Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Ajudhia And Others v. Kunjal And Others

    Knox, J.:— On the 3rd of August 1891, the father of the first four defendants executed a bond payable by installments in favour of one Kashi Prasad, father of the remaining defendants. The bond contained a provision that in default of the payment of any one instalment, it would be within the power of the creditor (Maliajan mazkur ko ikhtyar hoga) to sue for the whole amount due under the bond, without waiting for the period provided for the payment of other installments. The present suit is for the recovery of three installments due under the bond. The Munsif held that the suit was barred by the provisions of article 75 of schedule 2 of the Indian Limitation Act and dismissed the suit. The suit, we may here observe, was not for the enforcement of the option given by the bond, whereby the creditor could claim the whole amount unpaid. The plaintiff, appealed and the learned Subordinate Judge in a very able judgment held that the claim was not barred. The defendants come here in second appeal and again contend that the plaintiff's cause of action arose upon the default, made in payment of the first instalment, and that the suit is therefore barred by limitation. There might have been some force in this contention, if the suit had been to enforce the penalty and to recover the whole amount, left unpaid by the bond. But the suit was only for the instalments, unpaid at the time of the suit. In support of his argument the learned Counsel referred us to two decisions of the Calcutta High Court, namely, Jadab Chandra Bakhshi v. Bhairab Chandra Chukerbutty(1), and the case upon which that decision is based, vis. Hurri Pershad Chaudhry v. Nasib Singh(2). The latter case has been expressly dissented from in Letters Patent Appeal No. 81 of 1893, decided on the 10th of july 1894, in which the learned Judges held that the true rule of construction in cases of decrees for payment by installments is to be found, in the decision of this court in Shankar Prasad v. Jalpa Prasad(3). These rulings are distinctly against the appellants here. We may also refer to what was said in Mahardja of Benares v. Nand Ram(4). We agree with the remarks of the learned Judges who held in the last mentioned case that it would be very unfortunate if the view contended for by the appellant is sustained, as it would be to punish the creditor for forbearance shown to his debtor and compel him to press his demands at the earliest opportunity. It is conceivable that a bond might be so worded as to compel a creditor to sue for the whole amount immediately, if any default occurred. The bond with which we have to deal is not so worded. It merely gives the creditor an option. Following the law as laid down by this court, and with all deference to the learned Judges of the Calcutta High Court, who have taken the opposite view, we are unable to agree with them. This disposes of the first ground of appeal. The only other ground was not argued. We dismiss the appeal with costs including in this court fees on the higher scale.

    2. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajudhia And Others v. Kunjal And Others
    (Jan 2, 1908)