Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 26, sub-rule (1).
  • clause of rule 26 of sub-rule (2).
  • CCS (Pension) Rule 26, Sub-Rule (2)
  • CCS (Pension) Rule 26 (2)
  • Rule 26, Sub-Rule (1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 26, sub-rule (1).
  • clause of rule 26 of sub-rule (2).
  • CCS (Pension) Rule 26, Sub-Rule (2)
  • CCS (Pension) Rule 26 (2)
  • Rule 26, Sub-Rule (1)
Smart Summary

Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This Original Application (O.A.) arises from a claim under CCS (Pension) Rule 26, Sub‑Rule (2). The applicant, who joined his present post as a Technical Officer on direct recruitment with effect from 7.10.2003, sought counting of his past service as an Engineering Assistant under Doordarshan/Prasar Bharati for the period 1.5.1990 to 4.10.2003 for all purposes. Respondents rejected the claim on the ground that the applicant's application for the subsequent post had not been forwarded through the proper channel; consequently, counting of past service was said not to be permissible under the Rules. The O.A. challenged the impugned order dated 15.10.2007 rejecting the request and asked for a direction to Respondent No.1 to count the past service for all purposes.

Brief chronology drawn from the O.A.:

  • The applicant served as an Engineering Assistant at Doordarshan Maintenance Centre (DMC), Gwalior, and was later transferred to Doordarshan Kendra, Bhopal.
  • He applied in August 1999 for the post of Technical Officer in the Aviation Research Centre (advertised in Employment News) and was offered the post by Office Order dated 22.7.2003.
  • The applicant was relieved from Bhopal on 4.10.2003 (allowed lien for two years) and joined the new post on 7.10.2003.
  • The respondents maintained the application was not routed through the applicant's employer/competent authority and therefore did not attract the exception under Rule 26(2).

The decision in the opinion was delivered by Member (A) Dr. Veena Chhotray, and Member (J) Shanker Raju is also recorded on the order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant is entitled to counting of his past service under CCS (Pension) Rule 26(2) despite having applied directly for the subsequent post (i.e., whether the circumstances qualify the resignation as a "technical resignation" and satisfy the requirement of "proper permission" / forwarding by the competent authority).
  2. Whether communications and subsequent actions (the applicant informing his Station Engineer, a communication dated 6.9.1999, a certificate dated 29.8.2005, and forwarding of the service book with certification) suffice to satisfy the Rule 26(2) requirement of forwarding/unconditional permission.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant applied directly because the advertisement afforded only a short period (15 days) and he was undergoing sponsored training at IIT Kanpur; to avoid postal delay he applied directly.
  • He informed his immediate Controlling Authority (Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior) by letter dated 18.8.1999 and sought NOC; he relied on the reply dated 6.9.1999 and subsequent communications as evidence of informing and engagement with the employer.
  • The applicant relied on Government of India instructions (as included in Swamy's compilation) that the bond amount need not be enforced where subsequent employment is under the Government of India or a PSU under its control, so the Station Engineer's request for an undertaking or bond should not be an impediment.
  • On request a certificate dated 29.8.2005 was issued by the Station Engineer stating no objection to his continuity in service; the present employer also requested forwarding of the service book with a certificate that the applicant resigned with proper permission and was relieved on 4.10.2003, and that document was in fact forwarded.
  • On these facts, the applicant contended that the resignation should be treated as a "technical formality" under Rule 26(2) and that the past service ought to be counted for all purposes.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Both the current and erstwhile employers agreed the applicant's application had not been forwarded through the proper channel with the permission of the Controlling Authority; therefore, the case does not fall within the exception in Rule 26(2).
  • Respondent No.1 argued the Station Engineer's communication dated 6.9.1999 should not be construed as an NOC, and that the application by the applicant should have been routed through the proper channel.
  • Respondent No.1 also questioned certain procedural aspects such as to whom later communications were addressed and alleged possible manipulation regarding the certification in the service book; however, those contentions were not accepted as prima facie tenable by the court.
  • Respondents asserted the general rule that applications by existing employees should be routed through proper channel applied, regardless of whether the advertisement expressly mentioned it.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the factual matrix against the requirements of CCS (Pension) Rule 26(2) and the relevant Government of India instructions (as recorded in Swamy's compilation). The analysis proceeded in the following steps:

