M. Ramachandran, Vice Chairman (J):— The impugned order Annexure-A was issued on 31.01.2007 Thereby, the applicant, a Sub Inspector of Police, working under the Deputy Commissioner of Police (Crime & Railway) had been dismissed from service. This was purportedly in exercise of powers vested on him under the proviso to Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution of India. The appeal carried had been dismissed by the Additional Commissioner of Police, on 28.03.2008 These orders are under challenge.
2. The date of Annexure A has much significance. The powers to dispense with the services of the applicant have been exercised by the officer concerned for the reason that the officer earlier on the very day had been arrested. This is gatherable from the recital of the first paragraph of the order which could be extracted hereinbelow:—
“On 31.01.2007, SI (Exe.) Jagdish Kumar, No. D/3792 (PIS No. 16960073) of Anti-Extortion, Section/C&R, Delhi has been arrested by the Central Bureau of Investigation, Anti-Corruption Branch, Delhi, in case RC No. 08(A)/07-DLI dated 31.01.2007 under Section 7 Prevention of Corruption Act of 1988, while he was caught accepting illegal gratification.”
The incident of collection of illegal gratification had taken place, on 31.01.2007 and the dismissal had also completed on the same date. Mr. Shyam Babu, counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant, submits that the manner, in which the order has been drafted would indicate that it had been done with a closed mind and obviously perhaps with an intention to scuttle the rights of the applicant. This, according to him, is manifested by projecting the reason for not holding an inquiry. Paragraph 3 of the order as below had been highlighted:—
“After such act of serious misconduct, if he is allowed to continue in police force it would be detrimental to public interest. Besides, it is common experience that due to terrorizing and intimidation the witnesses and complainant do not come forward to depose against the delinquent in the departmental enquiry. It also calls for great courage to depose against such a police officer and the task becomes more acute and difficult where the delinquent is police officer who may use his job to influence their statements/deposition. In the instant case, the possibility of being unduly pressurized and threatened also cannot be ruled out. It would indeed be too much to expect witnesses to show requisite resolve through out the span of departmental proceedings against the defaulter police personnel and then bear the wrath of such a disgruntled person through out their life.”
He submits that the disciplinary authority has come to the above conclusion, sitting in his office and totally relying on imaginary materials.
3. The counsel draws sustenance from an order passed by the Delhi High Court in WPC 1101/2008 where the Court had dealt with almost an identical situation. A short circuit had been employed to dispense with the services of an officer without holding a formal inquiry. Confirming the order passed by this Tribunal, the High Court had observed that there was nothing gatherable from the finding of the authority to come to a conclusion that a regular departmental inquiry was not reasonably practicable. The person concerned had been caught red handed while accepting illegal gratification as in the present case. It had been observed as following:—
“The Department can prove the charge against the respondents by examining the witnesses from the Anti Corruption Department who apprehended the respondents and caught them red handed while accepting the bribe of Rs. 5000/- as well as other witnesses. This is certainly not a case where the witnesses may not come forward to depose against the respondents.”
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned orders require to be set aside.
4. Although Mr. Gangwani, counsel appearing for the respondents with reference to the counter statement filed attempted to support the stand of the respondents, we find that the settled position of law makes it impossible for him to defend the case.
5. We feel that the proviso to Article 311(2)(b) is intended to deal with cases of very special facts, and the reasons given in the impugned order nowhere come near the situations which might have been considered by the Parliament while drafting the Article. Here was a case of acceptance of an illegal gratification. Obviously, the authorities might have been before hand informed of the demands; a trap might have been arranged and more than one officers had got themselves involved. A private citizen had been bold enough to alert the Department about the demand of illegal gratification. Even in the above scenario without considering the whole aspects and studying the whole situation independently, the Deputy Commissioner obviously had committed an error by recording a conclusion that there was possibility of the witnesses not turning up or that they would have kept away, afraid of the wrath of the disgruntled persons. As pointed out by the Delhi High Court, in any case, the departmental witnesses would have been available, even if the apprehension, as suggested might be existing in the mind of a private individual. Annexure A as well as the appellate orders are, therefore, to be set aside, and we do so.
6. Mr. Shyam Babu had referred to a number of decisions of this Tribunal, some of them being OA 1358/2007, 2284 of 2006, etc. to show that this Tribunal had come heavily on the conduct of the Delhi Police, in attempting to short circuit proceedings by conveniently resorting to the proviso to Article 311(2)(b) for bringing about dismissal. The practice had been deprecated and he submits that as a matter of fact the highest authorities had decided that such methods are not to be resorted to (See the minutes of the meeting held by the Commissioner of Police on 27.08.2007, a copy of which has been produced as Annexure ‘D’.) All concerned were thereby advised that proper inquiry is a must and only in a case where witnesses were not coming forward to depose, such action was to be taken. Counsel submits that at least the appellate authority could have taken notice of the above guideline. Referring to Jaswant Singh v. State of Punjab, (1991) 1 SCC 362 and Chief Security Officer v. Singasan Rabi Das ((1991) 1 SCC 729) counsel submits that the reasons referred to in Annexure-A did not at all take note of the legal requirement for avoiding a regular inquiry to be held before terminating the services of an officer.
7. The recitals of Annexure-A show that applicant had got himself involved in a case where serious allegations are raised against him. Therefore, although the dismissal order as presently issued to him is being set aside, we are of the view that this order shall not preclude the right of respondents from taking all suitable and appropriate action, in the matter of enforcing discipline.
8. We leave all such rights open to the respondents. It will be within their rights to initiate action against applicant as law permits. But, however, the result of our declaration would be that the applicant would be deemed as continuing in service for the purpose of normal salary and increments, all through, till further action is taken against him. O.A is disposed of, as above. No costs.