Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.17.
  • Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.
  • record.10. Section 459 IPC
  • Section 459/34 IPC.15.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.17.
  • Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.
  • record.10. Section 459 IPC
  • Section 459/34 IPC.15.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants Suraj Giri, Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad appealed against the judgment dated 24 October 2016 in Session Case No. 57720/16, in which they were convicted under Section 459 read with Section 34 IPC and sentenced (different terms of rigorous imprisonment and fines for each appellant). The prosecution case, as narrated in the complaint (Ex.PW-1/A) by PW-1 Bahadur Baghel, was that Baghel ran a tea shop and had lent money to several neighbours including the accused. After repeated demands for repayment, on the night intervening 31.3.2012 and 1.4.2012 at about 4:30 a.m. four accused persons allegedly entered his house from the roof of an adjoining house. PW-1 alleges that Suraj and Pawan held him while Devender held his hands and Guddu stabbed him with a knife; the assailants then threatened him and fled. The matter was reported and an FIR (No. 80/2012) under Sections 450/326/34 IPC was registered. Suraj Giri, Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad were arrested during investigation and the knife was recovered; Pawan was declared as a person not traceable (P.O.). After investigation a charge-sheet was filed. At trial the three accused were charged under Section 459/34 IPC, pleaded not guilty, the prosecution examined nine witnesses, statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C. were recorded, and the trial court convicted them under Section 459/34 IPC and sentenced them as recorded in the impugned judgment.

These appeals challenge that conviction primarily on the ground that the elements required for Section 459 IPC were not satisfied.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants could be validly convicted under Section 459 IPC (grievous hurt caused whilst committing lurking house-trespass or house-breaking) when, according to the record, grievous hurt was caused after entry into the dwelling was effected.
  2. If conviction under Section 459 IPC is not sustainable, whether the conviction should be altered to an offence under Section 457 IPC (lurking house-trespass or house-breaking by night in order to commit an offence punishable with imprisonment).
  3. Whether the substantive sentences imposed require modification in view of the alteration of conviction and the personal circumstances / mitigation pleaded on behalf of the appellants.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants did not dispute the occurrence itself but challenged the legal characterization of their conduct: they submitted that grievous hurt was not caused "while committing" lurking house trespass or house-breaking, because the injuries were inflicted after entry into the complainant’s house was already effected.
  • Accordingly, they argued their convictions under Section 459/34 IPC were unsustainable and ought to be altered to convictions under Section 457/34 IPC.
  • The appellants sought a more lenient sentence, submitting they were sole breadwinners with dependent families, first offenders, and not involved in other cases.
  • Counsel for the appellants relied on Said Ahmed v. King Emperor (AIR 1927 Allahabad 536) in support of the contention regarding the temporal scope of Section 459.

Prosecution / State

  • The opinion records that the learned APP for the State conceded that while committing lurking house-trespass at night no grievous injury was caused to PW-1 (the complainant/injured).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Said Ahmed v. King Emperor, AIR 1927 Allahabad 536 Held that the offence of house-breaking is complete on entry into the house; grievous hurt caused after entry does not amount to grievous hurt "whilst committing" lurking house-trespass for the purposes of Section 459 IPC. The court relied on this authority to support the interpretation that grievous hurt inflicted after completion of entry cannot be treated as having been caused "whilst committing" lurking house-trespass, and thus Section 459 is inapplicable to such post-entry injuries.
Rohtas v. State, 1987 (1) Crimes 576 (Delhi) Reiterated the principle that to attract Section 459 IPC the grievous hurt must be caused in the course of committing the lurking trespass/house-breaking; if the hurt is caused after entry, Section 459 is not attracted (court in that case altered conviction from Section 459 to another section). The court treated Rohtas as a directly analogous precedent and followed its reasoning to alter the convictions in the present case from Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC because the injuries were caused after the lurking house-trespass was complete.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out the statutory language of Section 459 IPC and Section 457 IPC as reproduced in the opinion. It emphasized that Section 459 contemplates instances where grievous hurt (or an attempt to cause death or grievous hurt) occurs "whilst committing" lurking house-trespass or house-breaking.

