AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 (hereinafter called the Act)
  • provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1)
  • provisions of Section 3(4) read with Section 3(1)
  • Rule 26 of the CCI Regulations, 2009.
  • Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1)
  • provision of Section 3(3)(d)
  • COMPETITION ACT 2002
  • Section 3(3)(d).19.
  • Section 3(3)(d),
  • Section 27(b),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 (hereinafter called the Act)
  • provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1)
  • provisions of Section 3(4) read with Section 3(1)
  • Rule 26 of the CCI Regulations, 2009.
  • Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1)
  • provision of Section 3(3)(d)
  • COMPETITION ACT 2002
  • Section 3(3)(d).19.
  • Section 3(3)(d),
  • Section 27(b),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of three appeals challenging a common order passed by the Competition Commission of India (CCI). The CCI held that the appellants—MDD Medical System India (P) Ltd. (MDD), PES Installations Ltd. (PES), and Medical Products Services (MPS)—had contravened provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 by engaging in bid rigging related to the supply, installation, testing, and commissioning of Modular Operation Theatre (MOT) and Medical Gases Manifold System (MGMS) at the Sports Injury Centre (SIC), Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi. Penalties were imposed on all three appellants under Section 27 of the Act.

The case originated from information filed by an NGO, Foundation for Common Cause & People Awareness, alleging bid rigging in the tender floated by Hospital Services Consultancy Corporation Limited (HSCC) on behalf of Safdarjung Hospital. The tender combined MOT and MGMS works, allegedly to exclude specialized firms and limit competition. It was further alleged that the three appellants colluded in the tender process, submitting bids with common typographical errors and other indicia of coordination, including bid rotation and complementary bids. The CCI initiated an investigation through its Director General (DG), who submitted a report confirming collusion among the appellants.

The appellants denied the allegations, justifying the combined tender and rejecting charges of cartelization. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare also submitted a reply supporting the tender process and sought deletion from array of parties. The CCI framed two issues, but the second issue regarding Section 3(4) was not pursued against the appellants in this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants contravened the provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 by indulging in bid rigging in the supply and installation of MOT and MGMS at SIC, Safdarjung Hospital?
  2. Whether the dealership agreement between Stryker India Pvt. Limited and PES violated the provisions of Section 3(4) read with Section 3(1) of the Act?

Issue No. 2 is not considered in this appeal as the appellants were exonerated by the CCI on that account.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants denied bid rigging and cartelization allegations.
  • MDD argued that the combined tender was justified due to urgency related to the Commonwealth Games and to avoid delay and increased costs.
  • They contended that there was no mandatory requirement of minimum three bids and that MPS's bid could not be considered merely complementary or token.
  • They challenged the CCI's inference from common typographical errors and identical percentage rates quoted by PES and MPS, arguing that identical percentages do not prove collusion.
  • The appellants criticized the imposition of penalty without separate opportunity to address the issue and the lack of reasons for fixing penalty at 5% of average turnover.
  • They contended that turnover relevant for penalty should be limited to sales related to government hospital tenders, excluding private hospital sales.
  • They argued that PES and MPS should not be treated on par with MDD as only MDD was awarded the contract.

CCI's Position

  • The CCI found prima facie and concluded after investigation that the appellants engaged in bid rigging violating Section 3(3)(d) of the Act.
  • The CCI relied on evidence including common typographical errors, identical percentage rates in bids, bid rotation, and complementary bids to establish collusion.
  • The CCI rejected the appellants' explanations about common errors being due to use of a common cyber cafe.
  • CCI imposed penalties at 5% of average turnover without detailed reasons but justified the penalty based on the serious nature of cartelization and bid rigging.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Hindustan Development Corporation (1993) 3 SCC 499 Examination of validity of tender process and suspicion of cartelization based on identical pricing and post-tender conduct. The court distinguished the present case from this precedent, noting that suspicion alone is insufficient but here multiple factors including typographical errors and bid patterns supported the inference of collusion.
Hindustan Steel Ltd. v. State Of Orissa, (1969) 2 SCC 627 Discretion in penalty imposition requires consideration of aggravating and mitigating circumstances and judicial exercise of discretion. The court held that CCI failed to give reasons for penalty quantum, violating principles laid down in this precedent.
Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496 Necessity of giving reasons in quasi-judicial orders to ensure objectivity and enable appellate review. The court emphasized that CCI’s failure to provide reasons for penalty percentage rendered the exercise of discretion arbitrary and unjustified.
A.K Kraipak v. Union of India (1969) 2 SCC 262 Blurring distinction between administrative and quasi-judicial orders; requirement of reasoned orders in exercise of discretion. Referred to as foundational authority supporting the need for reasoned quasi-judicial decisions, relevant to CCI’s penalty order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the factual matrix, investigation report, and submissions of the parties. It found the CCI’s conclusion on bid rigging under Section 3(3)(d) to be well founded based on multiple circumstances: the combined tender which excluded specialized bidders, amendments to tender conditions favoring appellants, common typographical and clerical errors in bids indicating coordination, identical percentage rates quoted by PES and MPS for maintenance contracts, and the pattern of bid rotation with PES submitting a deliberately high losing bid to enable MDD to win.

The court rejected appellants’ explanations regarding the common errors and use of a common cyber cafe as implausible given the stakes involved. It also rejected the argument that MPS’s bid was not complementary, holding that the identical percentages and other evidence supported the inference of collusion.

The court distinguished the cited Supreme Court precedent on cartel suspicion, noting that here the evidence was stronger and more varied.

Regarding penalty, the court held that while the appellants had opportunity to argue on penalty, the CCI failed to give reasons for fixing penalty at 5% of average turnover, rendering the penalty arbitrary. The court emphasized the need to consider aggravating and mitigating factors, including the nascent stage of competition law in India, the fact that this was a first-time contravention, and the timely completion of the project of national importance.

Accordingly, the court reduced the penalty rate from 5% to 3% of average turnover for all appellants, maintaining parity among them. The court rejected appellants’ arguments to limit turnover to government hospital supplies or to differentiate between them on penalty quantum, holding that all acted in concert.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision is as follows:

The appeals are disposed of by modifying the penalty imposed by the CCI from 5% to 3% of the average turnover of the last three years for each appellant.

The penalties imposed on PES, MPS, and MDD are accordingly reduced and the appellants are directed to deposit the modified penalty amounts within 90 days of receipt of the order.

No new precedent is set beyond affirming the CCI’s finding of contravention of Section 3(3)(d) of the Competition Act, 2002 and emphasizing the requirement of reasoned orders when imposing penalties. The decision underscores the importance of examining multiple circumstantial evidence to infer collusion and the necessity of judicially exercising discretion in penalty determination.

