Chandrakantraj Urs, J.:— This Criminal Petition filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is directed against the orders made by the III Metropolitan Magistrate, Bangalore City, in Crime No. 838/78 calling upon the petitioners 2 and 3 to furnish cash security of Rs. 5,000 along with two solvent sureties for Rs. 10,000 and further to execute personal bond in a sum of Rs. 10,000 each, for enlarging them on bail. Similarly, on 21st July 1978 the learned Magistrate passed identical order in respect of the first petitioner. The accused have been charged with offences punishable under Section 489A to 489E of Indian Penal Code. All the petitioners are from Kodagui District.
2. Shri C.B Motaiya, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners contended that having regard to Section 441 of Cr. P.C and Section 445 of the said Code the learned Magistrate could not pass orders impugned in this petition.
3. Section 441 reads as follows:—
“441. Bond of accused and Sureties.—(1) Before any person is released on bail or released on his own bond, a bond for such sum of money as the police officer or Court, as the case may be, thinks sufficient shall be executed by such person, and, when he is released on bail, by one or more sufficient sureties conditioned that such person shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond, and shall continue so to attend until otherwise directed by the police officer, or Court, as the case may be.
(2) Where any condition is imposed for the release of any person on bail, the bond shall also contain that condition.
(3) If the case so requires, the bond shall also bind the person released on bail to appear when called upon at the High Court, Court of Sessions or other Court to answer the charge.
(4) For the purpose of determining whether the sureties are fit or sufficient, the Court may accept affidavits in proof of the facts contained therein relating to the sufficiency or fitness of the sureties, or, if it considers necessary, either hold an inquiry itself or cause an inquiry to be made by a Magistrate subordinate to the Court, as to such sufficiency or fitness.”
From the above it is clear that the accused persons could be released on bail on the terms and conditions set forth in the section. Similarly, Section 445 reads as follows:
“445. Deposit instead of recognizance.—When any person is required by any Court or officer to execute a bond, with or without sureties, such Court or officer may, except in the case of a bond for good behaviour, permit him to deposit a sum of money or Government promissory notes to such amount as the Court or officer may fix, in lieu of executing such bond.”
It is clear that the discretionary power exercised by the Magistrate or the Court, as the case may be, under the two sections extracted above, is mutually exclusive and not concurrent. It is also clear that on the Court requiring a person to execute a personal bond with sureties or without sureties, it is at the option of the accused persons to furnish cash deposit in lieu of the bond or sureties that the Court may make an order under Section 445. In the instant case, it is clear from the orders that the learned Magistrate has asked for securities in all the forms available under both the sections which is impermissible. This Page: 1830is not seriously disputed by the learned State Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondents-State and fairly conceded that the Court can follow the provisions contained in Section 441 or 445 of the Code but not both.
4. In these circumstances, the petitioners are bound to succeed and the trial Court's orders the legality of which are questioned in this petition are set aside to the extent of calling upon the petitioners to furnish cash deposits and, if the amount is already deposited, the same shall be refunded to them.
5. There will be no order as to costs.