Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter called the Code)
  • section 91 of the Code.2.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter called the Code)
  • section 91 of the Code.2.
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — C.M. Prasad, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant filed a petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 seeking to set aside the order dated 24.1.2004 of the Special Judge, C.B.I., South Bihar in Special Case No. 7 of 1997 (R.C. 8(A)/97). The impugned order rejected the petitioner's request, made under section 91 of the Code, to summon certain documents while witness P.W.2 was being cross-examined by the prosecution.

At trial, P.W.2 (an accountant) had come to prove signatures and to file papers and registers of his office. During cross-examination the petitioner sought production of specified documents for proper cross-examination. The Trial Court refused the application on the basis that P.W.2 had no concern with the letters and documents sought, and observed that the petitioner could call for those documents at the defence stage if necessary. The petitioner challenged that refusal before the High Court under section 482.

Documents sought by the petitioner (as pleaded):

  1. Specimen signatures sent by the accused (Ramanup Prasad, Executive Engineer) to Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Bharat Petroleum Ltd., and Indian Oil Corporation (addresses specified).
  2. Authorisation letter No. Camp-1, Patna dated 8.11.1995 and letter No. 731 dated 8.9.1994, sent by Ramanup Prasad to Hindustan Petroleum Corporation, Patna.
  3. Stock Register of Division No. 1, Road Construction Department, Jehanabad for years 1994–95 and 1995–96.
  4. File No. IG-2-91 for the years 1994–95 and 1995–96 from the office of the Executive Engineer, R.C.D. Division No. 1, Jehanabad.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court erred in rejecting the petition under section 91 of the Code for production of documents while P.W.2 was being cross-examined.
  2. What degree of specificity and showing of relevancy or bearing must an applicant make to obtain production of documents under section 91 (or the analogous powers under section 94 of the old Code) at a particular stage of proceedings?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The documents listed in the petition were necessary for proper cross-examination of P.W.2.
  • The Trial Court rejected the petitioner's prayer without assigning any reason.
  • During the hearing in the High Court the petitioner relied on authorities (cited in the petition) supporting calling for documents to vindicate innocence or to enable proper cross-examination.

Respondent (C.B.I.) Arguments

  • The Trial Court did assign a reason: P.W.2 was merely an accountant who proved signatures and filed office papers and registers and had no relation with the letters and documents sought to be called for.
  • The documents listed in the petition lack context and specific relevance to P.W.2: (a) the purpose or context for the specimen signatures is not explained; (b) the context and connection of the authorisation letters to P.W.2 is not shown; (c) the stock registers do not disclose what articles they record (e.g., bitumen, iron), nor how P.W.2 relates to them; (d) the file sought does not disclose context or relevance to cross-examination of P.W.2.
  • The petitioner was unable to clarify the specific relevancy of the listed documents to P.W.2's evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Sharan etc. v. C.B.I. Documents sought to prove innocence may be called for, but timing and stage (e.g., before framing of charge) matter; Trial Court indicated documents would be called at recording of evidence. Court noted this decision showing that courts may permit production at an appropriate stage; not an absolute right to immediate production during cross-examination.
Om Prakash Sharma v. C.B.I., Delhi Trial Court can reject prayer under section 91 after considering nature, bearing and relevance of documents; higher courts may uphold such rejection. Cited to support the discretion of Trial Court to refuse production when documents lack demonstrated relevance to the witness or case.
C.M. Arunugam v. The State of Mysore Section 94 (old Code) invested courts with discretionary power to exercise production powers at any stage. Used to emphasize the discretionary nature of production powers (analogous to section 91) rather than a mandatory right of the accused.
Gyatri Bais v. The State of M.P. Applicant must satisfy the Court that production is necessary in interest of justice; Court must consider whether document is necessary to find out truth regarding guilt or innocence. Adopted to require the petitioner to demonstrate bearing and relevancy of documents sought under section 91.
State of Kerala v. Babu Case diary in respect of the same statement of a witness in another case may be called for under section 91 (and not under section 172). Noted as a distinct factual situation; court referenced boundaries of section 91's application.
Dr. Raghotam v. The State of Andhra Pradesh A petition under section 94 (old Code) should be made even before framing of charge (contextual procedural guidance). Referenced as authority on the timing of applications, indicating some precedents expect early applications in the process.
Haricharan v. State of Punjab Rejection of request under section 94 without reasons can be improper; where nature of documents warranted it, High Court set aside Magistrate's order and ordered production. Cited by petitioner; court acknowledged that where rejection lacks reasons or documents demonstrably relevant, interference may be warranted — but found the present facts distinguishable.
Public Prosecutor, A.P v. Pockusyed @ Ismail Section 94 does not give an absolute right to an accused to summon documents; production is ordered only when court, considering facts and circumstances, finds it necessary or desirable for trial. Relied upon by Respondent to support that production is discretionary and contingent on necessity; applied to deny an absolute right to immediate production.
Bashir Hussain Peshimam v. Gulam Mohammad Ismail Peshimam Section can be invoked at any stage; words of the section confer discretion — production must be shown to be necessary or desirable and bear upon/relevant to the case. Adopted to underscore the discretionary test: production only when document has bearing/relevance; court applied this standard to the facts and found petitioner had not satisfied it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a fact-sensitive analysis focused on the nature of the witness (P.W.2), the nature and description of the documents sought, and the authorities on the exercise of production powers under section 91 (and analogous provisions under the old Code).