  1. The court acknowledged the undisputed fact that the application for the subsequent post had not been forwarded through the proper channel and that the applicant himself admitted applying directly.
  2. The court considered the applicant's explanation of a genuine circumstantial compulsion (short advertisement period and being at IIT Kanpur) for direct submission and noted that the applicant had informed his immediate controlling authority (Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior) and had sought NOC by a dated communication (Annexure A/3).
  3. The court reviewed the Government of India decision(s) summarized in Swamy's compilation which explain that Rule 26(2)'s phrase "proper permission" requires forwarding by the competent authority of the previous employer at the time of application, and that such forwarding should be unconditional. The decision also distinguishes "technical resignation" (which does not entail forfeiture of past service) from "subsisting" resignation covered by Rule 26(1), and lists scenarios where resignation will be treated as subsisting.
  4. The court examined whether any of the contingencies that would lead to treating resignation as subsisting existed in this case (application withheld by previous employer in public interest; impossibility of forwarding in public interest; service conditions mandating resignation). It found none of those contingencies present.
  5. The court took into account subsequent events and communications: (a) the Station Engineer's communication of 6.9.1999 (treated as a quasi‑NOC for present purposes), (b) a certificate dated 29.8.2005 by the Station Engineer certifying the applicant's prior service and stating no objection to continuity, and (c) the current employer's request dated 29.11.2005 for the service book to be forwarded with certification and the eventual forwarding of the service book with the required certification.
  6. The court also relied on the Government of India instruction that service bond enforcement is not required where the subsequent employment is with the Government of India or an undertaking under it, reducing the force of the Station Engineer's request for an undertaking as a bar to counting service.
  7. On the totality of facts, the court concluded that technicalities should not prevail over substance; the applicant's direct application was explained by bona fide circumstances, he had kept his immediate authority informed, there was effectively clearance (or no real impediment), and the employers later facilitated the formalities by forwarding the service book with certification.
  8. Therefore, the court found that the requirements of Rule 26(2) were satisfied in substance and that the applicant's resignation could be treated as a technical formality for the purposes of counting past service.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The O.A. was allowed. The court set aside the impugned order dated 15.10.2007 and held that the requirements of CCS (Pension) Rule 26(2) were met in the circumstances of this case. The core ruling can be summarized as:

OA allowed; impugned order set aside.

Implications:

  • The applicant is entitled to counting of his past service from 1.5.1990 to 4.10.2003 for all consequential purposes under the Rule.
  • The applicant is entitled to all consequential benefits flowing from the counting of that past service.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applies Rule 26(2) and the existing Government of India instructions to the specific facts, resolving that in this case substance and bona fide circumstances justified treating the resignation as a technical formality.

End of summary.

    Devendra Kumar Singh v. Union Of India

    By Dr. Veena Chhotray, Member (A): The instant OA arises from a claim under the CCS (Pension) Rule 26, Sub-Rule (2) which carving out an exception to the general rule of forfeiture of past service on resignation, provides  (2) A resignation shall not entail forfeiture of past service if it has been submitted to take up, with proper permission, another appointment, whether temporary or permanent, under the Government where service qualifies. (emphasis supplied)

    2. The applicant, working as a Technical Officer under Respondent No.1, seeks counting of his past service as an Engineering Assistant under the Prasar Bharati (Respondents 2 & 3). The applicant who joined his present assignment on direct recruitment basis w.e.f. 7.10.2003 claims the period of past service w.e.f. 1.5.1990 to 4.10.2003 to be counted for all purposes. The Respondents have rejected the claim of the applicant on the ground that since his application had not been forwarded through proper channel, counting of his past service was not permissible under the Rules. The OA seeks quashing of the impugned order dated 15.10.2007 rejecting the aforesaid request of the applicant (Annexure A/1). Besides, a direction to Respondent No.1 for counting of his past service for all purposes has also been sought.

    3. Briefly stated, the facts as revealed through this O.A. are that the applicant while working as an Engineering Assistant in the Doordarshan Maintenance Centre (DMC for short), Gwalior, had applied for the post of Technical Officer (Group A post) in the Aviation Research Centre, Directorate General of Security under the Cabinet Secretariat in response to an advertisement in the Employment News in August 1999. He was offered this post by the Office Order dated 22.7.2003 (Annexure A/6). In the meanwhile, the applicant had been transferred in his erstwhile Organization from Gwalior to Doordarshan Kendra, Bhopal (Respondent No.3). Consequent upon his selection for the post of Technical Officer, the applicant was relieved from Bhopal Doordarshan Kendra on 4.10.2003, while being allowed a lien for two years (Annexure A/7). The applicant joined his new position on 7.10.2003.

    4. The applicant is claiming counting of his past service under the Doordarshan (now Prasar Bharati) from 1.5.1990 to 4.10.2003 for all purposes. In support, it has been averred that the applicants service has been continuous throughout; he had been relieved properly by the erstwhile employers and the acceptance of his technical resignation by the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 was in terms of CCS (Pension) Rule 26 (2) (Grounds 5.D and F of the OA).

