AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 830
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 830
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant obtained a loan from the first respondent, Punjab Financial Corporation, in 1966. Upon defaulting on repayment, the appellant was declared a defaulter and a decree for the outstanding amount was passed against it. In execution of that decree, the appellant’s property was sold by court auction on 16 December 1983. Both the executing court and, on 24 February 2014, the High Court of Punjab and Haryana upheld the auction-sale. The present appeal challenges those concurrent findings before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the auction-sale dated 16 December 1983 was vitiated for non-compliance with the mandatory requirements of Order 21 Rule 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).
  2. Whether inadequate or untimely publication of the sale proclamation rendered the auction-sale invalid.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The sale contravened Order 21 Rule 85 CPC because the auction-purchaser (also the decree-holder) failed to deposit the purchase money within the prescribed time.
  • The sale proclamation was not published “well in advance” of 16 December 1983, undermining the validity of the auction.
  • Any failure to adjust payments and refund excess amounts would nullify the sale.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decisions in Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad, Balram v. Ilam Singh, Trinath Harichandan v. Paradeep Port Trust and Shilpa Shares and Securities v. National Coop. Bank Ltd.

Respondent 1's Arguments (Punjab Financial Corporation)

  • The Corporation, being both decree-holder and auction-purchaser, had obtained express permission of the executing court on 3 December 1983 under Order 21 Rule 72 CPC to bid and to set off the decree amount against the purchase price; therefore no cash deposit was required under Order 21 Rule 85 CPC.
  • A warrant of sale dated 19 November 1983 was affixed at the site, and wide publicity—including publication in the Daily Tribune—was given, satisfying the requirement of prior publication.
  • Both the executing court and the High Court found full compliance with all mandatory provisions, leaving no ground for interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad (AIR 1954 SC 349) Relied upon by the appellant to stress strict compliance with Order 21 Rule 85 CPC. The Supreme Court did not rely on this precedent, finding compliance on facts.
Balram v. Ilam Singh (1996 5 SCC 705) Cited by the appellant on mandatory deposit requirements in court auctions. Not expressly discussed in the Court’s reasoning.
Trinath Harichandan v. Paradeep Port Trust (1998 3 SCC 113) Referenced to support the appellant’s challenge to sale validity. The Court did not draw on this precedent in its analysis.
Shilpa Shares and Securities v. National Coop. Bank Ltd. (2007 12 SCC 165) Also cited by the appellant regarding consequences of non-compliance with auction procedures. No substantive reliance placed by the Supreme Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Issue 1 – Compliance with Order 21 Rule 85 CPC: The Court noted that the first respondent was both decree-holder and auction-purchaser. Under Order 21 Rule 72(2) CPC, such a purchaser may set off the decree amount against the bid price, eliminating the need for a cash deposit. The executing court had on 3 December 1983 expressly authorised the Corporation to bid and exempted it from the 25% and 75% deposit requirements under Rules 84 and 85. That order was never challenged. Consequently, the Supreme Court agreed with the concurrent findings below that Rule 85 was “duly complied with.”

Issue 2 – Adequacy of Publication: Evidence showed a warrant of sale dated 19 November 1983 was affixed at the property and notice was published in the Daily Tribune and other newspapers on 15 December 1983. The Court held that, given the earlier warrant and the overall publicity, no violation of the proclamation or advertisement requirements occurred. It accepted the findings of the executing court and High Court that the sale was properly advertised.

Finding no error in the concurrent conclusions of the lower courts on either issue, the Supreme Court declined to interfere.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The appeal is rejected and the auction-sale dated 16 December 1983 stands affirmed.

Implications: The property remains with the Punjab Financial Corporation in satisfaction of its decree. The judgment reiterates, without setting new precedent, that a decree-holder purchaser may set off the decree amount against the bid price when expressly permitted under Order 21 Rule 72 CPC, obviating the need for deposits mandated by Rule 85.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bee Gee Corporation Pvt. Ltd. (S) v. Punjab Financial Corporation (S).

    R. Banumathi, J.— Leave granted. This appeal has been preferred against the order dated 24-2-2014 in Bee Gee Corpn. Ltd. v. Punjab Financial Corpn. 2014 SCC OnLine P&H 25081 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana whereby the High Court confirmed the order of the executing court affirming the auction-sale in favour of the first respondent Corporation.