    Mdd Medical Systems India Private Limited v. Foundation For Common Cause & People Awareness B-203

    Mr. V.S Sirpurkar, Chairman:— This judgment shall govern and dispose of the three appeals namely - (i) Appeal No 93/2012 filed by one MDD Medical System India (P) Ltd. (hereinafter called “MDD” or the “appellant” as the case may be) (ii) Appeal No. 94/2012 filed by PES Installations Ltd. (hereinafter called “PES” for short) and (iii) Appeal No. 95/2012 filed by Medical Products Services (hereinafter called “MPS” for short). In all the appeals a common order passed by the Competition Commission of India (hereinafter called the “CCI”) is challenged. By that order, CCI held that all the three appellants had contravened the provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 (hereinafter called the “Act”) by indulging in the process of bid rigging in the matter of supply and installation, testing and commissioning of Modular Operation Theatre (MOT for short) and Medical Gases Manifold System (MGMS) at Sports Injury Centre (SIC hereinafter), Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi. The CCI has also proceeded to inflict the penalty against all the three appellants under Section 27 of the Act. While in the case of MDD the penalty is Rs. 18,470,778/-, in the case of PES the penalty is Rs. 6,840,252/- and in the case of MPS the penalty is Rs. 4,784,188/-. The CCI, however, exonerated the PES of the contravention of Section 3(4) read with Section 3(1) of the Act. The only question to be decided by us, therefore, is whether the CCI was right in holding the contravention on the part of the these three appellants of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) and whether the penalties under Section 27 have been properly and legally inflicted.

    2. Following factual matrix will help understanding the controversy involved. An organization called Foundation for Common Cause & People Awareness filed an information under Section 19(1) of the Act on 17.8.2010 The informant is an NGO. In its information, it is alleged that there was bid rigging in the tender for supply, installation, testing and commissioning of MOT and MGMS for SIC, Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi. This tender was floated through Hospital Services Consultancy Corporation Limited (HSCC for short) which is a government Public Sector Undertaking on behalf of the hospital. In this information, it was alleged that the procurement process for MOT and MGMS for SIC was initiated in the 10 Project Monitoring Committee Meeting on 26.8.2009 chaired by the then Joint Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. The Committee expressed an opinion that smooth coordination between the two works was required though these were conventionally two different product segments. In a further meeting dated 28.8.2009 under the then Additional Director General and Medical Superintendent of the Hospital, Dr. Jagdish Prasad, it was recorded that in other hospitals like Goa Medical College, KEM Hospital, Mumbai and Institute of Liver and Biliary Sciences, New Delhi for smooth coordination, the work of MOT and MGMS was awarded as combined work for a single firm. The informant alleged that this information was not correct and was only used with a purpose to proceed with floating a tender for a combined work order. The informant further alleged that initially the budget at the time of the project conception was fixed as Rs. 85 lakh and Rs. 170 lakh respectively. However this budget was enhanced to Rs. 10 crore by clubbing the two works together and subsequently a combined tender for MOT and MGMS was floated by HSCC on 1.10.2009 According to the informant this combined work order for both MOT and MGMS caused exclusion of those companies which specialized in either of these two products from participation in the tender. Further allegation was that certain pre-qualification criteria were also incorporated which resulted in limiting the competition. According to the informant, further, all these steps enabled the firms named in the information to manipulate the entire tender process and for this influential government officials used their authority which ultimately resulted helping the manipulation of bidding process. It was pointed out that initially in the pre-bid meeting dated 12.10.2009, as many as 12 firms had participated wherein a protest was raised over the conditions in the tender documents by every single prospective bidder except by the firms represented by the appellants. It was expressed therein that because of the restrictive tender conditions there was a possibility of cartelization in the tender process. The firms were directed to submit their concerns and objections regarding the clauses in writing. It was pointed out in the information that in another meeting dated 22.10.2009 certain amendments were issued by HSCC. However, these amendments were also tailored to help the three appellants firms. It is then pointed out that three appellants submitted tenders in connivance with each other on 29.10.2009 It is charged that the bid was submitted by MPS only to show that there was good response in the tender process. It is pointed out that all the bidders had to enclose a manufacturer's authorization form as per the tender document condition. However, MDD did not enclose the authorization form from M/s. Stryker, USA, Tarkett Germany and others. Similarly MDS did not enclose proper authorization forms. Same complaint was about the PES also, that it did not enclose the important form from foreign manufacturer of Germany, France and India. According to the informant these deficiencies were overlooked and the bids of MDD and PES were favourably considered for evaluation. While the bid of MPS was rejected in the technical committee meeting held on 13.11.2009 It was alleged that the signatures of all the persons present during the bid opening on 29.9.2009 were not there on the cover page/envelop of the price bid of MDD which suggests that the price bid of MDD had been illegally replaced at a later date. It is further pointed out that on 16.11.2009 commercial evaluation of bids submitted by MDD and PES was carried out. It was further pointed out that the allocated budget for the project was Rs. 10 crores which in addition to MOT and MGMS works also included warranty for five years, comprehensive maintenance contract for five years and operational and running cost of 10 years from the date of installation. It was pointed out that MDD bid was lowest one (L1) was for Rs. 24,32,55,406.73/- and PES bid was for Rs. 35,24,98,545.27/- and since the bid of MDD was the lowest, it was awarded the contract. It is pointed out in the information that in the meeting dated 3.12.2009 there was misrepresentation of the fact on the justified infracted bid. It is pointed out that subsequent CMC cost for five years and operational and running cost for MOT and MGMS for ten years were never contemplated in the cost of the project whereas in the 10 PMC meeting dated 28.8.2009 these were actually considered. Some additional items like integration equipments, ducting for air-conditioning, humidifier and third party validation were also incorporated after pre-bid meeting in the tender, whereas the items like integration equipment and third party validation were also incorporated and were not added after pre-bid meeting. The informant alleges that the committee deviated from its original stand of purchasing equipments along with their operation and running cost for ten years and reduced it from ten years to five years. According to the informant, this was how the committee compromised with the life of crucial MSMS and MOT systems. Ultimately the final order was placed on MDD for Rs. 16,11,92,206.73 with reduced warranty and operations and maintenance charges for five years only. According to the informant, this was done with the sole intention to justify the cost at approximately Rs. 16.11 crore against the budget value of Rs. 10 crore. According to the informant MDD would be asked in future to undertake CMC and O&M for the next five years and finally the total cost of the project would be Rs. 24.32 crores only which was quoted by the MDD in its tender. The informant also alleged non-verification of the fact regarding the rates quoted by MDD. It is also submitted that ultimately contract was signed on 6.1.2010 and the terms of contract were also modified favouring the MDD vide letter dated 1.2.2010 which was authored by an Under Secretary of the Ministry. The payment terms were favourably changed and a number of conditions were given a go by. All this caused advantage to MDD. It was pointed out that the companies named in the information managed to submit the tenders and price bids in connivance with each other as that was evident from the fact that the bids of all the three companies appearing to have been prepared on a single computer. The font used for typing the bids was also same and there were several common mistakes and typographical errors also in the bid documents which only suggested meeting of minds between these three appellants. Thus, informant alleged that these three firms manipulated and rigged the tender process with the active support of government officials associated with the project. It was further alleged that they have indulged in cartelization and manipulation of bids in number of projects concerning other government hospitals also. It is clear that these companies with connivance with each other had rotated the bids in order to win the contracts in other projects amongst themselves thereby killing competition in the market in violation of the provisions of the Act.

