Applicant, who retired on superannuation as Superintendent, Central Excise on 31.12.1997, pending disciplinary proceedings was allowed provisional pension.
2. On 16.8.2004, applicant was exonerated from the charges on dropping the chargesheet. An amount of gratuity and commuted value of fraction of pension through cheque of Rs.4,01,347/- dated 2.12.2004 was received by him. The claim of the applicant for interest on delayed payment of gratuity and commutation was approved by the Additional Commissioner on 13.7.2005, which was further reiterated by Under Secretary, Government of India on 22.7.2005. On 29.9.2005, Senior Pay & Account Officer confirmed the interest on account of late payment. However on 18.1.2006, the claim when rejected led to the present O.A.
3. During the course of submissions, applicant has relied upon the decisions of the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal at Mumbai in OA No. 884/2003 in B.N. Nadhamuni v. Union of India (UOI) and Another decided on 26.4.2005 and Delhi Transport Corporation v. K.K. Berry & Others, 2006 IX AD (DELHI) 778.
4. A Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal at Principal Bench in K.R. Kantiwal v. Union of India & others (OA-1312/2006) vide order dated 3.4.2007 rejected the claim made therein and dismissed the OA.
5. In Civil Writ Petition No. 5741/2007 filed by the applicant before the High Court of Delhi, vide order dated 7.8.2007, it was held as follows: We find from the reading of the impugned order that in support of this submission, learned counsel had referred to the judgment of Bombay Bench of the CAT in the case of Awadhut Wasudeo Waikar v. Union of India & Ors. (OA No.294/1995 decided on 12.4.1996). This judgment is noted by the learned Tribunal along with four other judgments cited, but the argument is brushed aside with one line observation in respect of all these five judgments to the effect that those cases were simple cases of retirement and not the cases where concerned employee was facing departmental enquiry at the time of retirement. However, this observation of the learned Tribunal is not correct inasmuch as Awadhut Wasudeo (supra) was also a case where the Government employee was not allowed to commute fraction of his pension on the ground that he was facing departmental enquiry. Nonetheless, in that judgment the Tribunal granted interest to the petitioner applying the Doctrine of Relation Back. It is trite law that the Tribunal cannot ignore judgment of another co-ordinate Bench and even if the Tribunal was not agreeing with the opinion of the Bombay Bench in the aforesaid judgment, proper course was to refer the matter to a larger Bench. {See- Jaisri Sahu v. Rajdewan Dubey & Ors., AIR 1962 SC 83}. We, therefore, set aside the impugned judgment and refer the case back to the Tribunal for deciding the matter afresh. In case the Bench, which heard the matter, disagrees with the opinion expressed by the Bombay Bench in the aforesaid judgment, the matter shall be considered by the larger Bench. With these observations, this writ petition and the accompanying applications are disposed of.
6. Accordingly, learned counsel of the applicant states that the decision of the Mumbai Bench covers the present issue, as non-payment of interest to the amount due, the doctrine of Relation Back would apply. As the applicant was exonerated from the charges by disciplinary authority on 16.8.2004, it has to be deemed that no DE was inexistence at the time of retirement. Accordingly, Rule 68 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 would come in operation. It is also stated that DOP&T advice tendered on 16.1.2006 is contrary to the decision of the Tribunal, as such would not be allowed to infiltrate the arena, which is covered by the judicial dicta.
7. On the other hand, respondents counsel opposed the contentions and stated that interest on commuted value of fraction of pension is not admissible as the applicant has drawn full pension and Rule 68 of the rules would not apply in such a case.
8. Learned counsel states that Rule 69 of CCS (Pension) Rules and non-payment of DCRG and commuted value is covered by Rule 4 of CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981 and as per Rule 6 of (Commutation of Pension) Rules, reduction in pension will be from the date of the receipt of the commutation value.
9. We have carefully considered the rival contentions of the parties and perused the material on record.
10. In our considered view, when the interest on commutation of pension has been made admissible by the Apex Court in Vijay L. Mehrotra v. State of U.P. and others, (2001) 9 SCC 687, I agree with the decision of the Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal in B.N. Nadhamunis case (supra) wherein the issue of interest has been put at rest with the following observations:
11. In New Delhi Municipal Committee v. Kalu Ram and Anr. AIR 1976 SC 1637, The Honble Supreme Court has held that: Section 7 of P.P. Act only provides a special procedure for the realization of rent in arrears and does not constitute a source or foundation of a right to claim debt otherwise time barred. PARA 11 to 25.
