Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • HINDU SUCCESSION AMENDMENT ACT
  • XLI Rule 31 of the Code,
  • Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code
  • rules, Rule 31
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • HINDU SUCCESSION AMENDMENT ACT
  • XLI Rule 31 of the Code,
  • Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code
  • rules, Rule 31
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-plaintiff filed a suit seeking a declaration that he was the owner and in possession of the suit land, asserting that the defendant had no right, title, or interest therein. The suit also sought an injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with the suit land and, alternatively, possession if the defendant took or was found in possession. The trial Court decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiff, holding him owner in possession and setting aside illegal entries in favor of the defendant. The defendant appealed under Section 96 CPC before the Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court, Una, but the appeal was dismissed, thereby upholding the trial Court's judgment and decree. The appellants subsequently approached the High Court by way of the instant appeal challenging the judgments and decrees passed by the lower Courts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the civil Court has jurisdiction to entertain the suit in view of the provisions of Section 7 of the Himachal Pradesh Consolidation of Holdings (Prevention and Fragmentation) Act?
  2. Whether the findings of the Courts below are dehors (outside) the evidence on record?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants contended that the first appellate Court failed to address the specific plea regarding the jurisdiction of the civil Court vis-à-vis the order of the Consolidation Officer, as raised in the grounds of appeal.
  • They argued that the appellate Court's judgment was cryptic and did not discuss the question of jurisdiction or other issues raised, thus rendering the judgment unsustainable in law.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents, through their counsel, argued that since the trial Court had found in favor of the plaintiff, there was no requirement for the first appellate Court to return specific findings on jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
L Caliteshwar Prasad Singh v. S.P. Srivastava, (2017) 2 SCC 415 Duty of first appellate Court to reflect conscious application of mind and record findings with reasons on all issues. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that the first appellate Court must deal with all issues raised and cannot decide appeals in a cryptic or vague manner.
Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) By Lrs., (2001) 3 SCC 179 First appeal is a valuable right; appellate Court must give reasons for its findings and address all issues. The Court cited this to reinforce the principle that appellate Courts must consider all grounds raised and provide reasoned decisions.
Madhukar v. Sangram, (2001) 4 SCC 756 High Court as first appellate Court must deal with all issues and evidence before recording findings. Used to stress the obligation of the first appellate Court to deal comprehensively with the appeal.
H.K.N Swami v. Irshad Basith (Dead) By Lrs., (2005) 10 SCC 243 First appellate Court must decide on facts and law, giving reasons for its findings. Reiterated the duty of the appellate Court to address all issues with reasons.
Jagannath v. Arulappa, (2005) 12 SCC 303 Scope of Section 96 CPC; appellate Court can reappreciate entire evidence and come to a different conclusion. Applied to underscore the appellate Court's power and duty to re-examine evidence and provide reasoned decisions.
B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530 Mandates that appellate Court's judgment state points for determination, decision, reasons, and relief if any. Relied upon to affirm that appellate judgments must be detailed and reasoned.
Shasidhar and others v. Ashw Pini Uma Mathad and another, (2015) 11 SCC 269 Defines the powers and duties of the first appellate Court under Section 96 CPC. Used to highlight the necessity for full and fair consideration by appellate Courts and the inadequacy of brief or glib disposal of appeals.
Kurian Chacku v. Varkey Ouseph, AIR 1969 Kerala 316 Emphasizes the duty of first appellate Court to provide full and fair consideration of evidence on appeal. Cited to support the principle that appellate Courts must not dispose of appeals summarily.
State Bank of India & Anr. v. Emmsons International Ltd. & Anr., (2011) 12 SCC 174 Reiterates the scope and powers of first appellate Court under Section 96 CPC. Referenced to corroborate the requirement for appellate Courts to discharge their duty properly.
Vinod Kumar v. Gangadhar, 2014(12) Scale 171 Confirms the principles related to appellate Court's duty to deal with facts and law comprehensively. Reinforced the Court's conclusion on appellate obligations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the impugned judgment and decree passed by the first appellate Court and found that it failed to address the specific plea relating to the jurisdiction of the civil Court vis-à-vis the order of the Consolidation Officer, which was explicitly raised in the grounds of appeal. The appellate Court proceeded to agree with the trial Court's findings without discussing or recording any findings on this crucial issue. The Court emphasized settled legal principles that the first appellate Court is a final court of facts and law and must apply its mind consciously, addressing all issues raised by the parties with reasoned findings. The Court relied extensively on authoritative Supreme Court precedents to highlight the duty of the first appellate Court to give comprehensive and reasoned decisions. Given the failure of the first appellate Court to discharge this duty, the Court held that the impugned judgment was cryptic, unsatisfactory, and legally untenable.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the impugned judgment and decree passed by the first appellate Court and remanded the matter back to the first appellate Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law. The Court directed the first appellate Court to decide the appeal afresh, taking into account all grounds raised, including jurisdictional issues, and to provide reasoned findings on all issues. The Court explicitly stated that its observations in this judgment shall not be treated as its opinion on the merits of the case, leaving the appellate Court free to decide the matter independently. The direct effect of this decision is to ensure a proper appellate adjudication in accordance with settled legal principles. No new precedent was set; rather, the judgment reiterates and enforces existing legal standards for appellate courts.