    3. The CCI formulated prima facie opinion that there existed a prima facie case against the appellants and directed investigation by the Director General (DG) under Section 26(1) of the Act.

    4. The Director General submitted his report of investigation on 10.8.2011 For the purpose of investigation, technical and financial bids submitted by the three firms were looked into by the Director General. He also called from the various entities dealing in MOT, MGMS. He also took consideration of the submissions of SIC, Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi and enquires from the various other firms and submitted his report on the basis of his investigation. The investigation report suggested that SIC had clubbed the tender for procurement of both MOT and MGMS as the project was a turnkey project. It was shown that though one Karl Storz had also purchased the bid document, it did not furnish the bid. It was found that bid of MPS was rejected on the ground that it did not meet the qualifying criteria in terms of annual turnover and experience of completing one similar project during the last three years. Ultimately two bidders i.e PES and MDD remained in the competition. The Director General pointed out several irregularities in the matter such, as these bidders were having common authorization from only one principal namely Stryker India which amounted to violation of the specified terms and conditions of the tender. According to the Director General's investigation it was revealed that MDD had requested Stryker India for its authorization and since PES was the exclusive distributor in India, it was decided that MDD would be authorized for the SIC tender on behalf of Stryker but it would be routed through PES. In fact according to the DG, there was some kind of mutual understanding between the two as both claimed through Stryker India of which PES was the exclusive distributor. Thus MDD was, technically, not qualified as it was not having the manufacturers' authorization for integration nor was it having five years experience with the principal. The Director General also submitted that the fact that MDD did not have requisite experience was well known to PES but it did not object since this would have resulted in disqualification of MDD. In fact, Stryker's certification which enabled MDD to quote in SIC tender was routed through PES itself. Thus, PES and MDD were not actual competitors but collaborators which would establish the collusion between the PES and MDD. The Director General also found that actual installation of Stryker integrated devices was undertaken by PES only which fact was accepted by PES in its statement. Thus according to the DG, this would establish that there was bid rigging scheme and for that PES deliberately submitted a losing bid and allowed MDD to win the bid because ultimately it seems that installation was done by PES only. The Director General also reported that there were various common typographical errors and identical typographic mistakes in the financial quotations which showed that these were typed or filled at the same place and this also established that the three bidders acted in concert while filling and submitting the financial bids of the tender. These three firms explained the common typographical mistakes and common computer used on the ground that there was shortage of time for submitting the tender and that price schedule submitted which showed these common mistakes was complicated as there were 75 items which needed to be indicated in the price schedule the three competing firms thought it convenient to get it typed from the nearby computer cafe; and hence there were common mistakes. The DG, however, concluded that these claims and explanations were hardly satisfactory as all these formats were already available on their website right from the time of inception of the tender. According to the DG the similarity in the price schedule format was on account of mutual consultation with each other which clearly reflected that there was meeting of minds and collusive action. According to the DG there was patent contravention of Section 3(3) of the Act. Further according to the DG, PES had inflated its price though it was exclusive dealer of Stryker for installation of the integrated device and one of the major players in the MOT and MGMS. Its price was much higher than MDD which was to get the installation done by PES only. It was observed that the PES had a motive that the tender should be awarded in favour of MDD and it therefore gave a bid much higher in comparison to the MDD. It was pointed out that in the other case which was a subject matter of case No. 40 of 2010 the contract was awarded to PES earlier. The Director General therefore concluded that the bid was cartelized and that there was overall collusion between these three firms which was totally in contravention of Section 3(3)(d) of the Act. The Director General also had examined the profit and loss and balance-sheets of the three firms and found that there were numerous financial and business transactions with each other in the accounts of MDD, PES and MPS installation. It was also found that among the contracts awarded to the different parties PES installations was the leading awardee while MDD and MPS had followed. Therefore, the Director General held that over a period of time these three firms were able to corner most of the MOT and MGMS projects in the various private and government hospitals. The Director General also reported that there was violation of Section 3(4) of the Act on the part of the PES. According to the Director General there were two companies namely Stryker India and Karl Storz which provide expertise in integrated devices and solutions in MOT. However, Stryker India was more preferred to the other. On account of its exclusive dealership with Stryker, PES was at an advantage as compared to other local dealers/agents who could not bid in various hospitals for MOT. This has resulted in restricting the competition.

    5. The CCI decided to send a copy of the said report to the parties for filing their replies and the parties denied the allegation of bid rigging. They pointed out that it was not uncommon for a combined tender for MOT and MGMS. According to MDD the common tender for both MOT and MGMS was floated by the government in view of the urgency and the exigency of work so as to complete the project within a period of 4-5 months, since the Commonwealth Games were to start in 2010. According to it, the separate tenders for MOT and MGMS would have resulted in delay for completion of the work as also increase in the tender price. Detailed replies seem to have been given by all the three appellants, which are not necessary to be quoted here. In addition to that, even Ministry of Health and Family Welfare gave a reply. The Ministry claims that since it was not a necessary party, it should be deleted from array of parties under Rule 26 of the CCI Regulations, 2009. According to it, its actions were also justifiable. According to Ministry, there was no procedural lapse. It was further contended that the entire process was transparent and the task undertaken by HSCC was completed without any lapse in procedure. It was pointed out that highly qualified experts and senior officers were involved in the process. They also justified the combined tender in view of the time bound nature of work and for ensuring smooth execution of work in coordinated manner. The other examples for the hospitals were not relevant where only two or three bidders had participated and in some cases only one single bidder had participated. It is pointed out that amongst the three bidders the contract was awarded to the lowest bidder. They outrightly rejected the charge of cartelization. In short, they justified the whole process. The informant also reacted to the Director General's report and concurred with it. The CCI framed two issues.

