A. Shankar Narayana, J.:— The instant appeal is preferred by the Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition, Telugu Ganga Project, Unit - I, Kadapa, aggrieved of the order and decree, dated 23-07-2002, passed by the District Judge, Kadapa, in O.P No. 439 of 2001.
2. By the aforementioned order, the reference Court fixed market value for the acquired land admeasuring Acs.4-27 cents in Survey No. 509/2A at Rs. 68,000/- per acre and concerning pomegranate trees numbering 343 located in Survey No. 510 and 136 trees in Survey No. 511/1 standing in Ac.1-59 cents and Acs.3-00 respectively, fixed price at Rs. 4,000/- per tree after deducting the compensation paid for Acs.1-59 cents and Acs.3-00 of land, covered by the said survey numbers, towards land value, with statutory benefits.
3. Briefly stated the facts are, the Government of erstwhile Andhra Pradesh, under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, “the Act”) acquired an extent of Acs.8-86 cents of land located in Bedusupalli Village of Atlur Mandal of Kadapa District, belonging to the respondent - claimant for the purpose of Somashila Project submergence.
4. Notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act was published in A.P Gazette Part - I on 30-04-1994. After completion of award enquiry, appellant passed Award No. 1/98-99 on 08-03-1999 fixing market value at Rs. 34,000/- per acre for the entire extent of Acs.8-86 cents. The Land Acquisition Officer has not awarded any amount towards 479 pomegranate trees on the ground that when he made inspection, he did not find them despite the fact that they were notified in the draft notification.
5. Dissatisfied with the compensation awarded, the respondent made a request for reference under Section 18 of the Act and, accordingly, the Land Acquisition Officer has made reference to the District Court, Kadapa. The respondent claimed that prevailing rate of market value of the acquired land on the date notification was Rs. 85,000/- per acre and the cost of each pomegranate tree was about Rs. 6,000/-, and, therefore, they sought the reference, for fixation of market value at Rs. 85,000/- per acre and the price for each pomegranate tree at Rs. 6,000/- with solatium, interest and costs.
6. During enquiry, before the reference Court, the respondent examined himself as R.W.1 and three others as RWs.2 to 4 and Exs.B-1 to B-13 were marked to substantiate his claim; whereas on behalf of the referring officer, M.S Prabhu, Land Acquisition Officer/Mandal Revenue Officer was examined as PW.1 and the award and award proceedings were marked as Ex.A-1.
7. The reference court, basing on the evidence of RWs.1 to 4, the sale transaction covered by Ex.B-5 and certified copy of the common judgment of this Court in A.S Nos. 2885 of 1990 and 667 of 1991, fixed market value in respect of Acs.4-27 cents of land in Survey No. 509/2A at Rs. 68,000/- per acre. Concerning pomegranate trees, since Ex.B-3 paper publication of the draft notification under Section 4(1) of the Act shows existence of a total number of 479 pomegranate trees in a total extent of Acs.4-60 cents comprised of survey Nos. 511/1 and 510, believed their existence on the date of notification under Section 4(1) of the Act and opined that the respondent is entitled to compensation for pomegranate trees.
8. The reference Court, basing on Ex.B-4 certified copy of No. 2 Adangal showing existence of pomegranate trees and Exs.B-9 and B-8 letters, dated 05-08-1998 and 29-12-1998, respectively, addressed by the Special Deputy Collector, Telugu Ganga Project, Unit - I, Kadapa to the Assistant Director, Horticulture, Kadapa, requesting him to send valuation of the trees of Bedusupally by inspecting the trees and also on the basis of Ex.B-7 bills issued by RW.4, a fruit vendor at Tirupati, and on the oral evidence of RW.2, K. Venkata Reddy, retired Assistant Director in Horticulture and Research Officer in Regional - II Section, Fruit Research Station, arriving the cost of each pomegranate fruit at Rs. 3/- and the yield per tree at 300 to 350 fruits per crop, fixed compensation at Rs. 4,000/- per tree and, accordingly, awarded the same with all statutory benefits.
