Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 23 item 36 C.C.S (Revised pay) Rules 1960
  • Section 23 item No. 25 of CCS (RP) Rules 1960
  • Central Civil Services (RP) Rules 1960
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 23 item 36 C.C.S (Revised pay) Rules 1960
  • Section 23 item No. 25 of CCS (RP) Rules 1960
  • Central Civil Services (RP) Rules 1960

    V.K. Dhir v. Union Of India

    S.K.S Chib, Vice-Chairman:— Applicant Shri V.K Dhir is presently Senior Supdt. of Post Offices, Indore, On 22.11.85 he moved an application under Section 19 of the A.T Act before the Principal Bench praying that his pay had not been properly fixed and should be refixed. It was registered as O.A-16/85 and transferred to Allahabad Bench of CAT on 3.12.85, which had territorial jurisdiction over this area then. It was subsequently transferred to this Bench for disposal and registered as TA-2/86.

    2. The undisputed facts of the case are that applicant Shri Dhir was earlier Asstt. Director Postal Services, Indore region from 25.10.78, and he was promoted and posted as Senior Supdt. of Post Offices Indore vide P.M.G Bhopal's order No. STA/1-788/Posting GRA/1 dated 12.5.83 He took over charge of the post on 31.5.83 His pay slip dated 8.6.83 issued by Dy Director Accounts (Postal) Bhopal Shows that his officiating pay was fixed at Rs. 1300/- per mensum. It is also admitted that from 25.10.78 onwards applicant worked continuously as Asstt. Director Post Offices for a period of more than four years on which post he drew Rs. 100/- per month as special pay. It is also confirmed from record that applicant was working as Senior Supdt. of Post Offices Indore since 31.3.83 and earlier had worked as Asstt. Director Postal Services Indore Region from 28.3.79 and before that as Asstt. Director Postal Services (East) Bhopal since 25.10.78 and he drew special pay of Rs. 100/- p.m continuously from 25.10.78 to 31.5.83 i.e for 4 years and 7 months as Asstt. Director (Postal Services).

    3. This is also on record that applicant's pay entitlement slip received under No. PA Misc/GE/PE/11/388 dated 8.6.83 fixed his officiating pay in the post of Senior S.P.O without counting special pay of Rs. 100/- per month on the lower post as it was not considered to have been granted in lieu of a separate scale of pay but treated to have been attached to the post of Asstt. Director Postal Service, as intimated to the petitioner vide Deputy Director of Accounts (Postal) letter No. PA-Misc/GE/PE-11/578 dated 7.7.83, which is the impugned order in reply to the petitioner's representation against his pay fixation vide his letter of 14.6.83 The petitioner requested for reconsideration of the matter vide his letter of 18.7.83 in which he stressed the fact that under Section 23 item No. 25 of CCS (RP) Rules 1960 as notified vide DG's circular of 19.8.60, the special pay of Rs. 100/- for incumbents holding posts of Asstt. Director had been shown as part of the revised scale and has, therefore to be treated as in lieu of higher scale of pay and accordingly his pay should be fixed at Rs. 1400/- in the post of Sr. Supdt. of Post Offices instead of Rs. 1300/-. This request was, however, rejected vide Director General Posts and Telegraphs letter No. 6/12/83.PAP dated 11.10.83 addressed to Director Accts (Postal) Bhopal under intimation to the petitioner on the ground that the special pay of Rs. 100/- p.m allowed to what is termed as P.S.S Group ‘B’ officers had been sanctioned in consideration of specific addition to the work and responsibility and was not in lieu of separate higher scale of pay. The petitioner then represented, through proper channel, to the Director General vide his letter of 2.6.84 citing Government of India Ministry of Finance OM No. F6(1)E-II(B)/68 dated 8.1.63 and note I below G.O.I Ministry of Finance OM dated 8.1.68 which reads:—

    “The special pay shown in the schedules to the Central Civil Services (RP) Rules 1960 will be treated as in lieu of higher scale of pay.”

    4. It was also pointed out by the petitioner that the Government continued the special pay of Rs. 100/- given to Asstt. Directors Post Offices even after review of the 3rd Pay Commission's recommendations and this is reflected in Directorate General's Letter No. 1-11/7S PAP/Pt dated 29.5.78, and therefore the schedule to CCS(RP) rules 1960 in so far as the special pay of Rs. 100/- to Asstt. Director, as part of revised scale of pay was concerned remained unaltered and was not superseded. The Director General Posts and Telegraphs however rejected this further representation of the petitioner in a rather cryptically worded letter of 6.12/83-P. AO/Post dated 27.12.84 which is the last impugned order.

    5. It has been contended by the petitioner and on his behalf that the above cited standing instructions of the Government and the provisions of FR-22(C)13 have been ignored by the Dy. Director Accounts and the Directorate General Post and Telegraphs and it is not correct that the special pay was attached to the post and did not form part of a separate scale of pay and that it could not be reckoned towards the pay fixation on the higher post in terms of FR-22-C(13)(i)(ii) read with note I thereunder and Ministry of Finance's OM/NO F-6(1)E-38/65 dated 25.2.65 which was not being interpreted by respondents correctly.

    6. Learned counsel for the applicant argued that according to Annexure ‘3’ special General Circular No. 19 issued by the Directorate General Post and Telegraphs on 19.8.60, the post of Assistant Directors carried a special pay of Rs. 100/-PM as per Sec. 23 item 36 C.C.S (Revised pay) Rules 1960 and this was part of the revised scale and not attached to the post. This was also carried as such after the 3rd Pay Commission's report and consequential revision of pay as per D.G (P &-T's) letter No. 1-4/78-PAP/Pt dated 29.5.78 (Annexure’ KE at page 28). Moreover, applicant got it for more than 4 years from 25.10.78 to 31.5.83 before his promotion to the post of Sr. Supdt. Post Offices and therefore he satisfies condition No.(ii) below para 13 of FR 22(C).

