Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant filed an Original Application challenging the disciplinary authority's order dated 11.1.2011, which imposed a penalty of reduction to a lower timescale of pay for one year by two stages. During the hearing, the applicant's counsel submitted that the applicant would be satisfied if the Tribunal clarified the expression "dies non without break in service" used in the disciplinary order. The respondents' counsel contended that the disciplinary authority's decision regarding the intervening period is self-explanatory and requires no further explanation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the expression "dies non without break in service" used in the disciplinary authority's order requires clarification by the Tribunal.
  2. Whether the period treated as "dies non" but not constituting a break in service affects the applicant's entitlement to financial upgradations and pensionary benefits.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant sought clarification on the meaning of "dies non without break in service" as used in the disciplinary order.
  • The applicant argued that if the period is treated as "dies non," it might lead to denial of benefits related to financial upgradations under the Assured Career Progression / Modified Assured Career Progression Schemes and pension.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents submitted that the disciplinary authority's order regarding the intervening period is self-explanatory and does not require further clarification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Government of India, C. & A.G., U.O. No.1947-A/438-58 dated 12.9.1958 Absence without leave, when not contiguous with authorized leave, constitutes an interruption of service for pension and is treated as "dies non" for increments, leave, and pension. The Court used this precedent to interpret "dies non" as an interruption of service but noted the disciplinary order's paradox in treating the period as "dies non" yet not a break in service, leading to the clarification issued.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the disciplinary authority's order which treated the period of absence as "dies non" but simultaneously stated it would not constitute a break in service, identifying this as a paradoxical position. Referring to the Government of India circular dated 12.9.1958, the Court explained that "dies non" implies an interruption of service affecting increments, leave, and pension. Since the disciplinary authority had declared the period not to be a break in service, the Court clarified that the applicant should not be denied financial upgradations and pensionary benefits for that period. The Court thus resolved the ambiguity by aligning the consequences of "dies non" with the absence of a break in service as per the disciplinary order.

Holding and Implications

The Original Application is disposed of with the clarification that the period treated as "dies non" without break in service shall not deprive the applicant of financial upgradations and pensionary benefits.

The decision directly affects the applicant by ensuring entitlement to benefits during the period of absence as clarified. No new precedent was established beyond the clarification of the existing disciplinary order.

    Nisha Rani v. Gnct Of Delhi

    Mr. A.K. Bhardwaj: Albeit the applicant filed the present Original Application against the order No. DE.7/363/PET/SWA/NGV/VIG/HQ/2010-4647 dated 11.1.2011 passed by the disciplinary authority imposing upon her the penalty of reduction to lower timescale of pay for a period of one year by two stages, during the course of hearing Mr. Sourabh Ahuja, learned counsel for applicant, on instruction from his client, submitted that the applicant would be satisfied if the expression dies non without break in service used in the order of the disciplinary authority is clarified by the Tribunal.

    2. On the other hand, Mr. Vijay Pandita, learned counsel for respondents fairly submitted that the decision regarding intervening period taken by the disciplinary authority in its order is self-explanatory and no further explanation is required.

    3. Re-joining the submissions, Mr. Ahuja espoused that once the disciplinary authority has directed the period to be treated as dies non, the ramification may be that the applicant will not be entitled to the benefit of the period of absence for the purpose of financial upgradations in terms of the Assured Career Progression / Modified Assured Career Progression Schemes and pension.

    4. We heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    5. We find that in Government of Indias decisions vide C. & A.G., U.O. No.1947-A/438-58 dated 12.9.1958 it has been made clear that such absence without leave where it stands singly and not in continuation of any authorized leave of absence will constitute an interruption of service for the purpose of pension and should be treated as dies non for all purpose, i.e., increment, leave and pension. The term dies non, as understood in the said U.O. is that when certain period of service is treated as dies non, it has to be treated as an interruption of service. In the present case, when the disciplinary authority has directed the period to be treated as dies non, it has also ordered that the period will not constitute break in service, thus the order of the disciplinary authority is paradox.

    6. In the circumstances, we clarify that once the disciplinary authority viewed that the absence period would not be treated as break in service, the applicant would not be denied the benefit of said period for the purpose of financial upradations and pensionary benefits. The Original Application stands disposed of. No costs. ( V. N. Gaur ) ( A.K. Bhardwaj ) Member (A) Member (J) November 7, 2014 /sunil/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nisha Rani v. Gnct Of Delhi
    (Nov 7, 2014)