Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Rule challenges the order dated July 17, 1978, passed by the Additional District Judge, 5th Court at Midnapore, which affirmed the dismissal of a pre-emption application by the learned Munsif, Second Court, Midnapore. The petitioner sought pre-emption rights over 3 acres of land (plots Nos. 551 and 552 in Mouza Dhekia, P.S Kharagpur, Midnapore district), claiming co-sharer status and vicinage rights under S. 8 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act. The trial court held the petitioner was not a co-sharer since the land was purchased before vesting under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953, and that the land was non-agricultural, thus outside the scope of the Land Reforms Act. The appellate court agreed that the land was agricultural but denied pre-emption on vicinage grounds, holding that the right applies only when the claimant holds a different contiguous land.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the land in question qualifies as agricultural land under the West Bengal Land Reforms Act for the purpose of pre-emption.
  2. Whether the petitioner, as a co-sharer or adjoining landholder, is entitled to claim pre-emption rights under S. 8 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act.
  3. The legal significance of holding a homestead (bastu) in relation to agricultural land for pre-emption claims.
  4. The applicable test for determining the nature of land (agricultural or non-agricultural) under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The appellate court erred in denying pre-emption since it found the land to be agricultural and the petitioner owned a portion of the plots.
  • A homestead held by a raiyat who owns agricultural land should be treated as agricultural land under the Land Reforms Act, even if the homestead itself is not used for cultivation.
  • Reliance on the decision in Khantamayee v. Rukmini, which defines agricultural land broadly to include dwelling houses used by cultivators and related accessory uses.
  • The nature of the land should be determined by actual use on the date of vesting under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, not by original settlement purpose.
  • Reliance on Misri Shaw v. Belur Nikunjamoyee Godar and Ram Kumar Kajaria v. Chandra Engineering (India) Ltd. to argue that the purpose of settlement governs the status of raiyat and pre-emption rights, not actual agricultural use.
  • The revisional record indicating the petitioner’s status as a raiyati sthithiban supports the agricultural character of the land.

Opposite Party’s Arguments

  • The petitioner admitted that the plots do not contain agricultural land, thus the land is non-agricultural.
  • The trial court correctly held the land to be non-agricultural, making S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act inapplicable.
  • The appellate court wrongly based its conclusion on the raiyati sthithiban status without considering evidence showing non-agricultural use.
  • Reliance on Eyachhin Ali Niskar v. Gopal Gazl, which held that bastu land with residential structures is non-agricultural unless agricultural use is evident.
  • Pre-emption rights under S. 8 are confined to portions of holdings used for agriculture and do not extend to bastu land unless it is connected with agricultural use.
  • The petitioner’s admission that no agricultural use occurred on the land in question negates a claim of agricultural land status.
  • A homestead (bastu) does not become agricultural land merely because the holder owns other agricultural land in a different holding.
  • The actual use at the date of vesting determines land nature under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, supporting the non-agricultural classification here.

Petitioner’s Reply

  • It is not necessary to own land to be a raiyat; holding land for agricultural purposes suffices.
  • If a raiyat holds agricultural land and a homestead, the homestead should be considered agricultural land under S. 2(1) of the Land Reforms Act.
  • It is not necessary that the land in question itself be held for agricultural purposes to qualify as agricultural land.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khantamayee v. Rukmini, 48 CWN 759 Definition of agricultural land including dwelling houses used by cultivators and accessory uses. Supported petitioner’s argument that homestead can be agricultural land if held by a raiyat owning agricultural land.
Misri Shaw v. Belur Nikunjamoyee Godar, 1978 (1) CLJ 532 Actual user of land on date of vesting determines nature of land under West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act. Petitioner relied on this to argue the land’s agricultural character based on use at vesting.
Ram Kumar Kajaria v. Chandra Engineering (India) Ltd., 77 CWN 426 Definition of ‘Raiyat’ under S. 2(10) of West Bengal Land Reforms Act; purpose of settlement governs status. Used to argue that settlement purpose, not actual use, determines pre-emption rights.
Eyachhin Ali Niskar v. Gopal Gazl, 83 CWN 87 Homestead (bastu) land with residential structures is non-agricultural unless agricultural use is evident. Court relied on this precedent to uphold the finding that land was non-agricultural and pre-emption did not apply.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed whether the land in question qualified as agricultural land under the Land Reforms Act. It acknowledged that a homestead is not ipso facto agricultural land but may be considered such if the holding includes land used for agricultural purposes. The Court rejected the petitioner’s contention that holding agricultural land elsewhere converts a homestead in a different holding into agricultural land. The petitioner’s own admission that no part of the land in question was used for agriculture was pivotal. The Court found the principle in Eyachhin Ali Niskar applicable, where bastu land with residential structures was held non-agricultural. Consequently, the Court agreed with the trial court’s finding that the land was non-agricultural and thus outside the scope of S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act, leading to dismissal of the pre-emption claim.

