclusively possessed by the plaintiff, and therefore injunction was not maintainable without partition.
  • Relied upon judgments of Punjab and Haryana High Court in Jaga Ram and others v. Amar Singh and others (1998 AIHC 2717) and Calcutta High Court in Sachindra Nath Sarkar and others v. Binapani Basi and others (AIR 1976 Calcutta 277).

Respondent's Arguments

  • The defendant was not entitled to encroach upon the common passage which was not exclusively in his possession and was liable to be restrained by permanent injunction.
  • The contradictions regarding description and dimension of the passage were trivial and inconsequential.
  • The existence of the common passage and encroachment was amply proved including by the Patwari’s evidence.
  • Disputed factual questions do not raise substantial questions of law and the Court should confine itself to the substantial question of law framed at admission.
  • Relied upon Punjab and Haryana High Court judgment in Sant Ram Nagina Ram v. Daya Ram Nagina Rai (AIR 1961 Punjab 528), this Court’s judgment in Abhey Singh v. Gian Singh and others (1971 JKLR 326), and Rajasthan High Court judgment in Chhagan Lal v. Kesar Lal and others.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sachindra Nath Sarkar and others v. Binapani Basi and others (AIR 1976 Calcutta 277)
  • A co-owner is not entitled to injunction against another co-owner simply by virtue of co-ownership.
  • Injunction requires showing of injury affecting enjoyment or user of joint property.
  • Relief is discretionary based on justice, equity, and good conscience.
The Court relied on these principles to hold that injunction is not absolutely barred but depends on injury and discretion.
Jaga Ram and others v. Amar Singh and others (1998 AIHC 2717)
  • Maintainability of suit for possession by co-sharer against another co-sharer.
  • Remedy is not necessarily limited to partition suit, depending on facts.
The Court distinguished this case to show that injunction suits may be maintainable in certain circumstances.
Sant Ram Nagina Ram v. Daya Ram Nagina Rai (AIR 1961 Punjab 528)
  • Detailed propositions on co-ownership rights and possession.
  • Possession by one co-owner is possession on behalf of all unless ouster is proved.
  • Co-owners have right to use joint property in a husband-like manner.
  • Injunction against co-owner for encroachment on joint property is maintainable without showing special damage.
The Court extensively relied on these propositions to affirm the plaintiff’s right to injunction for encroachment on the common passage.
Abhey Singh v. Gian Singh and others (1971 JKLR 326) Co-sharer cannot build on joint land without consent of others, even if no direct loss is caused. Supported the principle that injunction is maintainable against unauthorized construction by co-sharer.
Chhagan Lal v. Kesar Lal and others (Rajasthan High Court) In suit for injunction against co-owner for encroachment, special damage need not be shown; deprivation of user suffices. Used to reinforce that injunction is maintainable without proof of special damage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged that the substantial question of law was not res integra but proceeded to analyze the legal principles governing injunction suits between co-owners. It referred to authoritative precedents outlining that a co-owner is not automatically entitled to injunction against another co-owner merely due to co-ownership; rather, an injunction is warranted if the plaintiff establishes an injury affecting his enjoyment or use of the joint property. The Court examined the facts and found undisputed evidence that a common passage existed between the parties’ houses and that the defendant had encroached upon this passage by laying a plinth. The trial Court’s concerns about the exact dimensions and extent of encroachment were deemed trivial and inconsequential. The defendant failed to prove exclusive possession of the encroached portion. The Court emphasized that injunction suits by one co-sharer against another are maintainable under circumstances where encroachment or interference with joint property use occurs, without the necessity of prior partition. The Court thus upheld the appellate Court’s decision reversing the trial Court’s dismissal, finding no illegality or error in law or fact.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The Court held that a co-owner can seek a permanent prohibitory injunction against another co-owner for encroachment or interference with joint property without first seeking partition. The decision confirms that injunctions are maintainable in such circumstances and that the remedy of partition is not the sole recourse. The immediate effect is the affirmation of the appellate Court’s decree in favor of the plaintiff restraining the defendant’s encroachment. No new precedent was set beyond the application of established principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Girdhari Lal v. Ram Lal

    Honble Mr Justice Sanjeev Kumar, Judge Appearance: For the petitioner(s) : Mr. S.D.Sharma, Advocate. For the respondent(s) : Mr. P.N.Raina, Sr. Advocate with Mr. JA Hamal, Advocate and Ms. Garima Gupta, Advocate. i/ Whether to be reported in Yes. Press/Media? ii/ Whether to be reported in Yes. Digest/Journal?

