1. In the state of the evidence, particularly upon a sister of the victim being an eye-witness, the appellant has urged only one ground: that the act complained should fall within the fourth Exception to Section 300 of the Penal Code and he should have been given a lesser sentence under Section 304 Part II of the Code.
2. The incident occurred on the night of November 1, 1997. The father complained the next day that his son-in-law had come a few days back to the house of the complainant and on the night of November 1, 1997, the son-in-law quarreled with the daughter of the complainant. The complaint also referred to the appellant finding a katari in the room and killing his wife with the same.
3. The younger sister of the victim, who was about 11 years old at the time of the occurrence, deposed in course of the trial held in 2003 that the appellant had taken great umbrage at his wife going to attend a ‘kirtan’. According to such witness, the wife returned after the kirtan gave over at about 2.30 am. There was a loud altercation between the husband and wife and the witness claimed that she tried to separate the two but the appellant went into a fit of rage, took up a katari that was lying around and swung it at the neck of the victim, killing her. The witness also recounted that the appellant asked her to keep quiet before he escaped. At the time that the appellant was fleeing, the younger sister of the victim raised an alarm that drew the neighbours to the house.
4. It is evident that there was a quarrel between the husband and the wife over what may have been a trivial issue. It does not appear that the appellant herein had premeditated the murder of his wife or had prepared any plan therefor. The katari, according to both the father and the sister of the victim, just happened to be lying in the room; which the appellant picked up in a fit of rage and swung at his wife and caused her death. It does not appear that the appellant, apart from the getting into an altercation with his wife for the minor matter of her attending a kirtan, otherwise acted cruelly or in an unusual manner or attempted to take undue advantage of the situation. It was accidental that the appellant found a katari within his reach and not any other implement. It is evident that the appellant went into a fit of rage and, in the heat of passion, committed the offence without any premeditation and without otherwise taking undue advantage of the situation or acting cruelly or in an unusual manner.
5. The trial court should have given the appellant the benefit under the fourth Exception to Section 300 of the Penal Code and, as a consequence, awarded a lesser sentence under the second part of Section 304 thereof. Since the appellant is in a correctional home from or about 2005, when he was sentenced under Section 302 of the Penal Code, it is evident that the appellant has served out in excess of the period covered by the maximum sentence that ought to have been imposed on him in the circumstances.
6. CRA 421 of 2009 is disposed of by modifying the order of conviction from a conviction under Section 302 of the Code to one under the second part of Section 304 thereof. The fine imposed on the appellant is set aside. The sentence is reduced to the maximum punishment under the second part of Section 304 of the Penal Code. As a consequence, the appellant should be regarded to have served out the maximum sentence and entitled to be set at liberty immediately.
7. Let copies of this order be forwarded immediately to the appellant and the correctional home where he is lodged. Let the lower court records along with a copy of this order be sent down forthwith with a direction to the trial court to take immediate appropriate steps in accordance with law.