Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules 15 (3) and 16
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules 15 (3) and 16
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Two OAs with similar facts and identical legal issues were decided by a common order; OA No.1627/2012 was treated as the lead case. On directions of the Hon'ble High Court, a CBI enquiry was conducted to ascertain whether UTP Abhishek Verma misused his custody parole in the Naval War Leak case; the CBI reported no misuse. Despite that, disciplinary proceedings were initiated against Ct. Data Ram No.7201/DAP and Constable Raj Kumar No.65/DAP by order dated 14.5.2010 alleging they remained in contact with the accused and his relative and that Data Ram advised Vikas Raizada to apply for custody parole for Abhishek Verma. The Inquiry Officer (23.6.2011) found the charge proved to the extent that the applicants were in touch with the accused's relative by telephone. The Disciplinary Authority (15.7.2011) imposed punishment of forfeiture of two years' approved service temporarily with proportionate pay reduction and treated specified suspension periods as not spent on duty. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeals on 16.12.2011. The applicants filed these OAs challenging the disciplinary orders and seeking various reliefs including quashing the orders, release of increments and consequential benefits, and costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disciplinary proceedings and punishments imposed on the applicants are sustainable where the CBI enquiry concluded that there was no misuse of custody parole by Abhishek Verma.
  2. Whether statements recorded during the CBI investigation and the authenticated CBI enquiry report could be relied upon in departmental enquiry proceedings without calling the material witnesses (Abhishek Verma and Vikas Raizada) for cross-examination.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The main issue before the CBI was misuse of custody parole; CBI found no misuse, so the disciplinary charge against the applicants is unsustainable.
  • Material witnesses (Abhishek Verma and Vikas Raizada) were not examined in the departmental enquiry, denying the applicants the opportunity to cross-examine them.
  • Cited Kuldeep Singh vs Commissioner of Police & Ors : (1999) 2 SCC 10 for the principle that presence of witnesses can be dispensed with only when it is not possible to procure them without undue delay, inconvenience or expense.
  • Invoked Delhi Police (Punishment & Appeal) Rules 15(3) and 16(iii) that statements recorded during enquiry/investigation can be considered only when witnesses are no longer available.
  • Asserted Data Ram was not on escort duty during the custody parole and Raj Kumar was not on escort duty at all.
  • Cited Hardwari Lal vs State of U.P. & Ors : JT 1999 (8) SC 418 and Union of India & Ors vs Gyan Chand Chattar:(2009) 12 SCC 78 for the proposition that grave/quasi-criminal charges must be proved beyond reasonable doubt and not by mere probabilities.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The enquiry established that both applicants were in touch with Vikas Raizada by mobile and landline calls; call records were produced and authenticated by nodal officers of mobile companies and were relied upon in the departmental enquiry.
  • Five prosecution witnesses were examined, including nodal officers of Vodafone and Bharti Airtel and SP, CBI (PW-5); PW-5 stated that statements of the applicants and Vikas Raizada were recorded during the CBI preliminary enquiry and the applicant Data Ram had admitted contact with Vikas Raizada.
  • The CBI enquiry report and call records were authenticated during the departmental enquiry and are sufficient to establish the charge; the applicants did not summon the witnesses as defence witnesses.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kuldeep Singh vs Commissioner of Police & Ors : (1999) 2 SCC 10 Presence of witnesses can be dispensed with only when it is not possible to procure them without undue delay, inconvenience or expense. Applicants relied on this principle to argue witnesses should have been produced; the court noted the reliance but found no prejudice because the witnesses' statements were recorded in the CBI enquiry and authenticated in the departmental enquiry.
Hardwari Lal vs State of U.P. & Ors : JT 1999 (8) SC 418 Authority cited to support the contention that failure to examine material witnesses vitiates proceedings (as relied upon by applicants). Cited by applicants; the court nevertheless held the authenticated CBI statements and call records, and the applicants' failure to summon witnesses, rendered the contention unavailing.
Union of India & Ors vs Gyan Chand Chattar:(2009) 12 SCC 78 Serious/quasi-criminal charges must be proved "to the hilt" beyond any shadow of doubt and cannot be proved on mere probabilities (paragraph 21 quoted). Applicants invoked this to stress the high standard of proof; the court found the authenticated call records, CBI report and admissions sufficient and did not accept that the required standard was unmet in the circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that the respondents relied on call records produced in evidence and authenticated by nodal officers of the mobile companies (S/Shri Anil Bhatia and R.K. Singh), both of whom were cross-examined. PW-5 (Shri Ramnish, SP, CBI), who was the Investigation Officer, stated that statements of the applicants and of Vikas Raizada were recorded during the CBI preliminary enquiry and that the applicant Data Ram had admitted being in touch with Vikas Raizada. The CBI enquiry report was authenticated by SP, CBI during the departmental enquiry. The court held that the authenticated call records together with the authenticated CBI enquiry report and the admission by Data Ram were sufficient to establish the charge. The court concluded that non-examination of Vikas Raizada and Abhishek Verma in the departmental enquiry did not cause prejudice because their statements had been recorded during the CBI investigation and authenticated; additionally, the applicants did not summon those persons as defence witnesses. On that basis the court found no infirmity in the departmental proceedings.

