Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (zzzze)(iii) of Clause (105) of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994.
  • Section 65(105)(zzg) read with Section 65(64) of the Finance Act, 1994.
  • Section 65(105)(zzzze) of the Finance Act,
  • SECTION 65 A FINANCE ACT 1994
  • Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994
  • Section 65(105)(zzg) of Finance Act,
  • sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19),
  • FINANCE ACT 1994
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (zzzze)(iii) of Clause (105) of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994.
  • Section 65(105)(zzg) read with Section 65(64) of the Finance Act, 1994.
  • Section 65(105)(zzzze) of the Finance Act,
  • SECTION 65 A FINANCE ACT 1994
  • Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994
  • Section 65(105)(zzg) of Finance Act,
  • sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19),
  • FINANCE ACT 1994

    Larsen & Toubro Infotech Limited v. Commissioner of S.T., Mumbai-II

    [Order per : C.J. Mathew, Member (T)]. -  M/s. Larsen & Toubro Infotech Limited is in appeal against order-in-original No: 20/ST-II/WLH/2012, dated 10th February, 2012 confirming a demand of tax of ` 1,20,10,638/- as provider of ‘maintenance of repair service’ for the period from 9th July, 2004 to 6th October, 2005.

    2. The appellant had entered into a contract with eight recipients of service, namely, M/s. Ship Building Centre, Visakhapatnam, M/s. MTR Foods Limited, Bangalore, M/s. L&T Case Equipment Pvt. Ltd., Pithampur, M/s. Audco India Ltd., Chennai, M/s. L&T Komatsu Limited, Bangalore, M/s. Ultra Tech Limited, Mumbai and M/s. Larsen & Toubro Limited, Powai, M/s. L &T John-Deerre Pvt. Ltd., Pune for various activities including support and maintenance of facilities and maintenance of IT infrastructure services. The appellant had been discharging service tax on ‘maintenance of software services’ with effect from 7th August, 2005. It is the contention of the appellant that they provided ‘information technology services’ which was rendered taxable only with effect from 10th May, 2006. It is their further submission that, even if taxable as provider of ‘management-cum-maintenance or repair service’, it is only by insertion of explanation in Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994 with effect from 16th May, 2008 that computer software came to be included as goods with liability to tax under Section 65(105)(zzg) of Finance Act, 1994.

    3. Learned Counsel for appellant places reliance on the decision of the Tribunal in SAP India Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Bangalore-III [ (Tri.-Bang.)]. The said decision held that -

    ‘5.5. Going by the explanation (supra), we find from the above text of Section 65(64) that maintenance or repair of information technology software is specifically covered under sub-clause (b) whereas maintenance or repair of computer software is specifically covered under sub-clause (c). It is obvious that the legislature has understood information technology software to be distinct and different from computer software. The Circulars and decisions cited before us, all, discuss computer software. No material has been placed before us, other than the literature supplied by the learned Special Consultant for the Revenue, to show that activities of the kind undertaken by the appellant during the material period would be encompassed in the ERP regime. To our mind, these are activities very much within the coverage of sub-clause (zzzze)(iii) of Clause (105) of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994. Any incidental advice, consultancy or assistance given by the service provider will be squarely covered by sub-clause (zzzze)(iv). It is pertinent to note that adaptation, upgradation, enhancement, implementation, etc. of information technology software are expressly covered by the definition of ‘information technology software’ service and that these very operations have also been specified as different categories on software maintenance in the literature supplied to us. Thus there is almost total convergence between the technical literature on software and the definition of information technology software service given under Section 65(105)(zzzze) of the Finance Act, 1994.
    5.6 It is settled law today that a new taxable service covered by specific entry under Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994 will not attract levy of Service Tax under any preexisting entry. In this connection, the Karnataka High Court’s judgment in Commissioner v. Turbotech Precision Engineering Pvt. Ltd. (dated 15-4-2010) in CEA No. 4/2007 = 2010-TIOL-498-HC-KAR-ST is relevant. The Hon’ble High Court has held that the case of the assessee fell under the definition of ‘works contract’ and hence it could not be classified as ‘consulting engineer’s service’. It may be noted that ‘works contract’ came to be introduced as a taxable service w.e.f. 1-6-2007 only. The service rendered by the above company was for a period prior to the said date. The Revenue wanted to levy Service Tax under the pre-existent head “consulting engineer service”, which was negatived by the Hon’ble High Court.
    6. For the reasons already noted, we hold that the maintenance charges collected by the appellant from their customers during the period from 9-7-2004 to 31-1-2006 are not liable to be subjected to levy of Service Tax under the head ‘maintenance or repair service’ under Section 65(105)(zzg) read with Section 65(64) of the Finance Act, 1994. The services rendered by the appellant to their customers are in the nature of information technology software service which was made taxable w.e.f. 16-5-2008 only. Such service is not to be subjected to levy of Service Tax under any other entry. Therefore, the demand of Service Tax and the connected penalties are only liable to be set aside.’