9. Aggrieved of the fixation of market value for the land and the compensation for pomegranate trees at Rs. 4,000/- per tree, the instant appeal is preferred by the Land Acquisition Officer contending that the evidence of RWs.1 to 4 is interested and the reference Court ought not to have based on such interested evidence in fixing the market value at Rs. 68,000/- per acre for the land. It is also agitated that the lands covered by Ex.B-6 common judgment in A.S No. 2885 of 1990 are not similar to that of the acquired land, awarding compensation for trees separately after deducting the land value covered by the trees without any valid evidence on record, is improper. It is also stated that the reference Court without any basis arrived at Rs. 4,000/- per pomegranate tree, and, therefore, sought to set aside the award passed by the reference Court.
10. Respondent is represented by his G.P.A Holder, Smt. Pidugu Rama Subbamma. She is the wife of the respondent.
11. In the cross-objection filed, he claimed Rs. 6,000/- per pomegranate tree contending that the reference Court ought to have relied on Exs.B-7 and B-10 and the evidence of RWs.1, 2 and 4, as the evidence of RW.2 is very clear, reflecting that each tree would yield fruits from the second year onwards and about 200 to 250 fruits per crop and would yield two crops per year, and, thus, even based on the evidence of RW.2, net income for each tree would be Rs. 8,000/- to Rs. 10,000/- per annum. Even if, multiplier ‘10’ is applied, the net income for each tree will be Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 12,000/-, but the reference Court fixed the value per tree at Rs. 4,000/-, which is very low and inadequate. Thus, the respondent in his cross-objection (S.R) confined the claim to the extent of pomegranate trees numbering 479 only and claimed compensation at Rs. 6,000/- per tree.
12. Heard the learned Government Pleader for appeals and Sri. N. Vasudeva Reddy, learned counsel for the respondent - cross-objector (claimant).
13. The learned Government Pleader contended that Ex.B-5, since relates to a small extent compared to huge extent under acquisition for submergence, does not represent true value and Ex.B-6, since relates to acquisition of land covered by notification dated 19-01-1978, this Court fixed market value for the land therein at Rs. 20,000/- per acre and, therefore, market value fixed by the reference Court at Rs. 68,000/- per acre is unsustainable. Concerning compensation fixed for each pomegranate tree at Rs. 4,000/-, it is his submission that the reference Court did not properly appreciate the evidence on record and ought to have excluded the evidence of RWs.2 and 3, as they are set up witnesses and no sanctity can be attached to the evidence of RW.2, and, therefore, sought to set aside the award passed by the reference Court and affirm the market value for the land fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer. He has also placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Maddisetti Bharathi v. Special Deputy Collector 2013 (6) ALT 718 (D.B), and an unreported decision of this Court in Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy v. Special Collector (L.A), Telugu Ganga Project, Unit - I, Kadapa, Kadapa District in A.S Nos. 3798 of 2000 and 2081 of 2001, dated 06-08-2008, in support of his submission that the compensation awarded by the reference Court for each pomegranate tree is highly excessive.
14. Learned counsel for the respondent - cross-objector contends that the evidence of RWs.2 and 3 and Exs.B-7 and B-10 would clearly establish that each pomegranate tree would fetch Rs. 8,000/- to Rs. 10,000/- per annum and the reference Court, at least, ought to have fixed compensation at Rs. 6,000/- per tree instead of Rs. 4,000/-. Learned counsel has placed reliance on the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Assistant Commissioner - cum - Land Acquisition Officer, Bellary v. S.T Pompanna Setty (2005) 9 SCC 662, R. Saragapani (dead) through Lrs. v. Special Tahsildar, Karur-Dindigul Broadgauge Line (2011) 14 SCC 177, Land Acquisition Officer, A.P v. Kamadana Ramakrsihna Rao 2007 (4) ALT 29 (SC) and an unreported judgment of this Court in Special Deputy Collector (LA) Somasila Project, Unit-IV, Rajampet v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy in A.S No. 1749 of 2004 and Cross-Objection (S.R) No. 3962 of 2008, dated 01-03-2013.