12. The provisions of the P.P. Act do not take away any right or power available under the law for recovery of arrears of rent including damage rent. It is within the power of the Union Government to frame the rules under Article 309 of the Constitution for service matters which will also include rules of recovery of rent including damage rent from the employee. This power under Article 309 of the Constitution would not therefore be taken away by the provisions of Section 7 of the PP Act. It is also stated that Section 15 of the P.P. Act does not restrict the power of the Government to frame the rules under Article 3009 of the Constitution for recovery of rent including damage rent. It is also observed by the Full Bench that P.P. Act is only an alternative procedure which does not bar the recovery as per the Railway Board Circular. In view of the decision of Rampoojans case the provision under Section 7 of the P.P. Act is alternative procedure which does not bar recovery accordingly to the Railway Board Circular.
13. In Union of India and Anr. v. Wing Commander R.R. Hingorani 1987 ATC (Vol.2) 989; 1987(3) SLJ 154 (SC). It has been observed by the Apex Court in Para 7 as under: It is plain upon the term of SR-317-B-25 that the liability to pay damages equal to the market rent beyond the concession period is an absolute liability and not a contingent one. Both the learned Singe Judge as well as the Division Bench were clearly in error in subjecting liability of a Government Officer to pay market rent for the period of unauthorized occupation to the fulfillment of the condition that the Director of Estate should serve him with a notice that in the event of his continuing in authorized occupation he would be liable to pay market rent.
14. Madan Mohan Prasads case cited by the applicant, the Apex Court has held that: Non-vacation of Railway quarter after retirement cannot be a ground to with hold DCRG and the leave encashment. It is also held that penal rent/damages does not fall under the term admitted or obvious dues within the meaning of Rule 323. Tribunal rightly allowed the claim of respondent for payment of DCRG and leave encashment with interest. However the amount towards normal rent, electricity and water charges which are admitted and obvious dues can be deducted by the authorities, if still due.
15. In K. Balakrishna Nambiars case (supra) 3 Judges Bench of the Apex Court has held that: DCRG withheld for unauthorized retention of Government accommodation after retirement In such circumstances, interest on the withheld amount of gratuity, held, not payable in respect of B.N.Nadhamuni vs. Union of India (UOI) and Anr. (26.04.2005 CAT Mumbai) the period of such unauthorized occupation and for another month after vacation.
16. In Dr.Uma Agarwal v. State of U.P. and Anr. 1999 SCC(L and S) 742 : 1999(3) SU 212 (SC), it has been held by the Apex Court that: If rules instructions which prescribe time-schedule for settling of retirement dues are allowed strictly, much of litigation can be avoided and retired Government servants would not feel harassed Pension is not a bounty but right of a Government servant. Government is obliged to follow rules. Delay in settling retiral benefits is frustrating and must be avoided at all costs. Such delays are occurring even in regard to family pensions for which too, there is prescribed procedure. This indeed is unfortunate, in cases where a retired Government servant claims interest for delayed payment, the court can certainly keep in mind time schedule prescribed in the rules/instructions, apart from other relevant factors applicable to the case.
17. As per the ratio in Madan Mohans case the DCRG cannot be with held merely because the claim for damages for unauthorized occupation is pending against the applicant but amount towards normal rent, electricity and water charges which are admitted and obvious dues can be deducted. As per the ratio in Balakrishna Nambirs case the applicant is not entitled for interest on DCRG amount which was with held for unauthorized occupation of the quarter. As per Rampoojans case Full Bench held that no specific order canceling the allotment on expiry of permissible period of retention of the quarter on retirement is necessary. Retition of accommodation of the Railway servant would be unauthorized and penal/damage rent can be levied according to the rules prescribed from time to time. As per Hingorani, case (supra) and Railway Board Circular- no notice is required to be given before recovery of damage rent.
18. The applicant is entitled to interest on Provident Fund amount of Rs.2,58,359 from 1.6.1993 to August 2003 on prevailing rate. The contention of delay on the part of the applicant in submitting the papers is just lame excuse on the part of the respondents.
