AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963

    Dr. Rajesh Sharma And Anr. v. State (Medical And Health) Ors.

    1. Instant intra-court appeal has been preferred against two interim orders passed by the ld. Single Judge dt.26.03.2015 and in furtherance thereto a later order dt.30.03.2015 Counsel submits that they are not party to the litigation before the ld. Single Judge but their rights are seriously jeopardized by the orders impugned and the application for leave to appeal has been filed by the appellants, indulgence be granted to them.

    2. Application for leave to appeal is allowed, as prayed for along with exemption to file certified copies of the orders impugned.

    3. Counsel for the appellants submits that the appellants are In-Service Doctors and they had participated in the process of Pre-PG Medical/Dental Admission, 2015 against the seats reserved for In-Service Doctors and their eligibility for In-Service category, as per the booklet published from the office of the Chairman, PG Medical and Dental Counselling Board-2015 (NBE) for Rajasthan for the State Medical and Dental PG Seats On-Line Allotments, 2015 apart from other requirements for In-Service category, a candidate must have completed three years of Government Service in Rural Areas of the State of Rajasthan or two years of continuous service of rural areas of desert/hilly or scheduled area of the State (rural areas are defined as a rural area where Rural Allowance is admissible to the Doctors) and as regards Rural Allowance is concerned that is admissible to the Doctors in terms of the notifications of the State Government, Finance Department, Rural Division, dt.26.12.2011

    4. Counsel submits that indisputably all the appellants have been paid their Rural Allowance in terms of the notification dt.26.12.2011 and all of them fulfill the conditions of eligibility to participate for admission and eligible to be considered according to their merit against the seats reserved for In-Service category. However, the writ petitions came to be preferred earlier by few of the persons for seeking their Rural certificate as they have completed the pre-requisite requirement contemplated under the scheme through notification of the Finance Department dt.26.12.2011 in particular and the ld. Single Judge of this court in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 2923/2015 after hearing the parties passed interim order on 03.03.2015 to consider for grant of certificate of working in Rural Area which is a condition precedent for their participation against the seats reserved for In-Service category.

    5. Counsel further submits that a further petition came to be filed and their grievance was that apart from what has been contemplated under the scheme for admission circulated by the competent authority for admission to the Pre-PG Medical/Dental Admission, 2015 for In-Service category and so also the payment of Rural Allowance in terms of the Government notification dt.26.12.2011, at the same time such Doctors could be considered for Rural Allowance who are covered by R.22A of the amendment Notification dt.28.08.2000 which has been inserted under the recruitment Rules namely the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 and taking into consideration R.22A of the Rules, 1963 initially in the subsequent petition, ad-interim order came to be passed by the ld. Single Judge of this court dt.26.03.2015 and on the clarification when prayed for by the State Government regarding applicability of R.22A of scheme of Rule for the purpose of In-Service category candidate, the ld. Single Judge modified vide order dt.30.03.2015 and the candidates who are otherwise eligible under the scheme introduced for admission and in terms of the Notification of Finance Department dt.26.12.2011 have been eliminated from consideration on the pretext that R.22A of the Rules, 1963 has not been complied with in its true spirit.

    6. Counsel submits that R.22A of the Rules, 1963 is relevant for the purpose of recruitment to the service under the Rules, 1963 and so far as admission to the Pre-PG Medical & Dental Course is concerned that is to be looked into in terms of the admission booklet and the Notification dt.26.12.2011 for grant of Rural Allowance and that has been paid by the State Government in terms of the Notification dt.26.12.2011 to the respective appellants and that being so, if the candidates have complied with the twin conditions, as contemplated under the scheme for admission to the PG Course, the directions issued by the ld. Single Judge vide order dt.26.03.2015 and further modified vide order dt.30.03.2015 would certainly deprive the candidates who are otherwise eligible for admission against the seats reserved for In-Service category.

    7. Counsel submits that since there is no time left and the counselling is at the offing, if interim protection is not granted to the appellants and the operation and effect of the orders passed by the ld. Single Judge are not stayed, their rights would be seriously jeopardized.

    8. This court directed Mr. S.K Gupta, Additional Advocate General to accept notice and assist the court, looking to the paucity of the time and Mr. Gupta after taking instructions, appeared before the court.

    9. Mr. Gupta submits that list was published by the competent authority strictly in accordance with the scheme and taking into consideration the Notification issued by the State Government dt.26.12.2011 where the Rural Allowance has been made admissible to the In-Service Candidates but in the changed circumstances there is no option left with the State Government than to revise the list published by the competent authority for counselling.

    10. Heard.

    11. Admit. Issue notice to the respondents No. 4-7 as Mr. S.K Gupta, Additional Advocate General accepts notice on behalf of the respondents No. 1-3.

    12. In the meanwhile and until further orders, the operation and effect of the orders impugned dt.26.03.2015 and dt.30.03.2015 passed by the ld. Single Judge in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 3711/2015 shall remain stayed and the respondents represented by Mr. Gupta, Addl. Advocate General at at liberty to publish the list of candidates for admission to PG Course for counselling and for admission existing prior to the passing of the orders of the ld. Single Judge impugned herein.

    13. Let a copy of this order be placed in the SAW No. 329/2015.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Rajesh Sharma And Anr. v. State (Medical And Health) Ors.
    (Apr 3, 2015)