    MAST RAM ( Deceased ) through LRs. Smt. Shanti Devi Ors. v. SUBHASH CHAND

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

    RSA No. 337 of 2005 Decided on: July 25, 2017 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Mast Ram (deceased) through LR's ………Appellants

    Versus

    .

    Subhash Chand and others ….Respondents ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- . ---P---- Coram

    Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge

    Whether approved for reporting?1Yes. -------------------------------------------------------------- f ---- ----H---------------- For the appellants Mr. Rajnish Lal, A o dvocate, vice Mr. Sanjeev Sood, Advocate , for the appellants. For the respondents: Mr. N.K r . Th t akur, Senior Advocate with Mr. Nitish, Advocate, for respondents No. 1 and 2 M u r. R.P. Singh, Advocate, for respondent No.3.

    --------------------------- o ----------------------------------------------------------- Sandeep Shar C ma, Judge: Having regard to the nature of order this court prop h oses to pass, after having carefully perusing impugned g judgment and decree, passed by learned first appellate Court i

    vis-à-vis pleadings adduced on record, by the appellants, it H

    may not be necessary to give facts and circumstances of the case, save and except that the respondent-plaintiff, filed a suit for declaration to the effect that suit land is owned and possessed by him and defendant has no right, title or interest over the suit land. Plaintiff, by way of suit referred to above,

    prayed for injunction restraining the defendant from

    1 Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

    1

    2

    interfering in the suit land and, in the alternative, for possession in case, defendant succeeds in taking possession of suit land or if otherwise found in possession of suit land.

    2. Aforesaid suit having been filed by the plaintiff came to .

    be decreed, whereby he was held to be owner in possession P of the suit land. Learned trial Court, while holding plaintiff . to be owner-in-possession of the suit land also held tha H t defendant has no right, title or interest over the suit f la nd. Entries in favour of defendant are wrong, illegal, hence set aside. Defendant being aggrieved and t di ssaotisfied with aforesaid judgment and decree, preferr r ed an appeal under Section 96 CPC, before the Addition u al District Judge, Fast Track Court, Una, District Una, o which came to be registered as CA No. 21/98 RBT No. 80/04/98. However, the fact remains that the aforesaid a pp C eal was dismissed, as a result of which, judgment and h decree passed by learned trial Court came to be upheld. In g the aforesaid background, appellants have approached this i

    Court by way of instant proceedings, praying therein for H

    setting aside the judgments and decrees passed by learned Courts below. 3. Appeal at hand was admitted on 8.7.2005, on the following substantial questions of law:

    "(1) Whether the civil Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit in view of the provision of Section 7 of the H.P. Consolidation of Holdings (Prevention and Fragmentation) Act?

    (2) Whether the findings of the Courts below are dehors the evidence on record?"

    3

    4. Before this Court adverts to the records for exploring answer to the aforesaid substantial questions of law, Mr. Rajnish Lal, learned counsel representing the appellants invited attention of this Court to the grounds of appeal filed .

    before first appellate Court, laying therein challenge t . o P the judgment and decree passed by learned trial Court, to demonstrate that no findings, if any, qua issue of H jurisdiction of civil court, while entertaining s o uit a f gainst order of Consolidation officer, have been returned, as such, judgment passed by first appellate Court r is n t ot sustainable in the eyes of law and same deserves to u be set aside. 5. Before ascertaining the merits of the aforesaid submissions havin o g been made by the learned counsel

    representing C the appellants, it would be appropriate to take not of the ground No. 5 of the appeal preferred before the learn h ed Additional District Judge, which is reproduced as

    ig under: "5. That the order for correction of entries in the H

    record has been made by the competent court on the admission of the plaintiff and that order has not been challenged by the plaintiffs moreover the order of the Consolidation Officer is final and that cannot be challenged in the civil court. The ld. Lower court below has acted without any power and jurisdiction."

