Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Bai Chhagni v. State Of Gujarat

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1. The present Appeal is directed against the judgment and order passed in Sessions Case No. 85 of 1992 dated 04.02.1993 by the Learned Additional Judge, Panchmahal, Godhra recording conviction of the appellant-accused for the offence under Section 314 of the Indian Penal Code and imposed sentence for RI for two years and fine of Rs. 500/- and in default SI for two months.

    2. The facts of the case briefly summarized are that on 06.09.1991, the accused as a midwife carried out abortion of Bai Koyali by inserting medicine in her uterus resulting into miscarriage as well as death and thereafter committed offence under Section 314 of the Sessions Indian Penal Code. It is the case of the prosecution that the accused was not qualified and was not supposed to undertake any such procedure or treatment for the abortion and still she has carried out abortion of the pregnant woman resulting into her death and thereby committed offence under Section 314 of the Indian Penal Code.

    3. On the basis of the information given by one Chiman Halabhai of Village : Mota Natva regarding the death of the deceased, the investigation was initiated. I.O proceeded to the Village : Madhava, the dead body was taken to Fatehpura Government Hospital for postmortem, inquest panchnama was made and the Medical Officer, Fatehpura has given P.M Report opining that the cause of death was illegal abortion and the rapture of uterus, for which, he gave certificate at Exh.10 On the basis of such certificate and P.M Report, the complaint being C.R No. 122/1991 was registered by the I.O for the alleged offence under Section 314 of the Indian Penal Code, which is produced at Exh.20 Thereafter, the panchnama of scene of offence was made and the statement of the witnesses. On conclusion of the investigation, chargesheet came to be submitted.

    4. Thereafter, Learned Sessions Judge framed charge at Exh.2 and as the accused denied to have committed offence, he proceeded with the trial.

    5. In order to bring home the charges levelled against the accused, the prosecution has examined the witnesses, including P.W No. 1 viz., Dr. Maganbhai C. Bhedi, P.W No. 2 viz., Chimanbhai Halabhai Kataraat Exh.11, who intimated Police regarding the death, P.W No. 3 viz., Manjibhai Galabhai at Exh.13, husband of the deceased, P.W No. 4 viz., Dhanjibhai Galabhai at Exh.14, P.W No. 5 viz., Bhundiben Virjibhai at Exh.18, who accompanied the deceased to the house of the accused and P.W No. 6 viz., P.F Gohil at Exh.19, I.O The prosecution has also produced the documentary evidence,

    6. After recording the evidence of the prosecution witnesses was over, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Panchmahal, Godhra recorded the further statement of the accused, wherein the accused denied to have committed the offence.

    7. After hearing the learned Public Prosecutor as well as learned Advocate for the accused, the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Panchmahal, Godhra recorded the conviction of the accused for the alleged offence under Section 314 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced her as stated hereinabove.

    8. It is this judgment and order, which has been assailed on the ground inter alia that the conviction of the accused for the alleged offence was recorded erroneously and learned Judge has failed to appreciate the material and evidence on record.

    9. Learned advocate, Mr. Shashtri though summoned has not remained present, however, as the matter is old, the learned A.P.P has gone through the entire evidence.

    10. It transpires from the evidence of the witnesses, more particularly, testimony of P.W No. 5 viz., Bhundiben Virjibhai at Exh.18 that she had accompanied the deceased to the house of the accused for abortion, who had working as midwife. She has categorically stated that the deceased had gone to the house of the accused and, thereafter, she has stated what had transpired at the house of the accused regarding abortion. She has stated that Rs. 170/- was charged. She has denied the suggestion that she was sitting outside when the accused was carrying abortion. She has specifically stated that she was sitting there. This version is corroborated by the medical evidence in the form of testimony of P.W No. 1, Dr. Bhedi at Exh.9, who has carried out postmortem and has given P.M Report at Exh.10 He has stated that only qualifying doctor or the Government Hospital can carry out the abortion. Admittedly, the accused is not qualified and is not, therefore, supposed to do such work of abortion. However, in the examination, he has admitted that if a pregnant woman makes an attempt herself with some object then similar result could be there. P.M Report, Exh.10 states regarding the cause of death as “the cause of death was shock due to intra abdominal haemorrhage by rapture of uterus due to induced abortion by putting some hard object in uterus which has raptured the uterus.