    1. Whether the Opposite Parties have contravened the provisions of Section 3(3)(d) read with Section 3(1) by indulging in the process of bid-rigging in the matter of supply and installation of MOT and MGMS at Sports Injury Centre, Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi?

    2. Whether dealership agreement between Stryker India Pvt. Limited and PES was violative of the provisions of Section 3(4) read with Section 3(1) of the Act?

    We need not bother about Issue No. 2 in this appeal since that question is not pending before us owing to the exoneration of the appellants on that account by CCI.

    6. As regards the first issue, the CCI first gave the brief history of the whole process of tendering and also referred to the amendments of the tender condition. It has then quoted comparative offers made by MDD and PES. It then referred to the opinion of the Committee that the budget provision of Rs. 10 crores could not be considered as the overall estimated cost for the complete project inclusive of 5 years of warranty, 5 years of subsequent CMC and 10 years of operation cost. It has then gone on to mention about separate rates having been called for 5 years of subsequent CMC and 5 years to maintenance cost and hence mentioned the comparative tables of the prices with the fresh conditions. It also referred to the opening of the price bid of Medical products though it was disqualified which was only for comparison sake. In paragraph 6.24, the CCI criticized the tender design and specifications as uncertain. It also commented adversely on there being no payment by Stryker for PES which was indicative of the fact that PES was not doing the job at the behest of the Stryker but was directly dealing with MDD bypassing the Stryker. The CCI also referred to the fact that the payment for equipment was made by MDD directly to the PES. It is also referred to the Writ Petitions having been filed before the High Court of Delhi by the three firms challenging the combining of the work of the orders. It then observed in paragraph 6.26 that when tender specifications, terms and conditions and estimated cost are uncertain, firms tend to collude and manipulate the entire bidding process to their advantage and in this case the same thing happened. It then observed in the same paragraph that the quotation of MPS, PES and MDD was 268%, 252.40% and 143.20% respectively in comparison of the estimated cost of Rs. 10 crore. The CCI then criticised the tendering authority that had ignored the high offers in comparison to their own estimated tender cost. According to the CCI this was all the more necessary in view of the commonality of behaviour and conduct of the competing firms. It then went on to compare the common typographical and other errors in tender offers. From paragraphs 6.29 to 6.35 the CCI has in details dealt with these errors which were not possible unless the competing firms were acting in concert. In further paragraphs, the CCI considered the statement of Shri Rajan Verma, Director MDD. The representative of MPS and also the representative of PES and compared the contradictory nature of justification of those common errors. Ultimately, it is mentioned that it was unbelievable that all the appellants who were going to bid for contracts worth crores of rupees and whose turnover were also in crores would use common cyber cafe for getting the bids schedule typed. CCI goes on to hold that it cannot be a mere coincidence that though different stands had been taken by the OPs before the D.G, the stand taken by all the three appellants before the CCI is the same. After extensively dealing with common mistakes CCI has gone in to consider the price schedule for comprehensive annual maintenance contract after the one year warranty period where it has found that the offers of MPS and PES were identical percentage wise whereas offer of MDD was given in the actual figures. From this the CCI holds in paragraph 6.48 that MPS and PES were not simply interested in competing with MDD. From paragraph 6.49 the CCI has adversely commented upon the opening bid of MPS which was disqualified. The CCI mentioned in paragraph 6.49 as under:—

    “As per Government norms, minimum 3 bids should be there for considering any purchase. Technical and financial bids were together submitted by MPS and the record shows that MPSs financial bid was opened and considered for comparative purpose. It only seems that MPS deliberately filed bid so that the entire bidding process may not be rescinded. The finding is recorded in paragraph 6.50 that MPS was not acting independently and was acting in concert with the other bidders. The finding is then recorded that all the three firms were acting in concert with each other”.

    7. The CCI adversely commented on the fact that though MDD approached Stryker Limited for authorization, the PES who was the sole distributor of Stryker products did not object to such authorization being given by the Stryker to MDD particularly when PES was also competing with MDD. Further, the CCI found it strange that the rate of the Stryker related items quoted by MDD was lower than PES. According to the CCI, ordinarily the prices quoted by PES for the Stryker related items should have been competitive as compared to MDD. Even in the matter of maintenance and operation charges, PES had quoted almost double as compared to MDD. The CCI adversely noted that the items pertaining to Stryker were procured by MDD through PES for which even the advance was paid and the work of installation of these items was also awarded to PES by MDD. In the opinion of the CCI, therefore, the tender was jointly shared by PES and MDD. The CCI, therefore, concluded that PES had submitted a token bid and MDD kept enough cushion in its quoted price with an understanding that the PES shared the profit earned jointly out of the contract. The CCI also took into account the letter of MPS to the tendering agency dated 23 October, 2009 and wondered as to how the date 26 October, 2009 of the Bank guarantee could have been quoted in the same. From all this, the CCI concluded that there was manipulation of the entire bid process which was in contravention of the provision of Section 3(3)(d) of the Act. According to the CCI, PES and MPS had submitted only complementary bids and they were actually not participating in the bid process to compete with MDD. They were submitted only to complement, cover or as courtesy bids so that the procurement process did not get stalled due to the lack of enough competition. The CCI also found in paragraph 6.58 that the MDD had quoted inflated price which was substantially higher than the price of procurement. The CCI observed because of this escalation, MDD was able to make huge profit. The CCI also observed that all this caused appreciable adverse affect on the competition. In paragraph 6.61, the CCI observed that technical and financial evaluation committee did not adhere to the initial tender conditions at least in respect of Item III of Section 1 since the operation and maintenance which was sought for 10 years was relaxed at the stage of final evaluation of bids by bringing it down to 5 years. According to the CCI, since the price bid of winning firm was Rs. 24.32 crores which was too high from the initial projected cost of Rs. 10 crores, the Committee brought down the period from 10 years to 5 years and thus reducing the price bid to Rs. 16 crores approximately. The CCI, therefore, deduced that the awarded contract was at a price almost 142% more than the estimated cost of bid and that this caused huge loss to the exchequer and resulted in huge profit being made by MDD which was shared with PES. This prompted the CCI to pass the order under Section 27 of the Act and on the basis of 5% of the average turnover, the CCI imposed a penalty of Rs. 6,840,252 on PES, Rs. 4,784,188 on MPS and Rs. 18,470,778 on MDD.