    5. The claim of the applicant has been contested both by the current as well as the erstwhile employers through their separate counter affidavits. There is a unanimity that the application in this case had not been made through proper channel with permission of the Controlling Authority. Therefore, the case is averred not to fall within the purview of the exceptional clause of rule 26 of sub-rule (2).

    6. It is not disputed that the application for the subsequent post had been made by the applicant directly and it had not been routed through his erstwhile employer. This fact is admitted by the applicant himself. This, however, is stated to be because of the peculiar circumstances at that time. The representation dated 18.5.2005 by the applicant on the subject of counting of past services (Annexure A/11) states that the advertisement for the post of Technical Officer had appeared in the Employment News in August 1999, affording a time of only 15 days to the applicant. At that time the applicant was undergoing training at IIT Kanpur as a sponsored candidate from Doordarshan. As only 5-6 days were left in the dead-line, to avoid postal delays. he had applied directly. However, the applicant had intimated his Office at Gwalior and requested for NOC. In support, a copy of letter dated 18.8.1999 addressed to the Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior has been annexed with the OA as Annexure A/3. This is said to have been responded by the concerned officer vide OM dated 6.9.1999 asking the applicant for submitting an undertaking regarding deposit of the amount of Rs.2 lacs as per the bond before leaving the present post. Besides, other terms and conditions, if any, were also to be accepted by him. These contentions by the applicant have not been rebutted by either of the respondents though it is maintained by both that this communication by the Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior, should not be construed as an NOC (paras 4.4 and 4.5 of counter reply of Rs-2 & 3 and paras 4.1 to 4.5 of counter reply of R-1).

    7. The implication of Rule 26 (2) were further elaborated through certain executive instructions, which have been mentioned in the Swamys compilation as Government of India decisions. The Government of India decision No.1 is relevant in the present context. By these instructions, the case where resignation is a mere technical formality without entailing forfeiture of past service was distinguished from the situations where it is construed as subsisting, attracting the provisions of Rule 26, Sub-Rule (1). It was laid down that for taking a resignation to be technical resignation, the application should have been forwarded through the competent authority with whom the applicant had been serving at the time of applying for the subsequent post. Thus the use of the word proper permission under Rule 26 (2) read with this decision of the Government of India means forwarding by the competent authority of the previous employer at the time of applying for the post. The stipulation of forwarding the application envisages the option on the part of the previous employer to withhold the same in exigencies of public service. To eliminate all uncertainties on this score, it is also prescribed that there should be no strings attached and the act of forwarding should be unconditional. As to who should be the right person to forward the application in such cases, the instruction specifies that it should be the competent authority under whom the Government servant was serving at the time of the application. The other scenarios where the resignation would be taken as subsisting and thus coming with the purview of Rule 26, Sub-Rule (1) where the applicant has applied for the post on his own volition on three contingencies. These are (i) the application had not been forwarded by the erstwhile employer; (ii) it was not possible to forward the application in public interest; and (iii) where the conditions of service demanded a resignation before taking up another post. Another situation where the resignation can be treated as a technical formality is when an application being forwarded through proper channel, in the event of selection, the employee is asked to resign for administrative reasons. In such cases, if the rules permit for the purposes of pay fixation benefits of past service may be given treating the resignation as a mere technical formality.

    8. Besides the extenuating circumstances already mentioned in para 6 above, the applicant has sought to advance a few additional pleas to support direct submission of the application. These were (i) there was no such mention in the advertisement itself regarding the application being routed through proper channel; (ii) the applications had been invited only at a post box office number without giving any proper address. Further it has been averred that the Respondents had not raised any objection to such direct submission of the application at any stage either at the written test or at the time of the oral interview. The first contention about non-mention of such a condition in the advertisement has been rebutted by the respondent no.1 in their counter affidavit asserting that the general rule of the applications of existing employees being routed through proper channel would in any case be applicable. They have also tried to take the aid of Clause 5 of the advertisement (Annexure A/2) where on the subject of age limit it was mentioned that: Upto 35 years (relaxable for Government servants and SC/ST and OBC in accordance with the instructions or orders issued by the Central Government in this regard). We note that the applications in this case were being invited for direct recruitment which could have meant both from fresh applicants as also the existing employees working in other Organizations. Column 9 of the advertisement prescribes specific columns pertaining to previous experience. Column 10 is relating to the requirement of attaching certain certificates pertaining to castes. There is no specific mention in this advertisement regarding the application of existing employees being routed through their employers. We, however, do not consider it necessary to get into this dispute since there is a clear difference between accepting an existing employees directly submitted application and offering direct appointment on merit and the totally different proposition of counting of previous service of such an employee. There cannot be two views that for conferring the benefits under CCS (Pension) Rule 26 (2), a case has to come clear as per the stipulation envisaged under the Rules and the relevant Government of Indias decisions.

