[Order]. - The appellants in this appeal, namely, World Cargo Movers is a proprietory concern of one Shri Vishwa Kalyan Gupta (V.K. Gupta). They are a Customs House Agent (CHA) working under the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1984 made by the Central Board of Excise and Customs under Section 146 (2) of the Customs Act, 1962. The appeal is against the order of the Commissioner of Customs imposing a penalty of Rs. 50,000/- on the appellants under Section 114 of the Customs Act.
2. The appellants had filed a shipping bill dated 7-8-99, on behalf of M/s. Sterling Exports, for export of 393 wrist watches under DEPB Scheme. The declared value of the wrist watches was US$ 28 (Rs. 1208/-) per piece. After examination of samples of the goods followed by market inquiries, the customs authorities booked a case of over-invoicing against the exporter and one of abetment of the said offence against the CHA. Accordingly, show-cause notice was issued to the exporter and the CHA. As against CHA (the present appellant), the show-cause notice alleged that the CHA had helped the exporter in the latter’s attempt to export the overvalued goods for the purpose of taking higher DEPB credit with intent to defraud the Government. It was alleged that the CHA did not verify the bona fides of the exporter and failed to discharge his responsibility under Regulation No. 14(b) of the CHA Regulations. It was further alleged that the CHA contravened the provisions of Section 11 (i) of the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulations) Act, 1992 thereby rendering themselves liable to penalty under Section 114 of the Customs Act, 1962. All these allegations were denied by the appellants in their reply to the show-cause notice. In adjudication of the dispute, the Commissioner of Customs, imposed a penalty of Rs. 50,000/- on the appellants under Section 114 of the Customs Act. Hence the present appeal.
3. I have heard Shri J.M. Sharma, Consultant for the appellants, and Shri V.K. Verma, JDR for the respondent.
4. Shri J.M. Sharma, Consultant, submits that there is no evidence supporting the Commissioner’s finding that the appellant had contravened the provisions of Regulation No. 14 (b) or those of Section 11 (i) of 1992 Act. He submits that Section 114 of the Customs Act is not applicable to the facts of the case insofar as the appellant is concerned. This provision of law could be invoked only upon a reasoned finding that some commission or omission on the part of the CHA had rendered the export goods liable to confiscation. In the instant case, the goods have been found by the Commissioner to be liable to confiscation under Section 113 (d) of the Customs Act, without even a finding that the goods were prohibited for exportation. According to the ld. Consultant, the goods brought to Customs area for exportation could be held to be liable to confiscation only after such goods were found to be prohibited for exportation under the Customs Act or under any other law for the time being in force. But there is no such finding in the impugned order and, therefore, the order for confiscation of the goods under Section 113 (d) of the Customs Act is itself un-sustainable. Apart from this, ld. Consultant submits that there is no finding that any commission or omission of the appellant rendered the goods liable to confiscation. Therefore, Section 114 of the Customs Act was wrongly invoked against the appellant for imposition of penalty. Ld. Consultant has, in this connection, relied on the Tribunal’s decisions in the cases of Nirmala Rishi v. Commissioner of Customs, New Delhi - (Tribunal), Shaikh & Pandit v. CC (Prev.), Calcutta [ (T) = 2001 (43) RLT 852 (CEGAT-Kol)] and J.G. Exports v. CC, New Delhi - (Tribunal-LB). Relying on these decisions, ld. Consultant has submitted that it was no obligation of the CHA to check the credentials of the exporter under CHA Licensing Regulations, 1984 and, therefore, the allegation that he did not verify the bona fides of the exporter was not tenable. The appellant has only discharged his function as a CHA for the exporter in accordance with the latter’s instructions. The exporter has not adduced any evidence to the contrary. All the declared prices of the goods and other particulars were entered in the export documents by the CHA only in terms of the price stated in the invoice as well as the advice of the exporter. The appellant has only played his normal role as a CHA and has not contravened any of the provisions of law cited in the show-cause notice. Therefore, on the facts and evidence of the case, there is nothing to support the imposition of penalty on the CHA by the adjudicating authority. Ld. Consultant has therefore, prayed for setting aside the order of the Commissioner and allowing of the appeal.