Holding and Implications

This Rule is dismissed.

The Court held that the land in question is non-agricultural and therefore the petitioner is not entitled to pre-emption rights under S. 8 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act. The petitioner’s claim failed because the homestead (bastu) land was not agricultural land, and the petitioner admitted no agricultural use on the land. No new precedent was established; the decision confirms existing principles limiting pre-emption rights to agricultural land and holdings used for agricultural purposes.

    Kamaleswar Singha v. Bijoli Bhattacharjee & Ors.

    1. This Rule is directed against the order dated July 17, 1978 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 5th Court at Midnapore in Misc. Appeal No. 43 of 1978 affirming the order No. 27 dated January 31, 1978 passed by the learned Munsif. Second Court, Midnapore in J. Misc. Case No. 60 of 1975. The petitioner made an application for pre-emption of 03 acre of land being the eastern portion of plots Nos. 551 and 552 appertaining to Revisional Settlement Khatlan No. 29 within Mouza Dhekia, P.S Kharagpur in the district of Midnapore. The plaintiff based his claim for pre-emption on the ground that the plaintiff was a co-sharer in respect of the holding in question and the plaintiff also held land contiguous to the land in respect of which the said right of pre-emption was made. The trial Court on consideration of the materials on record and evidences adduced by the parties came to the finding that the petitioner was not a co-sharer because he had purchased some land in the holding in question prior to the vesting of estates under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953 and the petitioner was also not entitled to claim for pre-emption on the ground of vicinage because the land in question was not an agricultural land but a non-agricultural land and as such the same was not ‘land’ within the meaning of the Land Reforms Act. In that view of the matter, the trial court held that an application for pre-emption under S. 8 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act was not maintainable and the said application for pre-emption was dismissed by the trial court. The pre-emptor petitioner thereafter preferred an appeal being the said Misc. Appeal No. 43 of 1978 pending in the 5th Court of the learned Additional District Judge, Midnapore and as aforesaid the learned Additional District Judge dismissed the said appeal and affirmed the order of the learned Munsif rejecting the application for pre-emption it, however, appears that the Court of Appeal below held that the land in question was an agricultural land but the Court of Appeal below held that although it was an agricultural land the petitioner was not entitled to pre-emption on the ground of vicinage and the right of pre-emption on the ground of vicinage under S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act can be made if a person holds not any portion of the land sought to be pre-empted, but a different land contiguous to the land in question.

