Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • section 378(1)(111) Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • section 378(1)(111) Cr.P.C

    STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. HJ KLEIN

    Judgment 12/09/2017 State of Rajasthan has preferred criminal appeal 2under section 378(1)(111) Cr.P.C against the judgment of acquittal of accused H.J. Clien and in cross injured Sunil Kumar Jain has filed criminal revision petition against the judgment of acquittal praying therein to quash and set aside the judgment dated 4.5.1988 passed by learned Add. Chief Judicial Magistrate No.1, Alwar (the learned trial court for short) in Criminal Case No. 146/1987 and convict the accused suitably for the offences of which he has been charged. Both-

    Judgment 12/09/2017 State of Rajasthan has preferred criminal appeal 2under section 378(1)(111) Cr.P.C against the judgment of acquittal of accused H.J. Clien and in cross injured Sunil Kumar Jain has filed criminal revision petition against the judgment of acquittal praying therein to quash and set aside the judgment dated 4.5.1988 passed by learned Add. Chief Judicial Magistrate No.1, Alwar (the learned trial court for short) in Criminal Case No. 146/1987 and convict the accused suitably for the offences of which he has been charged. Both- i.e criminal appeal and the criminal revision petition arise out of common Judgment and facts in both the matters are identical, hence same are being decided by this common Judgment. Brief facts of the case are that one Dinesh s/o Ramkishan Arora, aged 26 years, r/o Dhakpuri Mohalla, Alwar, gave a Parcha-bayan (Ex.P10) on 3.11.1986 at Surgical Ward, General Hospital, Alwar, which was recorded by Mr. Narendra Singh, ASI, to this effect that today he, Jairaj and Sunil were going on a Scooter towards Moti Doongari. Jairaj was driving his Scooter bearing RRA-5883 and they were coming towards Stadium. When they reached near 3Moti Doongari Road then one Jeep came, which was being driven in a rash and negligent manner, towards S.M.D Chauraha. The said jeep hit their Scooter. He was sitting in the mid of the Scooter as a pillion rider, Sunil was sitting in the last of the Scooter also as a pillion rider. One foreigner hit their scooter from the Jeep and he took them in the hospital. Jairaj died on the spot and he and Sunil became injured. Complainant further mentioned that the jeep which hit them is bearing number RRA-3003 and the driver of the Jeep was foreigner. On the basis of the aforesaid Parcha-bayan, an FIR No. 615/1986 (Ex.P11) was got registered at Police Station Kotwali Alwar, District Alwar for the offence under sections 279, 338 and 304A IPC. Dinesh died during the course of treatment in S.M.S. Hospital, Jaipur. After investigation the police submitted charge- sheet against the accused. The learned trial court framed the charges against the accused on 29.1.1987 under sections 279, 4337, 338 and 304A IPC which was read over in sum and substance to him. The accused denied the charges and claimed to be tried. The prosecution in support of its case produced

    14 witnesses and got exhibited documents. The accused in support of his case produced one witness. The learned trial court after hearing learned APP appearing for the State and counsel for the accused acquitted the accused vide judgment dated 4.5.1988 for the offences punishable under sections 304A, 337,

    338 and 279 IPC by giving him benefit of doubt. Against the impugned judgment of acquittal the State has filed appeal and injured Sunil Kumar Jain filed criminal revision for quashing and setting aside the Judgment of acquittal and convicting the accused of the offences of which he has been charged. Hence, instant criminal appeal and criminal revision petition before this Court. Facts of S.B Criminal Appeal No. 402/1988: Learned PP appearing for the State has 5submitted that the learned trial court while passing the impugned judgment of acquittal has failed to consider that there was sufficient evidence available on record relating to accident occurred from the Jeep which the accused was driving. Learned PP submitted that the learned trial court erred in acquitting the accused only on the basis of slight contradictions of statements of the prosecution witnesses. Learned PP further submitted that the learned trial court has failed to consider that after the accident, the jeep stopped