The court analysed the sequence of events established on the record: the lurk/entry into the dwelling was effected when the accused entered the complainant's house; the injuries were proved to have been caused by the appellants only after that entry. On a plain reading of Section 459 and applying the teachings of the cited precedents (Said Ahmed and Rohtas), the court concluded that the causal and temporal requirement of Section 459 ("whilst committing" the trespass) is not satisfied where the grievous hurt is inflicted after the trespass is complete.

Relying on the precedents, which hold that house-breaking or trespass is complete on entry and grievous hurt caused subsequently cannot be regarded as occurring "whilst committing" the trespass, the court found that the proper charge sustained by the proved facts was under Section 457/34 IPC (lurking house-trespass by night with intent to commit an offence punishable with imprisonment), not Section 459/34 IPC.

The court also took into account the submissions regarding mitigation. In light of the altered legal characterization of the offence and the mitigation pleaded (status as breadwinners, first offenders), the court reduced the substantive prison sentence while retaining the fine, and reduced the default sentence for non-payment of the fine.

Finally, the court gave consequential directions regarding surrender, release (where the sentence had already been served), transmission of records (TCR) and communication to the prison authorities.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Convictions of the appellants are altered from Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.

Direct consequences and remedial orders made by the court:

  • The convictions were formally altered from Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.
  • The substantive sentence for each appellant was reduced to three years' imprisonment; the fines as originally imposed were maintained. In default of payment of fine, the substituted period of simple imprisonment was reduced from one month to one week.
  • The court recorded the periods already undergone by each appellant as per the nominal rolls and directed: Suraj Giri (whose substantive sentence had been suspended during appeal) to surrender on 23 October 2017; Guddu Giri, having already undergone three years' sentence, was ordered to be set at liberty if not wanted in any other case.
  • The Trial Court Record (TCR) was directed to be sent back along with a copy of the order, and a copy of the order was to be forwarded to the concerned Jail Superintendent for information and compliance.

Broader implications: The court applied established precedent on the temporal requirement in Section 459 IPC but did not purport to lay down a new legal principle; the decision is an application of existing authorities to the facts of this case. No novel precedent was announced in the opinion beyond the application of Said Ahmed and Rohtas to the facts before the court.

Annex: Key Statutory Extracts Quoted in the Opinion

Section 459 IPC — "Grievous hurt caused whilst committing lurking house trespass or house-breaking.—Whoever, whilst committing lurking house-trespass or house-breaking, causes grievous hurt to any person or attempts to cause death or grievous hurt to any person, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine."

Section 457 IPC — "Lurking house-trespass or house-breaking by night in order to commit offence punishable with imprisonment.—Whoever commits lurking house-trespass by night, or house-breaking by night, in order to the committing of any offence punishable with imprisonment, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to five years, and shall also be liable to fine; and, if the offence intended to be committed is theft, the term of the imprisonment may be extended to fourteen years."

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Suraj Giri v. State

    Pratibha Rani, J. (ORAL):— These three appeals have been preferred by appellants Suraj Giri, Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad assailing the judgment dated 24th October, 2016 passed in Session Case No. 57720/16 whereby they have been convicted for committing the offence punishable under Section 459/34 IPC and sentenced as under:—

    Appellant Suraj Giri: to undergo RI for 5 years with fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default of payment of fine to undergo SI for one monthAppellant Guddu Giri: to undergo RI for 7 years with fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default of payment of fine to undergo SI for one monthAppellant Devender Prasad: to undergo RI for 5 years with fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default of payment of fine to undergo SI for one month

