Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India v. State Of Gujarat

    COMMON ORAL JUDGMENT

    1. The appellant - original plaintiff has filed this Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code challenging the judgment and decree dated 23.04.2008 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court No. 1, Bhuj - Kutch in Regular Civil Appeal No. 11 of 2006 whereby the appeal filed by the appellant challenging the judgment and decree dated 03.02.2006 passed by the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge, Bhuj - Kutch in Special Civil Suit No. 99 of 2002 has been confirmed.

    2. The brief facts giving rise to the present second appeal as set out in the memo of appeal are that out of the total area of old Survey No. 898 at Bhuj (new Survey No. 359) admeasuring about 9 Acres 24 Gunthas, there was establishment of the old Bhuj Railway station and station yard on 2 Acres 22 Gunthas land of old Survey No. 898 of Bhuj (new Survey No. 359) since inception of the then Princely State ruling at Bhuj (i.e prior to independence). The remaining land admeasuring about 7 Acres 2 Gunthas of old Survey No. 898 was acquired by railway between 1951 to 1955 for conversion of narrow gauge line into meter gauge line and due to requirement of expansion of the railway. Thus, by the year 1955, all the land area i.e 9 Acres 24 Gunthas of old Survey No. 898 (new Survey No. 359) was being owned, occupied, possessed and utilized by the railway administration. The ownership, possession and use of all the land of the old Survey No. 898 continued by the appellant till the formation of the new Bhuj station in the year 1990 and even thereafter. The railway tracks were passing through the other land in dispute. As the new railway station and Station Yard have been constructed, the land of the old Bhuj Railway station and Station Yard had become out of use and was lying vacant/open. Taking advantage of this situation, some private parties had centered their eyes on the said land of the railway.

    3. As per the past record, all the land of old Survey No. 898 (new Survey No. 359) admeasuring about 9 Acres 24 Gunthas was shown in the name of the railway till the year 2000. The said position reflects from the jungle book, 7/12 extracts and other revenue records. The said position also gets established from the maps prepared by the railway administration and the State authorities jointly after actual measurement of the railway land and the said maps have been certified, sealed and signed by the authorities. The said maps are showing and demarcating the railway land by the specified railway land boundaries of respective period. These documents make it clear that the land of old Survey No. 898 is vested in the railway. The overall position of the land also shows that there was establishment of railway tracks over the land in question.

    4. Till the year 1996, there was no claim or dispute from anybody qua their rights, possession or title qua the land in dispute i.e 2 Acres 22 Gunthas of old Survey No. 898 (new Survey No. 359) and first time, one Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar had issued a letter and notice through his advocate requesting the railway administration to return the land contending that due to shifting of railway station and Station Yard, the railway land has become surplus, which may be given to him. His demand was declined by the railway administration vide letter dated 28.10.1996 Thereafter, Mr. Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar had by changing his stand, filed Case No. 01 of 1997 before the Deputy Collector, under Section 37(2) of the Bombay Land Revenue Code. Ultimately, order dated 31.07.2000 came to be passed giving the finding that the railway has not been able to produce the evidence qua the land claimed by Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar and the said piece of land belongs to the said Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar. While passing the said order, Land acquisition notifications of the year 1952 & 1955 had been taken into consideration, in which it was revealed that 7 Acres 02 Gunthas land of old Survey No. 898 was covered by Kutch Government Gazette of the year 1955. While coming to the conclusion, the Deputy Collector had not considered the fact that the said piece of land 2 Acres 22 Gunthas of the old Survey No. 898 was in the hands of railway even for the period prior to 1950 and there was the establishment of railway in the said land even as on 1950.

