Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994
  • sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19),
  • FINANCE ACT 1994
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994
  • sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19),
  • FINANCE ACT 1994

    Phoenix It Solutions Ltd. v. C.C.E., Cus. & S.T., Visakhapatnam-I

    [Order per : Madhu Mohan Damodhar, Member (T)]. - Appellant is engaged in providing various services to electricity companies and electricity departments including Andhra Pradesh Electricity and Power Distribution Company Ltd. (APEPDCL). The dispute involved in this appeal relates to demand of service tax on software maintenance services carried out by the appellant for APEPDCL during the period 1-10-2006 to 1-3-2007. This demand has been raised by department, inter alia, on the grounds that such software maintenance activity would fall under the category of management, maintenance or repair service and hence appellants were liable for payment of service tax from 9-7-2004.

    2. Today, when the matter came up for hearing, on behalf of the appellant ld. Counsel K. Dakshinamurthy submitted that the issue in dispute has been settled in their favour, in their own case, for an earlier period, by the Tribunal in Phoenix IT Solutions Ltd. v. CCE, Visakhapatnam reported in [ (Tri.-Bang.)]. In the circumstances he prayed that the present appeal may also be allowed in their favour. Ld. AR fairly reiterated the correctness of the impugned order.

    3. Heard both sides and gone through the facts. Ld. Counsel submitted that the matter has already been decided by this Tribunal in the case cited. Relevant portions of the said decision viz., of Paras 13, 14 and 15 are reproduced below for easy reference.

    13. The next service under dispute is software maintenance. The learned Commissioner in impugned order has held that e-care maintenance, website maintenance and data base maintenance are all maintenance contracts for the software used in their website, etc. Software are goods and repair of the same are chargeable to Service Tax under the category of management or repair service w.e.f. 9-7-2004, the date on which earlier Notification was rescinded by Notification No. 7/04-S.T., dated 9-7-2004. The learned Advocate submitted that it became taxable only w.e.f. 1-6-2007 as per the amendment of Finance Act, 1994 and explained in the Circular No. 334/1/2007, dated 28-2-2007. He submitted that this has been totally ignored to demand tax. He relied upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. as reported in 2009-TIOL-16 (SC) = (S.C.) to support the submission that even if particular amendment is made adding explanation to insert provision to remove doubt, the same cannot be retrospectively applied to demand tax. In the clarification issued by the department after Budget 2007-2008, it was stated that Section 65(64) of Finance Act, 1994 has been amended to clarify that “goods” for the purpose of this service (Management, Maintenance or repair service) includes computer software. It was also clarified that development of computer software would be liable to tax under Information and Technology service whereas maintenance and repair of computer software would be coming under management, maintenance or repair service.
    14. It is the submission of the appellant that maintenance and repair includes development of software and in fact development of software is outside the preview of service tax since the Information Technology service became liable to Service Tax on the development of software only w.e.f. 16-5-2008. However, there is no bifurcation of the cost of development and the cost of maintenance. Further, the contract also speaks of BMS software maintenance, e-care maintenance, maintenance of software and website maintenance. In every case, word ‘maintenance’ has been used. In the absence of the word ‘development ‘ and presence of word ‘maintenance’ in the agreement, ‘and also in view of the failure of the appellant to submit bifurcation, we have to take a view that the agreement covers maintenance only.
    15. The next question is whether the Service Tax can be levied w.e.f. 9-7-94. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. observed “while discussing the amendment introduced w.e.f. 16-5-2008, by way of explanation in sub-clause (ii) of Section 65(19), explanation cannot he considered to have been clarificatory or declaratory so as to have retrospective effect. The Apex Court observed “there is no other option to hold that by inserting the explanation appended clause (19) of Section 65 of the Act, new concept of imposition of tax has been brought in. The Parliament may be entitled to do so. It would be entitled to raise a legal fiction, but when a new type of tax is introduced or a new concept of tax is introduced so as to widen the net, it, in our opinion, should not be construed to have a retrospective operation on the premise that it is clarficatory or declaratory in nature. There is no doubt this clarification widen the scope of taxation of service. “In any case, the appellants themselves have submitted that the liability can arise after 1-6-2007. Therefore, in view of the ratio of the decision in the case of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd., we consider that it would not be appropriate to apply the explanation retrospectively and levy Service Tax w.e.f. 9-7-2004. In any case, the very fact that explanation has been added to clarify doubts, would show that suppression of facts could not have been invoked in this case. In view of the above decision, we hold that maintenance of software became taxable only from 1-6-2007.

    4. In the circumstances, adopting the ratio already set down by Tribunal, we hold that the activity of software maintenance provided by the appellant, which is subject matter of the dispute in this appeal, has become taxable only with effect from 1-6-2007. This being the case as the period of dispute is prior to this date, the impugned order will not sustain and will have to be set aside in toto which we hereby do. Appeal No. ST/1002/2010 allowed with consequential reliefs, if any.

    Appeal No. ST/1821/2010 and ST/2352/2010 :

    5. Appeal No. ST/1821/2010 is also filed on identical issue. However, involves period from April, 2007 to March, 2008.

    6. In view of the same discussions and conclusions, we hold that for the period prior to 1-6-2007, the activity of software maintenance provided by the appellant to APEPDCL will not be liable to service tax liability. However, for the period subsequent to 1-6-2007, said activity will definitely be liable to service tax under the management, maintenance, repair services. The impugned order will stand modified to that extent. Considering that the issue has already been in agitation and that periodical show cause notices have been issued to the appellant, issue being one of interpretation, the imposition of penalty under Section 76 on the appellant is hereby set aside. The matter is remanded to the original authority for the limited purpose of calculating the tax liability of the appellant for the said services for the period 1-6-2007 till 31-3-2008. It is clarified that the said tax liability worked out will be payable along with interest. At this juncture ld. Counsel submits that the said tax liability has been already calculated by them and paid along with interest. This aspect will also be verified and confirmed by the de novo adjudication. Adjudicating authority will ensure that an opportunity is given to the appellant to produce evidence in support of his claim regarding payment. Ld. Counsel also stated that the impugned order also concerns an amount of Rs. 18,17,375/- demanded on business auxiliary services rendered during the period from April, 2007 to March, 2008. He submits that the said demand has already been discharged by them along with interest and that the same is already been taken note of impugned order, and has been dropped by adjudicating authority. Appeal No. ST/1821/2010 disposed of as above. Appeal ST/2352/2010 has been filed against the same impugned order by the department O-i-O No. dated 4-5-2010, which had also been appealed against assessee in ST/1821/2010 discussed above. Department has came in appeal only on the grounds that Commissioner has erred in not imposing penalty under Section 77 ibid in respect of both the tax liabilities confirmed. That penalty under Section 78 of the Act has not also been imposed. In view of the discussions, herein above in respect of ST/2352/2010 we do not find any merit in the appeal of the department. Hence dismissed.

    7. In the result, -

    (i)      Appeal No. ST/1002/2010 is allowed with consequential reliefs, if any.
    (ii)    Appeal No. ST/1821/2010 is partly allowed and partly remanded for the limited purpose of calculating the tax liability for the period 1-6-2007 to 31-3-2008.
    (iii)   Appeal No. ST/2352/2010 is dismissed.

    (Pronounced & dictated in open Court)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Phoenix It Solutions Ltd. v. C.C.E., Cus. & S.T., Visakhapatnam-I
    (Nov 8, 2016)