1. The petitioner Pratic Kumar Sen, claiming to be the Proprietor of the Sea King Shipping Agency, submitted an application on October 1, 1981 to the Collector of Customs, Calcutta for the grant of Customs House Clearing Agents Licence under Section 146 of the Customs Act, 1962. A copy of this application is Annexure ‘C’ to the petition.
2. In reply to the aforesaid application the petitioner received a letter dated February 10, 1982, from the Assistant Collector of Customs (Establishment and Ad ministration), Calcutta informing him that it would not be possible to consider another ap plication for a Clearing Agents Licence from him inasmuch as it is seen from the records that the petitioner is already holding a valid Clearing Agents Licence.
3. A copy of this letter which is Annexure ‘D’ to the petition is the subject-matter of challenge in this Rule.
4. Mr. DN. Das appearing on behalf of the petitioner submits that the impugned letter is in fact order of the Collector of Customs refusing the prayer of the petitioner for the grant of Clearing Agents Licence on extraneous considerations. According to Mr. Das the petitioner does not hold any Clearing Agents Licence in his own name but he is a partner of a firm, namely, Messrs Orient Transport Company, which holds a Clearing Agents Licence. As such, the petitioner in his personal capacity is entitled to hold another licence.
5. Mr. SK. Mitra, appearing on behalf of the Customs Authorities has drawn my attention to paragraph 6 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by Mr. Lipika Majumdar, Assistant Collector of Customs, Establishment and Administration, Calcutta, on April 8, 1982. In paragraph 6 of the said affidavit it has been stated as follows:—
In the course of scrutiny of the petitioner's application it was observed that the petitioner was, and still is authorised to transact business at the Calcutta Customs House since 29.5.1962 as a partner of the firm M/s. Orient Transport Company. As the petitioner was already and still is transacting business as a Custom House Agent it was informed to him that his application could not be considered.
6. Therefore, according to Mr. Mitra inasmuch as the petitioner is in fact transacting business as a Customs House Clearing Agent as a partner of the Orient Transport Company he is not entitled to the grant of another licence in his personal capacity.
7. It appears from the averments made in the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent No. 2 and which has been quoted above that the petitioner was not holding a licence in his personal name but he-was working as a Customs Clearing Agent in his capacity as a partner of the firm of Messrs Orient Transport Company. Under the circumstances the statement made by the Assistant Collector of Customs in her letter dated February 10, 1982, is not factually correct. As such, I allow this application and direct the respondent No. 2 not to give effect to the impugned letter, with liberty tothe Customs Authorities to issue a fresh order in accordance with law the Rule is, therefore, made absolute to the extent indicated above without any order as to costs.