    8. Shri Dhruv Mehta, Sr. counsel appearing on behalf of MDD, Shri Neeraj Malhotra and Shri Kamal Mehta appearing for MPS and PES respectively severely criticized this order. Shri Mehta firstly contended that the finding of the CCI and its deductions regarding MPS were not correct. He pointed out that the CCI had held, that, though MPS was not qualified yet it had presented a bid to show that there were at least three competitors in the field. The CCI had observed in paragraph 6.49 that as per the government's norms minimum three bids were required for considering any purchase. The CCI had also observed in the same para knowing that it did not have the necessary qualification of not doing one project of the similar kind during the last three years for Rs. 400 Lakhs or above, the MPS should never have offered bid knowing fully well that it would not succeed. However, it did so only to provide a facade of competition. Shri Mehta was at pains to point out firstly, there was no such requirement of there being minimum three bids in every tender. He further points out that merely because MPS offered the bid knowing it fully well it was not technically qualified to offer the bid, it did not mean that it was only to help MDD in winning the contract. Shri Mehta gave number of examples and also invited our attention to the reply filed by the Government and more particularly wherein it was admitted that in majority of cases only two or three bidders participated and in some of the cases there was only a single bidder when it came to the tenders for OTS and Gas manifolds. Shri Balbir Singh, advocate for the CCI also very fairly submitted before us that he was not relying on the observations made in paragraph 6.49 and 6.50 and that he was not in a position to support the same. We therefore, hold that at least on this count the CCI committed a factual error. Again it could not be said that the bid of MPS was only a complementary bid to MDD. In our opinion, therefore, this circumstance could not have been taken into consideration while examining the question involved.

    9. Shri Mehta then took serious exception to the observation made in paragraph 6.47 where the CCI had observed that two losing firms - PES and MPS had quoted identical rates for comprehensive annual maintenance contract (CMC). He was at pains to point out that the CCI was incorrect in deducing that the rates quoted by MPS and PES were identical. In this behalf, the learned counsel contends that for CMC while MDD had given absolute figures, MPS and PES had quoted the rates percentage wise. This percentage, according to the learned counsel, was to depend on the price quoted by the MPS and PES in their price schedule. The learned counsel goes on to suggest that 10% quoted by the MPS would be a different figure than the 10% quoted by the PES. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, this could not be said to be a complementary bid as has been held by the CCI. It is also apparent from the finding that there was a huge difference in the bid rates between the two losing firms and MDD. Though Shri Mehta is right to the extent that the rates for CMC were not identical with each other in case of MPS and PES, the fact remains that the percentages are strangely identical. MPS has quoted 10%, 12%, 15%, 17% and 20% for the 1, 2, 3rd, 4 and 5 year respectively. PES has also identically quoted these percentages. In our opinion, this identity in the percentage itself should raise an eyebrow. Though, the price could not have been same, one wonders as to how the two competing firms could have quoted identical percentages. There is no fixed norm or any material to suggest that these percentages are standard percentages in case of the comprehensive annual maintenance. This is apart from the fact that the price covered by these percentages is almost the double of the price quoted by the MDD. Roughly, in case of MDD, the percentages for the 1, 2 and 3year would be nearly 5%, 6% and 7% which are almost double the percentages of MPS and PES. Shri Balbir Singh, advocate for the CCI pointed out that unless there was a meeting of minds at least between MPS and PES, they would not have quoted the identical percentage for comprehensive maintenance. He is undoubtedly right there. Such identical percentage could not have been a mere co-incidence. We can understand if there was any standard norm in the matter of annual maintenance of MOT and MGPS. There is nothing brought on record. We also fail to follow as to how in the matter of comprehensive annual maintenance there could be such difference which would double the price quoted by the successful bidder. Unless, therefore, this was meant to be a complementary bid such identity was not possible. We do appreciate the contention raised by the learned Senior Counsel that if these percentages are converted to the actual figures, they will be different. However, that fact does not help him. As firstly, the percentages are identical and secondly they are almost double the price quoted by the successful bidder MDD when the actual figures quoted by the MDD are converted into the percentage. Therefore, Shri Dhruv Mehta invited our attention to the Hon'ble Supreme Court decision in (1993) 3 SCC 499, Union of India v. Hindustan Development Corporation. This was a case where the Court was examining the validity of a tender process. The Delhi High Court at an interlocutory stage, pending the Writ Petitions challenging the counter offer given by some parties had directed the Ministry of Railways to accept allocation of bogies recommended by Tender Committee at a price of Rs. 67,000/- per bogie. This order was unsuccessfully challenged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the first round. Thereafter, High Court took up Writ Petitions for final hearing and allowed the same. The High Court maintained its directions given at the interim stage and set-aside the quantity allocation and directed the fresh consideration of the whole matter on a reasonable basis. It was this judgment which was impugned in the aforementioned matter. The Court went on to examine the validity of the whole tender process. It transpired that there was a formation of cartel at the instance of three big manufacturers. The Court went on to explain the dictionary as well as the other meaning of the term “cartel”. The allegation about cartelisation was based on the fact that the price quoted in the tender by three big manufacturers was identical and was in fact a cartel price. The Court observed in paragraph 17 as follows:— cartelisation

    “17. Therefore, whether in a given case, there was formation of a cartel by some of the manufacturers which amounts to an unfair trade practice, depends upon the available evidence and the surrounding circumstances. In the instant case, initially the Tender Committee formed the opinion that the three big manufacturers formed a cartel on the ground that the price initially quoted by them was identical and was only a cartel price. This, in our view, was only a suspicion which of course got strengthened by post-tender attitude of the said manufacturers who quoted a much lesser price. As noticed above it cannot positively be concluded on the basis of these two circumstances alone. In the past these three big manufacturers also offered their own quotations and they were allotted quantities on the basis of the existing practice. However, a mere quotation of identical price and an offer of further reduction by themselves would not entitle them automatically to corner the entire market by way of monopoly since the final allotment of quantities vested in the authorities who in their discretion can distribute the same to all the manufacturers including these three big manufacturers on certain basis. No doubt there was an apprehension that if such predatory price has to be accepted the smaller manufacturers will not be in a position to compete and may result in elimination of free competition. But there again the authorities reserved a right to reject such lower price. Under these circumstances though the attitude of these three big manufacturers gave rise to a suspicion that they formed a cartel but there is not enough material to conclude that in fact there was such formation of a cartel. However, such an opinion entertained by the concerned authorities including the Minister was not malicious nor was actuated by any extraneous considerations. They entertained a reasonable suspicion based on the record and other surrounding circumstances and only acted in a bonafide manner in taking the stand that the three big manufacturers formed a cartel.”

