Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules 1968. Rule 14
  • sub-clauses of Rule 14,
  • provisions of Rule 14
  • sub-rules of Rule 14
  • Rule 9 to 13.(i)
  • Rule 14(ii)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules 1968. Rule 14
  • sub-clauses of Rule 14,
  • provisions of Rule 14
  • sub-rules of Rule 14
  • Rule 9 to 13.(i)
  • Rule 14(ii)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Five special appeals challenged orders of a learned Single Judge who had allowed five writ petitions. The appeals concern the construction and scope of Rule 14(ii) of the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1968. The respondents in the appeals (petitioners in the writ petitions) were railway employees employed largely at Diesel Locomotive Works, Varanasi, and one employee at Gorakhpur. They were alleged to have taken an active part in the Railway Strike of May 1974.

The Disciplinary Authority removed these employees from service without serving any show-cause notice, framing charges or holding an enquiry, stating that it was "not reasonably practicable to hold an enquiry" and relying on Rule 14(ii) to remove them with immediate effect. The writ petitions challenged those removal orders as violative of principles of natural justice. The Single Judge quashed the removal orders on the ground that Rule 14 did not exclude application of natural justice. The Union of India appealed from that decision; these five special appeals raised common questions and were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the true scope and construction of Rule 14 (and specifically Rule 14(ii)) of the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1968, particularly the effect of the last part of Rule 14 requiring the Disciplinary Authority to "consider the circumstances of the case"?
  2. Whether proceedings under Rule 14 (and specifically under clause (ii)) permit the Disciplinary Authority to dismiss a railway servant without giving him any opportunity of representation or hearing — i.e., whether Rule 14 excludes the application of the principles of natural justice.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents / Petitioners

  • The removal orders were invalid because they were passed in violation of the principles of natural justice: no opportunity was given to explain conduct or to address the authority on severity of punishment.
  • Implicit in the challenge was the position that the last part of Rule 14 — requiring the Disciplinary Authority to "consider the circumstances of the case" — demands that the employee be given an opportunity to place relevant circumstances before the authority.

Appellant / Union of India (Disciplinary Authority)

  • The Union sought to support the removal orders relying on the provisions of Rule 14, in particular Rule 14(ii), which permits dispensing with the usual enquiry where it is "not reasonably practicable" to hold one.
  • Learned counsel for the appellant relied on decisions of the Calcutta High Court — notably Chief Mechanical Engineer, Eastern Railway v. Jyoti Prasad Somgir — that held the principles of natural justice were excluded by necessary implication in view of the terms of Rule 14(ii) (analogous, it was argued, to the proviso to Article 311(2) of the Constitution). Counsel also relied on Union of India v. P.C. Chowdhary where the Calcutta High Court sought to confine the Supreme Court's Divisional Personnel Officer decision to cases under clause (i) only.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
The Divisional Personnel Officer, Southern Railway v. T.R. Challappan, 1976 3 SCC 190 Interpreted the last part of Rule 14 (requirement to "consider the circumstances") to mean active application of mind and that the employee must be heard; any order of removal passed without such consideration is bad in law. The court held this decision to be directly applicable; it affirmed that "consider" postulates consideration of all aspects after hearing the aggrieved person and that Divisional Personnel Officer's ratio applies to all sub-clauses of Rule 14.
Ram Chandra Sharma v. Union of India, 1977 Bihar Law Journal Reports 6 Held that the last part of Rule 14 applies to all three sub-rules and that the disciplinary authority is bound to issue notice before passing final orders; orders in breach of natural justice are void. The court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that the last part of Rule 14 imports the rule of natural justice and applies to all sub-rules.
Raj Kumar v. Union of India (Madhya Pradesh High Court) Determined that the phrase "may consider the circumstances of the case" applies to all three clauses of Rule 14 and that the Disciplinary Authority is bound to hold a summary enquiry giving the servant an opportunity to explain the charges. The court cited and followed this view as supporting the proposition that Rule 14 requires an opportunity to be given to the employee.
Bhola Nath v. Union of India, 1975 1 S.L.R. 277 (Gujarat High Court) Interpreted Rule 14(ii) to require that opportunity be afforded to the railway servant in regard to the punishment proposed and held that Rule 14 does not take away principles of natural justice. The court treated this decision as consonant with the conclusion that Rule 14(ii) must be construed so as to preserve principles of natural justice and fair play.
Chief Mechanical Engineer, Eastern Railway v. Jyoti Prasad Somgir, 1975 2 S.L.R. 437 (Calcutta High Court) The Calcutta High Court held that principles of natural justice were excluded by necessary implication from Rule 14(ii), drawing analogy with proviso to Article 311(2) of the Constitution. The present court expressly disagreed with this view and stated it was unable to accept the reasoning; it emphasized that the last part of Rule 14 (absent in the Article 311 proviso) requires hearing and consideration.
Union of India v. P.C. Chowdhary (Calcutta High Court, Appeal No. 1022 of 1974 decided 16.7.1976) The Calcutta High Court sought to confine the Divisional Personnel Officer decision to clause (i) of Rule 14 and held it not applicable to clauses (ii) and (iii). The present court rejected that distinction and held that the Divisional Personnel Officer ratio applies to all sub-clauses, including clause (ii); thus P.C. Chowdhary's distinction was not accepted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court focused on the last portion of Rule 14 which requires the Disciplinary Authority to "consider the circumstances of the case and make such orders thereon as it deems fit." The court analyzed the clause as a duty imposed on the disciplinary authority to actively consider circumstances before taking any decision. The reasoning proceeded along the following steps (stated in the opinion):

