In this case, the complainant was absent on the day fixed for the hearing and the Magistrate discharged the accused by an order made under section 259 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. An application was made to me to revise this order, but I declined to interfere since the matter was one for the discretion of the Magistrate and I was not prepared to say he had exercised his discretion on wrong principles. The present application is, by way of petition, against an order made by the Magistrate refusing to proceed with the case on the filing of a fresh complaint by the complainant. The Magistrate dismissed the application of the complainant upon the ground that his order under section 259 could not be revised by him. Assuming this to be so, this does not, as it seems to me, preclude the Magistrate from proceeding with the case on a fresh complaint. It would be otherwise, according to the decisions of this Court, if the case had been disposed of on the merits and the order of discharge had been made under section 203 or section 253. No doubt section 258 applies only to compoundable offences but I do not think this affects the question of the jurisdiction of the Magistrate. I should of course be bound by the decisions of this Court to which my attention has been called, if they covered the present case. But so far as I am aware there is no decision of this Court that a Magistrate, who has made an order of discharge under section 259, has no jurisdiction to rehear the case on a fresh complaint. The order of discharge under section 259 is not an acquittal under section 403 and has not the effect of an acquittal.
In the case of Mahomed Abdul Mennam v. Panduranya Row(1), this Court expressed their approval of the decisions in Nilratan Sen v. Jogesh Chundra Bhutta Charjee(2), and Komal Chandra Lal v. Gour Chand Adikari(3), and disagreed with the decision in Mir Ahmad Hossein v. Mahomed Askan(4). But in all these cases the complaint had been dismissed on the merits, the order having been made under section 203. In the Full Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court in Dwarka Nath Mundul v. Beni Madhal Banerjee(5), the Court held that the Magistrate had jurisdiction to rehear a warrant case in which no had discharged the accused person by an order made under section 259. I do not find that this Court has ever declined to accept this view. I agree with this Calcutta decision and with the reasoning upon which it is based.
The case must go back to the Magistrate to be dealt with according to law.