  1. Character of the witness: P.W.2 was an accountant of the Road Construction Department who had come to prove signatures and to file registers and papers of his office. The Trial Court found he had no connection with the letters and documents the petitioner sought to call for.
  2. Insufficiency of the petitioner's showing: The Court examined the petitioner's description of the documents in para 4(i)–(iv) and found no specificity was furnished to show how the signatures, authorisation letters, stock register or file bore upon P.W.2's evidence or were required for proper cross-examination of that witness.
  3. Responses highlighted by the respondent: The Standing Counsel pointed out concrete gaps in the petition — lack of context for specimen signatures, no disclosed connection between the authorisation letters and P.W.2, absence of specification regarding what the stock register recorded, and lack of contextual relevance for the file sought.
  4. Principles from precedents: The Court reviewed cited authorities and extracted the governing principles — production under section 91/section 94 is discretionary, not an absolute right; the applicant must satisfy the court that the documents are necessary or desirable for trial and that they bear upon or are relevant to the case; timing and stage of application are relevant considerations.
  5. Application of principles to facts: Applying the above, the Court concluded the petitioner had not established the requisite bearing or relevancy of the documents to P.W.2's evidence. Because the petitioner merely asserted that the documents were necessary for proper cross-examination without specifying the precise connection, the Court saw no basis to disturb the Trial Court's exercise of discretion.
  6. Conclusion of analysis: The Trial Court's decision to refuse production at that stage was held to be appropriate; accordingly, the High Court found no reason to interfere.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court dismissed the application under section 482 and dismissed the appeal, thereby upholding the Trial Court's order refusing to call for the documents under section 91 of the Code.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the Trial Court's refusal to summon the specific documents at the stage of P.W.2's cross-examination is sustained; the petitioner did not obtain immediate production of the documents sought.
  • The decision applies established principles that production under section 91 is discretionary and contingent on a showing that the documents have bearing or relevancy to the issues or the witness in question. The opinion does not purport to establish a new precedent beyond applying these settled principles to the facts of the case.

    Ramanup Prasad v. State Of Bihar

    C.M Prasad, J.:— The applicant has filed this petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter called the Code) praying for setting aside the order dated 24.1.2004 of the Special Judge C.B.I South Bihar, passed in Special Case No. 7 of the 1997.R.C. 8(A)/97 whereby the learned Special Judge has rejected the petitioner's prayer for calling for some documents under section 91 of the Code.

    2. From the impugned order it appears that witness P.W 2 was being examined by the prosecution and during cross-examination the petitioner filed a petition before the Trial Court calling for some documents and the reason for calling for those documents was stated to be proper cross-examination of the witness.