    6. Perusal of averments contained in the aforesaid ground of appeal, clearly suggests that specific plea with regard to jurisdiction of civil court vis-à-vis order of Consolidation Officer was raised by the appellant before the first appellate

    4

    Court and as such, it was bound to decide the same in accordance with law.

    7. After having carefully perused impugned judgment and decree passed by first appellate Court, this Court sees .

    substantial force in the arguments having been made by M P r. Rajnish Lal, that there is no discussion at all in the judg . ment passed by first appellate Court, qua issue of juris di H ction of civil court. In the case at hand, first appellate Cou f rt after recording brief facts of the case as well as s ubmissions having been made by the learned counsel re t preseonting the parties, has proceeded to decide the appeal without caring to take note of specific grounds taken in u the rappeal. Perusal of the impugned judgment passed by first appellate Court, nowhere suggests

    that it had taken n o ote of ground No. 5, as reproduced above,

    while decid in C g appeal having been preferred by appellants. 8. By now, it is settled law that first appeal is a valuable

    g right h of parties and parties have a right to be heard, both on i

    the question of law and facts and first appellate Court is H

    required to address itself to all the issues and decide the case by giving reasons in support of such findings. 9. True, it is that it is always open for the first appellate Court to take a different view on question of facts after adverting to the reasons given by trial Court in arriving at

    findings in question. It has been repeatedly held by Hon'ble

    Apex Court as well as this Court that court of first appeal

    5

    being the last court of facts, must address all the questions involved in the case and, by no means, they should be general and vague. Similarly, it is well settled by now that whenever, appellate court intends to reverse the findings of trial Court, it .

    is expected to record findings in clear terms, specif . ica P lly stating therein in what manner, reasoning of trial court is erroneous. As has been observed above, first H appeal is a

    valuable right of parties and unless restri f cte d by law, the whole case therein is open for re-he ari o ng on questions of law and facts, as such, judgment of t first appellate Court must therefore reflect its conscious application of mind and must record findings supporte u d by rreasons on all the issues arrived from pleadings of th o e parties. 10. In this regard, reliance is placed upon judgment of Apex

    Court in L C aliteshwar Prasad Singh v. S.P. Srivastava repo h rted in (2017) 2 SCC 415, wherein Hon'ble Apex Court has g held as follows: i

    "13. An appellate court is the final court of facts. The judgment of the H

    appellate court must therefore reflect court's application of mind and record its findings supported by reasons. The law relating to powers and duties of the first appellate court is well fortified by the legal provisions and judicial pronouncements. Considering the nature and scope of duty of first appellate court, in Vinod Kumar v. Gangadhar . (2015) 1 SCC 391, it was held as under:- "12. In Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) By Lrs. (2001) 3 SCC 179, this Court held as under: (SCC pp. 188-89, para 15)

    "15. … The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. First appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate

    6

    court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court. … while reversing a finding of fact the appellate court must come into close quarters with the reasoning assigned by the trial court and then assign its own reasons for arriving at a different finding. This would satisfy the .

    court hearing a further appeal that the first appellate court had discharged the duty expected of it." P

    The above view has been followed by a three-Judge . Bench decision of this Court in Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756, wherein it was reiterated that sitting as a court of first appeal, it is the duty of the High Court to f deal wi H th all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. 13. In H.K.N Swami v. Irshad Basith (Dead) By Lrs. . Basith (2005) 10 SCC 243, this Court stated as under: (SCC p. 244, para 3) "3. The first appeal

    has to be decided on facts as well o as on law. In the first appeal

    parties have the right to r be h t eard both on questions of law as also on facts and the first appellate court is required to address itself to all issues and decide the case by giving reasons. Unfortunately, the High Court, in the present case has not recorded any finding either on facts or on law. Sitting as the first

    appellate o court it u was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording the finding regarding title."