19. The respondents ought to have got verified the service records during his service period. It is also apparent that the respondents finalized most of the settlement dues only after filing O.A. 969/2002. It is a clear case of departmental delay which is not excusable. The respondents brought on record the letter date 4.5.1993 to show that their representative had gone to the residence of the applicant for verification, that cannot be the excuse of lethargy of the department in as much as the rules and instructions require that these actions to be taken long before retirement. The Exercise which was to be completed long before retirement was in fact started after retirement. It is also apparent that from 1993 onwards till 2000 the respondents did not take any action for processing the pension papers. Even the respondents did not mention that when they got duly completed papers from the applicant for settlement dues. The applicant has mentioned that he has not filled up any new norms. The settlement dues have been paid on old forms only. Thus the delay in finalization of settlement dues is attributable to the respondents and it is not on account of late submission of papers. This is a fit case for awarding interest on delayed payment.
20. There is no dispute that the pension and gratuity become valuable rights and property in the hands of employees on their retirement and the payment of pension and gratuity cannot be withheld even after the employee has remained in unauthorized occupation of employees accommodation and become liable to pay damages under the allotment Rules for over stay.
21. The Dearness Relief on pension has been defined in Railway Servants (Pension) Rules, 1993 which are also statutory rules framed under the provisions of Article 309 of Constitution. Rule 75 Sub-para (21) reads as under:
21 Dearness relief on pension or family pension
(i) relief may be granted to the pensioner in the form of dearness relief as such rates and conditions as the Government may specify from time to time.
(ii) If a pensioner is reemployed under Central or State Government in India or abroad, including permanent absorption in such corporation, company, body or bank he shall not be eligible to draw dearness relief on pension or family pension during the period of such re-employment.
(iii) a Railway employee who gets permanently absorbed in terms of Clause (a) Rule 54 and opts for lump sum payment in lieu of prorata monthly pension in terms of Clause (a) Rule 54 shall not be eligible for dearness relief. In Chapter-I on Section 19 pension has been defined as under: Pension includes gratuity except when the term pension is used in contradistinction to gratuity but does not include dearness relief.
22. The Provisions concerning adjustment pertaining to Railway accommodation have been made in Rule 16. Sub-rule (6) of Rule 16 reads as under: (6) The recovery of licence fee for the occupation of the Government accommodation beyond the permissible period of four months after the date of retirement if allotted shall be the responsibility of the Directorate of Estates. Any amount becoming due on account of licence fee for retention of Government accommodation beyond four months after retirement and remaining unpaid licence fee may be recovered by the Directorate of Estates through the concerned Accounts Officer from the dearness relief without the consent of the pensioner. In such cases no clearness relief should be disbursed until full recovery of such dues have been made. Note: For the purpose of this rule, the licence fee shall also include any other charges payable by the allottee for any damage or loss cause by him to the accommodation or its fittings.
23. It is apparent from the above that definition of pension exclude Dearness Relief. In Smt. M.P.Kanals case (supra) recovery is held permissible from Dearness Relief as it does not fall under the definition of pension. The order of the Competent Authority directing the Manager, State Bank of India to stop Dearness Relief and deposit to Railway Revenue cannot be said to be illegal.
24. As per ratio in Madan Mohans case DCRG cannot be withheld for unauthorized occupation of quarter and for recovery of penal rent. However the amount towards normal rent, electricity, water charges which come under admitted and obvious dues can be deducted by the respondents. As per ratio in K.Balakrishnans case the respondents to pay DCRG amount after deducting normal rent with interest at the rate of 10% p.a. from 1.11.2002 as he is evicted on 30.9.2002 till actual payment is made.
25. The respondents are to pay the interest at the rate of 10% p.a. on arrears of pension, Commutation of Pension, leave encashment, CGEIS amount from two months after the date of retirement till the same is actually paid. The respondents are to pay interest on GPF amount on the prevailing rate till the same is actually paid.
