AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    M/S. Khatkar Rice And General Mills v. State Bank Of Patiala .

    R.A Mehta, Presiding Officer:— All the four appeals involving the common question are being disposed off by this common judgment.

    2. The Bank had filed suit on 2.11.92 against Defendant No. 1, the Partnership Firm of which Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 were the Partners while Defendant Nos. 4 to 7 were also added in the suit as the Guarantors or the mortgagor. The suit was for the recovery of Rs. 6,72,235.10. It was decreed against all the Defendants on 2.9.93 by the Additional Sr. Sub-Judge, Patiala. The decretal amount was directed to be recovered from Defendants jointly and severally and also by sale of pledged goods and the mortgaged property with future interest, (underline supplied).

    3. Five Hundred Sixty Five Quintals of Basmati Rice was pledged with the Bank. An attempt was made prior to the passing of the decree i.e during the pendency of suit to seek permission to sell the pledged goods. It was however, held on 9.4.91 that no permission for the sale of pledged or hypothecated goods was necessary.

    4. The decree is now sought to be executed through the Recovery Officer, Debts Recovery Tribunal, Jaipur by selling of the mortgaged properties. The objection was raised by the present Appellant (Judgment-Debtor) before Recovery Officer that unless and until the pledged goods are produced and the price realised the execution much less against the mortgaged properties cannot proceed. This objection was over-ruled by the Recovery Officer and it is against this order passed on 26.2.98 the original Defendant Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 have preferred those four appeals received by post.

    5. The appeals are handwritten. Moreover they are not in a proper form of paper book. The Appellants were intimated to remain present for preliminary hearing. It was informed that the Judgment-Debtors are paupers and that they are made paupers by the Decree-Holder/Bank. It was also informed that they are unable to engage the Advocate or to remain present for hearing. The written argument was therefore sent.

    6. Perused the written argument.

    7. Appellants (JD) knew very well that the rice bags were damaged and destroyed during the floods of July, 1993. The question of their production and realisation of the price at present does not arise. They have alleged negligence on the part of the Bank. The question of negligence if any cannot be determined before the Tribunal much less before Recovery Officer. It was altogether a different issue for which the appellants, it appears have approached the Consumer Forum. The Recovery Officer cannot go behind the decree. The insistence for the return of pledged goods was unwarranted and misconceived. Assuming that there was any negligence it has no impact on the property mortgaged.

    It was contended by the appellants that the immovable properties automatically get freed when the Bank had locked the goods and did not proceed to realise the price of the pledged goods. The said contention is also misconceived. The appellants were free to take steps against the Bank for the alleged negligence. The issue of return of goods or adjustment on sale is different than the issue of realisation of decretal dues by sale of mortgaged properties. Even the Civil Court which passed the decree was not called upon to consider this issue. Under the circumstances Recovery Officer was justified in negativing the contention raised by the Judgment-Debtors before him. The Appeals also merit no consideration and as such all the appeals are summarily dismissed.

    Appeals are summarily dismissed. Inform Appellant.

    Appeals dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Khatkar Rice And General Mills v. State Bank Of Patiala .
    (May 6, 1998)