Veerendr Singh Siradhana, J.:— Instant batch of review applications have been instituted seeking review of the order dated 27th March, 2015; in the view of the order passed by the Division Bench reserving liberty to the petitioner-Rajasthan Public Service Commission (for short ‘Commission’), to avail of remedy of review in the backdrop of law declared by the Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Kumar Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh: (2010) 3 SCC 119.
2. Mr. S.N Kumawat, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the review petitioner-Commission, reiterating the pleaded facts and grounds of the review applications, emphatically argued that though the order under review dated 27 March, 2015, was made in the presence of the counsel for the respective parties, however, the fact that the judgment rendered by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Madan Lal v. State of Rajasthan (S.B Civil Writ Petition Number 15152 of 2011 and analogous matters), was subjected to intra-court appeal, cannot be brought to the notice of this Court. The Division Bench of this Court, while adjudicating upon the intra-court appeal in the case of Rajesh Singh v. State of Rajasthan: 2014 (2) WLC (Raj.) 616; took note of the law declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra) modifying the operative portion of the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge, held thus:-
“61. Upshot of over-all discussions made (supra), all the special appeals (Schedule A) are disposed of and we modify the impugned judgment dt.27.04.2012 and 08.12.2013 passed by the learned Single Judge to the extent of relaxation in age having been availed by candidates of reserved category and find place in the select list on dint of merit of general/open category vacancies, deserves to be migrated against genera/open category vacancies; but at the same time, candidates availing special relaxation/concessions while participating in competitive test/process of selection, if find place in select/merit list of general/open category vacancies, they are not eligible to be migrated against open/general category vacancies and shall occupy the reserved seat in their respective category; as a result whereof, para (a) of the Circular issued by State Government dt.11.05.2011 being not in confirmity with the mandate of law can not be made applicable for public employment and accordingly deserves to be quashed & set aside.”
3. Counsel appearing on behalf of the writ petitioners, Mr. S.P Sharma, Senior Advocate, vehemently contended that the controversy is no more res-integra in view of what has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra), wherein the Supreme Court held that reserved category candidates do not acquire any advantage in the selection process owning to the concession in fee and age relaxation, which only enables certain candidates belonging to reserved category, to fall within the zone of consideration. Under Para 44 and 48, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, observed thus:-
“44. Taking note of the submissions, the Division Bench has concluded by considering questions 1, 2 and 3 that concession in respect of age, fee etc. are provisions pertaining to eligibility of a candidate to find out as to whether he can appear in the competitive test or not and by itself do not provide any indicia of open competition. According to the Division Bench, the competition would start only at the stage when all the persons who fulfill the requisite eligibility conditions, namely, qualification, age etc. are short-listed. We are of the opinion that the conclusion reached by the Division Bench on the issue of concessions and relaxations cannot be said to be erroneous.
48. In view of the aforesaid facts, we are of the considered opinion that the submissions of the appellants that relaxation in fee or age would deprive the candidates belonging to the reserved category of an opportunity to compete against the General Category Candidates is without any foundation. It is to be noticed that the reserved category candidates have not been given any advantage in the selection process. All the candidates had to appear in the same written test and face the same interview. It is therefore quite apparent that the concession in fee and age relaxation only enabled certain candidates belonging to the reserved category to fall within the zone of consideration. The concession in age did not in any manner tilt the balance in favour of the reserved category candidates, in the preparation of final merit/select list.
4. Explaining the object underlying Article 14, 15, 16 and 38 of the Constitution of India, which seeks to eradicate the disadvantages of candidates belonging to socially and educationally backward classes. It has been held that reservations are made to achieve the equality of opportunity guaranteed under Article 16(1) of the Constitution of India. Under paragraph 49, 51 and 52, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed thus:-
“49. It is permissible for the State in view of Articles 14, 15, 16 and 38 of the Constitution of India to make suitable provisions in law to eradicate the disadvantages of candidates belonging to socially and educationally backward classes. Reservations are a mode to achieve the equality of opportunity guaranteed under Article 16(1) of the Constitution of India. Concessions and relaxations in fee or age provided to the reserved category candidates to enable them to compete and seek benefit of reservation, is merely an aid to reservation. The concessions and relaxations place the candidates at par with General Category candidates. It is only thereafter the merit of the candidates is to be determined without any further concessions in favour of the reserved category candidates.
