Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1) and clause (d) and (h) of sub-section (2) of Section 62 of the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915
  • provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as, Rules of 1995)
  • Section 18 of Excise Act, 1915 or the Rules, viz, M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995.
  • Section 18(1) of 1915 Act and Rule 3(1) of the Rules of 11 1995,
  • provisions of Section 18 of 1915 Act and the Rules 1995,
  • Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995. These Rules
  • Madhya Pradesh. Rule 3(1) of the Rules 1995
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 18 of 1915 Act
  • Madhya Pradesh Distillery Rules, 1995.
  • Excise Act 1915 and Rules of 1995.
  • Rule 3 of Rules of 1995.
  • M.P. Excise Act 1915
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1) and clause (d) and (h) of sub-section (2) of Section 62 of the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915
  • provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as, Rules of 1995)
  • Section 18 of Excise Act, 1915 or the Rules, viz, M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995.
  • Section 18(1) of 1915 Act and Rule 3(1) of the Rules of 11 1995,
  • provisions of Section 18 of 1915 Act and the Rules 1995,
  • Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995. These Rules
  • Madhya Pradesh. Rule 3(1) of the Rules 1995
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 18 of 1915 Act
  • Madhya Pradesh Distillery Rules, 1995.
  • Excise Act 1915 and Rules of 1995.
  • Rule 3 of Rules of 1995.
  • M.P. Excise Act 1915
Smart Summary

High Court of Madhya Pradesh — W.P. No. 6525/2018

Date of judgment: 21/03/2018. Bench: Sanjay Yadav and Ashok Kumar Joshi, JJ.

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by Gwalior Distilleries Pvt. Ltd. (petitioner) challenging the validity of sub-clause (i) of Clause 2 of a notification dated 03/02/2018 which invited sealed tenders for supply of country spirit in sealed bottles in 51 districts of Madhya Pradesh for the period 1 April 2018 to 31 March 2019. The impugned clause required that "the tenderer must be licencee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in the State of Madhya Pradesh."

The tender related to grant of licence(s) under the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995 to supply country spirit through bonded storage warehouses to retail sale contractors. The petitioner is a private limited company holding a D-1 licence (under the Madhya Pradesh Distillery Rules, 1995) engaged in manufacturing spirit. The petitioner contended that because it does not hold a C.S.1 licence (for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply under the Country Spirit Rules, 1995), the impugned tender condition renders it ineligible to tender and is therefore unlawful.

The petition sets out prior administrative and judicial events in the petitioner’s history: intervention in Writ Appeal No. 670/2007 permitting an application which led to a Letter of Intent in 2010; a show cause notice and related Writ Petition No. 5684/2015 disposed of on 21/09/2015 with liberty to reply; and reference to an earlier Writ Petition (No. 5216/2015) by another party that led to issuance of a B-3 licence after litigation. The State/respondents supported the impugned clause as consistent with the Excise Act, 1915 and the Country Spirit Rules, 1995.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether sub-clause (i) of Clause 2 of the tender notification dated 03/02/2018 — which requires that the tenderer be a licensee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in Madhya Pradesh — is valid under the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915 and the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995.
  2. Whether the impugned stipulation is arbitrary or violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India, as contended by the petitioner.
  3. Whether, under the scheme of the Country Spirit Rules, 1995 and Section 18 of the Excise Act, 1915, a prospective tenderer must already hold a C.S.1 licence (manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply) to be eligible to bid, given the petitioner's position that C.S.1 licence is contingent on area allotment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner, holding a D-1 licence under Madhya Pradesh Distillery Rules, 1995, is ineligible to participate in the 03/02/2018 tender because it does not hold a C.S.1 licence under the Country Spirit Rules, 1995.
  • Under the scheme of the Country Spirit Rules, 1995, a C.S.1 licence for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply is dependent on allotment of an area; therefore the tender condition requiring an existing C.S.1 licence conflicts with Rule 3 of the Rules of 1995.
  • The impugned condition was not part of eligibility criteria in earlier years (2011–2018), when intending distillers could tender for districts without possessing a wholesale licence; the new stipulation arbitrarily excludes new distillers like the petitioner.
  • The clause is arbitrary and violates Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution by depriving those who do not possess a wholesale licence from participating in the auction proceedings.
  • Factual history of earlier judicial/interim relief (Writ Appeal No. 670/2007, Letter of Intent 2010, Writ Petition No. 5684/2015) is relied upon to show the petitioner’s long-standing attempts to obtain licences and participate in the industry.

