D.N Panda, Judicial Member:— The precise question in this appeal is whether the trading activity carried out by the appellant along with provision of taxable services of servicing of motor vehicle shall entitle the service provider to the Cenvat Credit of the taxes paid on services availed for trading as well as provision of taxable service in the light of the law before 01.04.2011 when there was no definition of “exempted services” under Rule 2(e) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004.
2. The appellant submits that there was no definition of the term “exempted services” under Rule 2(e) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004 encompassing trading activity to be exempt under such definition for which the Cenvat Credit of the service tax paid in respect of the services available for carrying out of combined activity of trading as well as provision of taxable services shall not disentitle the appellant to the Cenvat Credit in respect of such services for the period prior to 01.04.2011 He further says that following the ratio laid down in the case of UOI v. MARTIN LOTTERY AGENCIES LTD., 2009 (14) S.T.R 593 (S.C) the explanation added to the above Rule shall have prospective application but not applicable retrospectively.
3. Ld. DR on the other hand, says that the explanation being clarificatory in character and that not being declaratory in nature shall have with retrospective application without being prospectively applicable. Law is well settled that statutory provision incorporated into law is declaratory in nature, shall always have a prospective application whereas a clarificatory amendment shall have retrospective application. In common law, trading is not understood as provision of service Legislature was conscious for no levy of service tax on trading as is evident from the scheme of law relating to taxability of service. Finance Act, 1994 has never intended commodity to be taxed under the provisions thereof. Trading activity was all along exempted from service tax. But for the purpose of clarification, an express provision has been incorporated through explanation in Rule 2(e) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004. Rule is subordinate to the basic legislation. Therefore, does not defeat the object of the levy.
4. Against the above proposition of law by Revenue, appellant seeks time to prepare.
5. Considering the difficulties of the appellant to defend today on the interpretation of the statutue, the matter is adjourned to 03.08.2017