Holding and Implications

OAs dismissed. The court dismissed the OAs and made no order as to costs.

Implications: The disciplinary findings and punishments imposed on the applicants stand; the court did not set aside the departmental enquiry findings and did not indicate any creation of new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities and the authenticated evidentiary record.

    Data Ram v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi

    By Shekhar Agarwal: As both these OAs have similar facts and identical issues of law, they are being decided by this common order. The OA No.1627/2012 is being taken as the lead case with the references in this order pertaining to this OA, unless otherwise specified.

    2. The applicants in these OAs have sought the following reliefs:- 1. To quash and set aside the impugned orders as mentioned in Para-1 of O.A. and direct the respondents to release to the applicant his increments with all consequential benefits including promotion/seniority and arrears of pay.

    2. To award costs in favour of the applicant. To pass any order or orders, which this Honble Tribunal may deem just & equitable in the facts & circumstances of the case.

    3. The facts of the cases are that on the directions of the Honble High Court, an enquiry was conducted by CBI to ascertain whether UTP Abhishek Verma had misused his custody parole for destroying evidence related to Naval War Leak case in which he was one of the accused. The CBI submitted its report concluding therein that there has been no misuse of custody parole of Abhishek Verma. However, following the CBI report, disciplinary proceedings had been initiated against the applicants vide order dated 14.5.2010 on the following charge: It is alleged against Ct. Data Ram No.7201 DAP and Constable Raj Kumar No.65/DAP that while they were posted in VI Bn. and III Bn. DAP respectively they were detailed for escort duty with UTP Abhishek Verma on many occasions. They remain in constant touch with the under trial accused and his relative by telephonically or by other means. On 21.9.2006 Ct. Data Ram, No.7201/DAP advised Shri Vikas Raizada (relative of UTP Abhishek Verma) to apply for the custody parole of UTP Abhishek Verma to visit his house on medical ground of ailing mother and accordingly on 22.9.2006 an application for custody parole of UTP Abhishek Verma was filed. On 23.9.2006 court of ACMM, Patiala House Delhi passed the orders granting custody parole of UTP Abhishek Verma. Ct. Data Ram No.7201/DAP used Vikas Puri Police Lines telephone to contact to Shri Vikas Raizada. During the course of preliminary inquiry conducted by the CBI on the directions of Honble High Court of Delhi in Crl. Misc. (C) No.7905/2006 to probe into possible misuse of custody parole by UTP Abhishek Verma. Shri Vikas Raizada (relative of UTP Abhishk Verma) and Ct. Data Ram No.7201/DAP admitted maintaining contact with each other during the such inquiry.

    4. The Inquiry Officer submitted his findings to the Disciplinary Authority on 23.6.2011 concluding therein that the charge is proved to the extent that Ct. Data Ram and Ct. Raj Kumar were in touch with the relatives of the accused Abhishek Verma by telephone. The findings were considered by the Disciplinary Authority, who vide impugned order dated 15.7.2011 imposed punishment of forfeiture of two years approved service temporarily upon both the applicants for a period of two years entailing proportionate reduction in their pay. The suspension period from 20.9.2007 to 02.02.2001 in respect of Constable Data Ram and from 21.09.2007 to 02.02.2010 in respect of Constable Raj Kumar was treated as period not spent on duty for all intents and purposes. The Appellate Authority vide its Order dated 16.12.2011 rejected the appeals of both the Applicants. Aggrieved by the same, the Applicants have filed these two OAs before the Tribunal.

    5. The learned counsel for the Applicants argued that the main issue on which CBI inquiry was ordered by the Honble High Court was whether Abhishek Verma had misused his custody parole. Since CBI enquiry has established that there was no misuse of custody parole, the alleged charge on the applicants is not sustainable. Learned counsel stated that Abhishek Verma and his relative Vikas Raizada with whom the Respondents have alleged that the applicants had been in constant touch were material witnesses in this case. However, both these witnesses were not examined during the DE proceedings by the Respondents, thus denying the opportunity to the Applicants to cross-examine them.