    11. P.W No. 2 viz., Chimanbhai Halalbhai Katara at Exh.11, who had intimated regarding the accidental death at Exh.12

    12. P.W No. 3 viz., Manjibhai Galabhai (husband of the deceased) at Exh.13 has also corroborated that sister-in-law had informed that she is not well, however, in the cross-examination, he has denied that P.W No. 5 had informed him about the operation and he has learnt from P.W No. 5.

    13. P.W No. 4 viz., Dhanjibhai Galabhai (father) at Exh.14 has also stated in the same manner. The panchnama of scene of offence also confirms about the place of offence i.e the house of the accused and also medical evidence as stated above corroborates the testimony of eyewitnesses, P.W No. 5, Exh.18 (sister of the deceased). Therefore, it is evident that the death of the deceased has occurred during the process of carrying out abortion by the accused at her house. Say of the P.W No. 5, sister of the deceased, who had accompanied the deceased as to what had transpired, is corroborated by the medical evidence in the form of P.M Report, Exh.10 and the testimony of Dr. Bhedi, Exh.9

    14. The judgment refers to this aspect and the defence had raised contentions with regard to the fact that such incident had not occurred at the house of the accused or other possibility that the deceased died as a result of fever is not believable in view of the medical evidence. Therefore, the conclusion arrived at in the judgment cannot be said to be erroneous and contentions, which have been raised that it was a case of abortion and there would be bleeding and clothes would have been found with blood stain and, therefore, theory of abortion cannot be believed as cause of death is also discussed. It may be noted that though the clothes of the deceased may not have found with blood stain, P.M Report in Col. No. 15 refers to blood from vaginal and the cause of death in Col. No. 23 clearly mentions about the cause of death was shock due to intra abdominal haemorrhage by rapture of uterus due to induced abortion by putting some hard object in uterus which has raptured the uterus. This evidence also cannot be brushed aside and there is no reason to discard the evidence of eyewitnesses, P.W No. 5, which is corroborated by the medical evidence also.

    15. Testimony of I.O, P.W No. 6, Exh.19 where he has also clearly stated as to how he was informed. He visited the house of the deceased at Village : Madhva, made inquest panchnama and also made arrangement for performing postmortem of the deceased, obtained P.M Report and recorded the statements of witnesses and on the basis of that, the offence came to be registered.

    16. Therefore, considering this aspect and evidence, it cannot be said that the impugned judgment and order is erroneous, which would call for interference.

    17. However, at the same time, considering the lapse of time and other circumstance including the fact that the accused is a female, who was aged about 58 years in 1992 and, therefore, she would be about 76-77 years of age and, hence, considering this aspect, benefit under the provisions of Probation of Offenders Act is required to be given to her. The ends of justice would meet if the benefit as required under the Probation of Offenders Act is granted to the accused. Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act provide for giving such benefit to the accused who have not been indulging in heinous crime and the sentence is less.

    18. In the result, the present appeal stands rejected and the impugned judgment and order in Sessions Case No. 85 of 1992 dated 04.02.1993 recording conviction of the appellant-accused is maintained. However, while maintaining the conviction of the accused as recorded hereinabove, the benefit under the Probation of Offenders Act is granted to the appellant-accused. Therefore, the substantive sentence shall remain under suspension for a period of two years. The appellant-accused is directed to execute a bond of good behaviour of Rs. 5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand only) for two years with a surety before the trial Court within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this writ, failing which, the trial Court shall issue bailable warrant for arrest of the appellant-accused so that she may have to serve the sentence imposed upon her. It is also ordered that in case of breach of condition of the bond of good behaviour, the trial Court shall be at liberty to issue non-bailable warrant for arrest of the appellant-accused.

    19. The bail bond executed by the appellant-accused shall stand discharged on the day on which the appellant-accused execute the bond of good behaviour before the trial Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bai Chhagni v. State Of Gujarat
    (Jun 16, 2010)