Sirpurkar J.:— The applicants herein have raised their common questions. At the outset, it is pointed out that the first question which is an identical question is disposed of by this Authority in its judgment of dated 26 July, 2011 in the case of same assessee. The Department also agrees to this fact that the same question has been disposed of by this Authority in AAR No. 858-861 of dated 26 July, 2011. The present applications are identical with the earlier applications. We would, therefore, choose to take the same view in these applications also. It is an admitted position that the ruling of this Authority was confirmed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in its order of dated12.01.2016 read with 12188 of 2015.
2. The Department does not dispute this factual position, however, the only objection of the Department is that the aforesaid judgment of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court has been challenged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and is pending there vide Civil Appeal No. 8853 of 2011 and 8854 of 2011. In that view, the Department says that we must desist from disposing of these applications.
3. We do not agree with the Department's contention. There will be no point in unnecessarily keeping these applications without any reason. If the Department so chooses, it could challenge these rulings as per the procedure laid down by law. The applications are allowed.
4. The answer to question No. 1 is in the affirmative and it is held that it is not taxable.
5. Insofar as the 2 question is concerned, the learned counsel Shri Deepak Chopra says that he is not pressing this question and withdrawing the same. The Department has no objection to that also. Hence, we need not answer the second question. On this basis, we dispose of all the above applications.