  1. The clause applies to proceedings under all sub-rules of Rule 14; it imposes an obligation to "consider the circumstances of the case" in every case falling under any of the sub-rules.
  2. "Consideration of circumstances" necessarily means that the disciplinary authority must have before it circumstances suggesting certain inferences; those circumstances can come from the employee or from other sources.
  3. Information from other sources may be true or false and its veracity cannot be tested unless the railway servant is apprised of it; conversely, favorable information that is within the special knowledge of the servant will not reach the authority unless the servant is informed and has an opportunity to place it.
  4. For these reasons adverse orders affecting civil rights should not be passed "behind his back." The court concluded Rule 14 itself supplies safeguards — the authority must ensure it does not take into account unestablished circumstances or ignore relevant circumstances.
  5. The court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Divisional Personnel Officer v. T.R. Challappan to explain that "consider" implies an active application of mind and that such consideration can be made objectively only if the employee is heard and allowed to satisfy the authority about the final orders proposed.
  6. The court rejected attempts to confine Divisional Personnel Officer to clause (i) alone, holding the last part of Rule 14 applies to all sub-clauses including clause (ii). Similarly, the court disagreed with the Calcutta High Court's view in Jyoti Prasad Somgir that natural justice was excluded by necessary implication in Rule 14(ii), noting that the last part of Rule 14 is not found in the proviso to Article 311(2).
  7. On construction and principle, the court concluded the penalty under Rule 14 must be imposed on an objective basis after giving the employee an opportunity to be heard; therefore orders of removal passed without affording such opportunity were bad.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The court held that the last part of Rule 14 requires the Disciplinary Authority to consider the circumstances of the case after giving the employee an opportunity to be heard; Rule 14 does not exclude the application of the principles of natural justice. Consequently, the removal orders passed without affording an opportunity of representation or hearing were bad for non-compliance with the requirements of the last part of Rule 14.

Direct consequences: the appeals failed and were dismissed; the earlier orders (i.e., the removals that had been set aside by the Single Judge for violating natural justice) stood as unsupported by valid procedure. The court expressly made no order as to costs.

The opinion focuses on the immediate effect on the parties and interprets Rule 14 in light of prior authorities; it does not, within the text provided, purport to announce any broader doctrinal innovation beyond applying the established principle that "consideration" under Rule 14 requires hearing and active application of mind.

    Union Of India And Others v. Rajendra Prasad Srivastava

    K.B Asthana, C.J and Gopi Nath, J.:— These five special appeals are directed against orders of a learned Single Judge allowing five writ petitions. They raise common questions of law and fact and can be disposed of by a common judgment.

