Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 9(2) of CST Act, 1956 read with Section 12-A of the KST Act, 1957
  • Section 8(5) of CST Act, 1956 issued Notification No. FD 119 CSL 2002 (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 9(2) of CST Act, 1956 read with Section 12-A of the KST Act, 1957
  • Section 8(5) of CST Act, 1956 issued Notification No. FD 119 CSL 2002 (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State filed this petition aggrieved by an order of the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (the Tribunal) which had allowed an appeal by the assessee and granted a reduction to 2% Central Sales Tax (CST) on certain inter-State sales. The assessee operates a solvent extraction plant at Challakere, manufactures and sells solvent extracted oil and derives by-products including de-oiled cake and de-oiled rice bran. The business also involved purchase and sale of edible oils and oil cakes.

For the assessment year ending 31.03.2003, the assessee filed return under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 declaring turnover and admitted tax liability at 2% on sale of sunflower de-oiled cake in the course of inter-State trade. The Assessing Authority reopened the assessment and, invoking the provisions of Section 9(2) of the CST Act, 1956 read with Section 12-A of the Karnataka Sales Tax (KST) Act, 1957, held that inter-State sales of sunflower de-oiled cake were liable to tax at 4% (and not 2%) and concluded the reassessments accordingly.

The assessee appealed to the Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals), who allowed the appeal and set aside the Assessing Authority's reassessment, thereby restoring the original order dated 29.01.2005. The State (revenue) challenged that result before the Tribunal in STA No. 425/2006. The Tribunal allowed the assessee's appeal and modified the reassessment order of the first Appellate Authority to grant the benefit of 2% CST. The State filed the present revision petition challenging the Tribunal's order.

By an order dated 07.12.2009, the revision was admitted to consider two substantial questions of law listed below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the order dated 12.07.2007 passed by the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal in STA 425/2006 allowing the appeal is correct and in accordance with law?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in ignoring that under the KST Act in the Second Schedule in serial No. 1 of Part O, oil cake and de-oiled cake are listed under two separate sub-headings as two different commodities?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's (Assessee's) Arguments

  • The assessee contended that oil cake and de-oiled cake are one and the same commodity and so the benefit of the Notification dated 31.05.2002 reducing CST to 2% (which referred to de-oiled cake) should extend to oil cake as well.
  • To support this contention, the assessee relied on precedent (Habeeb Proteins and Fats Extracts v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes) and on the broader principle that the nature of a commodity is to be determined as in the eyes of the person dealing in it (Sterling Foods v. State of Karnataka).

Appellant's (State/Revenue's) Arguments

  • The State maintained that the Notification dated 31.05.2002 (issued under Section 8(5) of the CST Act, 1956) reduced the rate of CST to 2% only on the goods expressly specified (de-oiled cake) and did not extend to oiled (oil) cake.
  • The State argued that oil cake and de-oiled cake are distinct commodities (the former containing a higher percentage of oil and other ingredients), and when oil is extracted the resulting product (de-oiled cake) is different in character. Therefore, the Tribunal erred in extending the benefit to oil cake.
  • The State further relied on the necessity to strictly construe notifications and on a later Division Bench decision in State of Karnataka v. N.K. Agro Oils (P) Ltd., which, according to the opinion, supported the view that the reduction applied only to the specific commodity covered by the Notification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Habeeb Proteins and Fats Extracts, Hiriyur, Chitradurga District v. The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Bangalore, 2005 (58) Kar.L.J 155 (HC) (DB) Held that where de-oiled cake remaining after extraction does not lose its identity as oil cake, it cannot be held that oil purchased has been consumed or ceased to exist as oil cake (decision concerned levy of purchase tax). The Court observed that the facts, circumstances and law in that case were entirely different, the observation relied upon was obiter in a purchase tax context, and there was no finding that oil cake and de-oiled cake are the same commodity. The Court found the precedent not applicable to the present case.
Sterling Foods v. The State of Karnataka, STC 1986 Vol.63 239 Proposition that the nature of the commodity is to be determined as in the eyes of the person dealing in it (case concerned frozen shrimps, prawns and lobsters). The Court noted that the facts of Sterling Foods differ materially from the present case and therefore this principle did not assist the respondent in this matter.
State Of Karnataka v. N.K. Agro Oils (P) Ltd. (Division Bench order dated 29.06.2011) Addressed the interpretation of Notification dated 31.05.2002 and concluded on the scope of the tax reduction effected by it. The Court relied on this Division Bench conclusion to support the proposition that the Notification reduced the rate of tax only for the commodity expressly covered and that no broader interpretation (extending benefit to other entries) could be imported. The Court treated this decision as applicable and supportive of setting aside the Tribunal's order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded along the following lines, strictly following the materials and arguments recorded in the opinion:

  • The starting point was the Notification dated 31.05.2002 issued under Section 8(5) of the CST Act, 1956 (Notification No. FD 119 CSL 2002 (2)), which granted a reduction in the rate of CST to 2% on specified goods. The Notification expressly mentioned "de-oiled cake" (a commodity which earlier attracted 4% tax) as one of the items on which the rate was reduced.
  • The Court observed that the statutory schedule itself contains separate entries for "oil-cake" and "de-oiled cake," indicating that the framers of the schedule treated them as two distinct commodities listed under separate sub-headings. The Court emphasized that this distinction in the schedule must be respected.
  • The respondent's submission that oil cake and de-oiled cake are identical and should be understood in common parlance was examined and rejected. The Court held that what a "common man" might understand is not determinative of legal classification; where the legislature (or the schedule) has made a legal distinction between two commodities, that distinction controls.
  • The opinion addressed the precedents relied upon by the respondent. The Court found the Habeeb Proteins decision distinguishable in facts and context (it dealt with purchase tax and contained only an obiter observation), and that it did not establish identity between oil cake and de-oiled cake. The Sterling Foods principle regarding commercial perception of a commodity was also found not to be on point given materially different facts.
  • The Court referred to a Division Bench decision in State of Karnataka v. N.K. Agro Oils (P) Ltd., which had considered an identical issue and concluded that the Notification dated 31.05.2002 reduced the rate only insofar as the commodity specifically covered was concerned and that no broader interpretation could be read into it. The Court relied on that conclusion as applicable to the present controversy.
  • Relying on the express language of the Notification, the separate schedule entries for oil cake and de-oiled cake, the need for strict construction of notifications, and the distinguishing of the precedents relied upon by the respondent, the Court concluded that the Tribunal erred in extending the benefit of the Notification (2% CST) to oil cake/de-oiled cake beyond what the Notification expressly provided.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court answered the substantial questions of law in favour of the revenue and against the assessee. In specific terms, the Court held that the Tribunal's order dated 12.07.2007 in STA No. 425/2006 is set aside and the order passed by the Assessing Authority imposing tax at the rate of 4% (in terms of the Notification dated 31.05.2002) is restored.

Immediate Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is to deny the assessee the benefit of a reduced CST rate of 2% in respect of the sales at issue and to restore the tax liability at 4% as fixed by the Assessing Authority.
  • The Court emphasized that notifications must be strictly construed and that the legislative/schedule distinction between oil cake and de-oiled cake must be adhered to; accordingly, benefits granted by a notification apply only to the goods expressly specified.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader novel principle beyond interpreting the specific Notification and applying established rules of statutory/notification construction; the decision resolves the present dispute and restores the Assessing Authority's order but does not claim to create a new legal precedent beyond application of these principles.

    State Of Karnataka By The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes, Vanijya Therige Karyalaya, Gandhinagar, Bangalore-560 009 Petitioner v. M/S. Ravi Prakash Refineries (P) Ltd. A.G Road, Challakere - 577 522

    1. This petition is by the State being aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, wherein the appeal filed by the assessee was allowed by granting the benefit of reduction at 2% in the rate of CST.

    2. The assessee operates a solvent extraction plant in Challakere and carries the business of manufacture and sale of solvent extracted oil. By products of de-oiled cake and de-oiled rice bran are obtained in the manufacturing process. Business is carried on also for purchase and sale of edible oils and oil cakes. For the assessment year ending 31.03.2003, the assessee filed a return of turnover under the CST Act, 1956 declaring total and taxable turnovers while admitting liability of tax at 2% on the sale of sunflower de-oiled cake in the course of inter-State trade and commerce. The Assessing Authority reopened the assessment and in terms of the provisions of Section 9(2) of CST Act, 1956 read with Section 12-A of the KST Act, 1957 held that there was an escapement of tax due to the reason that the inter-state sales of sunflower de-oiled cake was liable to tax at 4% and not at 2% as erroneously adopted and accordingly, assessments were concluded. Aggrieved by the same, an appeal was preferred before the Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals), who allowed the appeal by setting aside the order of the Assessing Authority. Consequently, the original order dated 29.01.2005 was restored. aggrieved by the same, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Tribunal. The Tribunal by the impugned order allowed the appeal by modifying the reassessment order of the first Appellate Authority and accordingly, the benefit of reduction of 2% CST was granted to the assessee. Aggrieved by the same, the State has filed the present revision.

    3. By the order dated 07.12.2009, the appeal was admitted to consider the following the substantial questions of law:

    i) Whether, on the facts and in circumstances of the case can it be held that the order dated 12.7.2007 passed by the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal in STA 425/2006 allowing the appeal is correct and in accordance with law?

    ii) Whether on the fact and in circumstances of the case, can it be held that the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in ignoring that under the KST Act in the Second Schedule in serial No. 1 of Part O, oil cake and de-oiled cake are listed under two separate sub-headings as two different commodities?