    3. The reason for rejecting the petitioner's prayers as mentioned by the Trial Judge was that the P.W 2 was an accountant who had only proved the signature of certain persons and had filed papers and registers of this office. P.W 2 had no concerned with the letters and documents intended to be called for by the petition. However the learned Trial Judge also observed that the petitioner will be given opportunity for calling for those documents at defence stage if it so requires.

    4. In paragraph 4 of the application the petitioner has mentioned the details of the documents which were required to be called for details are as follows:

    (i) Specimen signature which was sent by the accused Ramanup Pd., Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department Division I, Jehanabad from Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Boring Road Patna 800001, Bharat Petroleum Ltd., Exhibition Road, Patna, Indian Oil Corporation, Maurya Lok Complex, Dak Bunglow Road, Patna-800001.

    (ii) Authorisation letter No. Camp-1, Patna dated 8.11.1995 and letter No. 731 dated 8.9.1994, which was sent by Ramanup Prasad, Executive Engineer to Hindustan Petrolium Corporation, Patna.

    (iii) Stock Register of Division No. 1, Road Construction Department, Jehanabad in the years 1994-1995, 1995-1996 from Executive Engineer, Division No. 1, Road Construction Department. Jehanabad.

    (iv) File No. IG-2-91 of the year 1994 to 1995 and 1995 to 1996 from the office of the Executive Engineer, R.C.D Division No. 1, Jehanabad.

    5. The learned Counsel for the petitioner argued that the documents as mentioned above in petition are necessary for proper cross-examination of the P.W 2. He also submitted that while rejecting the petitioner's prayer the learned Court below has not assigned any reason for rejecting the prayer. The learned Standing Counsel for the C.B.I, replied that the learned Trial Court has already assigned the reasons that the P.W 2 has no concern with the letters and documents prayed to be called for by the petitioner. He further submitted that the simple reason on which the petitioner sought to call for the documents is proper cross-examination of the P.W 2 who is an accountant who had come to prove some signature of certain persons and has filed some papers and registers of his office and who had got no relation with the documents required to be called for. The learned Counsel for the petitioner simply submitted that the documents are necessary for the cross-examination of the P.W 2 but he was not able to clarify the specific relevancy of those documents with respect to the P.W 2.

    6. As to the details of the documents as mentioned in petitioner's petition before this Court the learned Standing Counsel pointed out that regarding the documents as mentioned in para 4(i) of the petition it is not clear as to in what context signatures required to be called for were made or kept. As to the documents mentioned in para 4(ii) he pointed out that the context of the authorisation letter sought to be called for is not disclosed nor it has been stated in what manner the P.W 2 was related to it. As to the stock register mentioned in paragraph 4(iii) the learned Counsel for the C.B.I, submitted that only stock register has been mentioned but it does not disclose the stock register of what article like bitumen, iron, machine, electrical goods or any other article nor it is shown as to in what manner the P.W 2 was related to that stock register. As to the file mentioned in paragraph 4(iv) of the petition the learned Standing Counsel pointed out that it is not disclosed as to in what context the file was maintained and how it is relevant for the cross-examination of the P.W 2.

    7. Considering the nature of documents and file as mentioned in paragraph 4(i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) of the petition I find that the petitioner has not been able to show at this stage as to in what context those signature, registers and file are relevant and how they are required for proper cross-examination of the P.W 2 who was an accountant of the R.C.D department and who had come to prove some signature and registered of the office.