    1C 4. Again in Jagannath v. Arulappa (2005) 12 SCC 303, while considering the scope of Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, this Court observed as follows: (SCC p. 303, h

    para 2) g

    15. Again in B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy (2010) 13 i

    SCC 530, this Court taking note of all the earlier judgments of this Court reiterated the aforementioned principle with these words: (SCC pp. 530-31, paras 3-5) H

    "3. How the regular first appeal is to be disposed of by the appellate court/High Court has been considered by this Court in various decisions. Order 41 CPC deals with appeals from original decrees. Among the various rules, Rule 31 mandates that the judgment of the appellate court shall state:

    (a) the points for determination;

    (b) the decision thereon;

    (c) the reasons for the decision; and

    7

    (d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled.

    4. The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate .

    court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all P the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate . court.

    Sitting as a court of first appeal, it was the duty of the

    High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence

    led by the parties before recording f its fin H dings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the judgment in the first app eal o must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the fin t dings. (Vide Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiw r ari (2001) 3 SCC 179, SCC p. 188, para 15 and Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756 SCC p. 758, para 5.)

    5. In vie u w of the above salutary principles, on going th o rough the impugned judgment, we feel that the High Court has failed to discharge the obligation placed on it as a first appellate court. In our view, the judgment under C appeal is cryptic and none of the relevant aspects have even been noticed. The appeal has been decided in an unsatisfactory manner. Our careful perusal of the judgment in the regular first appeal shows that it falls h

    short of considerations which are expected from the court of first appeal. Accordingly, without going into the merits g

    of the claim of both parties, we set aside the impugned judgment and decree of the High Court and remand the i

    regular first appeal to the High Court for its fresh disposal in accordance with law." H

    14. The points which arise for determination by a court of first appeal must cover all important questions involved in the case and they should not be general and vague. Even though the appellate court would be justified in taking a different view on question of fact that should be done after adverting to the reasons given by the trial judge in arriving at the finding in question. When appellate court agrees with the views of the trial court on evidence, it need not restate effect of evidence or reiterate

    reasons given by trial court; expression of general agreement

    with reasons given by trial court would ordinarily suffice.

    However, when the first appellate court reverses the findings of

    the trial court, it must record the findings in clear terms

    explaining how the reasonings of the trial court are erroneous."

    8

    11. In the instant case, as has been noticed above, no findings, if any, qua issue of jurisdiction of civil court, specifically raised in grounds of appeal by appellant(s) have .

    been returned by first appellate Court, rather, first appellate Court proceeded to agree with the findings returned by le . arnPed trial Court, reiterating reasoning given by learned H trial Court while decreeing suit of the plaintiff. Needless f to say that if first appellate Court agrees with the findings of trial Court, it need not re-state effect of evidence or re t ite rat o e reasons given by trial Court, expression of general a r greement with reasons given by trial Court, would ordin u arily suffice, but while agreeing with the judgment passe o d by trial Court, it is incumbent upon first appellate Court to take into consideration all the issues raised before it b y t C he parties. 12. h But, in the instant case, this Court, after having g carefully perused impugned judgment passed by first appellate i

    Court, is in agreement with the arguments having been made H

    by Mr. Rajnish Lal, learned counsel representing the appellants that first appellate Court failed to take into consideration specific grounds with regard to jurisdiction having been raised by the appellants while agreeing with the judgment passed by learned trial Court. Keeping in view of

    controversy involved in the case, it was all the more important

    for the first appellate Court to consider specific plea of

    9

    jurisdiction raised in appeal and then record its findings, regarding maintainability, if any, of the suit having been filed by the plaintiff.

    13. In this regard, reliance is placed upon judgment of .

    Hon'ble Apex Court in Shasidhar and others versus Ashw P ini Uma Mathad and another, (2015) 11 SCC 269, wherein . it has been held as under: H

    "10. The powers of the first appellate Court, while deciding the first appeal under Section 96 rea d w o ith Ord

    fer XLI Rule 31 of the Code, are indeed well defined by various judicial pronouncements of this Co t urt and are, therefore, no more res integra. 11. As far back in 1969 r , the learned Judge - V.R. Krishna Iyer, J (as His Lordship then was the judge of Kerala High Court) while deciding the first appeal under Section 96 of the CPC

    in Kurian Chack u o vs. Varkey Ouseph, AIR 1969 Kerala 316, reminded the first appellate Court of its duty as to how the first

    appeal un o der Section 96 should be decided. In his distinctive s C tyle of writing and subtle power of expression, the learned judge held as under: "1. The plaintiff, unsuccessful in two Courts, has h

    come up here aggrieved by the dismissal of his suit which was one for declaration of title and recovery of g

    possession. The defendant disputed the plaintiff's title to the property as also his possession and claimed both in i

    himself. The learned Munsif, who tried the suit, recorded findings against the plaintiff both on title and possession. But, in appeal, the learned Subordinate Judge disposed of H

    the whole matter glibly and briefly, in a few sentences. 2. An appellate court is the final Court of fact ordinarily and therefore a litigant is entitled to a full and fair and independent consideration of the evidence at the appellate stage. Anything less than this is unjust to him and I have no doubt that in the present case the learned Subordinate Judge has fallen far short of what is expected

    of him as an appellate Court.