    1. This appeal was admitted to hearing on 21.08.2003 on the following substantial question of law:- Whether a co-owner can seek an injunction, restraining the other co-owner from using a joint property or raising construction thereon without seeking relief of partition?

    2. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length on the aforesaid question of law. Before I proceed to deal with the rival contentions, it would be appropriate to refer to the factual matrix in the context of which, this Civil Second Appeal has arisen. CSA No. 14/2003 Page 2 of 12

    3. The appellant herein was defendant in the trial Court. The respondent herein was the plaintiff who had filed the suit for permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendant, who is appellant herein. To avoid confusion, the parties are hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff and the defendant. The suit filed by the plaintiff against the defendant was for seeking a decree of permanent prohibitory injunction; with a further relief of mandatory injunction on the ground that the plaintiff and the defendant were joint owners in possession of the land measuring 4 kanals 10 marlas comprised in Khasra No.703 situated in village Dhanori, Tehsil Udhamapur in equal shares. The case set up by the plaintiff in the suit was that the parties without going for partition by metes and bounds had constructed their respective houses in two different portions of the aforesaid joint holding and that in between the houses of the parties, there exited a common passage. It was alleged that the defendant, who was raising the construction of his house had also raised the plinth over the common passage. The suit was resisted by the defendant on the ground that he had already completed the construction and was only to fix the doors and windows etc. and that he had raised the construction after dismantling the old structure of his house which was in his settled possession for the last several years. The CSA No. 14/2003 Page 3 of 12 defendant, however, admitted in the written statement that he had laid the plinth for Varandha but had not completed the construction. A specific plea was taken by the defendant that since the suit land was the joint property of the parties which had not been partitioned and therefore, the plaintiff was not entitled to claim any relief unless the suit land was partitioned by metes and bounds. The maintainability of the suit on this score was challenged by the defendant.

    4. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, four issues were framed by the trial Court. The issue No.1 which pertained to the maintainability of the suit was treated as a preliminary issue and the same was decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant by the order of the trial Court dated 22.05.1998. The other issues were not held proved in favour of the plaintiff and, accordingly, the suit was dismissed. The trial Court found discrepancy in the oral evidence with regard to the extent of encroachment allegedly made by the defendant over the suit passage. The trial Court also found fault with the frame of suit on the ground that the plaintiff in his suit had not specifically indicated demarcation and dimension of the suit passage. On an appeal, the appellate Court reversed the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court and decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff. The CSA No. 14/2003 Page 4 of 12 appellate Court reversed the judgment and decree of the trial Court primarily on the ground that the discrepancy in the oral evidence brought on record by the plaintiff was minor and inconsequential and the plaintiff had amply proved that their existed a common passage between the residential houses of the parties and the defendant had encroached a part of it by laying plinth for construction of his Varandha. The appellate Court also relied upon the statement of the defendant to come to the aforesaid conclusion.

    5. Feeling aggrieved, the defendant has come up before this Court in this Civil Second Appeal. As noted above, this Court on consideration of the matter admitted this petition on the solitary question of law as reproduced hereinabove in the beginning of this Order.

    6. In the backdrop of aforesaid facts, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the appellate Court failed to appreciate that in the absence of proper identification and demarcation of the suit passage and the exact encroachment made thereon, the suit of the plaintiff could not have been decreed and even if decreed, the same would be incapable of being put to execution. He, therefore, urges that the learned appellate Court committed a serious error of law and facts in reversing the well-reasoned judgment of the trial Court. He further CSA No. 14/2003 Page 5 of 12 reiterates his arguments with regard to the maintainability of the suit. Learned counsel submits that the suit for permanent prohibitory injunction by one co-sharer against the other was not maintainable as the plaintiff had an equal efficacious remedy of filing the suit for partition. Elaborating his arguments, learned counsel for the defendant submits that the suit passage as per the plaintiff was jointly owned and possessed by the parties and not in the exclusive possession of the plaintiff and therefore, that being the position, the suit for injunction simpliciter was not maintainable unless the plaintiff would have prayed for partition of the joint property including the suit passage by metes and bounds. Learned counsel for the defendant places strong reliance upon the judgment of Punjab and Harayana High Court rendered in the case of Jaga Ram and others v. Amar Singh and others reported in 1998 AIHC 2717 and the judgment of Calcutta High Court rendered in the case of Sachindra Nath Sarkar and others v. Binapani Basi and others reported in AIR 1976 Calcutta 277.

