1. The appellant is the widowed mother of her minor son Narayan and the respondent is her mother-in-law. While the appellant is a young woman of about 23 years of age, the respondent is a very old woman over 55. It appears that the appellant has a brother Shankar Rao whose word reigns supreme in the management of the affairs of the minor's estate. Naturally, Janabai the grandmother of the minor resents it, and, consequently, desires that the minor's estate should no longer remain under the management of her daughter-in-law Godubai. Various acts of alleged waste and mismanagement by Shankar Rao which led to the institution of these proceedings for the appointment of a proper guardian for the minor's property have been set forth in the application.
2. Soon after this application was made by Janabai, the District Judge was moved for appointing a receiver to take charge of the minor's estate, pending the disposal of the application for appointment of guardian.
3. The District Judge made an order appointing Mr. B.C Thakar, Pleader, as a temporary receiver. It is against this order dated 3rd November 1928 for the appointment of the receiver that the appellant Godubai has come up in appeal to this Court contending that the lower Court acted wrongly and without jurisdiction in passing the same.
4. I was asked to stay the carrying out of the order, pending the decision of this appeal. I, however, declined to grant an unqualified and unconditional stay of the order, but, directed that, if the appellant without prejudice to her right to press the appeal, be prepared to be accountable to the receiver for the crops or income she would collect pending the decision of this appeal, the Court below should permit her to do so, subject to her giving solvent security for the probable value of the crops and the income she was likely to collect. But I understand that she has not chosen to give the necessary security, and consequently, the receiver's management has come into force.
5. The respondent raises a preliminary objection that the order for the appointment of the receiver being one purporting to be passed under Section 12 of the Guardians and Wards Act, there is no appeal against it, under S. 47, of the said Act, and that the present appeal should, therefore, be thrown out as incompetent. In answer to this contention the appellant's learned counsel urges that the order for the appointment of the receiver must be deemed to have been passed under O. 40, R. 1 of the CPC, which must, by virtue of S. 141 of the Code, be read as applicable to proceedings under the Guardian and Wards Act, and that, as O. 43, R. 1, Cl. (s) expressly provides for an appeal against an order passed under O. 40, R. 1 of the CPC, the present appeal is competent. Reliance is placed by the appellant in In re Bai Janabai [1912] 36 Bom. 20 , 11 I.C 554 , 13 Bom. L.R 487, and Chandra v. Wati Jagan Nath Singh A.I.R 1925 Lah. 489. I have gone through these cases, and I think that, since, an application under Section 12 of the Guardian and Wards Act (8 of 1890) is a proceeding in a Court of civil jurisdiction, it is competent to the District Judge, to appoint a receiver in such a proceeding, under O. 40, R. 1. The learned Judge who decided the Bombay case has given very good reasons, at pp. 26 and 27, in support of his view that a receiver could be so appointed under O. 40, R. 1 in proceedings under Guardian and Wards Act. The case relied on by the respondent, viz. Chandra Sahai v. Durga Prasad A.I.R 1924 All. 682 , 46 All. 538, lends indirect support to the view that the present appeal is competent, because, in that case also, it was laid down that, no right of appeal can be claimed by virtue of Section 141 of the CPC, when O. 43 of the Code makes no provision for such an appeal. Here, as we know, O. 43, R. 1, Cl. (s) makes express provision for an appeal against an order passed under O. 40, R. 1. For these reasons I overrule the preliminary objection, and hold that, the appeal is competent. In this view of the case, it is not necessary for me to treat this appeal as a revision, and deal with it, under Section 115 of the CPC.
6. As to the merits, little or nothing need be said at this stage, as the main application for the appointment of the guardian for the minor's property is yet undisposed of, and I do not wish to prejudge the case in any way. I must, however, say that, as between Mr. Thakar who is a pleader, and the appellant, Godubai who has to depend upon her brother, the former must necessarily be a better manager. There can be no doubt that these proceedings, whether started with a bona fide intention to secure the welfare of the minor, or for self-aggrandizement, seem to be the result of a mere scramble for power to manage the minor's property, between the two opposing widows and their supporters. Under these circumstances, the order of the District Judge, putting in a third party as a receiver and manager, of the minor's estate so far as it may come into his hands, is expected to be in the best interests of the minor. I, therefore, see no valid reason to interfere with the merits of the order. The appeal fails and is dismissed with costs. Pleader's fee Rs. 25.
D.S/R.K
7. Appeal dismissed.