ORAL JUDGMENT
1. By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner seeks a direction to the respondents to refund Rs. 50,70,000/- paid by the petitioner towards sale consideration of Flat No. B/8, 2nd floor, Akshardeep Apartments, Opposite D.E.O Office, Law Garden, Ellisbridge, Ahmedabad along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum from the date of payment till realisation thereof.
2. The petitioner, a company incorporated under the provisions of The Companies Act, 1956 is engaged in the business of construction of residential and commercial buildings. The first respondent - Bank published an advertisement dated 4th January, 2013 on the website www.traderreader.com whereby offers were invited from the public at large in respect of Flat No. B/8, 2 floor, Akshardeep Apartments, Opposite D.E.O Office, Law Garden, Ellisbridge, Ahmedabad admeasuring 165 square yards (hereinafter referred to as “the property in question”). The petitioner company filled in the tender documents in the prescribed format and quoted a price of Rs. 50 lakhs and also deposited a demand draft of Rs. 5 lakhs as E.M.D On 5 February, 2013, the first respondent - Bank informed the petitioner that it was the successful bidder in respect of the property in question and called upon it to pay the remaining amount of Rs. 7,67,500/- because as per the terms and conditions, the petitioner was required to deposit 25% of the bid price on or before 6 February, 2013. The petitioner, accordingly, deposited Rs. 7,67,500/- on 6 February, 2013 by way of a cheque bearing No. 415760 drawn on Allahabad Bank, S.P Colony Branch, Ahmedabad for the balance amount of 25% of final sale amount and also intimated the respondent that the petitioner may be given possession of the property in question forthwith and the same should not be mortgaged to any individual or institution. The petitioner also made it clear that it would deposit 75% of the amount only if the peaceful and vacant possession of the property is handed over to the petitioner.
3. By a letter dated 22 February, 2013, the respondent Bank accepted the conditions stipulated by the petitioner whereby it was made clear that the petitioner will be given possession of the subject flat after depositing full amount and that all Government dues, semi-government dues and taxes are required to be paid by the petitioner. Subsequent thereto, the petitioner by a communication dated 11 March, 2013 requested the respondents that Condition No. 3 in the letter dated 22 February, 2013 namely, the words “dues of other financial institutions” should be deleted and the sale be confirmed so that the remaining amount of Rs. 38,02,500/- can be paid by the petitioner within 15 days thereafter. The respondent Bank by a communication dated 13 March, 2013 accepted the request of the petitioner and deleted the condition with regard to “dues of other financial institutions” which was included in Condition No. 3. Thereafter, on 15 March, 2013, the petitioner deposited a cheque for a sum of Rs. 38,02,500/- bearing No. 415761 along with a forwarding letter to the second respondent and requested that on receipt of the full amount, to arrange for registration of sale deed, transferring the property in the name of the petitioner and also to hand over peaceful and vacant possession of the flat. On 10 April, 2013, the respondent Bank confirmed that it has received the full consideration from the petitioner, but for the first time intimated to the petitioner that it was unable to hand over the possession of the property in question as an application was pending with the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate and that possession could be given only after obtaining necessary orders from the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate.
4. On 31st May, 2013, the petitioner intimated the respondent Bank that though the petitioner has deposited the entire amount of sale consideration, it has not got the peaceful and vacant possession of the property in question after three months of making full payment and requested to refund the amount with interest as the Bank was unable to hand over the possession. However, there was no response thereto. Therefore, the petitioner once again on 12 July, 2013 requested the bank that as it had failed to hand over the possession of the property in question till four and a half months, the amount deposited by it be refunded with interest or, in the alternative, the possession of the property in question be handed over. Once again on 29 July, 2013, the petitioner requested the respondents to refund the amount of Rs. 50,70,000/- with interest, however, there was no response thereto. It is in these circumstances that the petitioner has approached this court seeking the relief noted hereinabove.
5. Mr. B.T Rao, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner emphatically argued that the property in question has been auctioned by the respondent Bank in a public auction under the provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as “the SARFAESI Act”) and as such it is under an obligation to hand over the possession of the said property as provided under the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as “the rules”). Inviting attention to rule 9 of the rules which provides for time of sale, issue of sale certificate and delivery of possession etc., it was pointed out that once the terms of payment have been complied with, the authorised officer exercising powers of sale is required to issue a certificate of sale of the immovable property in favour of the purchaser and is also required to deliver the property of the purchaser free from all encumbrances. It was submitted that despite the fact that the entire sale consideration has been deposited by the petitioner way back on 15 March, 2013, till date, neither has the possession of the property in question been handed over nor has the amount been refunded to the petitioner. Consequently, the petitioner is not able to enjoy the property in question and is simultaneously losing interest on the huge amount of Rs. 50,70,000/-.