    7. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent argues that since the appellant and the respondent were the joint owner in possession of the suit passage and therefore, the defendant was not entitled to encroach upon the passage which was not exclusively in his possession and was, CSA No. 14/2003 Page 6 of 12 therefore, liable to be restrained by a decree of permanent prohibitory injunction. He places reliance upon the judgment of Punjab and Harayana High Court passed in case of Sant Ram Nagina Ram v. Daya Ram Nagina Rai reported in AIR 1961 Punjab 528 and judgment of this Court in the case Abhey Singh v. Gian Singh and others, reported in 1971 JKLR 326 and other judgment relied upon by the plaintiff is by the High Court of Rajasthan in the case of Chhagan Lal v. Kesar Lal and others.

    8. To the plea of the appellant that the suit could not have been decreed by the appellate Court as the suit property was neither identified nor the alleged encroachment was specified, learned counsel appearing for the respondent submits that as rightly observed by the appellate Court, the contradictions pointed out by the trial Court were trivial and inconsequential. He submits that from the pleadings of the parties, it was amply on record that there existed a common passage between the respective houses of the plaintiff and the defendant and the plaintiff had sufficiently demonstrated by way of his own evidence as also by recording the statement of the concerned Patwari that the common passage had been encroached. He further urges that the aforesaid plea raised by the learned counsel for the plaintiff pertains to the disputed question of facts CSA No. 14/2003 Page 7 of 12 and do not give rise to any additional substantial question of law. He, therefore, submits that in these proceedings, this Court should confine itself to the determination of the substantial question of law framed at the time of admission of this appeal.

    9. Considering the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing on both the sides, I am of the view that the question of law formulated is no longer res integra and therefore, strictly speaking, is not a substantial question of law for the purpose of admission of a Civil Second Appeal.

    10. In the case of Sachindra Nath Sarkar (supra) relied upon by the defendant, rendered by the Calcutta High Court, issue has been very succinctly dealt with. The observations of the Calcutta High Court made in Paragraph No.18 of the judgment are noteworthy and are therefore, reproduced herein under:-

    18. Consistent with the decisions of this Court, the position in law is as follows:-- (a) the co-owner is not entitled to an injunction restraining another co-owner from exceeding his rights in the common property, absolutely and simply because he is a co-owner. (b) before an injunction can be issued, the plaintiff has to establish that he would sustain, by the act he complains of some injury which materially would affect his position or his enjoyment or accustomed user of the joint property would be inconvenienced or interfered with. CSA No. 14/2003 Page 8 of 12 (c) the question as to what relief should be granted is left to the discretion of the Court in the attending circumstances on the balance of convenience and in exercise of its discretion the Court will be guided by consideration of justice, equity and good conscience.

    11. However, in the second judgment relied upon by the defendant rendered in the case of Jaga Ram and others (supra) the Punjab and Haryana High Court while dealing with the issue of maintainability of a suit for possession by a co-sharer against another co-sharer in Paragraph No.5 held thus:-

    5. Keeping in view the ratio decidendi of the aforesaid authorities, I am of the view that the learned District judge was wrong in observing that the remedy of the appellants lay not in a suit by way of permanent injunction but in an action for partition. The rulings alluded to by him in support of his observations are clearly distinguishable and have no bearing on the present case which does not relate to a cultivable land and in which it is also established from the evidence lead by both the parties that the construction of the Chhun (cattle shed) on the banks of the pond near Devasthan would not only cause obstruction to a large number of co-sharers in performing puja and other rituals but would also pollute the water of the pond which is used for drinking and washing purposes.