    8. During the hearing the learned Counsel for the petitioner cited some decisions in support of his prayer for calling for the documents, in the case of M. Sharan etc. v. C.B.I,1 the petitioner had prayed for calling for some documents which according to the petitioner can prove innocence of the petitioner and the Trial Court held that petitioner's prayer cannot be accepted before framing of charges as the determination of the same would be done after full fledged trial and the application was allowed in a different manner indicating that the documents would be called for at the stage of recording of evidence. The M.P High Court upheld the order. In another case of Om Prakash Sharma v. C.B.I Delhi,2 the Trial Court had rejected the petitioner's prayer under section 91 of the Code for calling for some documents on considering the nature of the documents, their bearing and relevance. The High Court upheld the order and the Hon'ble Supreme Court also made no interference in that order. In the case of C.M Arunugam v. The State of Mysore,3 in a similar prayer made under section 94 of the old Code it was held that section 94 invests the Court with a discretionary power to exercise power at any stage. In the case of Gyatri Bais v. The State of M.P, a similar prayer was made under section 91 of the Code and the High Court held that it is for the Court to consider whether such documents is necessary for the purpose of finding out truth in the context with guilt of innocence of the accused and for that purpose the person who moved such an application has to satisfy the Court that such order is necessary to be issued in the interest of justice. In the case of State of Kerala v. Babu the facts were different and it was held that the case diary in respect of the same statement of witness in another case or trial can be called for under section 91 and not under section 172 of the Code. In the case of Dr. Raghotam v. The State of Andhra Pradesh a petition was filed under section 94 of the old Code and the High Court held that such a prayer should be made even before framing of the charge. In the case of Haricharan v. State of Punjab,4 which is lastly relied upon by the petitioner, the case was under section 94 of the old Code and the petitioner of that case had prayed for calling for some documents. The Magistrate concerned had rejected the prayer without assigning any reason. The High Court considering the nature of the documents had held that the rejection of the prayer made by the petitioner was not proper and set aside the order of the Magistrate and the High Court ordered for calling for those documents.

    9. Thus considering the principles of law as laid down in the above decisions as cited above by the petitioner. I find that while praying for calling for any document the petitioner has to satisfy about its bearing and relevancy showing that the documents are necessary to be called for. The learned Standing Counsel for the C.B.I, cited the decision in the case of the Public Prosecutor, A.P v. Pockusyed @ Ismail.5 In the case a similar prayer was made under section 94 of the old Code and the High Court field that section 94 does not give any absolute right to the accused to ask for summoning any documents. It is only when a Court on consideration of all the facts and circumstances, considers that the production of the document or thing sought for is necessary or desirable for the purpose of the trial, inquiry or proceedings it summons the same but not otherwise. In one another decision in the case of Bashir Hussain Peshimam v. Gulam Mohammad Ismail Peshimam.6 In a similar prayer made under section 94 of the Code the High Court held that the section can be invoked at any stage of any inquiry or investigation or trial as indicated by the word ‘whenever’ in the section, however the words “such Court may issue” clearly show that the section confers discretion upon the Court to order production of the documents or thing. Before the Court exercises this discretion it must satisfy that such production is either necessary or desirable for the trial. In testing this the Court has to exercise its discretion judicially and must satisfy that the document or thing as a bearing upon or is relevant to the case.

    10. Thus considering what has been held in the decisions as cited by the learned Counsel for the C.B.I, it is clear that the petitioner has got no absolute right to compel for production of any documents or thing which he wishes to be called for. No doubt the petitioner has got a right to make such a prayer under section 91 of the Code but in order to establish his claim for calling for such documents he has to establish that the documents have a bearing upon or is relevant to the case. In this instant case the petitioner has prayed for calling for the documents as mentioned in para 4(i) to (iv) of his petition during cross-examination of the P.W 3 on the ground that those documents were necessary for proper cross-examination of the witness. The petitioner could not clearly establish as to in what context the signatures and documents, required to be called for were, made or kept and as to what bearing the signature or documents had with respect to the evidence of P.W 2 and in what manner it was required for the cross-examination of the P.W 2. The petitioner simply stated that the documents were necessary for proper cross-examination of the witness. Due to the petitioner having not established as to in what context the signature or documents required to be called for were made or kept or in what specific manner it was necessary for the cross-examination of P.W 2. I feel that the learned Trial Court has rightly rejected the petitioner's prayer at this stage. Under the circumstances, I find no reason to interfere with the impugned order of the Trial Court. The application is accordingly dismissed.

    11. Appeal Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramanup Prasad v. State Of Bihar
    (Aug 17, 2004)