50. It has been recognized by this Court in the case of Indra Sawhney (supra) that larger concept of reservation would include incidental and ancillary provisions with a view to make the main provision of reservation effective. In the case of Indra Sawhney (supra), it has been observed as under:
“743. The question then arises whether Clause (4) of Article 16 is exhaustive of the topic of reservations in favour of backward classes. Before we answer this question, it is well to examine the meaning and content of the expression “reservation”. Its meaning has to be ascertained having regard to the context in which it occurs. The relevant words are “any provision for the reservation of appointments or posts”. The question is whether the said words contemplate only one form of provision namely reservation simplicitor, or do they take in other forms of special provisions like preferences, concessions and exemptions. In our opinion, reservation is the highest form of special provision, while preference, concession and exemption are lesser forms. The constitutional scheme and context of Article 16(4) induces us to take the view that larger concept of reservations takes within its sweep all supplemental and ancillary provisions and relaxations, consistent no doubt with the requirement of maintenance of efficiency of administration--the admonition of Article 335. The several concessions, exemptions and other measures issued by the Railway Administration and noticed in Karamchari Sangh are instances of supplementary, incidental and ancillary provisions made with a view to make the main provision of reservation effective i.e, to ensure that the members of the reserved class fully avail of the provision for reservation in their favour.”
In our opinion, these observations are a complete answer to the submissions made by Mr. L.N Rao and Dr. Rajiv Dhawan on behalf of the petitioners.
51. We are further of the considered opinion that the reliance placed by Mr. Rao and Dr. Dhawan on the case of K.L Narsimhan (supra) is misplaced. Learned Sr. Counsel had relied on the following observations:
“5. …Only one who does get admission or appointment by virtue of relaxation of eligibility criteria should be treated as reserved candidate”.
The aforesaid lines cannot be read divorced from the entire paragraph which is as under:
“5. It was decided that no relaxation in respect of qualifications or experience would be recommended by Scrutiny Committee for any of the applicants including candidates belonging to Dalits and Tribes. In furtherance thereof, the faculty posts would be reserved without mentioning the specialty; if the Dalit and Tribe candidates were available and found suitable, they would be treated as reserved candidates. If no Dalit and Tribe candidate was found available, the post would be filled from general candidates; otherwise the reserved post would be carried forward to the next year/advertisement. It is settled law that if a Dalit or Tribe candidate gets selected for admission to a course or appointment to a post on the basis of merit as general candidate, he should not be treated as reserved candidate. Only one who does get admission or appointment by virtue of relaxation of eligibility criteria should be treated as reserved candidate. These observations make it clear that if a reserved category candidate gets selected on the basis of merit, he cannot be treated as a reserved candidate.
52. In the present case, the concessions availed of by the reserved category candidates in age relaxation and fee concession had no relevance to the determination of the inter se merit on the basis of the final written test and interview. The ratio of the aforesaid judgment in fact permits reserved category candidates to be included in the General Category Candidates on the basis of merit.”
5. In the case of State of Punjab v. Manjit Singh: (2003) 11 SCC 559; the criteria of shortlisting through written screening test to shortlist the Scheduled Caste candidates for recruitment to a State service where the recruitment was to be done by only interview of eligible candidates and not by competitive examination, was declared to be valid observing thus:-
“10. As observed earlier, for the purpose of short listing it would not at all be necessary to provide cut-off marks. Any number of given candidates could be taken out from the top of the list upto the number of the candidates required in order of merit. For example, there may be a situation where more than required number of candidates may obtain marks above the cut-off marks, say for example out of 10,000 if 8,000 or 6,000 candidates obtain 45% marks then all of them may have to be called for further tests and interview etc. It would in that event not serve the purpose of short listing by this method to obtain the given ratio of candidates, and, the vacancy available. For 100 vacancies at the most 500 candidates need be called. If that is so any candidate who is otherwise eligible upto the 500 position whatever be the percentage above or below the fixed percentage would be eligible to be called for further tests. Thus the purpose of short listing would be achieved without prescribing any minimum cut-off marks.