5.1 It was vehemently argued that when the property in question was not in the possession of the respondents, they ought not to have put the same to public auction. It was pointed out that in the public advertisement, nothing has been mentioned to the effect that the possession of the property in question has not been taken over by the bank and that it was only after accepting the full amount of consideration that the bank has disclosed that the application for taking over the possession was pending with the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. It was submitted that before knocking the doors of this court, the petitioner had made several requests to the respondents, however, till date, there is no response thereto and it is in these circumstances that the petitioner has been constrained to approach this court. It was, accordingly, urged that the petition deserves to be allowed by directing the respondent to refund the amount paid by the petitioner towards sale consideration along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum.
6. Opposing the petition, Mr. Punit Juneja, learned advocate for the respondents submitted that this petition is not maintainable as there is an efficacious alternative remedy available to the petitioner under the provisions of section 17 of the Act which provides that where any person is aggrieved by any action of the bank or financial institution taken under section 13 of the Act, he can approach the Debts Recovery Tribunal.
6.1 Referring to the advertisement issued by the respondents, it was pointed out that the auction of the property in question was on “as is where is” condition and it was also advertised in the auction notice that the interested parties can inspect the properties on the date and time given namely, 21 January, 2013 from 11:00 a.m to 4:00 p.m Therefore, the petitioner was well aware about the condition of the property in question and had, therefore, participated in the auction proceedings by making payment of Earnest Money Deposit and filing the tender document being conscious of the fact that the possession of the property was not taken over by the respondents. It was submitted that the petitioner was also aware of the proceedings pending with the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate for taking over possession of the property in question and that in the auction proceedings, the petitioner has specifically accepted the fact that they have inspected the property and its title and are participating knowing well all the terms and conditions of auction.
6.2 Mr. Juneja further submitted that the petitioner was informed by the respondent Bank that the Bank has taken over the symbolic possession of the property and will take over the physical possession of the property and hand over the same to the petitioner on payment of full amount and the respondent Bank has also made it clear in the letter dated 22 February, 2013 that the offer of the petitioner was accepted on “as is where is” basis and “as is what is” basis. It was argued that the petitioner had acquiesced with the fact that the physical possession of the property could be handed over to the petitioner only after the application pending before the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate is decided. It was pointed out that the borrower had filed objections which were not decided by the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate despite a long time having been passed and that though the representatives of the bank were always present before the court, the matter was not decided within a reasonable time. It was submitted that since the respondent Bank was concerned about the delay in handing over the possession to the petitioner, it had approached this court by way of a writ petition being Special Civil Application No. 13589/2013 and had prayed for a direction to the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate to decide the application made by the respondents under the provisions of section 14 of the SARFAESI Act. The said writ petition has been disposed of with a direction to the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate to decide the application expeditiously. It was submitted that it is in these circumstances that there has been a delay in handing over the possession of the property and that as and when the necessary police protection is granted in terms of the order dated 21 November, 2013 passed by the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate directing the police authorities to assist the respondents to take over the possession of the property, the same shall be handed over to the petitioner. It was submitted that in these circumstances, there is no warrant for interference by this court.
7. In the backdrop of the facts and contentions noted hereinabove, it may be apposite to make a brief reference to the record of the case. A perusal of the record of the case reveals that in the auction notice issued by the respondents, it has been stated that the authorised officer has taken possession of the property under section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. By a communication dated 22 February, 2013 of the respondents addressed to the petitioner, it has been stated that the higher authorities have confirmed the sale of property mortgaged in account M/s. D'Computer Mart of their branch in favour of the petitioner for Rs. 50.70 lakhs on the terms and conditions enumerated thereunder. Condition No. (5) reads thus:-
“5. Vacant possession along with title documents of the properties of Mrs. Bhavnaben H. Shah A/c M/s. D'Computer Mart shall be handed over to him after receipt of full amount.”
Subsequent thereto, by a communication dated 15 March, 2013, the petitioner forwarded a cheque bearing No. 415761 for a sum of Rs. 38,02,500/- being the remaining 75% towards purchase of the property in question and called upon the respondents to give the peaceful possession thereof. In response thereto, the respondents, by a communication dated 10 April, 2013 acknowledged that the sale consideration amount as per the auction has been deposited by the petitioner. As regards physical possession of the property, it was informed that the application was pending in the court of the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate and the last date was on 9 April, 2013. The matter was scheduled for 24 April, 2013 and that they would provide the physical possession of the property after getting orders from the said court.