    4. In Phoenix IT Solutions Ltd v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Visakhapatnam [ (Tri.- Bang.)] it was held that insertion of explanation renders the service to be taxable retrospectively by holding that -

    ‘13. The next service under dispute is software maintenance. The learned Commissioner in impugned order has held that e-Care maintenance, website maintenance and data base maintenance are all maintenance contracts for the software used in their website etc. Software are goods and repair of the same are chargeable to Service Tax under the category of management or repair service w.e.f. 9-7-2004, the date on which earlier Notification was rescinded by Notification No. 7/2004-S.T., dated 9-7-2004. The learned Advocate submitted that it became taxable only w.e.f. 1-6-2007 as per the amendment of Finance Act, 1994 and explained in the Circular No. 334/1/2007, dated 28-2-2007. He submitted that this has been totally ignored to demand tax. He relied upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. as reported in 2009-TIOL-16 (SC) = (S.C.) to support the submission that even if particular amendment is made adding explanation to insert provision to remove doubt, the same cannot be retrospectively applied to demand tax. In the clarification issued by the department after Budget 2007-2008, it was stated that Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994 has been amended to clarify that “goods” for the purpose of this service (Management, Maintenance or repair service) includes computer software. It was also clarified that development of computer software would be liable to tax under Information and Technology service whereas maintenance and repair of computer software would be coming under management, maintenance or repair service.
    14. It is the submission of the appellant that maintenance and repair includes development of software and in fact development of software is outside the preview of service tax since the Information Technology service became liable to Service Tax on the development of software only w.e.f 16-5-2008. However, there is no bifurcation of the cost of development and the cost of maintenance. Further, the contract also speaks of BMS software maintenance, e-care maintenance, maintenance of software and website maintenance. In every case, word ‘maintenance’ has been used. In the absence of the word ‘development’ and presence of word ‘maintenance’ in the agreement, ‘and also in view of the failure of the appellant to submit bifurcation, we have to take a view that the agreement covers maintenance only.
    15. The next question is whether the Service Tax can be levied w.e.f. 9-7-2004. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. observed “while discussing the amendment introduced w.e.f. 16-5-2008, by way of explanation in sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19), explanation cannot be considered to have been clarificatory or declaratory so as to have retrospective effect. The Apex Court observed “there is no other option to hold that by inserting the explanation appended clause 19 of Section 65 of the Act, new concept of imposition of tax has been brought in. The Parliament may be entitled to do so. It would be entitled to raise a legal fiction, but when a new type of tax is introduced or a new concept of tax is introduced so as to widen the net, it, in our opinion, should not be construed to have a retrospective operation on the premise that it is clarificatory or declaratory in nature. There is no doubt this clarification widen the scope of taxation of service.” In any case, the appellants themselves have submitted that the liability can arise after 1-6-2007. Therefore, in view of the ratio of the decision in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd., we consider that it would not be appropriate to apply the explanation retrospectively and levy Service Tax w.e.f. 9-7-2004. In any case, the very fact that explanation has been added to clarify doubts, would show that suppression of facts could not have been invoked in this case. In view of the above decision, we hold that maintenance of software became taxable only from 1-6-2007.

    5. Learned Authorised Representative placed reliance on the decision of the Tribunal in Choudhary International Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax [ (Tri.-Mum.)]. The said order has distinguished the application of the decision of the Tribunal in re SAP India Pvt. Ltd. by holding that the service is classifiable under “information technology service” when the bulk of the activity was related to upgradation and enhancement of software which takes it out of the purview of ‘maintenance or repair’.

    6. There is no doubt that the definition of maintenance or repair of software relates to properties, whether movable or immovable and it has been held that software is goods. Consequent upon this, the explanation was inserted in Section 65(105)(zzg) and as pointed out supra, this Tribunal has considered in Phoenix IT Solutions whether the insertion of the explanation could further the case of Revenue for demand tax from the date that the service was made taxable. Taking all factors into consideration, the Tribunal has held that there is no retrospective application by insertion of the explanation. The period under dispute in the present case is from 9th July, 2004 to 6th October, 2005.

    7. Respectfully following the decision of the Tribunal in re Phoenix IT Solutions we hold that the demand of service tax is not sustainable. For this reason we set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal.

    (Pronounced in Court on 3-4-2017)

    Finance Act, 1994

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Larsen & Toubro Infotech Limited v. Commissioner of S.T., Mumbai-II
    (Apr 3, 2017)