15. In view of the rival contentions, the following points would arise for determination:
1. Whether the fixation of the market value at Rs. 68,000/- per acre by the reference Court can be sustained?
2. Whether the compensation fixed at Rs. 4,000/- per pomegranate tree by the reference Court can be sustained?
16. The appellant challenged both, the market value fixed for the land and the price fixed for each pomegranate tree by the reference Court, whereas the respondent - cross-objector confined his claim to compensation awarded by the reference Court for pomegranate trees claiming Rs. 6,000/- per tree as against Rs. 4,000/- awarded by the reference Court.
POINT No. 1
17. We have perused the order and both oral and documentary evidence on record let in by the rival parties. Notification under Section 4(1) of the Act, in the instant case, was issued on 30-04-1994. The Land Acquisition Officer fixed the market value at Rs. 34,000/- per acre for the entire land basing on the available sales statistics for three years preceding the date of notification. Respondent requested to fix the market value for the acquired land at Rs. 85,000/- per acre and, of course, for each pomegranate tree at Rs. 6,000/-.
18. Reference Court relied on Ex.B-6, certified copy of the common judgment in A.S Nos. 2885 of 1990 and 667 of 1991, wherein, this Court held that enhancement of compensation, in respect of the lands, from Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 20,000/-, by the Senior Civil Judge, Rajampet as quite reasonable and the reference Court basing on the circumstances, that the entire land was acquired by the Government for Somasila Project, that the livelihood of the respondent is being affected on account of acquisition of land and since he was rooted out from his parent village once for all and he has to seek shelter elsewhere by acquiring new source of income by purchasing the lands elsewhere to eke-out his livelihood, by taking a liberal and construed approach, which the appellant failed to consider, and basing on Exs.B-1, B-4, B-5, B-6 and B-12 and the oral evidence of RWs.1 and 3, fixed the market value for the acquired land at Rs. 68,000/- per acre for the land comprised of Survey Nos. 509/2A in respect of Acs.4-27 cents. There appears to be no elaborate discussion referring to each of the documents i.e, Exs.B-1, B-4, B-5, B-6 and B-12, though, they were referred to while narrating the evidence of RWs.1 to 4.
19. Ex.B-1 is certified copy of 10(1) Account. Ex.B-4 is certified copy of No. 2 Adangal. Ex.B-5 is certified copy of the sale deed, dated 26-10-1992. Ex.B-12 is the letter issued by the Agricultural Market Committee, Kadapa. Ex.B-6 is certified copy of the common judgment in A.S Nos. 2885 of 1990 and 667 of 1991. So, the relevant documents for the purpose of fixation of market value for the land are only Exs.B-5 and B-6. RW.3 is A. Narayan Reddy, who is purchaser under Ex.B-5. His evidence shows that he purchased Ac.0-45 cents of land in Survey No. 138/3 in Akkireddypalli village from one Anduri Chinna Bayyanna for a total consideration of Rs. 27,000/-, on 26-10-1992, which works out to Rs. 600/- per cent and Rs. 60,000/- per acre. He states that to avoid stamp duty, he has shown lesser value compared to the prevailing rate in the market. Ex.B-6 is common judgment of this Court in A.S Nos. 2885 of 1990 and 667 of 1991 preferred by the Land Acquisition Officer and the claimant respectively, against one and the same award passed by the Subordinate Judge's Court, Rajampet. The reference Court fixed the market value for the land therein at Rs. 20,000/- per acre as against Rs. 10,000/- fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer. The notification under Section 4(1) of the Act was issued therein on 19-01-1978 and the lands are situated in Korlaguntlapalli village of Kadapa District. An extent of Acs.181-71 cents of land was under acquisition in that case for the very same purpose of Somasila Project submergence. The notification in the instant case was issued on 30-04-1994. If the escalation in prices at 10% per year is taken, for 16 years time lag, it works out to Rs. 52,000/- per acre. Whereas, under Ex.B-5 when the time lag is taken, for one and half years, it works out to Rs. 69,000/- per acre. The reference Court awarded Rs. 68,000/- per acre. Since the land was acquired for the purpose of submergence of Somasila Project and as the respondent was deprived of his main stay of living on account of acquisition, we are of the considered view, that fixation of market value at Rs. 68,000/- per acre by the reference Court is just and reasonable since it can be construed as an exemplar. We, therefore, confirm the said market value holding this point against the appellant.
