Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. 1
  • Section 146 (1), Exception 2 to Section 153 and Section 155 (3) of the Indian Evidence Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. 1
  • Section 146 (1), Exception 2 to Section 153 and Section 155 (3) of the Indian Evidence Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Navneet Arora, challenged an order dated 07.12.2015 passed by the trial court which denied him the opportunity, during cross-examination, to confront a prosecution witness with an earlier statement alleged to have been made by that witness, pursuant to Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The trial court had applied the Supreme Court's ratio in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh (2014) 15 SCC 661 to decline permission for confrontation using an audio-video recording of the alleged earlier statement. The petitioner sought revision of this order before the High Court of Delhi.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in refusing the accused the opportunity to confront a prosecution witness with an earlier audio-video recording of a statement under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court's decision in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh (2014) 15 SCC 661 is binding or per incuriam regarding the applicability of Section 145 to statements made before or after filing of the charge sheet.
  3. The proper interpretation and scope of Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act concerning previous statements made by a witness in writing or reduced to writing.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The trial court wrongly denied the accused the opportunity to confront the prosecution witness with an audio-video recording of an alleged earlier statement.
  • The ratio in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh is not applicable as the recording predates the filing of the charge sheet.
  • The Supreme Court in the judgment dated 14.08.2017 in Jasdeep Kaur Chadha Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors held the Mukesh decision to be per incuriam, thereby undermining its binding effect.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh (2014) 15 SCC 661 Held that previous statement for confrontation under Section 145 must be made during investigation. The trial court relied on this precedent to deny confrontation with the audio-video recording; however, the High Court found this precedent to be per incuriam based on later authority.
Jasdeep Kaur Chadha Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors, Supreme Court, 14.08.2017 Held that Section 145 does not limit previous statements to those made only during investigation and declared Mukesh to be per incuriam. The High Court relied on this judgment to set aside the trial court’s order and allow confrontation with the earlier statement.
N. Sri Rama Reddy and Ors. Vs. Sh. V.V. Giri, AIR 1971 SC 1162 Established that tape recordings are primary, direct evidence admissible to corroborate, contradict, test veracity, and impeach impartiality of a witness. The court cited this precedent to support the admissibility and use of audio-video recordings for confrontation under the Indian Evidence Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions of Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, which allows cross-examination of a witness regarding previous statements made in writing or reduced to writing without necessarily showing the writing unless it is intended to contradict the witness. The court noted that the trial court had relied on the Mukesh judgment, which restricted confrontation to statements made during investigation. However, the court recognized the Supreme Court’s later ruling in Jasdeep Kaur Chadha, which held that Section 145 does not impose such a limitation and declared Mukesh to be per incuriam. The court also referred to the N. Sri Rama Reddy precedent, which affirms that tape recordings are admissible as primary evidence for corroboration, contradiction, and testing the witness’s veracity. Based on these principles, the court found that the trial court erred by denying the accused the opportunity to confront the witness with the earlier recorded statement. The court directed the trial court to allow confrontation subject to compliance with Sections 64, 65, and the safeguard of Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act.

Holding and Implications

The impugned order dated 07.12.2015 is set aside. The trial court is directed to afford the accused-petitioner the opportunity to confront the prosecution witness with the earlier audio recording, subject to compliance with the evidentiary safeguards under Sections 64, 65, and 65B of the Indian Evidence Act.

