Judgment / Order 13/09/2017
1. The petitioner by way of present writ petition has prayed that his period of service be counted from 1952 to 1999 as qualifying service for grant of pension & retiral benefits and his pension be revised accordingly.
2. The respondents have filed reply and state that the petitioner was appointed on 1.10.1955 on Rs.50/- per month as P.P. Compounder in Sawai Man Singh Hospital, Jaipur. It is further stated that the period from 1952 to 1955 was treated as training compounding, Dressing and Nursing.
3. Learned counsel for the respondents has placed before this Court copy of the service book of the petitioner wherein it is (2 of 5) [CW-45/2014] shown that he was initially appointed on 1.9.52 on substantive post of Compounder of Rs.20/- per month vide office order dated 29.8.1952. His pay was thereafter increased to Rs.25/- per month on 15.2.1953 and thereafter he passed qualifying examination for appointment as temporary III Grade Compounder in the grade 50- 3-80 vide order dated 7.12.1955. Thus from the service book it is apparent the petitioners service from 1952 was required to be counted for the purpose of counting qualifying service. Rajasthan Service Rules 1951 came into force w.e.f. 1st April, 1951 and the same were applied as per Rule 2(3)(a) and (b) of the Rules of 1951 to all the persons initially appointed on such post in service on the basis of contracts entered into & subsequently appointed in regular manner would be entitled for counting of his service as qualifying service for the purpose of pension. It will be useful to quote, the same for the said purpose rule 2(iii)(a)&(b) of the rules of 1951: rule 2(iii)(a) to all persons appointed to such posts or services on the basis of contracts entered into by the Government Rajasthan or by the Government of a Covenanting State in respect of such matters covered by these Rules as are not specially provided for in their contracts for appointment. (b) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub clause (a) these rules shall also apply to the persons initially appointed to such posts or services on the basis of contracts entered into but subsequently appointed in regular manner in respect of counting of contract service as qualifying service for the purpose of pension. The contracts service followed by regular appointment shall count as qualifying service for the purpose of pension if no contribution towards Contributory Provident Fund for the period of contract service has been paid by the Government. In cases where contribution towards Contributory Provident Fund has been paid by the Government, contract service would count for the purpose of pension if the concerned employee deposits in the general revenues (3 of 5) [CW-45/2014] of the State, the entire amount of contributions paid by the Government together with interest thereon @7% per annum for the period from the date of payment of contribution to the date of deposit in the general revenues of the State. Provided that persons of the category specified in clause (ii) may, within two months of the commencement of these Rules or of their appointment as a result of the said integration, whichever may be later, apply for retirement and shall be granted pension or gratuity in accordance with the rules by which they were governed previously to such commencement or appointment :
4. The said provisions were inserted pay benefit on 11.3.1958. For the purpose of employees who were appointed in the State Government on contract basis or otherwise and regularized later. So far as the petitioner is concerned from the service book. It is seen that he was appointed on substantive basis and on fixed salary and thereafter placed in the pay scale after clearing the examination in 1955. Thus the entire period of service from 1.9.52 was required to be counted for the purpose of pension. As per the decision of the Government for 1951 as quoted above.
5. In view thereof, the period of service from 1.9.1952 till 1.10.1955 could not have been discounted and the petitioner could not have been denied the benefit of the said period for the purpose of qualifying service for fixation of pension. Accordingly, the said period is directed to be counted for the purpose.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents has relied upon the judgment passed in the case of State of Rajasthan Vs. Jagdish Narayan:AIR2010SCC157.
7. I have considered the submission of the learned counsel. The Judgment as cited (supra) was relating to grant of selection scale (4 of 5) [CW-45/2014] and the counting period of service in terms of selection scale circular. It has been stated in the judgment that the period shall be calculated only after regular selection for the purpose of counting 9, 18 & 27 years of service. However, the said judgment has no application to the facts of the present dispute which has been raised by the learned counsel on petitioner where the question is regarding counting of service for the purpose of qualifying service of pension.
8. Admittedly, the Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1965 have come into force and Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 also came into force on their promulgation in the year 1965 & 1963. In the year 1952, when the petitioner was appointed against his substantive post, he was appointed under the Rajasthan Service Rules, 1951 alone without there being any specific Rules of Medical & Health Department. Thus the regular service defined under the Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1965 would not relate to the service of employee appointment prior to 1965.
9. In terms of provision contained under the Rajasthan Service Rules, hereinabove decision was taken by the State Government, 1958 itself to count ad-hoc/contractual period of service whereafter regular appointment, as given was to be included as qualifying service of pension hence, there remains no manner of doubt not to include the period rendered by the petitioner from 1.9.1952 till 1.10.1955 as period eligible for counting qualifying service for pension.
10. Accordingly the writ petition is allowed. (5 of 5) [CW-45/2014]
11. The respondents are directed to revise the pension of the petitioner and other retiral benefit and grant to petitioner all the retiral benefits by counting period of service from 1.9.1952 continuously and qualifying service and release the arrears after calculating the same within a period of three months hence forth alongwith the interest @ 9% per annum gratuity and other benefits to which the petitioner would entitled by counting the said period, service shall also be recalculated and release as above.
12. No costs. (SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA)J. Anu/83