    2. The appeals are concerned with the true scope and construction of Rule 14(ii) of the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules 1968. Rule 14 is as under:

    “14. Special procedure in certain cases notwithstanding anything contained in Rule 9 to 13.

    (i) Where any penalty is imposed on a railway servant on the ground of conduct which has led to his conviction on a criminal charge; or

    (ii) Where the disciplinary authority is satisfied, for reasons to be recorded by it in writing, that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an enquiry in the manner provided in these rules; or

    (iii) Where the President is satisfied that in the interest of the security of the State it is not expedient to hold an enquiry in the manner provided in these rules.

    The disciplinary authority may consider the circumstances of the case and make such orders thereon as it deems fit provided that the Commission shall be consulted, where such consultation is necessary before any orders are made in any case under this rule”.

    3. The petitioners of the writ petitions are the respondents in the appeals. All of them except Rajendra Prasad Srivastava, respondent in Special Appeal No. 273 of 1976 were employed in various capacities in the Diesel Locomotive Works Varanasi (hereinafter referred to as D.L.W) a public undertaking administered by the Railway Board. Rajendra Prasad was a clerk in the North Eastern Railway at Gorakhpur. They were alleged to have taken active part in the Railway Strike in May, 1974. The Disciplinary Authority by the orders impugned in the writ petitions removed them from service without serving any show cause notice or framing any charges or holding any enquiry. The impugned orders said that since it was not reasonably practicable to hold an enquiry as provided in the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules 1968 the Disciplinary authority in exercise of powers conferred under Rule 14(ii) of the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules 1968 removed the employees concerned with immediate effect.

    4. The orders were challenged as invalid on the ground of their being passed in violation of the principles of natural, justice, in that the incumbents were not given any opportunity to explain their conduct or to address the authority on the severity of punishment. The Union of India sought to support the orders on the strength of the provisions of Rule 14 which disposed with the holding of enquiry in certain disciplinary proceedings. Learned Single Judge quashed the orders on the ground that they were violative of the principles of natural justice and Rule 14 did not exclude the application of those principles as regards infliction of punishment.

    5. The question for consideration thus is whether a railway servant proceeded against under Rule 14 is liable to be condemned unheard and subjected to the severest punishment of dismissal without any opportunity of representation. To put it in other words whether Rule 14 excludes the application of the principles of natural justice in proceedings under that rule. This leads us to examine those provisions in order to determine their true scope and effect.

    6. The last portion of the rule requires the Disciplinary Authority to “consider the circumstances of the case and make such orders thereon as it deems fit”. This clause applies to proceedings under all the clauses of the rule and the Disciplinary Authority is required to consider the circumstances of the case falling under any of the sub-rules. Consideration of circumstances is thus a duty enjoined on the disciplinary authority by the last part of the rule. Thus before taking any decision the Disciplinary authority must have before him circumstances suggesting certain inferences. These can come to his knowledge either through the employee concerned or other sources. Information received from other sources may be true or false. Their veracity cannot be tested without the railway servant being apprised of them. Further, material information bearing on the question in favour of the servant may never reach the authority unless the party concerned is informed of the proceedings. Circumstances which are within the special knowledge of the party concerned can also be brought to the notice of the authority only when the party is informed of the proceedings and has an opportunity of placing them. It is for these reasons that adverse orders affecting civil rights of a person are never passed behind his back. It seems to us that the rule has, for reasons mentioned, made enough safeguard for the employee concerned, and the authority has, before reaching a decision, to make sure that he does not take into account circumstances whose existence has not been fully established and has further does not ignore from consideration circumstances which are relevant to the issue.