8. It may be noted that the authorised officer recorded the proceedings of the auction (page 48), wherein details of the bids received in respect of the property in question and recommended confirmation of sale in favour of the petitioner. The confirmation of the sale was recommended subject to certain conditions one of which being that possession of the securities shall be handed over to the petitioner. On the basis of the recommendation of the authorised officer, the SAC decided that the property in question be sold to the highest bidder, namely the petitioner herein and confirmed the sale on the terms and conditions enumerated thereunder. The last condition reads thus: “Possession of the securities shall be handed over to M/s. Atishaya Construction Pvt. Ltd. on receipt of full amount”. It may be noted that the reason stated by the respondents for not handing over the property in question to the petitioner is that proceedings under section 14 were pending before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Ahmedabad. However, along with the affidavit-in-reply filed by the respondents, a copy of an order dated 21 November, 2013 made by the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 151/2013 has been annexed which reveals that the application has been granted and the bank is authorised under section 14 of the SARFAESI Act to take possession of the secured property with the help of the police; the concerned police station has been informed to provide necessary help to the applicant bank; and the bank is given the liberty to take possession of the secured property narrated in paragraph 3 and 4 of the application to realise their loan amount. In paragraph 14 of the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the respondents, it has been submitted that in view of the order dated 21 November, 2013 passed by the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, the respondent would be able to hand over the physical possession of the property in question in a matter of few days. The said affidavit has been made on 9 December, 2013. However, it is the specific case of the petitioner that till date, the possession of the property has not been handed over by the Bank which fact has not been controverted by the respondents.
9. Thus, it is an undisputed position that though the auction came to be carried out sometime in March, 2013 and the entire sale consideration was deposited by the petitioner on 15 March, 2013, till date, the possession of the property in question has not been handed over to the petitioner.
10. In the aforesaid backdrop, it may be germane to refer to the provisions of the rules and more particularly, rule 9 thereof. Sub-rule (3) thereof provides that on every sale of immovable property, the purchaser shall immediately pay a deposit of twenty-five per cent, of the sale price, to the authorised officer conducting the sale and in default of such deposit, the property shall forthwith be sold again. In the present case, the petitioner has immediately deposited 25% of the amount of the sale price within the stipulated period. Under sub-rule (4), the balance amount of purchase price is payable by the purchaser to the authorised officer on or before the fifteenth day of the confirmation of sale of the immovable property or such extended period as may be agreed upon in writing between the parties. It is an admitted position that the petitioner has paid the balance amount of purchase price within the time envisaged under sub-rule (4) of rule 9 of the rules. sub-rule (6) of rule 9 of the rules provides that on confirmation of sale by the secured creditor and if the terms of payment have been complied with, the authorised officer exercising the power of sale shall issue a certificate of sale of the immovable property in favour of the purchaser in the form given in Appendix V to the rules. A perusal of Appendix V shows that the same is the prescribed form of a sale certificate for immovable property, and to the extent it is relevant for the present purpose reads thus:-
“Whereas
The undersigned being the authorised officer of the … ………………………. (name of the Institution) under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (54 of 2002) and in exercise of the powers conferred under section 13 read with rule 12 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 sold on behalf of the … ……………… (name of the secured creditor/institution) in favour of … ………….. (purchaser), the immovable property shown in the schedule below secured in favour of the … ………… (name of the secured creditor) by … ……………… (the names of the borrowers) towards the financial facility …… ………………. (description) offered by … ………… (secured creditor). The undersigned acknowledge the receipt of the sale price of Rs. ………………. (Rupees … ………………….. only) in full and handed over the delivery and possession of the scheduled property. The sale of the scheduled property was made free from all encumbrances known to the secured creditor listed below on deposit of the money demanded by the undersigned.”
Thus, the authorised officer while issuing the sale certificate is required to acknowledge the receipt of sale price and hand over the delivery and possession of the scheduled property. Thus, upon confirmation of sale by the secured creditor, if the payment has been made in full, the authorised officer is required to issue a sale certificate and deliver the possession of the property in question to the purchaser. In the present case, admittedly, though the entire purchase price has been deposited by the petitioner, the property in question has not been delivered to the petitioner. On a plain reading of the provisions of rule 9 of the rules, it is apparent that once the sale consideration has been received by the authorised officer, he is required to issue a sale certificate in terms of Appendix V and is required to hand over the delivery and possession of the property in question. However, in the facts of the present case, it is clear that the above referred statutory provisions have not been complied with, inasmuch as, though the sale consideration has been deposited in full, way back on 15 March, 2013, even as on date, i.e in August, 2014, the possession of the property in question has not been handed over. Under the circumstances, the respondent Bank cannot be permitted to, on the one hand, retain the sale consideration and on the other hand, not hand over the possession of the property in question to the petitioner. The action of the respondent Bank in not handing over the property in question to the petitioner despite the total sale consideration having been deposited in terms of sub-rule (6) of rule 9 of the rules, is clearly contrary to rule 9 of the rules. In these circumstances, the court is of the view that the petitioner is entitled to refund of the amount deposited towards sale consideration for the property in question.
11. For the foregoing reasons, the petition partly succeeds and is accordingly allowed to the following extent. The respondents are directed to refund to the petitioner Rs. 50,70,000/- paid by the petitioner for sale consideration towards plot Flat No. B/8, 2 floor, Akshardeep Apartments, Opposite D.E.O Office, Law Garden, Ellisbridge, Ahmedabad. Insofar as the payment of interest on the amount deposited by the petitioner till the same is returned is concerned, it shall be open for the petitioner to avail of the appropriate civil remedy in that regard. Rule is made absolute accordingly to the aforesaid extent.