    7. It has been particularly emphasised that according to Note 1 in GI MS Ministry of Finances OM F-6(1) B-II(B)/68 dated 8th January 1968 reproduced below FR 22(c)(13) the special pay shown in the schedules to the C.C.S (Revised Pay) Rules 1960 are to be treated as in lieu of higher scale of pay. Therefore, the special pay of Rs. 100/- p.m drawn by the petitioner was in lieu of higher scale of pay. The order of Government of India view MF OM No. 6(1) E-iii/B/(65) dated 25.2.65 reproduced as para (13)(a) FR 22(C)(13) lays down that in cases where a government servant is in receipt of a special pay in a post, his pay on promotion to higher post may be fixed after taking into account to the special pay drawn in the lower post subject to the conditions mentioned below:

    (i) The special pay in the lower post should have been granted in lieu of separate higher scale.

    (ii) If the special pay has been drawn in the lower post continuously for a minimum period of three years of the date of promotion, the pay in the higher post will be fixed, under the normal rules, treating the special pay as part of basic pay drawn in the lower post (excluding the special pay) where it results indrop in emoluments the difference between the pay so fixed and the pay plus special pay drawn in the lower post will be allowed in the form of personal pay to be absorbed in the future increases of pay.

    (iii) In both the kinds of cases referred to in clause above it should be certified that, but for the promotion the government servants would have continued to draw the special pay in the lower post.”

    8. The learned counsel for the petitioner has pointed out that all the above conditions are satisfied in the case of the petitioner and Para (b) under FR 22(C)(13) is not applicable in the case of the petitioner. Therefore, his pay in the higher post of Sr. Supdt. post offices should be fixed treating the special pay as part of basic pay. He has also cited the ruling of 1980 L.A.B.I.C NOC- 34/(Ker) K. Bherkarm in the cause of Sakaira v. Central Board of Taxes in support of his stand.

    9. Respondent's stand is that because the special pay was attached to a particular post of Asstt. Director on account of special responsibility it could not be counted towards fixation of pay in the higher post. In the junior class I post of Asstt. Director post Offices, applicant's pay was notionally fixed at 1100/- on 31.5.83 excluding special pay of Rs. 100/-.

    10. One of the arguments advanced by learned Shri Tare for the respondents is that the Government of India's orders cited by the petitioner were no more effective when applicant got promotion as they got superseded consequent to 3rd pay Commission's recommendations which had recommended that basic pay itself should include ‘special pay’. In the counter affidavit dated 30.6.86 filed on behalf of respondents (para 2) it has, however, been stated that “In the instant case, the special pay is attached to the ‘revisad_scale’ and is not in lieu of higher scale (italics for emphasis). It is significant to note that in this extract it has not been stated that the special pay was ‘attached to the post’ but it has been stated that it was ‘attached to the revised scale’. The distiction between a special pay being attached to a revised scale, and not being in lieu of higher scale is not understood and this fiction seems to have been introduced as an argument by the respondents, not supported by the provisions of para (13) under FR-22(C). The learned counsel has not shown us any circular or Government's instructions in support of his various contentions.

    11. On the other hand apart from notes 1 and 2, note 4 under FR 22(C) refers to G.I MF's OM No. 6(1) E III/L/68 dated 12.12 74 which relates to cases where a special pay is enhanced during the preceeding 3. years of the date of promotion. It appears that even after revision of pay scales had come into force on 1.1.73 the above orders also remained in force. Again letter No. 1-11/76-PAP/Pt dated 29.5.78 from D.G.P and T (Annexure ‘K’ page 28) shows that that these special pays continued to remain in force. Hence we do not agree with the arguments advanced oh behalf of respondents by learned Shri Tare.

    12. As regards the plea of “delays and latches” advanced in the counter reply of respondents dated 30.6.86, we find that Director General P & T had sent letter No. 6/12/83.PAP/Post. dated 27.12.83 through respondent 2 to the petitioner which reached him only on 15.1.85 Therefore the contention of respondents regarding latches and delays on the part of the petitioner has also no force. As the application was presented on 22.11.85 before the Principal Bench of C.A.T this petition is also within limitation as envisaged in Sec. 21 of the A.T Act. Under the circumstances we find that this petition has considerable force on merits, and in particular, considering Note 1 under FR 22(C), introduced by Government of India's order M.R.O M-F-ii(B)/68 dated 8.1.68 we hold that special pay of Rs. 100/- per month drawn by the applicant as Assistant Director Post Offices was in lieu of a separate scale of pay and was not attached to the post. Therefore considering the circular 61.MF OM 6(1) E-III/B/65 dated 25.2.65 and in the light of provisions of Rule F.R 22(C)(13) we direct respondents that applicant's pay on the post of Senior Supdt. Post/Office should be refixed counting the special pay, drawn by him on the post of Asstt. Director (Post Offices) of Rs. 100/- per month, under Rule FR 22(0(13). The arrears of pay and other allowances as admisible should be paid to him within a month from the date of communication of this order.

    13. In the circumstances of the case costs of Rs. 500/- towards this litigation are also awarded in favour of the petitioner which should also be paid by the respondent within the same period of a month.

    14. Application allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V.K. Dhir v. Union Of India
    (Oct 8, 1986)