11. Furthermore, the Patna Bench of the Tribunal in Upendra Prasad v. Union of India & others, (OA-294/98) decided on 10.9.1999, as regards the interest party, made the following observations: 9. It is the admitted position that no departmental or criminal proceedings has been initiated against the applicant for any act of misconduct. The only ground for withholding retrial dues of the applicant in that the Special Audit report in respect of some alleged acts of irregularity in giving sanction to withdrawal of money is pending against the applicant. In other words, in contemplation of an inquiry into the alleged excess withdrawal of government money, the retrial dues of the applicant is said to have been withheld.
10. The learned counsel for the applicant contended that no retrial dues can be withheld in contemplation of an inquiry into an allegation. A contemplated inquiry cannot be equated with an inquiry initiated by issue of charge-sheet as has been held in Narendra Dev Sharma v. State of Punjab (1996 (2) SLR). The Honble Supreme Court in P.R. Narain and Union of India, 1972 SLR 219, held that an inquiry cannot be said to have been initiated against Member of All India Service till the charge3-sheet/Statement of allegations has been issued to him. That was a case in which suspension of the petitioner was caused in question on the ground that the Government had exercised the powers of suspension before initiation of inquiry. Upholding the contention of the petitioner that the suspension could not have been ordered without initiation of an inquiry, the apex Court held that mere contemplated inquiry cannot furnish basis for taking action for suspension of the employee.
11. Reliance is also placed on the decision of this Tribunal in Krishnadeo Prasad Singh v. The Union of India, as reported in (1996) 34 ATC page 596, where the applicant, an IAS Officer retired on superannuation on 31.12.1993. At that time, no charge-sheet had been issued to him. The pensionary benefits were not paid to him immediately on his retirement on the ground that there was complaint against him and that he made irregular appointment against clause III posts sometime before 31.10.92. Provisional Pension, however, was sanctioned to him at the rate of 90% on 2.1.96. DCRG was also sanctioned on 16.1.96. In the circumstances, the withholding of the full and final payment of pension, as a result of contemplated proceedings was held not justified. The applicant was held entitled to full and final payment of pension as he had been allowed to retire without initiation of any disciplinary proceedings. He was also held entitled to receive the interest at the rate of 18%.
12. In Ramshiromani v. Union of India and others as reported in (1995) 30 ATC page 333, the Patna Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal held withholding of pension, gratuity, commutation of pension, etc. not permissible mere on the basis of intimation received from CBI advising major penalty proceeding against a retired employee. In this case, the applicant was retiring from service on 30.6.93. Before that date, General Manager (Vigilance) vide his letter dated 15.6.93 informed that a letter has been received from CBI advising major penalty proceedings against the applicant. However, no charge-sheet was issued to the applicant till his retirement. In the circumstances, it was held that DCRG/Commutation of pension cannot be withheld unless a formal charge sheet was issued in a departmental proceeding and filed in the Court in a criminal trial. Mere receipt of intimation from CBI was not sufficient to withhold DCRG/Commutation of Pension. The Respondents were directed to release the same with interest at the rate of 15%.
13. In G.R. Venkatasubramanyam v. Divisional Railway Manager, Southern Railway, Mysore and Others, as reported in (1991) 15 ATC page 119, the Bangalore Bench of the CAT held that withheld payment of retrial benefits in contemplation of DAR action against the Board of Directors including the applicant for mismanaging co-operative stores cannot be allowed to sustain.
14. In the case of Nareshwar Prasad Sinha v. The Union of India and Ors., this Tribunal in OA -29/92 decided on 18.8.91, where the Railway withheld the payment of death-cum-Retirement Gratuity as also the commuted value of pension of a Divisional Accounts Officer after his retirement on the ground of a major penalty charge-sheet having been issued after obtaining the sanction of the President directed the Railways Authorities for releasing with withheld retrial dues as the relevant Railways Rules did not provide for withholding of such dues after retirement.
15. The learned counsel for the applicant has relied upon a decision of the Patna High Court as reported in Patna Law Journals, 1996 Patna 337, in which it is held that merely institution of a criminal case is no ground for withholding the amount of gratuity.