    10. Relying heavily on the observations in this paragraph, the learned counsel says that a mere quotation of identical price by itself could not justify the inference of cartelisation, though it would raise a suspicion to that effect. The learned counsel, therefore, says that merely because MDD, PES and MPS had quoted identical percentages that by itself could not be held to be a circumstance against the two concerns. We have examined the facts of this case very carefully. It must be said here that even in the reported decision, the Apex Court at the end of the paragraph has called such inference to be a reasonable suspicion. In fact, the Apex Court has not exonerated the parties who had quoted the identical prices. The Court came to the conclusion that this suspicion of cartelisation was then got strengthened by post tender attitude of the said big manufacturers. Thus, the Court took into account the post tender attitude shown by the parties to the cartelisation also. In the present matter, the things are slightly different. The three competitors are not being viewed adversely only because of the identical pricing between PES and MPS. There are number of other circumstance like the common typographical error and the common errors committed by all the three competing parties which will be discussed in the further paragraphs. Therefore, in our opinion this decision does not help the appellants. We, therefore, reject the contention raised by the learned counsel on this count that the inference drawn by the CCI on account of this fact could not have been drawn in law. We have already noted herein that like the common typographical and other errors in the bid documents by all the three competitors at least in case of these two so called competitors, there was an identity of figures in percentages. Presently, we rest at that.

    11. This takes us to the contention raised by the learned counsel for all the three parties about the finding in common errors in the bid documents and the common typographical errors. Shri Dhruv Mehta, Senior counsel as well as two other advocates - Shri Neeraj Malhotra and Shri Kamal Mehta, very earnestly argued that though there were common errors and the common typographical errors in the three bid documents, the same was an innocuous factor. The learned counsel also pointed out that in spite of all these common errors and common typographical errors, no inference could be drawn about there being a meeting of minds between the three competitors. The learned counsel pointed out those common errors occurred in typing of price schedule. As per the procedure prescribed in the tender document the price of the items picked up from the bill of quantity was to be incorporated in either Form XIA or XIB. In this behalf, in paragraph 6.29 the CCI has noted that the prices of goods available in India were quoted in the column meant for price schedule for goods to be imported from abroad. This was a common mistake committed by all the three competitors. The CCI noted that the price schedule XIA was to be used for the domestic goods or foreign goods located within India while price schedule XIB was to be used for foreign currency items. There were in all 71 items to be quoted by the companies in the price schedule. The CCI found that all the three companies have identically wrongly distributed all the items under price schedule XIA and XIB. In paragraph 6.32, the CCI noted that MDD had incorrectly used the heading XIB for Item Nos. 26, 27, 47, 74 and 75. Though for these items the correct price schedule was XIA and surprisingly identical mistakes were also committed by PES and MPS. The CCI noted that such identical and common mistakes had also been committed for Item Nos. 32, 34, 35, 36, 38 to 46 by all the three companies in the price schedule. In paragraph 6.33 the CCI found that in the price schedule MDD had amended government's original format and mentioned different size of three OTs on the top left at page 18. Similar identical additions were made by other firms PES and MPS at pages 42 and 47 respectively. In Paragraph 6.34 the CCI observed that the DG had shown the common typographical errors in the bid documents. The CCI had described these common typographical errors in a long tabular form and covered them from letter (a) to (s). We have carefully examined these common errors. They are not only the common errors but the typographical errors also. For example at serial H it was found that the word ‘of’ is mis-typed as ‘o’ and the same mistake was committed by MDD, PES and MPS. At serial i, j, k, l, m, n, o and p it was found that they were identically typed with the identical mistakes or fonts. Even in item (6) the common spelling mistake in the word ‘over lapping’ was committed as in all the three documents over lapping spelt as ‘overelapping’. The CCI, therefore, deduced in paragraph 6.35 that that such common errors and common typographical mistakes showed that there was certainly a meeting of minds among all bidders and such large number of common errors can only occur when the documents were prepared in mutual consultation with each other or by a common person. The CCI has also taken into consideration the explanation to the effect that these errors occurred as the price schedule were got typed through one common source at a cyber cafe. Here also the explanation given before the DG by PES vide letter 29.7.2011 was that generally the price bid format was provided by the tendering authorities but since in the present tender such price bid format was not available in the price bid meeting held on 12.10.2009, the price bid format had to be got typed and printed by the tenderer themselves and as it was an exhaustive format consisting of about 75 items with their descriptions the officials of tendering companies for convenience got it typed from some nearby computer cafe and since only one typist typed the price bid format for all the three companies such common typographical errors occurred. The CCI then noted the statement of Shri Rajan Verma of MDD Medical. The CCI noted that in his answer he had stated “MDD cannot confirm, neither is aware how all these typographical mistakes have happened in the price schedule form which is identically similar with PES and MPS”. The CCI also noted the explanation by MPS through its representative in the statement dated 1.8.2011 and found that the same was different. The CCI, therefore, concluded in its order that explanations were also contradictory with each other. Shri Balbir Singh invited our attention to the finding in paragraph 6.41 and argued that the bidders were not truthful in their submissions. He pointed out that the explanation, that the price bid format was got typed from common cyber cafe as per the explanation of one of the companies was extremely lame. He argues and in our opinion rightly, that the three companies which were going to bid for contract worth crores of rupees and whose annual turnover is also in crores would use a cyber cafe that too a common cyber cafe for getting the bid price schedule typed. In our opinion, this should clinch the issue about the three companies acting in unison. We have carefully seen the observation of the CCI in paragraph 6.42, 6.43 6.44 and 6.45 and we are thoroughly convinced about the mix up of dates which has been shown by the CCI. The learned counsel argued that the CCI had not considered the statements recorded of the representatives of MDD, PES and MPS. When we see the impugned order, this argument clearly falls to the ground as the CCI has very meticulously considered all the explanations and found them to be frivolous. In our opinion, this finding regarding the common typographical errors is a correct finding.

    12. The CCI has also adversely commented about the written submission by PES to the effect that all the parties had filled price quotations at their own respective offices. The CCI has rightly questioned as to how could PES know that the other two parties filed quotations at their respective offices. Similarly, the CCI has rightly commented about the PES quoting comparatively higher price when in fact it was the sole distributor of Stryker from whom even MDD was to obtain the components. In our opinion, no fault can be found with the reasoning given by the CCI in paragraph 6.46 We therefore endorse the finding of the CCI in paragraph 6.48 to the effect that there was a huge difference in the bid rates between two losing firms on one hand and L1 bidder on the other hand and this huge difference only suggested that the other two firms were not interested in competing with L1 firm and hence they had not quoted the competitive rates.

    13. The CCI has also adversely commented that the rates for Stryker related items quoted by the MDD were lower than PES, when in fact PES was the dealer of the Stryker and as such was in a position to quote competitive price as compared to MDD. The CCI found out that PES had quoted almost double of maintenance and operational charges compared to MDD which was also not natural considering the fact that PES alone had experience of installation and integrated items of Stryker. It must be mentioned here that ultimately though the contract was given to MDD but the installation work was got done through PES only. The learned counsel tried to justify this on the grounds that PES was interested in making profits and had, therefore, quoted prices higher than MDD and that all this was possible during the course of business. The learned counsel also urged that the products of Stryker quoted by MDD constituted only 6% of the entire project. In our opinion, such explanation is of no consequence and there had to be a handshake between MDD and PES who were the only competitors.