Respondents' (State's) Position

  • The State supported the impugned clause, contending that the requirement is in consonance with statutory provisions under the Excise Act, 1915 and the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995 and thus permissible.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the impugned tender condition by reference to the statutory framework under the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915 and the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995. It noted that the Country Spirit Rules, 1995 were framed under Section 62 of the Excise Act, 1915 and apply to manufacture, bottling, supply, transport, import, export and sale of country spirit in Madhya Pradesh.

The court summarised relevant statutory provisions:

  • Chapter IV of the Excise Act, 1915 deals with manufacture, possession and sale of intoxicants.
  • Section 13 requires licences for manufacture or bottling of intoxicants.
  • Section 14 empowers establishment or licensing of distilleries and warehouses by the Excise Commissioner.
  • Section 17 requires a licence for sale of intoxicants.
  • Section 18(1) expressly empowers the State Government to lease, to any person and on such conditions as it thinks fit, rights "of manufacturing, or of supplying by wholesale or of both" within any specified area.
The court quoted Sub-section (1) of Section 18 to show the State's competence to issue individual or composite licences for manufacture and/or wholesale supply.

The court further referred to Rule 3(1) of the Country Spirit Rules, 1995, which provides the procedure for grant of a C.S.1 licence for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply — stating that such a licence may be granted by the Excise Commissioner after approval of the State Government, specifying commencement date, period and area(s), and prescribing the fee and security deposit.

Applying these provisions, the court reasoned:

  • Because Section 18(1) permits the State to issue licences for manufacturing and/or wholesale supply (including composite licences), the State is within its competence to prescribe a tender condition that tenderers must be licencees for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in Madhya Pradesh.
  • Rule 3(1) confirms the statutory recognition and procedure for a C.S.1 licence for such activities, which aligns with the tender stipulation.
  • The petitioner's contention that a C.S.1 licence cannot exist prior to area allotment — and therefore the tender condition is inconsistent with the Rules — was held not to be borne out by Section 18 or the Rules themselves.

On this basis, the court concluded that the impugned clause, when tested against Section 18(1) of the Excise Act, 1915 and Rule 3(1) of the Rules, 1995, could not be said to be in violation of those provisions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the impugned condition in clause 2(i) of the tender notice dated 03/02/2018 is in consonance with Section 18 of the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915 and Rule 3(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995. Consequently, the petition was dismissed.

Petition dismissed

Implications

  • Direct effect on parties: The tender condition requiring that tenderers be licensees for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply (C.S.1 licence) stands validated; the petitioner’s challenge to that condition failed and the petitioner remains unable, under the impugned tender condition, to participate by virtue of not holding a C.S.1 licence.
  • No broader precedent or new legal principle was announced beyond the court's application of Section 18(1) of the Excise Act, 1915 and Rule 3(1) of the Rules, 1995 to uphold the tender stipulation. The opinion does not discuss wider policy implications beyond the determination that the impugned clause is lawful under the cited statutory provisions.

Judges: Sanjay Yadav and Ashok Kumar Joshi, JJ. Result: Petition dismissed on the grounds stated above.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gwalior Distilleries Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of M.P.

    THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH W.P. No. 6525/2018 Gwalior Distilleries Pvt. Ltd. The State of Madhya Pradesh and others Gwalior, 21/03/2018 Shri D.P.S. Bhadoriya, learned counsel for the petitioner. Shri Yogesh Chaturvedi, learned Government Advocate for the respondents/State. Validity of sub-clause (i) of Clause 2 of the notification dated 03/02/2018 inviting tenders for supply of country spirit in sealed bottles in 51 districts of the State of Madhya Pradesh is being questioned vide this petition. The impugned clause stipulates निविदादाता को आसवर्क डिस्टलर होना चाहिए, जिसके पास अनिवार्यतः आसवनी डिस्टलरी एवं देशी स्प्रिट के विनिर्माण, बोतल भराई एवं थोक प्रदाय हेतु मध्यप्रदेश का उपयुक्त लायसेंस हो। (The tenderer must be licencee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in the State of Madhya Pradesh). The tender notice, as evident therefrom, invited sealed tenders for each district of State of Madhya Pradesh for grant of licence(s) under the provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as, Rules of 1995) to supply country spirit through bonded storage warehouses to the retail sale contractors in sealed bottles for a period commencing 1st April 2018 to 31st March, 2019. The petitioner, a private limited company, registered under the provisions of Companies Act, holder of D-1 licence engaged in the business of manufacturing the spirit being ineligible to participate in the tender process because of the impugned stipulation in the tender conditions, has filed this petition challenging its validity. It is contended that as per the scheme of the Rules of 1995, unless an area is first allotted, the CS-1 licence under Rule 3(1) of 1995 is not allotted. Therefore, stipulation in the tender that the applicant must be licencee for manufacturing, bottling & wholesale supply of country spirit is contrary to the Rules of 1995. It is further contended that earlier for the years 2011-12, 2012-13, 2013-14, 2014-15, 2015-16, 2016-17 & 2017-18, no such condition as find mention in clause 2(i) of the tender notice was laid down. It is urged that in these years, the eligibility criteria was that every intending distiller is free to tender for any one or more supply districts. Thus, there was no necessity for the distillers to have a licence for wholesale supply also. It is further contended that having inserted the second part of clause 2(i) that the tenderer shall be a distillers who shall necessarily have licence for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in the State of Madhya Pradesh, is contrary to the Rule 3 of Rules of 1995. It is contended that the licence in the shape of CS-1 is required for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit. Whereas, licence in form of CS-1-B is required for the bottling of country spirit. It is urged that in case if the distiller does not succeed in the tender process, no areas is allotted to him and as such he will be deprived of grant of CS-1 licence and even if the distiller succeeded but different area(s) is allotted to him, in such situation the CS-1 licence issued of earlier years cannot be held to be valid. It is accordingly contended that insertion of requirement to have licence for wholesale supply is arbitrary, violative and in violation of Article 14 & 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. It is contended that the impugned clause has been inserted to eliminate the new distillers like the petitioner, who earlier had applied for seeking licence in the form of D-1 for establishing a unit. However, it was because of intervention of the Court and order passed in Writ Appeal No. 670/2007 on 12/11/2007 that the petitioner was allowed to file an application for grant of licence which was directed to be considered on its own merit. Consequence thereof the respondents issued the Letter of Intent to the petitioner in the year 2010. It is urged that subsequently a show cause notice was issued to the petitioner which was challenged in the Writ Petition No. 5684/2015 which was disposed of on 21/09/2015 with a liberty to the petitioner to file a comprehensive reply to the show cause notice and direction to the respondents to take decision thereon. It is further contended that one Writ Petition was filed before this Court by one M/s Himalayan Ales Pvt Ltd. i.e. Writ Petition No. 5216/2015, for grant of B-3 licence (brewery licence). The said Writ Petition, it is urged, was allowed on 16/09/2015, whereagainst a Writ Appeal (W.A. No. 318/2015) filed by the State of Madhya Pradesh was dismissed on 14/01/2016. Consequence whereof, the respondents were directed to issue B-3 licence to the M/s Himalayan Ales Pvt. Ltd. Forthwith. In nutshell, the case of the petitioner is that the stipulations brought in vogue by inserting second part of clause 2(i) of tender notice, all such contenders who do not possess the wholesale licence are deprived to participate in the auction proceedings. Respondent on its turn has supported the clause. It is contended that the same is in consonance with the statutory provisions contained under the Excise Act 1915 and Rules of 1995. Considered the rival submissions. The tender notice as evident therefrom is issued by the State in exercise of its powers under the Madhya Pradesh Country Spirit Rules, 1995. These Rules are framed by the State Government in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) and clause (d) and (h) of sub-section (2) of Section