16. The case of the applicant is on better footing. Admittedly, no departmental proceedings or criminal case has yet been initiated against the applicant. If a charge-sheet has been framed and issued before he retired, that too with the permission of the President, there was some justification to withhold pension or gratuity depending on the facts of the case. The applicant retired on 31.7.97. He is alleged to have sanctioned withdrawal of money from Government Treasury against the schemes which had not been sanctioned by the Government/The State Government in the Finance Department has constituted a Special Audit Team for verification of the withdrawal on the basis of sanction accorded by the applicant. The report of the Auditor is yet to be received till date. It appears from Annexure-R/3 filed on behalf of the Respondents-State of Bihar that Shri S.N. Bishwas, the Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Forest and Environment Department in his communication dated 15.7.97 to the Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Finance, has written for post facto sanction of the withdrawal as sanctioned by the applicant against the schemes. I may usefully extract the relevant portion of the order as hereunder:- In Yognaon so sambandhit bastu isthiti is prakar hai ki ye yojnayain pradhikrit Samiti mein swikrit hain: Yogana awam vikash vibhag ka anumodan prapta hain. Manniya mukhyamantri Mahodaya ka anumodan bhi prapata hai I vitya vibhag ki sahmati prapt nahian hone ke karan rajyadesh nigra t nahi kiya ja saka. (I) wastawik rup se yojanayon ki sankhya awatn wastawik rup si nikasi ki gayee rjkshi awam wyay ki gayee rakshi ki suchana pradhan mukhya wan samraksha k aur mukhya wan sanrakshak (vikas) se prapta kija rahi hain (I) Yah sahi hain ki wina rajyadesh dngart kiye rashi ki nikashi sarwatha anuchit hain kintu isthi ka nirakaran ghanouttar swikriti pradan kar hi ki ja sankti hain
17. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests has also written to the Government for post facto sanction of the withdrawal after examining the matter without raising acusing fingure on the applicant. He has also issued nodues Ceritificate in favour of the applicant. The Accountant General, Bihar, Patna, has also recommended for sanction of withdrawal of retrial dues of the applicant, vide Annexures-A.B. and C filed on behalf of the Respondents Nos. 1 and 4.
18. Thus, there is nothing against the applicant so far on the record to justify the withholding of pension or other retrial dues of the applicant. The applicant filed several representations, vide Annexure-A/7 series, for the release of his pensionary benefits which relicited no response. He is in the evening of his life. He has unblemished career till the date of retirement. There is nothing on the record to show that his services were not found satisfactory at any point of time. It may be pointed out that Gratuity payable to an employee has been recognized as his property right by the Apex Court. In Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar and Ors. (AIR 1971 Supreme Court 1409), the Apex Court held that no one can be deprived of his property except by due process of law.
19. It is also settled that no recovery can be made against DCRG and pension except by due process of law and the terminal benefits cannot be adjusted against dues. Thus, I come to the irresistible conclusion that the applicant is entitled for the relief of pensionary benefits as claimed by him.
20. So far the claim for interest on the retrial dues is concerned, the applicant has already been paid GPF and Group Insurance amount, but he has not been paid pension, gratuity, leave encashment as yet. The payment of gratuity is deemed to have fallen due on the date of his retirement. The other dues are also expected to be paid within a reasonable period of three months from the date of his retirement. As stated above, the applicant is entitled for release of the aforesaid retrial dues which has not been paid to him for about more than two years for no fault on his part. In the circumstances, he is entitled to interest at the rate of 12 % on the amount due from the date of retirement till the payment is made.
12. Further the High Court of Delhi in K.K. Berrys case (supra) has held as follows: 15. The learned Single Judge noted that upon retirement, the respondents pensioners were entitled to receive the commuted value of pension in terms of Rule 6(1) (I-a) of the Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981 (1981 Rules) on the date following the date of retirement. The learned Single Judge thereafter observed as under:- It seems unreasonable that on the amount which the Respondents are asking Petitioner No.1 to refund, they are claiming interest but on the amount which they are giving to him, they are not paying any interest. The Respondents cannot have their cake and eat it too. Either they should not demand interest from Petitioner No.1 on the EPF or if they do so, they should pay interest to Petitioner No.1 on the commuted value of pension which was not paid to him on the due date. Alternatively, the Respondents may adjust both the amounts and on the balance, interest may be calculated. The learned Single Judge held that since the appellant had in any event taken a lenient view of the applicability of the 1972 Rules they could not avoid paying interest on the commuted value of the pension merely because the 1972 Rules did not contain a provision in that behalf. Consequently the learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petitions in the manner stated at the beginning of this judgment.