    9. Even though the application in this case had not been forwarded through proper channel, we would still be inclined to lend credence to the plea of a bonafide circumstantial compulsion leaving the applicant with no option other than a direct application. We would also not demur in taking note of the fact that the applicant had after all sought to keep his immediate Controlling Authority, the Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior informed of the fact of the application (Annexure A/3). Further, we would also consider the respondents view in not treating the communication dated 6.9.1999 as NOC as rather formalistic. This is more so because, as pointed out by the applicants counsel, in the light of the clear instructions by the Government of India, there was no requirement for enforcement of such service bonds in cases where the subsequent employment was only under the Government of India or a Public Sector Undertaking under its control (Annexure A/5.) Again, the objection raised by the current employer (Respondent No.1) that the applicant had not submitted his technical resignation through his parent department at Doordarshan Kendra, Bhopal (Paras 4.11 to 4.14) is not found to be factually true in view of the relevant documents annexed with the OA as Annexures A/7 and A/8. Similarly, while the respondent no.1 has raised an objection to the applicant addressing his letter dated 6.8.2005 to the Station Engineer, Gwalior instead of the Doordarshan Kendra, Bhopal (para 4.15 of the counter reply of R-1); no such averment has been made by the erstwhile employers (R-2 and R-3).

    10. Considering the background facts as this case does not ex-facie fall within either of the two categories of the resignation being technical formality or its subsisting, we would need to go beyond the form and take into account the spirit of the rule in the interest of justice. This was not a case where the previous employer had withheld the application in exigencies of public service; nor did the conditions of service mandate a resignation. Again in view of the clear GOI instructions regarding exemption from payment of the sum undertaken in the bond, even this aspect of the communication dated 6.9.1999 would not pose as an impediment byway of conditionality.

    11. While pursuing his case, at the request of the applicant, a certificate dated 29.8.2005 was issued by the Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior certifying that the applicant had been working with them from August 1990 to 7.12.1999. It was also stated that in view of his appointment under the Cabinet Secretariat, the Office has no objection for the purpose of his continuity in service. On receipt of the same, the current employers of the applicant had issued a letter dated 29.11.2005, which has been annexed as Annexure A/14 with the OA. The relevant extracts are as below: 2. In order to take up his case further the Service Book of Shri D.K. Singh maintained in your office be forwarded to this office after endorsing a certificate under proper attestation to the effect that he resigned from the post of Engineering Assistant in Doordarshan Maintenance Centre with proper permission to join ARC as Technical Officer and relieved on 4.10.2003 and benefit provided under Rule 26(2) will be admissible to him. Paras 4.16 and 4.17 of the OA make an averment in this regard and state that on the basis of this letter from the Office of Respondent No.1, the Service Book of the applicant had been received together with the necessary certificate that the applicant had applied proper permission to join his post as Technical Officer, ARC and he had been relieved on 4.10.2003. The above contention of the applicant has not been rebutted by the respondents no. 2 and 3. The averment by the respondent no.1 regarding an alleged manipulation in the Service Book regarding the aforesaid certificate is not taken as prima facie tenable. Several facts such as the Service Book being in the possession of the respondents no.2 and 3; the aforesaid Certificate being a kind of a legal fiction in response to the request by the Respondent No.1 would seem to discount the same.

    12. To conclude, this was a case where even though the application for the subsequent post had instead of being forwarded through proper channel had been submitted by the applicant directly because of a bonafide circumstantial compulsion; the applicant had kept the immediate controlling authority duly informed. Further on his request, a communication dated 6.9.1999 was also issued by the Station Engineer, DMC, Gwalior which was a virtual NOC. On being selected to the post, the respondents had suo-motu relieved the applicant and also forwarded the Service Book with due certification. Thus the technicalities must not be allowed to prevail over substance, in the interest of justice. We therefore, hold it to be a case where the requirements of CCS (Pension) Rule 26 (2) are met. Accordingly the OA is allowed and the impugned order is set aside. The applicant would be entitled to all consequential benefits. There shall be no order as to costs. (Veena Chhotray) (Shanker Raju) Member (A) Member (J) /pkr/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devendra Kumar Singh v. Union Of India
    (May 6, 2009)