POINT No. 2:
20. We have already adverted to, the contentions raised by the learned Government Pleader and the learned counsel for the claimant - cross-objector.
21. The appellant during pendency of the appeal filed L.A.A.S M.P No. 767 of 2014 under Order - XLI Rule - 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to receive copy of G.O Ms. No. 601, Revenue (LA) Department, dated 19-06-1992, as additional evidence as Ex.A-2, we have allowed the said petition and received the same by order, dated 18-09-2014. The said G.O is filed to show the details of cost of cultivation for pomegranate trees in Annexure - I (vi) showing the bearing period as twelve (12) years. The gross value is shown at Rs. 75/- and the net value at Rs. 52-15 paise. The said G.O was issued based on the report of the expert committee containing guidelines for valuation of orchards.
22. Coming to the evidence on record, respondent examined RW.2, K. Venkat Reddy, a retired Assistant Director in Horticulture and Research Officer in Regional - II Section, Fruit Research Station. His evidence shows that in the year 1992, when the claimants approached him for his guidance and advice concerning pomegranate trees, he visited the field and according to him, 300 trees of pomegranate were planted by the respondent in his field and the expenditure for raising pomegranate trees and maintenance would be at Rs. 20,000/- to Rs. 25,000/-. The fruit bearing is from second year onwards and its life period is 25 years and fruit bearing period is 23 years. Two crops would yield per year. Each tree would yield 200 to 250 fruits and the cost of each pomegranate fruit is Rs. 2/- to 3/- and the respondent will be getting an income of Rs. 80,000/- to Rs. 90,000/- per year after deducting all expenses and natural calamities. In his cross-examination, he admits that all the 300 trees will not yield same fruits. He has denied the suggestion that the life period of pomegranate tree is 12 to 16 years only. In fact, evidence of this witness appears to be not convincing. At one stage, in his chief-examination, he asserts that the respondent planted 300 plants and in the concluding portion of his chief-examination, he states that 479 trees belonging to the respondent are located in Ac.1-70 cents. Thus, his assertions run contra to the actual situation on the ground, since the notification itself shows that 479 trees were existing in an extent of Acs.4-59 cents. This apart, this witness does not refer to any of the guidelines framed by the expert committee or on what basis, he was able to give the particulars mentioned in his chief-examination. Therefore, we have no hesitation to exclude his evidence.
23. Coming to the evidence of RW.4, he claims that, he was running a fruit mandi business at Tirupati under the name and style of P.R.K.R and Sons in the name of his father and they were dealing in wholesale business of all fruits. The respondent supplied pomegranate fruits to his mandi and he visited the gardens of the respondent since he was doing wholesale business and has issued Ex.B-7 bills to the respondent. He denied the suggestion that he did not issue Ex.B-7 bills and that the respondent never supplied any pomegranate fruits to him and he was deposing falsely in order to help him.
24. Ex.B-7 bills would show the number of pomegranate fruits supplied and the rate per 100 fruits. But, the very certificate issued by the Agricultural Market Committee marked as Ex.B-10 would show that the fruits were measured in terms of Kilograms and the price per quintal ranging from Rs. 6,313/- to Rs. 9,992/- relating to the period from 1989 to 1995. However, the evidence of RW.4 is not convincing for the reason that the respondent as RW.1 did not mention that he was selling the fruits to the wholesale dealer at Tirupati. Except filing Ex.B-7 bills and vaguely stating that he was filing the bills showing that he sold the fruits and Ex.B-7 is the bills nothing is elaborated. In fact, when he was deriving fruits, he was not assigning any reason as to why he was not selling the fruits in the local market and in case really he was selling fruits to RW.4, the relevant details, such as the amount spent towards transportation charges and the amount spent towards loading and unloading charges would have been mentioned.
