AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 1107
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 1107
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The order concerns challenges to the 2015 selection process for appointment as District & Sessions Judges in the Kerala Higher Judicial Service. Under a notification dated 30-9-2015, the selection comprised two written papers (300 marks in total) and a viva voce (50 marks). Candidates of the General and OBC categories who secured 50 % in the written examination and SC/ST candidates who secured 40 % became eligible for the viva voce. A Full Court Resolution dated 13-12-2012 specifically stated that no minimum cut-off marks would be prescribed for the interview and that the final merit list would be based on the aggregate of written and oral marks.

During the 2013 and 2014 recruitment cycles, the Selection Committee followed this scheme, but after interviewing candidates the Administrative Committee introduced a new requirement: candidates had to obtain the same minimum percentage in the viva voce as was required in the written examination. The Full Court approved the resulting merit list, and appointments were made. Those appointments are the subject of the present litigation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Administrative Committee’s post-hoc prescription of minimum qualifying marks for the viva voce—contrary to the notified scheme—constitutes an impermissible change to the “rules of the game” after the selection process had commenced or concluded.
  2. Whether the precedent in K. Manjusree v. State of A.P. (2008) 3 SCC 512, which prohibits such post-selection changes, continues to hold the field in light of doubts expressed in Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court (2013) 4 SCC 540.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The governing rules explicitly disallowed any minimum cut-off for the viva voce; imposing such a cut-off after interviews violates the principle that selection criteria cannot be altered after the process is underway (“changing the rules of the game after the game is played”).

Respondents’ Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents’ legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Manjusree v. State of A.P. (2008) 3 SCC 512 Introducing minimum interview marks after completion of the selection process is impermissible; constitutes changing the rules mid-way. Viewed as directly governing the present facts; forms the basis for the petitioners’ challenge.
Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court (2013) 4 SCC 540 Doubts the correctness of Manjusree on the “rules of the game” principle and refers the issue to a larger Bench. Cited to show that the legal principle relied upon in Manjusree is under reconsideration; prompts the present referral.
Salam Samarjeet Singh v. High Court of Manipur (2016) 10 SCC 484 Deals with a similar controversy regarding post-selection changes in interview criteria. Noted that this case is already tagged with Tej Prakash; present matter is ordered to be heard along with them.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognised that the factual matrix mirrors Manjusree, where post-selection fixation of interview cut-off marks was invalidated. However, because Tej Prakash has questioned the continued validity of that precedent and the issue is pending before a larger Bench, the Court found it appropriate not to decide the merits immediately. Instead, it determined that consistency and judicial discipline warranted referring the present matter to the same larger Bench so that a definitive pronouncement could be made on the principle prohibiting alteration of selection norms mid-process.

Holding and Implications

REFERRED TO LARGER BENCH.

The case is to be listed along with Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court (2013) 4 SCC 540 and Salam Samarjeet Singh v. High Court of Manipur (2016) 10 SCC 484. No final adjudication on the merits has been rendered; consequently, the appointments in question remain under judicial scrutiny, and the broader legal standard regarding mid-process changes to selection criteria awaits authoritative resolution.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sivanandan C.T And Others v. High Court Of Kerala And Others

    Order

    1. The selection of the District & Sessions Judges in the Kerala Higher Judicial Service in the year 2015 has given rise to this litigation. As per the Notification dated 30-9-2015, the selection was to be conducted by written examination and viva voce. The written examination of two papers carried 300 marks (150 marks for each paper). The viva voce was for 50 marks. It was stipulated that those general and OBC candidates who secured 50% in the written examination without any separate minimum and SC/ST who secured 40% were qualified to participate in the viva voce.

    2. In terms of the Resolution of the Full Court dated 13-12-2012, there should be no minimum cut-off marks for the interview. The final merit list was to be prepared in the following manner:

    “… The merit list of successful candidates will be prepared on the basis of the total marks obtained in the written examination and viva voce.”

    3. As a matter of fact, two selections were held in the years 2013 and 2014 without cut-off marks for the viva voce. As per the Resolution dated 13-12-2012, after publishing the result of the examination, the candidates were interviewed by the Selection Committee. However, after the viva voce, the Administrative Committee (consisting of the same members as the Selection Committee) resolved to draw up a list of successful candidates on the basis of same separate minimum percentage of marks in the viva voce as in the written examination. According to the Administrative Committee, the fixing of the minimum marks for the viva voce was not a deviation from the approved scheme since “it was never the intention of the Full Court to select persons who do not attain the minimum required benchmark for such a responsible post”. The merit list thus drawn by the Administrative Committee on the basis of the minimum marks in the viva voce was approved by the Full Court and those candidates were appointed accordingly. That selection is challenged in these cases.

    4. The main contention is that the rules of the game could not have been changed after the game is played and the result of the game is known to the selectors.

    5. Though several other contentions are raised by both sides, we find that the decision in K. Manjusree v. State of A.P (2008) 3 SCC 512, squarely applies to the facts of this case. In Manjusree (2008) 3 SCC 512, 75 marks were allotted for the written examination and 25 marks for the interview. The aggregate governed the merit. However, the written examination was conducted for 100 marks. When the Full Court noticed this, a sub-committee was appointed to make the arithmetical correction to scale down the marks in the written examination to 75 instead of 100. The sub-committee did two things — (1) it made the arithmetical correction, (2) it introduced the same cut-off percentage for the interview as in the written examination and thus revised the merit list, which was approved by the Full Court. In the process, a few candidates were removed from the original merit list including Manjusree. A Bench of three Judges of this Court held that:

    “27. … introduction of the requirement of the minimum marks for interview, after the entire selection process (consisting of written examination and interview) was completed, would amount to changing the rules of the game after the game was played which is clearly impermissible.”

    The Bench specifically noted that the Resolution of the Full Court to not specifically stipulate minimum marks for viva voce was still in force. Yet, when the sub-committee introduced the change, the same was approved by the Full Court.

    6. Tej Prakash Pathak v. Rajasthan High Court (2013) 4 SCC 540 has, however, specifically doubted the correctness of Manjusree (2008) 3 SCC 512 on the point whether “… changing the rules of the game after the game was played … is clearly impermissible” and has made a reference to a larger Bench for an authoritative pronouncement.

    7. It is also relevant in this context to note that Salam Samarjeet Singh v. High Court of Manipur (2016) 10 SCC 484 which dealt with almost a similar issue was heard by a three-Judge Bench in view of the difference of opinion and it has also since been posted along with Tej Prakash (2013) 4 SCC 540 by order dated 10-8-2017 WP (C) No. 294 of 2015. Hence, it is only appropriate to refer this matter also to the larger Bench to be heard along with Tej Prakash (2013) 4 SCC 540. Ordered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sivanandan C.T And Others v. High Court Of Kerala And Others
    (Nov 14, 2017)