    2. The appellant herein obtained loan from the first respondent Corporation in 1966 and has not adhered to the terms and conditions of the loan in repayment and was declared as a defaulter. For the subsisting amount of loan, decree was passed. In execution of the decree, the appellant's property was sold on 16-12-1983 by the Court following the order of executing court in the execution petition.

    3. We have heard Mr A.K. Chopra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr T.S. Doabia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 1.

    4. The appellant herein challenges the court auction-sale held on 16-12-1983 which has been upheld by both the executing court as well as by the High Court. The contention of the appellant is that the court auction-sale is vitiated primarily on: (i) on account of non-compliance of mandatory provisions of Order 21 Rule 85 CPC and (ii) that the same is further vitiated on account of non-publication of sale notification well in advance prior to the date of sale (16-12-1983).

    5. Insofar as the first contention of non-compliance of Order 21 Rule 85 CPC is concerned, even at the outset, it is to be pointed out that the first respondent Corporation is not only an auction-purchaser but also a decree-holder. As per Order 21 Rule 72 CPC, the decree-holder cannot bid to buy the property put to auction except by express permission of the Court. As per Order 21 Rule 72(2) CPC, the amount of decree may be taken as payment to set off against one another. In this case, our attention has been drawn to the order of the executing court dated 3-12-1983 by which the executing court has granted permission to the first respondent Corporation under Order 21 Rule 72 CPC to participate in the bid. Thus the first respondent Financial Corporation bid in the auction by virtue of the permission granted by the Court. In view of the provision to set off under Order 21 Rule 72(2) there was no requirement of depositing the sale proceeds of Rs 12 lakhs or any part thereof in the Court.

    6. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant contended that Order 21 Rule 85 CPC has not been properly complied with and the High Court failed to consider the objections so raised by the appellant. It was further submitted that adjustments not having been made and repayment of excess amount not done would nullify the entire sale and this has not been considered by the High Court. In support of his submission, the learned Senior Counsel has placed reliance on judgments of this Court in Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad AIR 1954 SC 349, Balram v. Ilam Singh (1996) 5 SCC 705, Trinath Harichandan v. Paradeep Port Trust (1998) 3 SCC 113 and Shilpa Shares and Securities v. National Coop. Bank Ltd. (2007) 12 SCC 165

    7. Order 21 Rule 85 mandates the deposit of the bid amount. As per proviso to Order 21 Rule 85 CPC an amount of bid, in which the decree-holder is a purchaser, can be set off. Since first respondent Corporation is not only the auction-purchaser but also a decree-holder as well, there is no question of deposit of the auction amount. Since there was no prospective buyer to offer bid on the occasion of the previous auction-sale, the first respondent Corporation filed application on 3-12-1983 seeking permission under Order 21 Rule 72 CPC and also exemption from depositing 25% of the bid amount at the time of auction and remaining 75% later under Order 21 Rules 84 and 85 CPC respectively. This application was allowed by the executing court on the same date i.e. 3-12-1983 and the same was not challenged. Both the executing court as well as the High Court have concurrently held that mandatory provisions of Order 21 Rule 85 CPC has been duly complied with. As pointed out earlier, the first respondent Corporation is not only an auction-purchaser but also a decree-holder entitled to the provisions of set-off under Order 21 Rule 85 proviso, as noted above.

    8. Insofar as the contention of the appellant that there was no prior publication done on 15-12-1983, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent Corporation has drawn our attention to the findings of the courts below that there was notification of warrant of sale dated 19-11-1983. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent has submitted that from the evidence of K.R. Bhalla (DW 1) it is clearly brought on record that wide publication was given regarding the sale by publication in Daily Tribune as well as other papers. That apart warrant of sale dated 19-11-1983 was affixed at the spot. Thus there was wide publication about the sale well prior to the date of auction. Though publication was done in the newspaper on 15-12-1983, since warrant of sale was affixed well in advance, we do not find any violation either in the proclamation of sale or in the advertisement of sale. Both the courts below concurrently recorded that the provisions of Order 21 Rule 85 CPC and other mandatory provisions were duly complied with and we are not inclined to interfere with the concurrent findings of the courts below.

    9. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bee Gee Corporation Pvt. Ltd. (S) v. Punjab Financial Corporation (S).
    (Sep 18, 2018)