    5. Being aggrieved by the said order dated 31.07.2000 passed by the Deputy Collector, the railway administration filed Special Civil Application No. 3411 of 2002 before this Court and the said petition came to be withdrawn on 08.07.2002 with a view to avail the alternative remedy. The appellant thereafter filed an appeal before the Gujarat Revenue Tribunal on 25.07.2002 challenging the order passed by the Deputy Collector and the said appeal, after considering the legal fiction, was decided by an order dated 21.03.2003 The appeal was thereafter filed before the Collector with delay condonation application. The same was decided against the railway administration. The railway administration thereafter filed review application before the Collector and during the pendency of the said review application, the appellant filed Special Civil Application No. 10 of 2005 seeking direction against the Collector to decide the said review application. Pending the said petition, the Collector passed an order in review application which came to be challenged in the pending petition being Special Civil Application No. 10 of 2005. The said petition was ultimately dismissed by this Court. The said order was challenged in Letters Patent Appeal No. 856 of 2006 which came to be dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court vide its order dated 18.01.2007 with observation that Appeal No. 11 of 2006 shall be disposed of on its own merits without being influenced by the outcome of the said Letters Patent Appeal.

    6. During the pendency of the proceedings before the revenue authorities, the original defendants No. 3 & 4 - Shri Govindbhai Ukabhai Patel and Khengarji Lakhdirsinh Jadeja had committed criminal trespass in the land of the railway admeasuring 2 Acre 22 Gunthas of old Survey No. 898 (new Survey No. 359) on 01.08.2000 and had got the sale deed dated 10.01.2001 executed with Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar. The appellant therefore filed Special Civil Suit No. 99 of 2002 on the ground that the land bearing old Survey No. 898 belongs to railway administration and the defendants No. 3 & 4 have encroached upon the part of the said land by committing forcible tress-pass and have made unauthorized construction. The appellant has also made a prayer in the said suit for declaring the alleged sale deed executed in favour of the original defendants No. 3 & 4 by Mr. Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar.

    7. After considering the evidence led by both the parties and after considering their submissions, the Trial Court has passed a judgment and decree dated 03.02.2006 and thereby the suit came to be dismissed. The appellant preferred Regular Civil Appeal against the said judgment and decree before the District Court at Bhuj and upon hearing both the sides, vide judgment and decree dated 23.04.2008, the said appeal was dismissed by the learned Additional District Judge.

    8. Apart from the above proceedings, certain other proceedings were also initiated by the parties before this Court. In Special Civil Application No. 17582 of 2003, by an order dated 16.12.2003, this Court had directed the trial Court to decide Special Civil Suit No. 99 of 2002 as expeditiously as possible. In Special Civil Application No. 09 of 2005 filed by the appellant on the point of framing of issues, initially, stay was granted and continued and at the time of dismissal of the said petition, no further direction was issued to complete the proceedings of the suit.

    9. In the above premises, the appellant has submitted that the appeal deserves to be admitted and suggested to frame the following substantial questions of law:-

    i. Whether the land already in the hands of railway administration due to merger of State Railways could have been the subject matter of acquisition in the Notification under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act?

    ii. Whether the learned Trial Court and the first Appellate Court have erred in not considering and examining the position prior to 1955, particularly when it was a contention that the land in question derived to the appellant on merger of Princely State Railways into Indian Railways?

    iii. Whether the learned Trial Court and the First Appellate Court have erred in not considering the provisions of Works Manual and Engineering Code as well as the provisions of Article 295 of the Constitution of India particularly when the issue was raised by the appellant and further for testing validity of maps of the railway produced by the appellant?

    iv. Considering the oral and documentary evidence submitted by the appellant, whether it can be said that the appellant is not in a position to produce the necessary documentary evidence to substantiate the stand?

    v. Whether the learned Trial Court and the First Appellate Court has erred in not considering the provisions governing the railway's land and aspect with regard to the validity of the maps prepared thereunder with regard to railway's land?

    vi. Whether the learned Trial Court and the First Appellate Court have erred in not dealing with and giving reasons on the issues raised and arguments made on different points and the judgments under challenge are unreasoned orders in absence of discussion and reasoning on various points raised?

    vii. Whether not granting the application for amendment and Panchnama etc. would affect the final outcome of the proceedings, particularly, when it was necessary to bring the correct facts before the Hon'ble Courts?

    viii. Whether the learned Trial Court and the Hon'ble First Appellate Court erred in not considering application of original owner as well as the complaint of third party leading to the fact that the land in question was of land in possession of the appellant?