5. Shri V.K. Verma, JDR, submits that, in terms of Section 18 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973, the exporter had to declare the export value true in all material particulars and that, in the absence of such declaration, the goods became prohibited for exportation. According to ld. JDR, the declared value of the goods was very high when compared to the market price of identical goods and, therefore, the declared value was not true in material particulars and such untrue declaration rendered the goods prohibited for exportation. This prohibition attracted Section 11 of the Customs Act as well and, consequently, Section 113 (d) and 114 of the Customs Act became applicable. The ld. JDR submits that the CHA had an obligation to ensure the correctness of the value of the goods and to ensure that the declared particulars were true in terms of Section 18 of the 1973 Act. This function of the CHA was not properly discharged and, therefore, the CHA was liable to be penalized under Section 114 of the Act. The JDR has prayed for rejecting the appeal.
6. I have examined the submissions. I note that the show-cause notice has alleged contravention of Regulation No. 14 (b) of the CHA Licensing Regulations 1984, against the appellant. This regulation casts an obligation on the CHA to transact business in the Customs Station either personally or through an employee approved by the Asstt. Commissioner or Dy. Commissioner, designated by the Commissioner. The respondent has no case that the appellant transacted any business in the Customs Station in the Airport otherwise than personally or through an employee duly approved by the Asstt Commissioner or Dy. Commissioner of Customs, designated by the Commissioner. Therefore, Regulation No. 14 (b) appears to have been invoked erroneously by the Commissioner for a finding that the appellant attempted to help the exporter in over-invoicing the goods for the purpose of obtaining higher DEPB benefits. On the facts and evidence of this case, I find nothing to support such a finding, nor is there anything to substantiate the allegation that the appellant violated Regulation No. 14 (b) of the CHA Licensing Regulations. I have also examined the provisions of Section 11 (1) of the Foreign Trade (Development & Regulation) Act, 1992 and I find that these provisions contain a mandate to importers and exporters and not to CHAs. Therefore, the allegation of contravention of Section 11 (1) of the 1992 Act also cannot be sustained. Numerous statements of the exporter were recorded by the Customs officers before issuing the show-cause notice to the appellant. All those statements have been referred to in the impugned order, as well. However, none of the statements contains anything incriminating against the present appellant. The statements, insofar as they relate to the present appellant, are only to the effect that the exporter had filed the export documents through the appellant. The exporter has never stated that the value of the goods or any other material particulars relating to the goods were entered in the documents by the CHA contrary to his instructions or advice. A CHA can act only in accordance with the instructions of the importer/exporter. Of course, he has to ensure that all the particulars so entered in the export documents are true and correct with reference to the particulars furnished to him by the importer/exporter. The respondent in the instant case has not contested the appellants’ plea that he has only acted in accordance with the instructions of the exporter. It is no job of the CHA to compare the invoice price with the market price of identical goods for the purpose of checking correctness of the value declared in export documents. It is upto the exporter to ensure the correctness before instructing/advicing the CHA.
7. In the instant case, therefore, I do not find any substance in the finding of the Commissioner that the appellant was liable to be penalized under Section 114 of the Customs Act. In this view, I am supported by the case law cited by the Consultant. As rightly pointed out by the ld. Consultant any penalty to be imposed on the CHA under Section 114 of the Customs Act should be supported by a finding that some omission or commission of the CHA rendered the goods liable to confiscation. No such finding is forthcoming in the impugned order. For these reasons, the order of the Commissioner imposing penalty on the appellant under Section 114 of the Customs Act cannot be sustained. Therefore, I set aside the impugned order and allow this appeal.