Sudhir Agarwal, J.:— Deficiency of stamp has been made good. Delay in filing court fee is hereby condoned. Let the appeal be registered with regular number and the old number shall also continued to be shown in bracket for finding out details of case, whenever required by parties with reference to either of the two numbers.
2. As agree by learned counsel for the parties, I proceed to hear the appeal finally at this stage.
3. The appellants have claimed compensation @ Rs. 115/- per sq. yard though the Court below has allowed compensation @ Rs. 90/- per sq. yard.
4. Counsel for the appellants submitted that a Bunch of the matters involving same acquisition, as is involved in the present case, came up for hearing before a Division Bench of this Court in the bunch, led by First Appeal No. 910 of 2000 (Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Kashi Ram, decided on 13.11.2014, where also compensation @ Rs. 90/- per sq. yard was allowed. The appeals filed by Ghaziabad Development Authority, the acquiring body, has been dismissed but the appeals filed by tenure holders for enhancement of compensation has been allowed by allowing compensation @ Rs. 297/- per sq. yard.
5. The judgment of Division Bench has been placed before this Court. From perusal of aforesaid judgment, it is evident that, therein, tenure holders claimed for enhancement of compensation and lowering deduction from 33% made towards development cost. The Court while deciding the bunch of appeals preferred by land acquiring body as also tenure holders, passed the order, operative portion of which reads as under:
“It may be added that counsel appearing in First Appeal No. 700 of 2002 has filed an application brining on record the notification dated 7.11.1977 issued by the District Magistrate, Ghaziabad whereby the Khasra Plot acquired has been brought under municipal limits of Ghaziabad. Therefore, there is no doubt that the land in question of the claimants acquired for the Vaishali Scheme of Village Makanpur has already been brought under the limit of Nagar Palika before issuance of notification under the Land Acquisition Act.
In view of the location of land in municipal limits, nature of soil and other factors, referred to above, we find no force in the submissions made by the counsel for the GDA for enhancing the deduction to the tune of 75% and held that 33% deduction made by the Reference Court is fully justified.
In view of the aforesaid detailed discussions, the appeals filed by the GDA are hereby dismissed and the appeals filed by the claimants/landloosers for enhancement of the compensation are allowed. The claimants-private respondents shall be entitled for compensation @ Rs. 297/- per square yard, as held by us above and they shall be paid the enhanced compensation together with other statutory dues [like solatium, interest etc.], as directed by the Reference Court, within three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
So far defective appeals are concerned, any defect/s was/were deficiency of court fees, it is directed that same will be recovered/adjusted in accordance with rules, while preparing final decree by the department.
All the pending applications shall also stand disposed of accordingly.
Parties shall bear their own costs.”
6. In the circumstances, it is evident that enhancement of compensation of land, acquired by respondents, as demanded by appellants, is wholly justified.
7. Since appellants have demanded compensation specifically @ Rs. 115/- per sq. yard and court fee has also been paid accordingly, this Court find it difficult to allow compensation at any rate higher than that as claimed by the appellants.
8. The appeal is accordingly allowed. The impugned judgment of Court below dated 19.04.1999 passed in L.A.R No. 128 of 1991 is hereby modified to the extent that appellants shall be entitled to the compensation against acquisition of their holding by calculating market value of their holdings @ Rs. 115/- per sq. yard, as claimed in this appeal.
9. The appellants shall also be entitled to cost.