    ix. Whether the learned Trial Court and the First Appellate Court have erred in not considering the fact that respondent Nos. 3 & 4 have not lead any evidence with regard to the position and possession of the land in question prior to the year 2001, more particularly, when there was no evidence produced by the respondent Nos. 3 & 4, about the land in possession of the original owner in past and on the other hand, railway administration has produced the documentary evidence of the possession of the land in question?

    x. Whether the respondent Nos. 3 & 4 could have taken over the possession of the land in question by tress-passing and disturbing the possession of the appellant of the land in question and whether the issue with regard to the possession of the land in question prior to the year 2001 and the right vested in the appellant for consistent possession for long period since 1950 onwards has remained unconsidered?

    xi. Whether the order of the First Appellate Court is unreasoned order qua the points raised and agitated in the appeal?

    10. Mr. Mukesh A. Patel, learned advocate appearing for the appellant, based on the above facts and keeping in mind the substantial questions of law suggested to be framed, has further pointed out that the appellant has filed application for directing the State Government authorities to produce the record which came to be declined as the respondent Nos. 3 & 4 have objected to the same. The appellant has also filed application for joining third party as defendant. The same also came to be rejected. The appellant thereafter filed another application for joining Bakali Jusab as defendant in the suit. The same was also rejected. The application for appointment of Commissioner and drawing the Panchnama and preparation of map of railway land was filed by the plaintiff which also came to be rejected. Mr. Patel has further submitted that even the First Appellate Court has failed to appreciate that the land in dispute belongs to the railway administration and the defendants No. 3 & 4 have committed criminal tress-pass and encroachment over the land in dispute. Hence, the sale deed executed on 19.01.2001 in their favour is absolutely null and void. Both the Courts below have not properly considered or appreciated the complete evidence, oral as well as written submissions/arguments made by the plaintiff. Thus, the impugned judgment and orders are without due consideration and appreciation of evidence as well as provisions of law and are in violation of the principles of natural justice. Both the Courts below have not believed the possession of the appellant only on the ground that there was no reference of the land in question in the land acquisition notifications of 1955. He has submitted that when the land in question had been derived from the then Princely State railway, on the basis of the oral evidence as well as documentary evidence produced by the appellant, the possession and ownership of the land in question of the plaintiff ought to have been believed. He has further submitted that the important evidence in the form of three maps produced by the appellant clearly show the railway land boundary and establishment over the land. Thus, maps are prepared by the competent authorities after due measurement of railway land and that too in the presence of the railway authorities. He has, therefore, submitted that such important piece of evidence should not have been brushed aside by the Courts below. He has, therefore, strongly urged before the Court that the appeal deserves to be admitted and the questions of law suggested by the appellant are required to be formulated for consideration and determination of this Court.

    11. Mr. Patel, in support of his submission that this Court in exercise of its appellate jurisdiction under Section 100 can interfere with the orders and judgments passed by the Courts below in certain circumstances, has relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dilbagrai Punjabi v. Sharad Chandra, 1988 (Supp) SCC 710 wherein it is held that the High Court can reverse concurrent findings of fact in Second Appeal on failure of Courts below to consider important and relevant evidence. He further relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State Of Rajasthan v. Harphool Singh (Dead) Through His Lrs) through his Lrs, (2000) 5 SCC 652 wherein it is held that the findings based on surmises and conjectures and also perverse findings not based on legally acceptable evidence and which are patently contrary to law declared by Hon'ble Supreme Court, cannot have any impunity from interference in the hands of the appellate authority.

    12. Mr. Patel further relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of P. Chandrasekharan v. S. Kanakarajan, (2007) 5 SCC 669 wherein it is held that the interpretation of a document which goes to the root of the title of the property, gives rise to a substantial question of law and hence, the Courts below having misread and misinterpreted a document of title read with other documents and the identification plan of the suit lands, the High Court was justified in interfering in the second appeal.