    7. Further the penalty under the rule has to be imposed on an objective basis. We have accordingly to consider the true effect and scope of the words “considered the circumstances” as occurring in Rule 14. They came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in The Divisional Personnel Officer Southern Railway v. T.R Challappan . 1976 3 SCC 190. In that case Rule 14(i) was considered with reference to the last part of the rule. It was held that since that part required “the consideration of the circumstances” any order of removal passed without such consideration was bad in law. As to the extent and ambit of the last part, it was observed that the word “consider” suggested that there should be active application of mind by the disciplinary authority to the circumstances of the case in order to decide the nature and extent of the penalty to be imposed. This could be determined objectively only if the employee was heard and given a change to satisfy the authority regarding the final orders that may be passed by him. In other words the term “consider” it was said postulated consideration of all the aspects viz. the pros and cons of the matter after hearing the aggrieved person. Since the disciplinary authority did not comply with the requirements of the last part of the rule in that case, in that he did not hear the delinquent employee and consider the circumstances the order of removal was found bad.

    8. It is thus abundantly clear that the question of penalty has to be considered objectively after giving an opportunity of hearing to the party concerned.

    9. Learned counsel for the appellant tried to distinguish the Divisional Personnel Officer's case (supra) on the ground that it arose out of proceedings under Rule 14(1). We have already held that the last part of Rule 14 applies to all the sub-rules of Rule 14 and the penalty imposed has to comply with the requirements of that part whether or not the case falls under sub-rule (i), (ii) or (iii) of the rule. In Ram Chandra Sharma v. Union of India . 1977 Bihar Law Journal Reports 6. it was held that the last part of Rule 14 applies to all the three sub-rules of Rule 14 and the disciplinary authority was bound to issue notice to the delinquent employee before passing final orders of punishment. Any order passed in violation of the rules of natural justice it was held was void. It was further held that the statutory provision contained in the last part of the rule merely imported the rule of natural justice as was observed by the Supreme Court in Divisional Personnel Officer's case (supra). Thus any order passed under any of the sub-rules of Rule 14 in breach of the requirements of the last part renders the same void. The same view was taken in Raj Kumar v. Union of India3. It was held by the Madhya Pradesh High Court that the word “may consider the circumstances of the case” as occurring at the end of Rule 14 applied to all the three clauses of the rule and the Disciplinary authority was bound to hold a summary enquiry, in which it had to give an opportunity to the railway servant concerned to explanation the charges”. The Gujarat High Court in Bhola Nath v. Union of India . 1975 1 S.L.R 277. while interpreting Rule 14(ii) took the same view and held that opportunity was required to be afforded to the railway servant in regard to the punishment proposed to be awarded and the principles of natural justice were not taken away by the rule. It was observed that Rule 14(ii) must be so construed as preserving the maximum and destroying the minimum principles of natural justice and fair play.

    10. Learned counsel for the appellant has placed strong reliance on Chief Mechanical Engineer, Eastern Railway v. Jyoti Prasad Somgir . 1975 2 S.L.R 437. where the Calcutta High Court held that the Principles of Natural Justice were excluded by necessary implication in view of the terms of Rule 14(ii) which were analogous to those contained in the proviso to Article 311(2) of the Constitution. It has to be noted that the last part of Rule 14 is not to be found in the proviso to Article 311(2). We are mainly concerned with the interpretation of the last part of Rule 14 and the determination of its effect. We have held that on a true construction of that part the employee concerned is entitled to an opportunity of representation or hearing. With great respect to the learned Judges of Calcutta High Court we find ourselves unable to agree with the view expressed in the case cited. Learned counsel then invited our attention to another decision of that court in Union of India v. P.C Chowdhary . Appeal No. 1022 of 1974 decided on 16.7.1976 where the Breach distinguished the Divisional Personnel Officer's case (supra) on the ground that case related to a matter falling under Rule 14(1) and “the decision is expressly confined to cases contemplated in clause (i) and shall not be applicable to cases under clauses (ii) and (iii) of the rule.” We find ourselves unable to appreciate the distinction. The Supreme Court in the Divisional Personnel Officer (supra) laid down the true scope and effect of the last part of the rule. If that part applies to all the sub-clauses of Rule 14, as we have held, then the ratio of that case applies to cases falling under clause (ii) of the rule as well. We have accordingly reached the conclusion that the case of Divisional Personnel Officer (supra) fully applies in the instant case and the orders of the disciplinary authority were bad for non-compliance of the provisions of the last part of the rule.

    11. The appeals accordingly fail and are dismissed but we make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Rajendra Prasad Srivastava
    (Mar 4, 1977)