    62 of the Madhya Pradesh Excise Act, 1915 and apply to manufacture, bottling, supply, transport, import, export and sale of country spirit in Madhya Pradesh. Chapter IV of the M.P. Excise Act 1915 deals with manufacture; possession and sale of intoxicants. Section 13 envisages that no intoxicant shall be manufactured; no liquor shall be bottled for sale, no person shall use, keep or have in his possession any materials, still, utensils, implement or apparatus whatsoever for the purpose of manufacturing any intoxicant except under the authority and subject to the terms and conditions of a licence granted in that behalf. Section 14 provides for establishment or licensing of distilleries and warehouses. It stipulates that the Excise Commissioner may- (a) establish a distillery in which spirit may be manufactured under a licence granted under Section 13 on such conditions as the State Government may impose; (b) discontinue any such distillery; (c) licence, on such conditions as the State Government may impose, the construction and working of a distillery or brewery; (d) establish or licence a warehouse, wherein any intoxicant may be deposited and kept without payment of duty, but subject to payment of such fee as the State Government may direct; and (e) discontinue any such warehouse. Section 17 makes a provision regarding licence for sale of intoxicant. It stipulates that no intoxicant shall be sold except under the authority and subject to the terms and conditions of licence granted. Section 18 empowers the State Government to lease to any person, on such conditions and for such period as it may think fit, the right of manufacturing, or of supplying by wholesale or of both, or of selling by wholesale or by retail, or of manufacturing or of supplying by wholesale, or of both, and selling by retail, any liquor or intoxicating drug within a specified area. Sub-section (1) of Section 18 of 1915 Act stipulates:-

    (1) The State Government to lease to any person, on such conditions and for such period as it may think fit, the right- (a) of manufacturing, or of supplying by wholesale or of both, or (b) of selling by wholesale or by retail, (c) of manufacturing or of supplying by wholesale, or of both, and selling by retail, any liquor or intoxicating drug within any specified area.
    Thus, it is within the competence of the State Government to issue individual licence either for manufacturing or of supplying by wholesale or composite licence of both and selling by retail. Thus, if it is within the competence of the State Government to issue a composite licence under Sub-section (1) of Section 18 of 1915 Act, it is within its jurisdiction to lay down such condition in the tender for supply of country spirit in sealed bottle that tenderer must be licencee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in the State of Madhya Pradesh. Rule 3(1) of the Rules 1995 provides for the procedure for grant of licence for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit. It stipulates:-
    3(1)(a) A licence in from C.S. 1 for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit may be granted by the Excise Commissioner after approval of the State Government. It shall commence on such date as may be specified therein and be in force for such period as the State Government may decide and shall be for such area or areas as may be determined by the Excise Commissioner from time to time. (b) Licence in form C.S.1 shall be granted by the Excise Commissioner as aforesaid on payment of fee in advance at the rate of 1,50,000 rupees (Rupees one lac and fifty thousand) for a period of one year's licence or such proportional amount of fees for the period of licence to be granted. The licensee shall be required to deposit security deposit as fixed by the Excise Commissioner in cash or in any, other form as may be directed by the Excise Commissioner for the due observance of conditions of licence, provisions of the Act and the rules made thereunder and orders issued by the State Government or Excise Commissioner. The Excise Commissioner may ask for additional sum as security deposit as and when he deems it necessary in circumstances of repeated breaches of conditions or increase in area of supply and the licensee shall comply with such order within 15 days of its communication to him.
    In view whereof, when the stipulations contained in clause 2(i) of the tender notice dated 03/02/2018 which stipulates that the tenderer must be a licencee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country liquor in the State of Madhya Pradesh, is tested on the anvil of Section 18(1) of 1915 Act and Rule 3(1) of the Rules of 1995, the same cannot be said to be in violation thereof. Petitioner admittedly does not have the licence in form CS-1 but holds D-1 licence under the Madhya Pradesh Distillery Rules, 1995. Thus he does not possess any licence under the M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995, contention that unless an area is allotted the petitioner cannot have licence under the Country Spirit Rules, 1995 is not borne out from Section 18 of Excise Act, 1915 or the Rules, viz, M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995. Since the condition No. 2(i) of the tender notice dated 03/02/2018 is in consonance with the provisions of Section 18 of 1915 Act and the Rules 1995, we find no substance in the challenge. Consequently, petition fails and is dismissed. (Sanjay Yadav) (Ashok Kumar Joshi) Judge Judge shubh*

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gwalior Distilleries Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of M.P.
    (Mar 21, 2018)