    14. The learned counsel invited our attention to the comments made by the CCI on the forwarding letter of MPS to the tendering agency and urged that in that letter MPS had referred to bank guarantee No. 2384 1 BG-10-09 dated 26.10.2009 for twenty lacs. The learned counsel argued that this circumstance was in fact an innocuous circumstance and there was nothing suspicious about it, as the bank guarantee dated 26.10.2009 could have been got made prior to or on 23.10.2009 and thus there was nothing unusual about it and the CCI should not have drawn adverse inference from this circumstance. We do not think that this circumstance was weighty enough, as the bank guarantee could have been got prepared for covering future period from 26.10.2009 also. Though such explanation has not been offered, however, we refuse to draw any inference from this circumstance.

    15. These were all the circumstances from which the CCI reached the inference that there was a manipulation of bidding process in contravention of provision of Section 3(3)(d) of the Act.

    16. While arriving at a finding regarding Section 3(3)(d), the CCI has explained that there was a manipulation of entire bid process in as much as it was proved that all the three competitors acted in such a manner so as to adversely affect and manipulate the process of bidding. The CCI has further held that these three parties actually had an understanding between them and it was in pursuance of that understanding that PES and MPS submitted complementary bids which were uncomparably high to the bid by the MDD. Inference drawn by the CCI that MPS and PES were not participating in bid process to compete with MDD but were only submitting complementary/cover or courtesy bids appears to be correct. It appears to be correct from the bids given by PES and MPS in pursuance to the bid given by MDD. Shri Dhruv Mehta invited our attention to the comment made by the CCI about another tender of JPNA Hospital, the CCI has referred to the fact that the contract therein was awarded to PES when MDD and MPS had submitted complementary bids in order to show that there was enough competition in the above tender. Shri Mehta criticized this, that the CCI could not have taken into consideration the facts in the other tender. The submission is clearly incorrect as all these facts which have been taken into consideration were in the knowledge of all the three parties. It was not as if some facts were being relied on behind the back of three parties. We therefore reject the contention.

    17. The CCI has also noted the aspect of the harm caused to SIC because of the bid rigging and has also noted that on examination of the Bill of Entries and Import Invoices of MDD, the DG had noted that the landed cost of equipments and the custom duty paid by MDD was insignificant as compared to what was quoted by it to SIC and thus MDD had escalated the selling price of equipments compared to the landed cost and thus was able to make huge profit. This was reflected by PES and MPS by quoting further escalated price. In the analysis which is reflected in paragraphs 6.58 in a tabular form, this inference is firmly supported. The CCI has further observed that the price bid of the successful firm was Rs. 24.32 crores. However, it was scaled down to Rs. 16 crores by limiting the O&M charges not for 10 years as was the proposal but to 5 years only. It will not be for us to make any comment on the wisdom of the Tendering Committee in modifying these tender terms. However, we do find that the contract price was brought down artificially to Rs. 16 crores even by changing the tender terms. As to what is its effect on the whole tender process is not for this Tribunal to decide. It is for some other authorities to consider these facts.

    18. The learned senior counsel had argued that there was no evidence in shape of written agreement nor was there any independent evidence available to suggest that there was an understanding or meeting of minds amongst the three competing parties. The learned counsel very earnestly argued that the circumstances held proved for supporting such inference were not sufficient enough to clinchingly reach the inference of the meeting of minds by the three competitors. We must point out here that we are not in the realm of criminal jurisprudence where a proof beyond the reasonable doubt is required, though there is a provision for penalty for the acts committed by the competing parties. In our view the test of probability would be a good test. However, we hasten to add that in this case the factors proved like the huge disparity in the rates between the MDD on one hand and PES and MPS on another, the identical price bids in respect of the O&M percentages between PES and MPS, as also the common typographical errors and other common errors do drive us to hold that there was guilty meeting of minds in between the three competitors. A conspiracy in criminal law does not normally have a support of direct evidence. The finding there is more or less inferential. In this case, the facts held proved by us do reach us to a clinching inference that there was meeting of minds of a nature as would be in contravention of Section 3(3)(d).

    19. Shri Mehta again adversely commented on the observations by the CCI in para 6.64 that the Central Vigilance Commission and Comptroller and Auditor General had adversely commented on manipulation of the process of tender. We must make it clear that we are not impressed by any action by these authorities, but we have arrived at the conclusion on the basis of available evidence before us.

    20. This takes us to the orders of penalty against the three firms. A very severe comment was made by Shri Dhruv Mehta and two other counsels that firstly, no opportunity was given by the CCI to address “separately” on the question of penalty. Secondly, the learned counsel criticized that the CCI had given no reasons as to why it had inflicted the penalties at 5% of the average turnover. We must note here that PES had given only two years turnover when it was supposed to have given previous three year's turnover. It does not appear from the record that the appellants did not have any opportunity to address the CCI on the question of penalty. A mere contention raised in this behalf will be of no consequence. In fact all the parties were represented by the counsel who had the full opportunity to argue their matter before the CCI. We therefore, do not accept this argument that there was no opportunity given to address on the question of penalty. However, the second criticism appears to be somewhat justified that the CCI has not given any reasons as to why it was ordering the penalty at the rate of 5% of the average turnover and that too for all the three parties.

    21. In that behalf, we must note that the CCI should have considered certain factors while inflicting the penalties. In our opinion those factors would be:—

    (i) That this was a single incident and there is no evidence that the three companies were engaging themselves in such practice earlier.

    (ii) That the parties are being booked for the first time.

    (iii) Any post tender development, such as timely execution of contract of a complicated and technical nature.

    22. We also do not find any justification in the order for the penalty at the rate of 5% of the average turnover. While considering the question of penalty, the CCI has to be very careful and must not appear to be arbitrary. Giving the reasons would be a sure and certain answer to the criticism of arbitrariness as has been held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the number of cases. Unfortunately, we do not find any reasons. The learned counsel for the MDD argued that the CCI should not have considered the whole turnover, but should have limited itself to the sales covered by the tenders in case of Government Hospitals only (being the relevant turnover) and should not have considered the sales made and services offered to the private parties. Even the learned counsel representing PES and MPS also addressed us on the similar lines. The learned counsel further argued that such course would be necessary as there is an essential difference in the supplies made to the Government Hospitals through tender and the supplies made to the private hospitals. The learned counsel argued that the prices on which the material supplied to the private hospitals and services offered to them would depend on so many other factors like the need of the private party, the urgency of the need, the availability of the materials in the market and profit negotiations on the basis of which the supplies are made and the services offered. According to the learned counsel these factors may not be present in the matter of supply of material and the services to the Government Hospitals on the basis of tender. The learned counsel, therefore, argued that the figures regarding the supplies of materials and services offered to the Government Hospitals through tenders should alone be taken into consideration for fixing the amount of penalty.