    2. In brief the prosecution case as narrated in the complaint Ex.PW-1.A made by PW-1, Bahadur Baghel is that he was residing at House No. E-141, Laxmi Vihar, near Shivam Model School, Prem Nagar-III, Delhi and was running a tea shop. Pawan, Devender, Suraj and Guddu were residing in his neighbourhood. Pawan took a loan of Rs. 15,000/- from him about 3 years prior to 1.4.2012 and Guddu took a loan of Rs. 25,000/- about 6-7 months prior to 1.4.2012 Suraj and Devender also took some money from him. When he asked all of them to return the money, they deferred the repayment on one pretext or the other. About 4-5 days prior to 1.4.2012 all the four accused came to his shop and when he asked them to return his money they refused to return the money. They not only abused him but also threatened to teach him a lesson. On the night intervening 31.3.2012 and 1.4.2012 at about 4.30 a.m when he along with his wife and daughter was sleeping in his house all the four accused persons entered his house from the roof of the adjoining house. On hearing some sound, when he woke up, accused Suraj and Pawan caught hold of him from his neck and Devender caught his hands whereas Guddu started stabbing him with the knife saying that ‘TUJHE HUM ABHI PAISE DETE HAI’. He raised alarm and his wife and daughter came there. All the four accused ran away saying that ‘AAJ KE BAAD PAISE MAANGE TO TUJHE ZINDA NAHI CHHODENGE’. The matter was reported to the police and he was taken to the hospital.

    3. On the basis of above statement case FIR No. 80/2012 under Sections 450/326/34 IPC PS Aman Vihar was registered. During investigation the accused Suraj Giri, Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad were arrested and weapon of offence i.e knife was recovered. After completion of investigation charge-sheet was filed. Accused Pawan was not traceable hence declared P.O

    4. On the basis of the material placed by the prosecution all the three accused persons, namely, Suraj Giri, Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad were charged for the offence punishable under Section for 459/34 IPC to which they pleaded not guilty. The prosecution examined 9 witnesses in all to prove its case. Statement under Section, 313 Cr.P.C of the accused persons/appellants herein have also been recorded to explain the incriminating evidence appearing against them.

    5. After trial the accused persons were convicted for committing the offence punishable under Section 459/34 IPC and sentenced in the manner stated above.

    6. Appellant Suraj Giri is present on bail. Pursuant to the production warrants being issued, appellants Guddu Giri and Devender Prasad have been produced from J/C.

    7. Mr. Biswajit Kumar Patra, Advocate for appellant Suraj Giri, Ms. Inderjeet Sidhu, Advocate for appellant Guddu Giri and Mr. Jatin Rajput, Advocate for appellant Devender Prasad, on instructions, submit that the appellants are not disputing the incident and they are challenging their conviction only to the extent that they could not have been convicted for committing the offence punishable under Section 459/34 IPC as no grievous injury was caused while committing lurking house trespass at night. It has been submitted that the injuries have been caused to injured Bahadur Baghel (PW-1) only after the appellants had entered his house. Thus, they could only be convicted under Section 457/34 IPC. Hence, their conviction may be altered from under Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC. The appellants have also prayed for a lenient view on the quantum of sentence submitting that they are the sole bread earner in their family which consist of their wife, children and aged parents. They are the first offenders and not involved in any other case prior to this case or thereafter.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellants have placed reliance on Said Ahmed v. King Emperor AIR 1927 Allahabad 536 in support of his contentions.

    9. I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the appellants and carefully gone through the record.

    10. Section 459 IPC provides as under:—

    “459. Grievous hurt caused whilst committing lurking house trespass or house-breaking.—Whoever, whilst committing lurking house-trespass or house-breaking, causes grievous hurt to any person or attempts to cause death or grievous hurt to any person, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”

    11. Section 457 IPC reads as under:—

    “457. Lurking house-trespass or house-breaking by night in order to commit offence punishable with imprisonment.—Whoever commits lurking house-trespass by night, or house-breaking by night, in order to the committing of any offence punishable with imprisonment, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to five years, and shall also be liable to fine; and, if the offence intended to be committed is theft, the term of the imprisonment may be extended to fourteen years.”

    12. A bare reading of Section 459 IPC would reveal that it contemplates a situation wherein the grievous hurt or attempt to cause grievous hurt is while committing lurking house trespass or house breaking.