    20 ft. ahead from which it is proved that the speed of the jeep was very high and same was beyond the control of accused (driver). Learned PP also submitted that if the Jeep would have been in the control of accused (driver) then same would have stopped immediately. Thus it is clear that the accused was driving the jeep rashly and negligently. On 19.9.1988 this Court issued notice to the accused but from the case file it reveals that the service of notice has not been effected upon the accused. 6Facts of Criminal Revision Petition No. 402/1988: Mr. R.K. Mathur, Sr. Advocate assisted by Mr. Aditya Mathur appearing for injured Sunil Kumar Jain has submitted that the learned trial court has committed serious illegality in not considering the site plan. From the site plan it is clear that at the time of accident the accused was coming from wrong side and the accident was taken place on the side in which the Scooter was proceeding. Thus it is clear that the accused was driving the jeep rashly and negligently. Sr. Counsel submitted that the learned trial court committed serious illegality in disbelieving the statements of PW9-Narendra Singh and PW12-Sunil Kumar Jain and holding that there are contradictions in between the statements of PW12-Sunil Kumar Jain and deceased Dineshs statement (Ex.P10). Sr. Counsel submitted that there is no basic difference between the statement of PW10-Madan Lal Bhargava and Parcha-bayan (Ex.P10). Sr. counsel further submitted that the learned trial court committed serious illegality by holding that the prosecution has 7not succeeded in proving rash and negligent driving of the accused. Sr. Counsel also submitted that the finding given by the learned trial court in para No. 15 of the Judgment that the jeep was not driven rashly and negligently is absolutely absurd and perverse. Sr. Counsel further submitted that the learned trial court has committed serious illegality by giving benefit of doubt to the accused on the count that identification parade was not conducted. Heard learned PP appearing for the State and learned counsel appearing for the injured, perused the impugned judgment and also gone through the record of the case. As per the evidence available on record, it isan admitted fact that three persons namely; Jairam, Dinesh and Suresh were on the Scooter. Dinesh (deceased) in his Parcha-bayan (Ex.P10) has specifically stated that when Jairaj was driving the scooter, in the mid Dinesh was sitting as pillion rider and in last Sunil was also sitting as a pillion rider. PW9 Narendra Singh, ASI, in his cross-examination has 8specifically stated that Jairaj who was driving the scooter was not having any licence for driving light motor vehicle. It is an admitted fact the Scooter is a two seator vehicle. As per Parcha-bayan (Ex.P10) and FIR (Ex.P11) the alleged accident taken place at 11:30 P.M. Thus it is clear that there was a dark night when the alleged accident took place. If someone comes on a vehicle from the front side and the light of that vehicle is on, due to rays of light the person coming from other side will not be in a position to see properly and the visibility of such person driving the vehicle shall be very dim. Site inspection report is Ex.P4. In Ex.P4 there is a note that on the spot the accidented jeep and scooter are standing in dashed condition. PW5-Bachhu Singh who was on the spot told that he went on the spot at 10:00 and on the spot the jeep and scooter were standing in dashed condition. As per statement of PW6-Rakesh, the Scooter was standing in damaged condition 4-5 ahead to the jeep. Thus, it is clear that 9at that time on the spot it was not the position, which is clear from Ex.P14. PW9-Narendra Singh, I.O in his statement has stated that he reached on the spot at 6:30 A.M and then he prepared the site inspection report (Ex.P4). This witness in his statement has stated that at 6:30 AM the position was that the Scooter and jeep were standing in dashed condition and as per the statement of PW5-Bachhu Singh and PW6- Rakesh, the jeep and scooter were standing at some distance. PW10- Madan Lal in his statement has stated that when he reached on the spot at 8-8:30 then he found that the scooter was entangled in the jeep. Both the contrary statements cannot be true together. Site inspection report (Ex.P4) has not been corroborated by any other evidence. From the evidence of the prosecution witnesses it is not clear that the accused was driving the jeep rashly and negligently and no-one has identified that the said jeep was being driven by accused. Unless there is any evidence regarding driving of the jeep by accused rashly and negligently, the accused cannot be convicted and sentenced for the offence punishable under section 304-A IPC. The settled position of law is that in every case evidence cannot be re-appreciated and the High Court will not re-appreciate evidence and come to its own conclusion on the same when the evidence has already been appreciated by the learned trial court unless any glaring feature is brought to the notice of the High Court which would otherwise tantamount to gross miscarriage of justice. In the case in hand no such glaring feature has been pointed out by the learned PP as discussed above. The aforesaid view has been taken by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in S.B Criminal Revision Petition No. 70/1999, Bhagirath Singh Vs. State of Rajasthan, decided on 5.4.1999. In the case in hand the eye-witness of the alleged accident/ incident is PW12 Sunil Kumar who also received injury in the said accident. This witness in his examination-in-chief has stated that जीप ने टक्कर स्कुटर के मारी जिससे स्कुटर को जीप बीस फुट तक खेंचकर ले गई .....This witness in his cross-examination has stated that ---मैं टक्कर होने पर स्कुटर के साथ ही था। जयराज दूर जाकर गिर गया था। दिनेा व मैं स्कुटर के साथ ही थे ...... जीप के नीचे स्कूटर आया था..... The prosecution got recorded the statement of Madan Lal Bhargava as PW10, who at the time of alleged accident was posted as Incharge of M.B.O., C.I.D and Police Photographer, S.P. Office, Alwar. This witness in his statement has stated that स्कूटर जीप के आगे आधा अंदर घुसा हुआ था। इनके फोटो एक्जी.पी. 13 से 15 उसने लिए थे। उसके 7-1/2-8 बजे सुबह बुलाया गया था। वह 10-15 मिनट में वहाॅ पहुंच गया। मौके पर एक काॅन्सटेबल खडा था जो घटनास्थल की सुरक्षा के लिए खडा था। एक्जी. 14 व 15 फोटोज को देखकर बताया कि स्कूटर चलाने वाला व उसके पीछे बैठने वाला भी अंदर दबा होना चाहिए ........ यह सही है कि एक्सीडेन्ट जिस हालत में हुआ उस हालत में आदमी को निकालने के लिए स्कूटर को निकालकर आदमी को निकालना होगा। स्कूटर के दोनों पहिए जीप के दोनों अगले पहियों से भिडे हुए है और स्कूटर अंदर घुसा हुआ है।