    13. Mr. Mihir Joshi, learned Senior advocate appearing with Mr. Vimal Patel for the respondent Nos. 3 & 4 - original defendants No. 3 & 4 has submitted that there is concurrent finding of fact of both the Courts below. Not only this, in several other proceedings, this Court has consistently held that the appellant/original plaintiff had no evidence whatsoever to establish that the appellant had any right over the land of 2 Acres 22 Gunthas. Different opportunities were given to the appellant to produce necessary evidence showing that the said land belongs to them. The appellant has, however, failed to produce this evidence and accordingly, this Court has dismissed the writ petitions filed by the appellant. He has further submitted that the suit as well as the appeal both came to be dismissed inter alia on the ground that the appellant failed to produce any evidence worth its name to establish that the land belongs to the appellant. In this view of the matter, he has strongly urged that the concurrent finding of fact given by the Courts below should not have been disturbed by entertaining the present Second Appeal. He has further submitted that when this Court has already taken the view in the allied proceedings that the plaintiff has no evidence whatsoever to establish the fact regarding its ownership over the disputed land, there is no question of deciding the issue in favour of the appellant. This Court should, therefore, follow the view taken by this Court in earlier allied proceedings. Lastly, he has submitted that the finding given by the Courts below is a finding of fact and no question of law, much less, any substantial question of law is involved and hence, all the questions suggested by the appellant are based on mere appreciation of evidence which can never be said to be substantial questions of law. He has, therefore, submitted that the appeal deserves to be dismissed at the very threshold.

    14. Having heard learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and having gone through the impugned orders and judgments passed by the Courts below and having considered the documents produced before this Court by way of separate compilation and also along with the appeal memo, this Court is of the view that both the Courts below have come to the just and proper conclusion after appreciation of all the documents and evidence placed before them and the impugned orders do not require any interference by this Court while exercising its appellate jurisdiction in second appeal preferred by the appellant under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Apart from the present civil litigation, the revenue proceedings were initiated in respect of the land in question and all the authorities have decided the issue in favour of the private respondents and against the appellant - railway authority. Orders were challenged before this Court in separate proceedings and this Court had also come to the conclusion that in absence of any evidence showing that the petitioner has acquired the land in question or that the petitioner is the owner of the said land, it cannot be held that the said piece of land does not belong to one Mr. Bakali Jusab @ Budha Umar. The revenue authorities while arriving at this finding have considered the land acquisition Notifications of the year 1952 & 1955 wherein it was clearly revealed that only 7 Acres and 2 Gunthas of land of old Survey No. 898 was covered by the Kutch Government Gazette of the year 1955. Nothing has come on record to show that 2 Acres and 22 Gunthas of old Survey No. 898 was in the hands of railway even for the period prior to 1950. All throughout, it was the case of the private respondents that the land bearing Survey No. 898 admeasuring about 9 Acres and 24 Gunthas, out of which only 7 Acres and 2 Gunthas land was acquired for railways. Hence, the remaining 2 Acres and 22 Gunthas land continue to belong to the original owners or their successors in title. This Court in its order dated 31.08.2005 in Special Civil Application No. 10 of 2005 has clearly held that considering the facts and circumstances of the case, inspite of remanding the matter to the Collector for his decision afresh, this Court called upon the petitioners to satisfy this Court on merits and to produce any record available with them with regard to acquisition of the land in question. However, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners in that matter has fairly conceded that they are not in a position to produce any record showing the acquisition of the land in question. In that view of the matter, the contention on behalf of the petitioner that the land in question came to be acquired for the benefit of the petitioners cannot be accepted in absence of any other documentary evidences on record. The Court further observed that the Deputy Collector on appreciation of evidence in a proceedings under Section 37(2) of the Bombay Land Revenue Code and after holding necessary inquiry and giving opportunity to all the concerned parties, had specifically held that the concerned respondents are the owners of the land in question. In this view of the matter, the Court held that there was no substance in the said Special Civil Application and even on merits, the petitioners have failed to establish their case as they did not have any documentary evidence to show that the land in question came to be acquired for the benefit of the petitioners. Even Letters Patent Appeal filed against the said judgment and order of the Learned Single Judge being Letters Patent Appeal No. 856 of 2006 was dismissed by this Court on 18.01.2007