    13. In Said Ahmed's case (Supra) relied upon by learned counsel for the appellants the offence of house breaking was held to be complete when entry into the house is effected. It was also held that any grievous hurt caused after breaking into the house would not amount to causing grievous hurt while committing the lurking house trespass within the meaning of Section 459 IPC. This Court has taken a similar view in the decision reported as Rohtas v. State, 1987 (1) Crimes 576 Delhi. In the above noted case, the occurrence had taken place at about 1.30 a.m on the night intervening 8/9 February, 1979 at the house of the complainant where he along with his wife was sleeping at his house. The injuries were caused to the complainant and his wife with a ‘mussal’ picked from the room. The appellant Rohtas was convicted for committing the offence punishable under Section 459 IPC. In appeal the conviction under Section 459 IPC was challenged on the ground that to attract the provision of section 459 ipc the attempt to cause grievous hurt or an attempt to cause death or grievous hurt to any person must be done in the course of commission of offence of lurking house trespass or house breaking. While accepting the submission made on behalf of the appellant in para No. 7 of the report it was held as under:—

    “7. There is much substance in the contention of learned counsel for the appellant. In order to attract the provisions of section 459, the causing of grievous hurt or the attempt to cause death or grievous hurt must be done in the course of the commission of the offence of lurking trespass or house breaking. It is not sufficient that the grievous hurt was caused or the attempt made after the completion of lurking trespass or house trespass. The offence of house breaking is complete when the entry into the house is effected, and grievous hurt caused subsequently cannot be said to be caused “whilst committing” the trespass. However, the fact remains that the accused committed house trespass by entering into the building which was being used by Tara Chand as a dwelling place. The mere fact that the accused entered the house and committed assault on Tara Chand and his wife does not necessarily pre-suppose preparation. In fact, there is no clear proof of preparation for causing hurt etc. All these facts taken together will bring the case within the four corner of Section 452 IPC. I, therefore, alter the conviction of the accused from one under Section 459 to the one under Section 452 IPC.”

    14. Reverting to the facts of the instant case, from the statement of the complainant/injured (PW-1) it is proved that the hurt was caused by the appellant not in the process of committing lurking house trespass. The offence of lurking house trespass was complete once they entered into the dwelling unit of the complainant. The injuries subsequently caused by the appellant after breaking into his house do not satisfy the requirement of section 459 IPC as held in Said Ahmed's case (Supra) and by this court in Rohtas's case. Since the grievous hurt has been caused after committing the lurking house trespass, the offence proved against the appellants would be under Section 457/34 IPC and not under Section 459/34 IPC.

    15. I find force in the submissions made on behalf of the appellants that the offence proved to have been committed by them does not fall under Section 459/34 IPC. Learned APP for the State also concedes that while committing lurking house trespass at night no grievous injury was caused to PW-1 Bahadur Baghel - complainant/injured.

    16. In view of the above discussion, the conviction of the appellants is altered from Section 459/34 IPC to Section 457/34 IPC.

    17. Now coming to the quantum of sentence, in view of the submissions made on behalf of the appellants, the substantive sentence awarded to them is reduced to three years. The sentence of fine is maintained. However, in default of payment of fine, the SI of one month is reduced to one week.

    18. As per the nominal rolls of the appellants available on record, the period of sentence undergone by them in this case is as under:—

    Sl. No.Name of the appellantAs on datePeriod of sentence undergone1.Suraj Giri20.01.20173 months and 20 days2.Guddu Giri04.05.20172 years, 9 months and 23 days (meaning thereby that as on date, the appellant Guddu Giri has undergone 3 years and 2 months.3.Devender Prasad25.05.20177 months and 21 days

    19. Appellant Suraj Giri, whose substantive sentence was suspended till the pendency of the appeal vide order dated 24 March, 2017, is directed to surrender before the concerned Jail Superintendent on 23 October, 2017 and intimation thereof shall be send to the Registry by the concerned Jail Superintendent.

    20. Since appellant Guddu Giri has already undergone the sentence of three years in this case, he be set at liberty if not wanted in any other case.

    21. The appeals are allowed in above terms.

    22. TCR be sent back alongwith copy of this order.

    23. A copy of this order be sent to the concerned Jail Superintendent for information and compliance.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suraj Giri v. State
    (Oct 11, 2017)