    Thus, if the statement of PW12 Sunil Kumar Jain is taken into consideration in the light of statement of Madan Lal Bhargava (PW10) then it is wrong that due to accident only Sunil Kumar Jain (PW12) and Dinesh came under the jeep. From the overall statements of the aforesaid witnesses it is clear that only scooter came under the jeep. From a bare perusal of statement of PW12 Sunil Kumar it is clear that there are material contradictions in his statement and the statement of this witness is not reliable and trustworthy. The statements of other prosecutions witnesses are formal in nature, therefore it is not necessary for this Court to discuss the same. It is mandatory on the part of the prosecution to establish and prove the criminal culpability beyond reasonable doubt to fasten guilt but the afore- discussed evidence reflects that prosecution has miserably failed to adduce material and reliable evidence against the respondent. Nothing is positive in the evidence of the prosecution to connect the accused with the alleged crime. The Supreme Court has laid down that finding of acquittal may not be disturbed and the High Court should be slow in disturbing the same. In the case of Sukliya Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in (2010) 16 SCC 745, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held as under :-

    6. The settled position of law regarding the powers to be exercised by the High Court in an appeal against the order of acquittal is that though the High Court has full powers to review the evidence upon which an order of acquittal is based, it will not interfere with an order of acquittal because with the passing of an order of acquittal the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused is reinforced. The High Court should be slow in disturbing the finding of the fact arrived at by the trial court. The golden thread which runs through the web of administration of justice in criminal case is that if two views are possible on the evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the guilt of the accused and the other therefore his innocence, the view which is favourable to the accused should be adopted.

    21. In Narendra Singh and Another v. State of M.P., (2004) 10 SCC 699, the Apex Court has recognized presumption of innocence as a human right and has gone on to say that:

    30. It is now well settled that benefit of doubt belonged to the accused. It is further trite that suspicion, however grave may be, cannot take place of a proof. It is equally well settled that there is a long distance between may be and must be.

    31. It is also well known that even in a case where a plea of alibi is raised, the burden of proof remains on the prosecution. Presumption of innocence is a human right. Such presumption gets stronger when a judgment of acquittal is passed. This Court in a number of decisions has set out the legal principle for reversing the judgment of acquittal by a Higher Court (see Dhanna v. State of M.P., Mahabir Singh v. State of Haryana and Shailendra Pratap v. State of U.P.) which had not been adhered to by the High Court. Xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx

    33. We, thus, having regard to the post- mortem report, are of the opinion that the cause of death of Bimla Bai although is shrouded in mistery but benefit thereof must go to the appellants as in the event of there being two possible views, the one supporting the accused should be upheld. The decision taken by this Court in the aforementioned case, has been further reiterated in State Of Rajasthan v. Raja Ram, (2003) 8 SCC 180, wherein this Court observed thus: Generally the order of acquittal shall not be interfered with because the presumption of innocence of the accused is further strengthened by acquittal. The golden thread which runs through the web of administration of justice in criminal cases is that if two views are possible on the evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the guilt of the accused and the other to his innocence, the view which is favourable to the accused should be adopted. The paramount consideration of the Court is to ensure that miscarriage of justice is prevented. A miscarriage of justice which may arise from acquittal of the guilty is no less than from the conviction of an innocent. In a case where admissible evidence is ignored, a duty is cast upon the appellate court to reappreciate the evidence in a case where the accused has been acquitted, or the purpose of ascertaining as to whether any of the accused committed any offence or not. The principle to be followed by the appellate court considering the appeal against the judgment of acquittal is to interfere only when there are compelling and substantial reasons for doing so. If the impugned judgment is clearly unreasonable, it is a compelling reason for interference. In the aforesaid scenario, I am of the considered view that prosecution has not succeeded in establishing its case beyond contours of reasonable doubt, so I do not find any reason to disturb the findings of the trial court. Therefore, the criminal appeal filed by the State and the criminal revision petition filed by injured Sunil Kumar Jain are devoid of any merit, hence the same are dismissed. Let record of the trial court be transmitted back immediately with a copy of the judgment. (GOVERDHAN BARDHAR),J. Sharma NK

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. HJ KLEIN
    (Sep 12, 2017)