    3. Although there is furious contest between the counsel for the appellant and for the respondent, they appear to agree with me in this observation....."

    10

    (Emphasis supplied)

    12. This Court in a number of cases while affirming and then reiterating the aforesaid principle has laid down the scope and powers of the first appellate Court under Section 96 of the Code. We consider it apposite to refer to some of the decisions.

    "16. In Santosh Hazari vs. Purushottam Tiwari .

    (Deceased) by L.Rs. (2001) 3 SCC 179, this Court held (at pages 188-189) as under: ".........the appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of P the trial court. First appeal is a valuable right of the . parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court mu f st, t here H fore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth , a o nd pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court......while reversing a finding of fact the appellate court must come into close quarters with the r reas t oning assigned by the trial court and then assign its own reasons for arriving at a different finding. This would satisfy the court hearing a further appeal th u at the first appellate court had discharged the duty expected of it............" The abov o e view has been followed by a three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in Madhukar & Ors. v. Sangram & O C rs.,(2001) 4 SCC 756, wherein it was reiterated that sitting as a court of first appeal, it is the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. h

    14. In H.K.N Swami v. Irshad Basith (Dead) By Lrs. . Basith,(2005) 10 SCC 243, g

    this Court (at p.244) stated as under: i

    "3. The first appeal has to be decided on facts as well as on law. In the first appeal parties have the right to be H

    heard both on questions of law as also on facts and the first appellate court is required to address itself to all issues and decide the case by giving reasons. Unfortunately, the High Court, in the present case has not recorded any finding either on facts or on law. Sitting as the first appellate court it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording the finding regarding title."

    15. Again in Jagannath v. Arulappa & Anr., (2005) 12 SCC 303, while considering the scope of Section 96 of the Code this Court (at pp. 303-04) observed as follows:

    "2. A court of first appeal can reappreciate the entire evidence and come to a different conclusion........."

    11

    16. Again in B.V Nagesh & Anr. vs. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530, this Court taking note of all the earlier judgments of this Court reiterated the aforementioned principle with these words:

    "3. How the regular first appeal is to be disposed of by the appellate court/High Court has been considered by this Court in various decisions. Order 41 CPC deals with .

    appeals from original decrees. Among the various rules, Rule 31 mandates that the judgment of the appellate court shall state: .P

    (a) the points for determination;

    (b) the decision thereon; H

    (c) the reasons for th o e decisi f on; and (d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the rel t ief t o which the appellant is entitled. 4. The appellate r court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable u right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on qu o estions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the C issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court. Sitting as a court of first appeal, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence h

    led by the parties before recording its findings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to g

    be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the i

    judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the findings. (Vide Santosh Hazari v. H

    Purushottam Tiwari, (2001) 3 SCC 179 at p. 188, para 15 and Madhukar v. Sangram, (2001) 4 SCC 756 at p. 758, para 5.) 5. In view of the above salutary principles, on going through the impugned judgment, we feel that the High Court has failed to discharge the obligation placed on it as a first appellate court. In our view, the judgment under appeal is cryptic and none of the relevant aspects have

    even been noticed. The appeal has been decided in an

    unsatisfactory manner. Our careful perusal of the

    judgment in the regular first appeal shows that it falls

    short of considerations which are expected from the court

    of first appeal. Accordingly, without going into the merits

    of the claim of both parties, we set aside the impugned

    12

    judgment and decree of the High Court and remand the regular first appeal to the High Court for its fresh disposal in accordance with law."

    17. The aforementioned cases were relied upon by this Court while reiterating the same principle in State Bank of India & Anr. vs. Emmsons International Ltd. & Anr., (2011) 12 SCC

    174. This Court has recently taken the same view on similar facts .

    arising in Vinod Kumar vs. Gangadhar, 2014(12) Scale 171.