    2. Mr. Satinath Mukherjee, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that the court of appeal below having come to the finding that the land in question was an agricultural lard, it should have allowed the application for pre-emption because admittedly the pre-emptor petitioner was owner of a portion of the plots in question Mr. Mukherjee submitted in his usual fairness that ??? ipso facto will not determine the question as to whether the land is agricultural or non agricultural. Mr. Mukherjee contended that if a person holds any land for agricultural purpose and also holds a homestead then such homestead of a person holding any land for agricultural purpose is an agricultural land Mr. Mukherjee submitted that it has not been found by any of the Courts below that the petitioner does not hold any land for agricultural purpose. It has only been held by the trial court that the lands in question were not held for agricultural purpose but such land consisted of structures meant for residential purpose. Mr. Mukherjee submitted that a house for residential purpose is not an agricultural land ordinarily but if a raiyat bolds other lands for agricultural purpose and also holds a plot comprising his homestead then the said homestead becomes an agricultural land, although the ??? house and the lands appertaining thereto as such are not actually utilised for cultivation. Mr. Mukherjee in this connection referred to a Bench decision of this Court made in the case of Khantamayee v. Rukmini reported in 48 CWN at page 759. It was held in the said decision that the lands actually used for raising by cultivation foodgrains, vegetables and fodder as also other marketable ??? such as jute, hemp, cotton, lac, etc.; lands lying unused but capable of being used for the above purposes; lands used for purposes accessory to cultivation, e.g the thrashing floor and irrigation tanks; lands containing cat is sheds and sheds for ploughs, etc; lands used for orchards or for farming purposes; i.e, raising or feeding of cattle or other livestock; pathways, khals nullas serving the agricultural lands and sites of dwelling houses of culttvators are all agricultural lands for the purposes of Item No. 21 of list II of the Government of India Act, 1925 but dwelling houses other than those used for the residence of cultivators or farmers; lands which are being actually used for raising mineral; lands covered by forest; Debasthanas; and possibly lands used for planting trees for the purposes of fact are non agricultural lands. It was also held that “Dwelling house” would include adjacement ??? or ??? uses, curtilage, garden, ???, orchard within the compound of the house and all that is necessary for the convenient use thereof. Relying on the aforesaid decision, Mr. Mukherjee contended that there is no material which establishes that the pre-emptor petitioner does not hold any land for agricultural purpose. On the contrary the interest relating to the land in question was recorded as that of a raiyati sthithiban. Accordingly it must be held that it was an agricultural land. Mr. Mukherjee also contended that actual user of land on the date of vesting must determine the nature of the land under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act. It is immaterial as to for what purpose the land was settled earlier and the legal principle that the purpose of original settlement of the land will govern the nature of the tenancy has undergone a change because of the provisions of West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953. It is the actual user of the land on the date of vesting which will date mine the nature of the land, namely whether land is agricultural or non agricultural under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act. For this contention Mr. Mukherjee referred to the decision of this Court made in the case of Misrl Shaw v. Belur Nikunjamoyee Godar reported in 1978 (1) CLJ at page 532, Mr. Mukherjae also referred to another Bench decision of this Court made in the case of Ram Kumar Kajaria v. Chandra Engineering (India) Ltd. reported in 77 CWN at page 426. It was held in the said decision that S. 2(10) of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act defines the term ‘Raiyat’. ‘Raiyat’ means a person who holds land for purposes of agriculture. It is clear from the definition of the term ‘Raiyat’ that the only rest whether a person is a raiyat or not is the purpose for which the land was settled. If the purpose for which the settlement was made is agricultural purpose the person in whose favour such settlement was made, is raiyat. On the other hand, if the purpose is other than agricultural purpose for which the land was settled, in that case the settlement cannot be said to be a raiyati settlement and the persons in whose favour the settlement was made cannot be regarded as a raiyat within the meaning of S. 2(10) of the Act, even though the land is actually used for agricultural purpose. Cultivation of the land or actual user of the same for agricultural purpose by a co-sharer raiyat is not a condition precedent for enforcing the right of pre-emption under S. 8(1) of the Act. Relying on the aforesaid decision Mr. Mukherjee submitted that the right of pre-emption will not depend upon the actual user of the land but the purpose for which the land was settled. Mr. Mukherjee submitted that it will appear from the revisional record of rights that the interest recorded in respect of the said land was that of a raiyat sthithiban which indicates the purpose of settlement of the land in question. Accordingly even assuming that the land was a bastu land comprising structure thereon it cannot be held that it was not a raiyati land and as such it is not an agricultural land within the meaning of the Land Reforms Act.