    23. The term “turnover” has been defined in the Act under Section 2(y), as per which turnover includes value of sale of goods or services. From plain reading of Section 27(b), it is evident that the maximum penalty can be 10% on the average of the turnover for the last three years. In case of cartels, a penalty could be up to three times of the profit for each year of continuance of such agreement of cartel or 10% whichever is higher. In order to determine the turnover, the CCI would be required to go to the duly certified and audited financial statements of the enterprise. That would be the surest way to fix the turnover of an enterprise in a particular year. The question is whether the CCI should have in the circumstances of this case, split this turnover treating it to be a relevant turnover by taking into consideration only the value of the materials, supply to the Government Hospitals and the services offered to them through the tender. In our opinion, the argument is completely illogical. In fact there would be no difference in the nature of business in case of Government Hospitals and the private hospitals. In both what the enterprise would be doing is only supplying the necessary materials for building operation theatres and creating the said theatres so that they are efficient and without any fault. In the matter of service also, the task of maintaining these operation theaters would be no different. Therefore, we cannot persuade ourselves to accept such argument and we do not see any justification to take into account only the value of materials, supplied to and the services offered only to the Government Hospitals through tenders. That would be a hair splitting exercise. We also do not accept the argument that there would be any material difference in between the Government Hospitals and Private Hospitals or the materials supplied to and the services offered to them. The argument is, therefore, rejected.

    24. The learned counsel for PES and MPS then urged that they should not have been weighed in the same scale along with MDD, an enterprise which won the contract in the tender. In our opinion, considering that all the three enterprises having come together and acting in concerted manner which we have shown earlier in this judgment such differentiation is not possible. They were after all acting in unison with each other so that the tender should go to a particular enterprise, MDD in this case. Their responsibility, therefore, cannot vary merely because two of them were not awarded tender. After all there was clear design in the award of tender to a particular enterprise and the calculated moves were taken for that purpose. We, therefore, cannot accept the contentions raised in this behalf.

    25. This takes us to the last question as to whether the CCI was right at fixing the penalty at 5% of the average turnover. The learned counsel relied on the reported decision in Hindustan Steel Ltd. v. State Of Orissa . reported in (1969) 2 SCC 627 : AIR 1970 SC 253 wherein it is observed “if there is discretion, authority is bound to take into account aggravating or mitigating circumstances and exercise discretion laid down under the law, judicially”.

    26. There is catena of Supreme Court decisions which have unhaultingly held that in the absence of any justifying reasons the exercise of discretion tends to become arbitrary. In reported decision of Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan reported in (2010) 9 SCC 496, after discussing the earlier case law on this subject, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has reiterated the necessity of giving reason in paragraph-15 and has observed that, though initially there was a demarcation between administrative orders and quasi-judicial orders, but with the passage of time the distinction between the two got blurred and thinned out and virtually reached a vanishing point in the judgment in A.K Kraipak v. Union of India reported in (1969) 2 SCC 262 : AIR 1970 SC 150. It must be noted here that the present order is undoubtedly in the nature of adjudicatory jurisdiction and can be termed as a quasi-judicial order. In this judgment the Apex Court has taken the stock of practically all the earlier judgments on this subject and in paragraph-51 culled out the 15 conclusions, all of which speak about the necessity of giving reasons not only by quasi-judicial authorities, but also by the administrative authorities. It cannot be disputed that the reasons display as to how the mind of a particular authority exercising discretion was working or has worked. It also provides an opportunity for the Appellate Authorities to test the correctness of the same and thus the exercise of the discretion does not remain subjective, but remain objective because of the reasons.

    27. In the earlier paragraphs, we have already noted that the CCI has not given any reasons nor has it discussed as to why it was pegging the penalty at 5%.

    28. While inflicting the penalty the CCI should have considered the aggravating as well as the mitigating circumstances. This case, being held of cartelization and bid rigging is undoubtedly a very serious circumstance against the appellants. In the competition jurisdiction, bid rigging and cartelization have been treated to be abhorrent to the competition and have been looked down upon internationally. The trend in the countries where the competition jurisdiction has been in prevalence for substantial number of years, the judicial thought favours stiff penalties which can be deterrent. However, at the same time, we would have to consider the peculiarity of this jurisdiction in India. It is only for last three years that the competition jurisprudence has been introduced through the Competition Act, 2002. The nascent stage of competition jurisdiction would be one of the factors to be taken into consideration while inflicting penalties.

    29. This is apart from the fact that this was for the first time that these parties have been found to have engaged in cartelization and bid rigging. There is no allegation or evidence that they have been cartelizing in the past. Therefore, some consideration would have to be shown for that factor.

    30. Lastly but importantly, this was a contract for building a Operation Theatre for the Sports Injury Centre (SIC) which subject itself is relatively new. This Sports Injury Centre was to be created before the Commonwealth Games. The said games were to be held in India in the year 2010. The MDD seems to have completed this exercise within time and at least there is no evidence to suggest that the said Operation Theatre has not worked well. The Commonwealth Games were undoubtedly a matter of national importance and prestige. Some credit has to be given to MDD for this purpose. We would, therefore, bring down the penalty of MDD to 3%. In that view, showing due consideration to all the other factors, and to maintain the parity between the parties, we would bring down the penalty from 5% of the average turnover of last three years to 3% of the average turnover of last three years even in case of PES and MPS also. Calculated in that light, the penalty would be as per the following table:—

    Appellants Average Turnover of last 3 years (in Rs.) Penalty imposed by CCI vide order Dtd. 16.04.2012 at 5% of average turnover (in Rs.) Penalties to be Modified at 3% of average turnover (in Rs.) PES 136,805,050 6,840,252 4,104,159 MPS 95,683,771 4,784,188 2,870,513 MDD 369,415,564 18,470,778 11,082,467

    31. We, therefore, inflict the penalty as shown in the table. The penalties imposed by the CCI in the impugned order dated 16.04.2012 shall stand modified to that extent.

    32. The three enterprises on whom the penalties have been imposed are directed to deposit the amount of penalties within 90 days of the receipt of this order.

    Pronounced in open Court on 25 day of February, 2013.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mdd Medical Systems India Private Limited v. Foundation For Common Cause & People Awareness B-203
    (Feb 25, 2013)