    18. Applying the aforesaid principle to the facts of th . e c P ase, we find that the High Court while deciding the fir H st appeal failed to keep the aforesaid principle in consideration and rendered the impugned decision. Indeed, it is clear by m ere reading of the impugned order quoted below:

    "1. The appellants are defend f ants in the suit. The plaintiffs are the respondents. The respondents are the children of 1st appellant born in the wedlock between 1st

    appellant and his div t orc ed o wife Smt. Uma Mathad. It is admitted fact th r at the 1st appellant has married the 2nd respondent after the divorce and in the wedlock he has two children and they are appellant Nos.3 and 4. The suit properties at item Nos.1 and 4 are admitted to be the ancestral properties. Item Nos.2 and 3 are the properties

    be o longing u to the mother of the 1st appellant and after her demise the said properties are bequeathed to 1st appellant. Therefore, the said properties acquired the C status of self-acquired properties. 2. The respondents filed a suit for partition. The parties are governed by Bombay School of Hindu Law. In h

    view of the provisions of Hindu Succession Amendment Act of 2005, the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are entitled to a g

    share as co-parceners in the ancestral properties. The wife i

    who is the second appellant also would be entitled to a share in the partition. In that view, the appellant Nos. 1 and 2 and respondent Nos.1 and 2 will have 1/4th share H

    each in item Nos.1 and 4 of the suit properties. 3. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the appellants 2 to 4 would not claim any independent share in item Nos.1 and 4 of the suit properties, but they would take share in the 1/4th share allotted to their father.

    4. In view of the said submissions, the appellant Nos.1 and 2 and respondent Nos.1 and 2 would be entitled to 1/4th share in item Nos.1 and 4 of the suit properties.

    13

    5. Accordingly, a preliminary decree to be drawn and the appeal and cross objections are disposed of in the terms indicated above."

    19. In our considered opinion, the High Court did not deal with any of the submissions urged by the appellants and/or respondents nor it took note of the grounds taken by the appellants in grounds of appeal nor took note of cross objecti P ons .filed by plaintiffs under Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code a . nd nor made any attempt to appreciate the evidence adduced by the parties in the light of the settled legal principles and decided case laws applicable to the issues arising in the case with a view to find out as to whether the judgment of the trial Court can be

    sustained or not and if so, how, and if not, why? H

    14. Though Mr. N.K. Thakur, learned Seni f or Advocate, duly assisted by Mr. Nitish, Advocate, on b eh o alf of respondents No.1 and 2, made an attempt to persua t de this Court, to agree with his contention that in light of the finding returned by trial Court, there was no requ u iremrent as such for the learned first appellate Court to o ret rn specific finding with regard to jurisdiction C raised by appellants, but aforesaid argument having be en made by Mr. N.K. Thakur, learned Senior Advo h cate can not be accepted in light of aforesaid law laid g down by the Hon'ble Apex Court as well as this Court. i

    15. Consequently, in view of detailed discussion made herein H

    above, as well as salutary principles, as have been laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in judgments referred to above, as well as judgments passed by this Court, this Court is of the view that first appellate Court has failed to discharge its obligation being a court of first appeal. 16. Accordingly, without going into merits of the claims of both the parties, impugned judgment and decree passed by

    14

    first appellate Court, are set aside and matter is remanded back to the first appellate Court, with the direction to decide the same afresh, in accordance with law. It may be observed that observations, if any, made by this Court, while passing .

    instant order/judgment, may not be considered as opinion P of this Court, especially qua issues involved in the present . case, rather, first appellate Court may proceed to de H cide appeal afresh, without being influenced by any of the observations made in this judgment. f

    17. Parties through their counsel aore directed to remain present before first appellat r e C t ourt on 30.8.2017. Since parties are litigating in th u e courts of law since 1981, this Court hopes and trusts t o hat first appellate Court shall decide the matter preferably on or before 31.12.2017.

    18. Regi str C y is directed to send a copy of instant order along h with records of the case forthwith to the learned Court g below, enabling it to do the needful within stipulated period. i

    19. That appeal stands disposed of accordingly. Pending H

    applications, if any, are disposed of. Interim directions, if any, are also vacated. (Sandeep Sharma) Judge

    July 25, 2017 (Vikrant)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MAST RAM ( Deceased ) through LRs. Smt. Shanti Devi Ors. v. SUBHASH CHAND
    (Jul 25, 2017)