    4. The Government of Karnataka in exercise of powers conferred by Section 8(5) of CST Act, 1956 issued Notification No. FD 119 CSL 2002 (2) dated 31.05.2002 granting reduction in the rate of CST payable on inter-State Sales to 2% on the goods specified, subject to conditions. The goods mentioned therein was de-oiled cake, which earlier attracted 4% tax. The assessee had sold oiled cake also in the course of interstate trade and commerce. Hence, he claimed the benefit of reduction of CST from 4% to 2% in terms of the Notification dated 31.05.2002 for oiled cake on the ground that oil cake and de-oiled cake are one and the same.

    5. In terms of the Notification dated 31.05.2002, the rate of tax on de-oiled cake was reduced from 4% to 2%. The said schedule contains oil-cake as well as de-oiled cake. In terms of notification dated 31.05.2002, it is only de-oiled cake wherein the rate of tax has been reduced from 4% to 2%. But the sale of oiled cake is not covered under the Notification.

    6. The learned Counsel appearing for the respondent contends that the oil cake and de-oiled cake are one and the same and therefore, he pleads that the oil cake and de-oiled cake should be understood in a common parlance as understood by a common man. In support of his contention, he relies on the judgment of this Court in the case of Habeeb Proteins and Fats Extracts, Hiriyur, Chitradurga District v. The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Bangalore reported in 2005 (58) Kar.L.J 155 (HC) (DB), wherein it was held that “where de-oiled cake remaining after extraction of oil from oil cake purchased, does not lose its identity as oil cake, it cannot be held that oil purchased has been consumed or has ceased to exist as oil cake.” Consequently, purchase tax was not leviable on purchase of oil cake. The facts, circumstances and law declared in the said case are totally alien to the facts of the present case. The Court was dealing with the levy of purchase tax and as an obiter a passing reference was made. There is no finding recorded in the said judgment that oil cake and de-oiled cake constitutes the same commodity. That oil cake contains a certain percentage of oil and several other ingredients. When these commodities are subjected to processing of extraction of oil, some quantum of oil is removed but they continue to remain as oil cakes with lesser content of oil. The judgment relied on by the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent is not applicable to the case on hand and we are unable to accept the said contention. The facts and circumstances of the case involved in the above referred judgment are totally different compared to the facts and circumstances of the present case. The said case has no bearing on the case on hand. Reliance was also placed on the judgment in the case of Sterling Foods v. The State of Karnataka reported in STC 1986 Vol.63 239 to contend that the nature of the commodity is to be determined in the same way as in the eyes of the person dealing in it. The said case was with reference to frozen shrimps, prawns and lobsters. The facts therein are not in consonance with the facts of the present case.

    7. In the instant case, the distinction is between the oil cake and de-oiled cake and they are the two different commodities and they are not the one and the same. The oil cake contains a certain percentage of oil and other ingredients and when these commodities are subjected to processing of extraction of oil, some quantum of oil is removed but they continue to remain as oil cakes with lesser content of oil. Therefore, to contend that both commodities are the same commodities and are to be taxed in the same bracket cannot be accepted.

    8. The contention that the commodities will have to be understood in common parlance as understood by a common man is even harder to accept. What a common man understands need not necessarily mean what is understood in accordance with law. In the instant case, the framers of the schedule were aware of the distinction between oil cake and de-oiled cake. Accordingly, they have treated it as two different commodities. Therefore, to hold that the view of a common man has to necessarily over ride the view of the Legislature is difficult to accept. The distinction in law has been made which requires to be followed. Oil cake and de-oiled cake are two different commodities. The benefit granted to oil-cake cannot stand extended to de-oiled cake. The impact of the notification reducing the tax impact was very well known when the benefit was granted. A notification has to be strictly construed. The Court cannot read into the notification what is not there. The notification is clear and unambiguous. Any attempt to read it otherwise is not only uncalled for but would amount to redrafting the notification.

    9. An identical issue came up for consideration in the case of State Of Karnataka v. N.K Agro Oils (P) Ltd.. The Division Bench of this Court by an order dated 29.06.2011 came to the conclusion that by the very Notification dated 31.05.2002 the rate of tax was reduced from 4% to 2% in only so far as oiled cake is concerned and no other interpretation can be imported into it. The same is applicable to the present case also. Hence, on this ground also, the tribunal committed an error in allowing the benefit and extending the benefit of the notification to the asseesee in so far as de-oiled cake is concerned. Hence, we are of the view that the order passed by the Tribunal requires to be set aside.

    10. For the aforesaid reasons, the questions of law are answered in favour of the revenue and against the assessee. Consequently, the order dated 12.07.2007 passed by the Tribunal in STA No. 425/2006 is set aside and the order passed by the Assessing Authority imposing tax at the rate of 4% in terms of notification dated 31.05.2002 is restored.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Karnataka B... v. M/S. Ravi Prakash Re...
    (Aug 11, 2011)