25. It is now to be seen whether the amount of Rs. 4,000/- per tree fixed by the reference Court is highly excessive as contended by the appellant or inadequate and not just and reasonable as contended by the respondent.
26. Turning to the decisions relied on by the learned Government Pleader, in Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy's Case (A.S No. 3798 of 2000 and 2081 of 2001, dated 06-08-2008), this Court fixed market value at Rs. 700/- towards each pomegranate tree basing on the inspection report, dated 21-11-1991 therein.
27. In Maddisetti Bharathi's Case (Supra), relied on by the learned Government Pleader, this Court basing on the decision in Peddireddy Madhavareddy's Case (A.S No. 1749 of 2004 and Cross-Objection (S.R) No. 3962 of 2008, dated 01-03-2013), fixed the rate at Rs. 2,000/- per pomegranate tree. So, it is the submission of the learned Government Pleader that the guidelines and the rate fixed by this Court in Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy's Case (A.S No. 3798 of 2000 and 2081 of 2001, dated 06-08-2008), may be applied in fixing the rate at Rs. 700/- per tree.
28. On the other hand, learned counsel relied on the decision in R. Saragapani's Case (Supra) for the proposition that the evidence of an expert can be based in fixing the market value of the trees.
29. In the said decision, the reference court appointed a commission and the Court Commissioner with the assistance of Agricultural Department Officer, submitted reports, dated 07-11-1992 and 20-11-1992. Since it is settled proposition that the Court Commissioner is an extended limb of the Court, the report of the Commissioner unless objected to by the opposite party, would constitute part of record, but in the instant case, the services of RW.2 were sought by the respondent on his own and, certainly, the evidence of RW.2 cannot be equated with that of the evidentiary value attached to the reports of the Court Commissioner and the expert, who assisted the Court commissioner. In Pompanna Setty's Case (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that cultivation expenses would not be 50% where the fruit bearing trees are old and grown up. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also held that the proper multiplier would be ‘10’ and the multiplier of ‘15’ applied by the reference Court and affirmed by the High Court was on higher side. In Kamadana Ramakrsihna Rao's Case (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that in fruit growing trees, the expenses would not be 50%. In Peddireddy Madhavareddy's Case (A.S No. 1749 of 2004 and Cross-Objection (S.R) No. 3962 of 2008, dated 01-03-2013), this Court fixed the value for each pomegranate tree at Rs. 2,000/- by the judgment, dated 01-03-2013. Since, we observed in the above that there is no convincing evidence let in by the respondent to substantiate his claim for Rs. 6,000/- for each pomegranate tree and since the decision of this Court in Peddireddy Madhavareddy's Case (A.S No. 1749 of 2004 and Cross-Objection (S.R) No. 3962 of 2008, dated 01-03-2013), the value of each pomegranate tree was fixed at Rs. 2,000/-, we are inclined to fix the value of each pomegranate tree at the rate of Rs. 2,000/- (Rupees two thousand only) for the 479 trees existing in the two survey numbers referred to above. Accordingly, we hold that the respondent is entitled to Rs. 2,000/- towards the value of each pomegranate tree as against Rs. 4,000/- per tree fixed by the reference Court. Thus, the value of pomegranate tree is reduced from Rs. 4,000/- to Rs. 2,000/-.
30. For the foregoing reasons, the market value fixed by the reference Court at Rs. 68,000/- per acre for Acs.4-27 cents of land is hereby confirmed and the value of the pomegranate trees fixed by the reference Court at Rs. 4,000/- each for 479 trees, is reduced to Rs. 2,000/- (Rupees two thousand only) per tree.
31. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed in part to the extent indicated above and the Cross Objection (S.R) No. 12501 of 2013 is dismissed. It is needless to mention that the respondent is entitled to all statutory benefits including interest on solatium. We make no order as to costs.
32. As a sequel thereto, Miscellaneous Applications, if any, pending stand disposed of.