    12. Similarly, in the case of Abhey Singh (supra) rendered by this Court, it has been clearly laid down that one co-sharer out of the many has no right to build on what is joint land without the consent of others notwithstanding that the erection of such building may cause no direct loss to other joint owners. Similarly, the CSA No. 14/2003 Page 9 of 12 High Court of Rajasthan in the case of Chhagan Lal (supra) alluded to the same question of law and held that in suit for injunction against the co-owner relating to the encroachment on joint property, there is no occasion for the plaintiff to show any special damage. It is sufficient for the plaintiff to demonstrate that all by an act and admission of defendant, he has been deprived of the user of the property as it stood originally. In the case of Sant Ram Nagina Ram (supra) the Division Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court after elaborately discussing the issue in paragraph No.78 laid down nine propositions. It would not be inappropriate to reproduce what was held by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Paragraph No.78 of the aforesaid judgment:-

    78. The weight of the authorities and the principles which have been discussed above, give rise to the following propositions - (1) A co-Owner has an interest in the whole property and also in every parcel of it. (2) Possession of the joint property by one co- owner is in the eye of law, possession of all even if all but one are actually out of possession. (3) A mere occupation of a larger portion or even of an entire joint property does not necessarily amount to ouster as the possession of one is deemed to be on behalf of all. (4) The above rule admits of an exception when there is ouster of a co-owner by another. But in order to negative the presumption of joint possession CSA No. 14/2003 Page 10 of 12 on behalf of all, on the ground of ouster, the possession, of a co-owner must not only be exclusive but also hostile to the knowledge of the other, as, when a co-owner openly asserts his own title and denies that of the other. (5) Passage of time does not extinguish the right of the co-owner who has been out of possession of the joint property except in the event of ouster or abandonment. (6) Every co-owner has a right to use the joint property in a husband like manner not inconsistent with similar rights of other co-owners. (7) Where a co-owner is in possession of separate parcels under an arrangement consented to by the other co-owners, it is not open to anyone to disturb the arrangement without the consent of others except by filing a suit for partition. (8) The remedy of a co-owner not in possession, or not in possession of a share of the joint property, is by way of a suit for partition or for actual joint possession, but not for ejectment. Same is the case where a co-owner sets up an exclusive title in himself. (9) Where a portion of the joint property is, by common consent of the co-owners, reserved for a particular common purpose, it cannot be diverted to an inconsistent user by a co-owner; if he does so, he is liable to be ejected and the particular parcel will be liable to be restored to its original condition. It is not necessary in such a case to show that special damage has been suffered.

    13. When the issue raised in this appeal is examined in the backdrop of the legal position adumbrated herein above, it is noticed that indisputably the suit property in the instant case is a common passage existing between the CSA No. 14/2003 Page 11 of 12 houses of the plaintiff and the defendant. It is not the case of the defendant that except for the land under their respective occupation in the shape of construction of the houses, the rest of the land is vacant and un-partitioned. Rather the defendant in his written statement and also in his statement recorded before the trial Court has admitted that there exists the common passage between the two houses belonging to the plaintiff and the defendant respectively. There is un-rebutted statement of the plaintiff and corroborated by the evidence of Patwari, who had visited the site in the presence of both the parties that the suit passage existing between the two houses has been encroached. In that view of the matter, the contradiction with regard to the description and dimension of the suit property and exact extent of encroachment as noted by the trial Court is, in essence, trivial and inconsequential. Once it has been demonstredly proved that a common passage between the houses of the parties exists and that a part of it, is encroached by the defendant, the trial Court had no option but to decree the suit and to ensure that the defendant does not encroach upon the common passage and thereby caused hindrance in the ingress and egress of the plaintiff. It has not been proved by the defendant in the trial Court that he had laid the plinth for raising of construction of Varandha on a land which was exclusively CSA No. 14/2003 Page 12 of 12 in his possession. Had that being the case, perhaps, going by the principles laid down on the subject, suit by the plaintiff was not maintainable, without seeking partition of the joint property by metes and bounds. In such situation, where one of the co-sharers is found encroaching upon the property which is jointly owned and possessed by all the co-sharers, in my humble opinion and as held in the judgments referred to above, suit for injunction simpliciter is maintainable. There is no absolute law that a suit for injunction by one co-sharer against another co-sharer is not maintainable and the co- sharer approaching the Court should be relegated to the alternative efficacious remedy of seeking partition. Under certain set of circumstances as explained above, particularly, those enumerated in Paragraph No.78 of the judgment rendered in the case of Sant Ram Nagina Ram (supra) suit for injunction by the co-sharer(s) against another co-sharer (s) is maintainable.

    14. In view of the foregoing reasons, I do not find any merit in this appeal. The appellate Court committed no illegality in reversing the judgment and decree of the trial Court. Accordingly, this appeal is dismissed along with connected MP(s). Jammu (Sanjeev Kumar) 03.10.2018 Judge (Madan-PS)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Girdhari Lal v. Ram Lal
    (Oct 3, 2018)