    6. Learned counsel for the Applicants cited judgment in the case of Kuldeep Singh vs Commissioner of Police & Ors : (1999) 2 SCC 10, wherein the Honble Supreme Court observed that the presence of the witnesses can be dispensed with only when it is not possible to procure the same without undue delay, inconvenience or expense and not otherwise. Learned counsel stated that both Abhishekh Verma and Vikas Raizada could have been asked to appear in the enquiry and prove the contents of the statements they gave to CBI which have been relied upon by the Respondents. According to the learned counsel, since this was not done their statements cannot be made admissible as evidence in the DE proceedings and thus this has become a case of no evidence. He further stated that Delhi Police (Punishment & Appeal) Rules 15 (3) and 16 (iii) also provide that the statements recorded during the enquiry/investigation can be brought on record and considered only when the witnesses are no longer available. Learned counsel went on to say that it has been established that the applicant Data Ram was not on escort duty with Abhishek Verma during his custody parole, but had only done escort duty with him on a few occasions earlier. Regarding the other applicant, Raj Kumar, the learned counsel stated that he (Raj Kumar) was not even on escort duty. He further quoted the case of Hardwari Lal vs State of U.P. & Ors : JT 1999 (8) SC 418 to emphasize that since these two material witnesses had not been examined, the proceedings stand vitiated. He further relied upon the case of Union of India & Ors vs Gyan Chand Chattar:(2009) 12 SCC 78 of Honble Supreme Court decided on 28.5.2009. Para 21 of judgment reads as under: 21. Such a serious charge of corruption requires to be proved to the hilt as it brings civil and criminal consequences upon the employee concerned. He would be liable to be prosecuted and would also be liable to suffer severest penalty awardable in such cases. Therefore, such a grave charge of quasi-criminal nature was required to be proved beyond any shadow of doubt and to the hilt. It cannot be proved on mere probabilities. His contention was that such a grave charge should be proved beyond any shadow of doubt and not merely on probabilities. The Respondents in their reply have stated that the enquiry has clearly established that both the applicants were in touch with Vikas Raizada, the cousin of UTP Abhishek Verma on mobile as well as land line phones. They have contended that the Inquiry Officer had examined five prosecution witnesses which included Shri Anil Bhatia, Nodal Officer of Voda Phone, New Delhi, Shri R.K. Singh, Nodal Officer of Bharti Airtel Limited, Delhi Circle and Shri Ramnish, SP, CBI. According to the respondents, the call records produced in evidence established that the applicants were in touch with Raizada. Moreover, in the enquiry before the CBI, the applicant Data Ram had himself admitted that he had been in touch with Vikas Raizada. We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record. We find that the Respondents have relied on the call records produced as evidence before the Inquiry Officer in the CBI Inquiry regarding misuse of custody parole. The call records produced as evidence were authenticated by the Nodal Officers of the Mobile Cos. viz. S/Shri Anil Bhatia and R.K. Singh. Both of them were cross-examined by the Applicants also. PW-5 was Shri Ramnish, SP, CBI, who stated that he was the Investigation Officer of the Naval War Room leak case also. He further stated that during the preliminary enquiry as ordered by the Honble High Court, the I.O. had recorded statements of both the applicants, Data Ram and Raj Kumar as well as statements of Shri Vikas Raizada, the cousin of Abhishek Verma, which have been adduced as evidence in the DE proceedings. Shri Ramnish said that in his statement before the CBI, the Applicant Data Ram had admitted being in touch with Vikas Raizada. We find that the Respondents have relied on the call records which have been authenticated as also on the CBI enquiry report, which has been authenticated by SP, CBI during the DE proceedings. In our opinion this is sufficient to establish the charge made against the applicants. We do not feel that any prejudice has been caused to the applicants by non-examination of Vikas Raizada and Abhishek Verma in the DE proceedings since their statements were recorded during CBI investigation and the CBI enquiry report was authenticated by SP, CBI during DE proceedings. The applicants also did not choose to summon them as defence witnesses.

    9. Thus, we find that there is no infirmity in the DE proceedings and we see no reason to interference in the matter. The OAs are accordingly dismissed with no or0der as to costs. (SHEKHAR AGARWAL) (G. GEORGE PARACKEN) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J) /PKR/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Data Ram v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi
    (Feb 15, 2013)