BY THE COURT:
By the judgment dated 18.9.2013 the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jodhpur Bench, Jodhpur dismissed the Original Application preferred by the petitioner-applicant to have a direction for the respondents to employ him in Class-D service on compassionate grounds, being a ward of late Shri Suleman, who died while in service of the respondents. The authority competent by the order dated 15.9.2011 refused to grant appointment, being a case old for more than three years. A challenge to the same was given by way of filing Original Application.
The learned Tribunal after examining several judgments passed by Hon'ble Apex Court held that the appointment on compassionate grounds cannot be given as a matter of right as it is a device only to meet harness due to death of sole bread-earner of a family.
In the instant matter, admittedly the petitioner-applicant is a mature man of about 38 years and he applied for appointment on compassionate grounds at a belated stage i.e after lapse of three years from the date of death of his father. At this belated stage the harness suffered by him must have already been neutralized. It is further relevant to mention that the petitioner-applicant is a man of quite mature age and in this mature age he must have been adequately settled. The learned Tribunal, thus, rightly affirmed the decision of the employer for not extending benefit of appointment to the petitioner-applicant.
The writ petition, thus, is dismissed.