    15. While going through the order passed by the Additional District Judge, it appears that he had come to the conclusion, after considering the documentary evidence produced by both the parties, that certain land was acquired for the purpose of railway in the year 1955 which consists of land bearing Revenue Survey No. 897, 898, 899, 900, 930, 931 and 933 of Bhuj. The land bearing Survey No. 898 was admeasuring about 9 Acres and 24 Gunthas and out of which, only 7 Acres and 2 Guntha's land was acquired under the notification. The documentary evidence revealed that the proceedings had been conducted before the Deputy Collector, Bhuj in respect of the land admeasuring 2 Acres and 22 Gunthas as per Case No. 1 of 1997. The learned Deputy Collector, after due inquiry, has come to the conclusion that the said land belongs to the private respondents. The said order of the Deputy Collector has been challenged by the petitioners before this Court and those proceedings were ultimately confirmed by this Court. The petitioner has heavily relied on the maps prepared by the railway authority which are nothing but a worksheet. On consideration of this documentary evidence coupled with the oral evidence, the learned Additional District Judge had come to the conclusion that the witnesses examined on behalf of the petitioners' side have no personal knowledge as to the actual ownership of the suit land. They have heavily relied on the railway maps which are not prepared in presence of the defendants. On behalf of the petitioner, no documentary evidence worth its name was produced except the copies of map, to show that the suit land was ever acquired by the railway administration or by the State Government from the original owner and handed over to the railway administration. It was for the petitioner to produce necessary documentary evidence to show that prior to 1955, the disputed land of 2 Acres and 22 Gunthas was acquired by the railway administration or by the State Government or by the then Princely State. No documentary evidence has been produced by the petitioners, whereas as per the notification of 1955, only 7 Acres and 22 Gunthas of land of old Survey No. 898 was acquired for the railway administration and handed over to it. The learned District Judge has, therefore, came to the conclusion that there was no iota of any documentary evidence to show that the land in question was ever acquired by the railway and possession thereof was ever handed over to the petitioner.

    16. The learned District Judge has further observed in the impugned judgment that on considering the entire facts and circumstances coupled with the oral and documentary evidence, it is clearly found that the petitioner is unable to prove the issues, the burden of which lies on the petitioner by leading cogent documentary evidence. The learned District Judge has further observed that while disposing of Letters Patent Appeal No. 856 of 2006 dated 18.01.2007, this Court has observed that the said appeal which was pending before him being Appeal No. 11 of 2006 shall be disposed of on its own merits without being influenced by the outcome of the Letters Patent Appeal. The learned District Judge has, therefore, held that the petitioner is not in a position to produce necessary documentary evidence to substantiate its stand that the land in question was in its possession as owner due to acquisition of the land prior to 1955. It is, therefore, held that when the petitioner has miserably failed to prove the point of acquisition of entire land of Survey No. 898 (old) new 359 and its exclusive possession and the facts of tress-pass by the private respondents, on the said land, no decree could be passed in favour of the petitioner. The learned District Judge has, therefore, held that the Trial Court has considered the entire evidence on record in its proper perspective and has not committed any error of facts or law which requires interference by the appellate Court. This Court is also of the same view and since, not only the Trial Court but Appellate Court has also taken into consideration the entire facts and circumstances of the case as well as after due and careful appreciation of the documentary evidence as well as oral evidence, both the Courts have come to a correct view which cannot be interfered with by this Court while exercising its appellate jurisdiction in second appeal preferred under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The judgments relied upon by Mr. Patel do not render any assistance to the appellant as in the present case, no documentary evidence has been produced and hence, there is no question of failure of Courts below to consider important and relevant evidence. The finding given by the Courts below cannot be said to be the findings based on surmises and conjectures or it is not a perverse finding based on illegal acceptable evidence. The Court is, therefore, of the view that no question of law, much less any substantial question of law arises out of the order passed by the Courts below. The second appeal is, therefore, dismissed at the threshold.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. State Of Gujarat
    (Jan 28, 2009)