16. The approach to the issue on hand has to be based on certain settled legal principles explaining the nature and purpose of pension to a retired employee of the State or undertaking of the State. It has been long recognized in judicial decisions that pension is akin to property and is not a bounty or charity. In D.S. Nakara Vs. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 305, the concept of pension as a measure of socio-economic justice was explained thus: 29. Summing up it can be said with confidence that pension is not only compensation for loyal service rendered in the past, but pension also has a broader significance, in that it is a measure of socio-economic justice which inheres economic security in the fall of life when physical and mental prowess is ebbing corresponding to aging process and, therefore, one is required to fall back on savings. One such saving in kind is when you give your best in the hey-day of life to your employer, in days of invalidity, economic security by way of periodical payment is assured. The term has been judicially defined as a stated allowance or stipend made in consideration of past service or a surrender of rights or emoluments to one retired from service. Thus the pension payable to a government employee is earned by rendering lo9ng and efficient service and therefore can be said to be a deferred portion of the compensation or for service rendered. In one sentence one can say that the most practical raison detre for pension is the inability to provide for oneself due to old age. One may live and avoid unemployment but not senility and penury if there is nothing to fall back upon.
30. The discernible purpose thus underlying pension scheme or a statute introducing the pension scheme must inform interpretative process and accordingly it should receive a liberal construction and the courts may not so interpret such statute as to render them inane (see American Jurisprudence, 2d, 881). Although the judgment in D.S. Nakara to the extent that it invalidated a cut off date for grant of revised pensionary benefits has been subsequently watered down in a series of judgments including Krishena Kumar v. Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 207, Action Committee South Eastern Railway Pensioners v. Union of India 1991 Supp (2) SCC 544 and Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Vs. R. Veerasamy 1999 III AD (S.C.) 273=(1999) 3 SCC 414, the nature of what pension is as explained in D.S. Nakara still remains good law.
17. Viewed in light of the above legal principles, we agree with the reasoning of the learned Single Judge that, in the above circumstances it would be unfair and unreasonable to deny the pensioners interest on the commuted value of the pension paid to them. Mr. Datta is perhaps right in his submission that charging 12 % per annum compound interest on the EPF amount required to be refunded has the backing of the Circular dated 25.8.1994 issued by the Government of India. However, that still does not explain how it is fair and just to deny the respondents pensioners the corresponding rate of interest on a compounded basis on the commuted value of pension which is payable to them. We are of the view that the denial to the respondents the benefit of the interest on the commuted value of pension on the same basis as what is being charged from them in terms of para 6 of the pension scheme and the Circular dated 25.8.1994 of the Government of India would be plainly arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
18. There is also no answer by the appellants to the point made by the respondent pensioners that while the award of pension is calculated on the basis of the pension likely to be earned by the retiring person during the next ten years depending on his age factor, the full pension is received only after 15 years and not after 10 years. Therefore, obviously, the portion of the commuted value of pension paid in advance is recovered back together with the interest that such amounts could have earned. There appears to be no specific denial by the appellant to this averment made in para 12 (iii) of the writ petition. The only stand by way of reply is that there is no specific provision in the 1972 Rules for payment of such interest. We are of the view that the absence of a provision to pay interest on the commuted value of the pension cannot be offered as an explanation for answering the charge of arbitrariness and unreasonableness resulting from the denial of the payment of such interest, particularly in view of the fact that the Government, and now the appellant, have chosen to arm themselves with specific powers to charge such interest from the pensioners on the amounts that they seek to recover from them by way of refund of the EPF dues.
13. In the light of the order passed by the High Court remanding back this case, we agree with the decision of the Mumbai Bench. Accordingly, DOP&T advice tendered when in conflict with the judicial dicta has to be overridden. There is no justification on legality in the action of the respondents to deny the interest to the applicant.
14. Accordingly, OA is allowed. Impugned order is set aside. Respondents are directed to pay simple interest @ 8% to the applicant on account of delayed payment of DCRG and commuted value of fraction of pension w.e.f. 1.1.1998 till May 2006. This shall be done within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs. (Shanker Raju) Member (J) /lg/