11. In the case in hand, it was not for the Commission to have fixed any cut-off marks in respect of reserved category candidates. The result has evidently been that candidates otherwise qualified for interview stand rejected on the basis of merit say, they do not have the upto the mark merit, as prescribed by the Commission. The selection was by interview of the eligible candidates. It is certainly the responsibility of the Commission to make the selection of efficient people amongst those who are eligible for consideration. The unsuitable candidates could well be rejected in the selection by interview. It is not the question of subservience but there are certain matters of policies, on which the decision is to be taken by the Government. The Commission derives its powers under Article 320 of the Constitution as well as its limits too. Independent and fair working of the Commission is of utmost importance. It is also not supposed to function under any pressure of the government, as submitted on behalf of the appellant Commission. But at the same time it has to conform to the provisions of the law and has also to abide by the rules and regulations on the subject and to take into account the policy decisions which are within the domain of the State Government. It cannot impose its own policy decision in a matter beyond its purview.”
6. In the case of Dr. Bheru Singh v. The State of Rajasthan: 2008 (2) WLC (Raj.) 656; a Division Bench of this Court considering the scope of Rule 19 and 26 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963; observed that the Commission as a matter of policy has taken a decision that if number of applications exceed three times the posts so advertised, then number of candidates shall be called for interview on the basis of screening test. Thus, holding of such screening test to shortlist the candidates be suffered from any legal flaw. Paragraph 8 and 10 of the judgment reads thus:-
“8. The reliance upon the decision of this Court in the case of Dr. Bhanwar Singh is also mis-placed. The matter in Dr. Bhanwar Singh was also carried to Supreme Court by Rajasthan Public Service Commission in special leave to appeal (Civil) No. 14821/2001. While disposing of that special leave to appeal on 10.9.2001, the Supreme Court said in unmistakable terms that the order passed by the High Court is not to be treated as precedent. This is what the Supreme Court said:
Considering the facts and circumstances of the cases, particularly, the fact that some of the respondents are in service for more than ten years, the impugned order does not call for any interference under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. However, we make it clear that the order passed by the High Court is not to be treated as precedent.
9. Rule 19 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 reads thus:
19. Scrutiny of applications.- The Commission shall scrutinise the applications received by them and require as many candidates qualified for appointment under these Rules as seem to them desirable to appear before them for interview:
Provided that the decision of the Commission as to the eligibility or otherwise of a candidate shall be final.
10. The Commission as a matter of policy has taken a decision that if number of applications exceed three times the posts so advertised, then number of candidates shall be called for interview on the basis of screening test. A close look at Rule 19 would show that upon receipt of the applications, the Commission scrutinises the applications so received and require the qualified candidates for appointment as may be found desirable to appear for interview. To achieve this, when number of applications exceed three times the posts so advertised, the holding of screening test to shortlist candidates cannot be said to suffer from any legal flaw. Merely because the petitioners were appointed on urgent temporary basis under Rule 26 of the Rules of 1963, they do not get entitled for being exempted from screening test. In no way they are class separate or different from other applicants insofar as screening test is concerned.”
7. In view of the fact that Madan Lal's case has already been subjected to an intra-court appeal in the case of Rajesh Singh (supra), and the Division Bench relying upon the case of Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra), modified the relief(s) holding that relaxation in age having been availed of by the candidates of reserved category and the candidate finds place in the select list on dint of merit of general/open category vacancies, deserves to be migrated against general/open category vacancies. Thus, the order passed by the learned Single Judge in case of Madan Lal (supra), merged in the order passed by Division Bench in the case of Rajesh Singh (supra).
8. For the reasons and discussions herein above, the review applications are disposed of with the observations that the review petitioner would proceed with the selection process in accordance with law declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra).
9. No costs.