    3. Mr. Monomohon Mukherjee, the learned Counsel appearing for the opposite party however submitted that the pre-emptor himself deposed in the proceeding and had admitted that the plots appertaining to the holding in question do not contain any agricultural land and in view of such clear admission made by the pre-emptor, it must be held that the lands appertaining to the holding in question are non agricultural lands and the trial court was quite justified in holding that the lands in question are non-agricultural, lands and as such S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act was not attracted in the facts of the case. Mr. Mukherjee submitted that the Court of appeal below did not consider the ??? evidence on record but held that the land was agricultural land simply because the interest was recorded in the Revisional Record of Right as that of a Ratyati Sthithiban. In this connection Mr. Mukherjee referred to a decision of this Court made in the case of Eyachhin Ali Niskar v. Gopal Gazl reported in 83 CWN at page 87 (:1979 ??? CHN 139). In the said case the right of the preemption in respect of a land comprising the bastu with hut standing there on ??? taken into consideration by tail Court. The interest of this tenant in respect of the land was recorded at that of Raiyati Sthithiban as in the instant case. But S.K Dutta, J. held that under the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, raiyat has been defined as person who holds for the purpose of agriculture. When a raiyat, who holds land for the purpose of agriculture, has also homestead in such holding, in such a case, a homestead will be agricultural land. But in a case where the holding is recorded as bastu and the non-agriculture user is evident as appearing from the Revisional Record of Rights wherein it has been stated that there are two buts standing thereon, the land cannot be treated as agricultural lands to which the provisions of the Land Reforms Act will be applicable inasmuch as the Land Reforms Act applies only to agricultural lands. It was also held by His Lordship that under S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act if a portion or share of a holding of a raiyat is transferred to any person other than a co-shares in the holding, it is liable to be pre-empted under certain conditions by a raiyat possessing land adjoining such holding. The right of pre-emption is thus confined to portion or share of holding of the raiyat and not to any other kind of holding. Relying on the aforesaid decision Mr. Monomohan Mukherjee submitted that in the instant case it will appear from the Revisional Record of Rights that the land is Bastu land and there are residential structures on the said land and non-agricultural user is manifest from the nature of the land recorded in the Revisional Record of Rights. Mr. Mukherjee submitted that under certain circumstances the homestead may become agricultural lands if within the holding in question there era lands used for agricultural purpose or used in connection with agriculture but in the instant case the pre-emptor himself has stated in his evidence to the effect that lands appertaining to the holding in question are not used for agricultural purpose. Mr. Mukherjee submitted that a Bastu will not ipso facto become a homestead within the meaning of the Land Reforms Act and as such an agricultural land simply because the person holding a there in the bastu also holds land in some other holding for agricultural purpose. Mr. Mukherjee also submitted that is the user on the rate of vesting which will determine the nature of land for the purpose of West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act as was held by this Court in the aforesaid case of Misrl Shaw Shaw Mr. Mukherjee submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case when admittedly no land appertaining to the holding in question was used for agricultural purpose the land in question cannot be held to be an agricultural land and as such the application for pre-emption under S. 8 of the Land Reforms Act must fail and no interference is called in this Rule.

    4. Mr. Saktinath Mukherjee, the learned Counsel for the petitioner in reply to the said contention, however, submitted that for becoming a raiyat it is not necessary to became owner of a land but a person may become raiyat if he holds land for agricultural purpose and he submitted that if a raiyat holds some lands for agricultural purpose and he has also a homestead the said homestead becomes agricultural land within the meaning of S. 2(1) of the Land Reforms Act. He submitted that it is not necessary that the lands appertaining to the holding in question should be held for agricultural purposes

    5. After considering the submissions of the respective Counsels appearing for the parties it appears to me that a homestead ipso facto is not an agricultural land. It is only under special circumstances, a homestead may become an agricultural land provided the lands comprising the holding where the homestead appertains are also used for agricultural purpose. I am unable to accept the contention made by Mr. Saktinath Mukherjee that even if a raiyat holds other lands for agricultural purpose in a different holding, a homestead appertaining to another holding not used for agricultural purpose will also become an agricultural land within the meaning of S. 2(1) of the Land Reforms Act. Mr. Monomohan Mukherjee the learned Counsel appearing for the opposite party is justified in contending when the pre-emptor petitioner has clearly admitted that no portion of the land comprising the holding wherein ‘bastu’ appertains is used for agricultural purpose and as such the homestead or bastu in question cannot be held to be an agricultural land simply because the pre-emptor petitioner holding the bastu also holds some other land appertaining to a different holding for agricultural purpose. In my view, in the facts of the case, the principle in Eyachhin Ali Naskar's case fully applies and I respectfully agree with the view made in the said case Accordingly, this Rule fails and is dismissed but I make no order as to costs.

    Rule discharged.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kamaleswar Singha v. Bijoli Bhattacharjee & Ors.
    (Nov 14, 1979)