The decision reverses the trial court’s restrictive interpretation of Section 145 and aligns with the authoritative Supreme Court ruling in Jasdeep Kaur Chadha, thereby clarifying the admissibility of prior statements beyond investigation phase for confrontation purposes. No new precedent is established by this order; its direct effect is to ensure the petitioner’s right to confront evidence in accordance with the correct legal interpretation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Navneet Arora Petitioner v. State (Govt Of Nct Of Delhi)

    $~29

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    % Judgment delivered on: 08.05.2018 + CRL.REV.P. 282/2016

    NAVNEET ARORA ..... Petitioner versus

    STATE ( GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI) ..... Respondent

    Advocates who appeared in this case:

    For the Petitioner : Mr.V. Madhukar & Mr. Aditya Kapoor, Advs. For the Respondent : Mr. Mukesh Kumar, APP for the State with SI Narendra Kumar

    CORAM:-

    HON'BLE MR JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA

    JUDGMENT

    08.05.2018

    SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J. (ORAL)

    CRL.REV.P. 282/2016 & Crl.M.A.5964/2016 (stay)

    1. Petitioner impugns order dated 07.12.2015, whereby, the petitioner accused was not permitted, at the time of cross examination, to confront the prosecution witness with an earlier statement alleged to have been made by the witness, in terms of Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

    1

    2. The trial court applying the ratio of the judgment of Supreme Court in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh (2014) 15 SCC 661, declined the accused permission to confront the witness with an earlier audio- video recording containing the alleged statement of the witness.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the trial court erred in denying the opportunity to the accused to confront the witness with an audio-video recording of an alleged earlier statement. He further submits that the ratio of Mukesh (Supra) is not applicable in the present case, in as much as, the recording to be confronted was prior to the filing of the charge sheet. However, he submits that the Supreme Court vide judgment dated 14.08.2017 in Crl. Appeal No. 1405-1406 of 2017 titled „Jasdeep Kaur Chadha Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors.', has held that Mukesh (Supra) to be per incuriam.

    4. Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as under:-

    "145. Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing.—A witness may be cross-examined as to previous statements made by him in writing or reduced into writing, and relevant to matters in question, without such writing being shown to him, or being proved; but, if it is intended to contradict him by the writing, his attention must, before the writing can be proved, be called to those parts of it which are to be used for the purpose of contradicting him."

    5. Supreme Court in N. Sri Rama Reddy and Ors. Vs. Sh. V.V. Giri, AIR 1971 SC 1162 has held that tape recording itself is primary and

    2

    direct evidence admissible as to what has been said and picked up by the recorder and a previous statement made by a person recorded on tape can be used not only to corroborate the evidence given by the witness in Court but also to contradict the evidence given before the Court, as well as to test the veracity of the witness and also to impeach his impartiality. And further apart from being used in corroboration the evidence is admissible in respect of the other three last mentioned matters under Section 146 (1), Exception 2 to Section 153 and Section 155 (3) of the Indian Evidence Act.

    6. Further the Supreme Court in Jasdeep Kaur Chadha (Supra) held as under:-

    "6. On bare perusal of Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, we find that the section does not put any limitation that the previous statement must be during investigation nor creates a bar to a statement subsequent to investigation being confronted to the witness if such statement is in writing and is relevant as per the said provisions. The only requirement is the provision is that the statement should be in writing or should be reduced to writing and relevant to the matter in question.

    7. No doubt, the judgment of this Court in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Mukesh (Supra) has expressed the view that the previous statement must be the statement made during investigation only but the said judgment is per incuriam. The view taken by the larger Bench of this Court in Tara Singh Vs. The State (Supra) has not been referred to and thus, the law laid down by the larger Bench continues to be the binding law."

    (underlining supplied)

    3

    7. Clearly in view of the above, the trial court has erred in denying the opportunity to the accused to confront the prosecution witness with an alleged earlier statement recorded on a Compact disc.

    8. In view of the above, the impugned order is set aside. The trial court is directed to afford an opportunity to the accused-petitioner to confront the witness with the audio recording subject to compliance of provisions of Section 64 and if warranted, Section 65, with the safeguard of Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act.

    9. The petition is, accordingly, disposed of in the above terms.

    10. Order Dasti under the signatures of the Court Master.

    SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J

    MAY 08, 2018

    'rs'

    4

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Navneet Arora Petitioner v. State (Govt Of Nct Of Delhi)
    (May 8, 2018)